In theory, this sounds good. However, the reality is that very few people here are willing to involve themselves in a discussion about their differences of theological beliefs because they know full well that a small group of people here roam the Forums looking for anyone who posts a comment that does not agree with their particular beliefs.
These people will immediately attempt to take control of the discussion by attacking the one who disagrees with their beliefs by name calling, belittling, berating and condemning them as false teachers.........whatever.
Reasonable and respectful debates on these Forums are an endangered species at the very best.
What I do, and you/others could try, if I have a question for a specific person, is start a new Thread addressed to that person specifically. If they answer, good...........but, even then, one must expect the wee group of ne'er do wells to jump in with insults flying.
Anyway.............in theory, it is a good idea