Lets Talk Free Choice

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
B

BeyondET

Guest
Quite correct. Gen 3.6

[SUP]6 [/SUP]When the woman saw that the tree was good for food, and that it was a delight to the eyes, and that the tree was desirable to make one wise, she took from its fruit and ate; and she gave also to her husband with her, and he ate.

I wonder what is meant by: " and that the tree was desirable to make one wise"

There is a whole lot going on here we do not see all the time.
That's the temptation IMO, the desire to be wise, to be notice as a wise person,
 
B

BeyondET

Guest
It was a tree of KNOWLEDGE of good and evil...
Indeed and God inspired those verses IMO, surely He knew what part of the tree Eve was looking at.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
55,819
25,996
113
Indeed and God inspired those verses IMO, surely He knew what part of the tree Eve was looking at.
The general consensus seems to be they were looking at living by their own ideas of good instead of following the principles of God, Who is Himself the embodiment of good from Whom all blessings flow. That remains the problem to this very day. The pride of life has dictated man's rejection of God; man puts himself on the throne. The only thing that has changed between then and now is the fact that the solution in Christ has come and gone. Human nature is the same.
 

Desertsrose

Senior Member
Oct 24, 2016
2,824
207
63
So I posted this with the purpose to comment, but had to rush my puppy to its vet appointment. :) Yeah, he's fine. Comments in blue.


Here's the difference between the two camps.

Calvinism's
Unconditional Election
Calvinism teaches total depravity to the point where man cannot choose God. God has to cause the new birth before man can respond to God to be saved. So God does everything. His will is not free because he's in bondage to his evil nature. The Spirit doesn't assist the person, the Spirit has to regenerate the sinner. In other words they are born again before they could ever possibly cry out to God for help. Faith is God's gift to the sinner.

I don't see how those who claim free will choice that are Calvinist/Reformed can make that statement. Because they have nothing to do with their salvation. With this belief system, you aren't choosing, you aren't doing anything......God does it all. In fact you can't because you're so depraved that you
can't respond to God's call. You play no part in your salvation experience unless you're not a 5 pointer.

Arminian's
Conditional Election
Arminianism teaches that although man is depraved, he's not totally depraved that he can't respond to God. God gives them grace to be able to respond to the gospel through faith of their own free will. The free will of man is not in bondage to the evil nature to the point that they can't respond to God's call. And that free will determines if they will be saved or damned. Man's will is not enslaved to his sinful nature - by God's grace He's able to choose for himself if he'll be saved or not. And once man hears the gospel and responds in faith, he is at that time born of the Spirit. Faith is our gift to God as we cooperate with Him in the gift of His grace that enables us to be born again.

Calvinsim's
Limited Atonement
God chooses of His own sovereign will without it being based on any foreseen response to faith or repentance. He only gives faith and repentance to those that He selects. It ends up that He has no condition for salvation other than the fact that they are chosen by Him for no reason of desire or willingness, it's not conditioned on the faith of the believer because it's based on God choice and not mans. If a person has faith it's after being born again, not beforehand. If they have repentance, it's after they're born again, not beforehand. So if they choose, it's after God has given them the new birth, not before.

Those of you who say you have a choice to be saved, you don't if you're a 5 pointer. It's God's decision alone and not yours at all. You had no part in your salvation and this is why those I've talked with about this don't know if they're saved or not.


Arminian's
General Atonement
Jesus died for everyone, but only those who believe in Him are saved. God pardons every sinner based on belief. They must have faith for the redemption of Jesus to become effective. When they believe, they are born again at that moment. For it's by grace through faith. They believe, they've been convicted, therefore they have faith in the truth of the gospel and respond with repentance.

Calvinism's
Irresistible Grace
Calvinists have a special inward call that can't be resisted. Because they believe God has pre chosen certain people, if they are one of those then they can't reject it. They can't because God causes them to be born again in a moment of His choosing. Man does not cooperate with the Spirit at the time of his being born again. The Spirit causes him to cooperate in the new birth - He causes them to repent and believe.

Every step of the way, Calvinism is
consistent. You can't resist being saved because it's all God's doing and choosing, not yours.

Arminian's
The Holy Spirit can be Resisted
The Spirit calls mankind through the gospel invitation. He does all He can to bring sinners to salvation. But because man is free to choose, he can resist the Spirit's call. The Holy Spirit does not regenerate the sinner without faith which is man's response to the Holy Spirit's calling. Man must respond by faith before the Spirit can give life.

Calvinism's
Perseverance
Because God has done the work in man, He can not loose His salvation. It can't be lost.

So when all is said and done, the Calvinist is saved forever because they did nothing to save themselves and they can do nothing to unsave themselves. They can't walk away from God.

Arminian's
Falling from Grace
Because man responds to God by faith, if he loses faith in God, his salvation can be lost. But many are divided on this. Some believe that once born again, you can't lose salvation.

So for those who are essentially a Calvinist, you can't say that you have free will or free choice because you don't and either you don't know all you
believe or it could be that some of you are not being totally honest. I'd rather believe you just don't understand fully what Calvinism teaches. :) And the same would go for the lost. They have no free will because God did not choose them. They are doomed to hell without a reason except that God passed them up and chose others instead of you.

And yet, when I read the bible, I read of a totally different God who wants all mankind to be saved and provided the way for them to come to Him. Through the shed blood of Jesus on the cross who atoned for man's sins...by His grace and through faith man is born again.

God says if you will, I will. If you repent, I will forgive you and cleanse you and give you a new heart. Our response is repentance through faith and I see no other way to God through the scriptures except by grace through faith.


 
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
Ouch! Too steep for my blood!

Am I understanding Lordship salvation as someone who goes to the alter,gets saved,walks away unchanged and later comes back to the Lord later in life? Then they are saying they made God Lord of their life the second time? I wont say more until Im sure what you are talking about and if this is correct.
I'm still waiting for you to show me how you got I don't believe in OSAS out of my statement.

There are free works you could read from some of the reformers that would help you. If you can get MacArthur's book, The Gospel According to Jesus you would understand better. You can find them used. It would be worth the investment. Instead of listening to the naysayers on here who will attack him, read it with an open mind. All he is doing is crystallizing the Gospel that Christ preached, Paul preached, and the church fathers and reformers preached and defended. Scripture and history both back it up.
 
B

BeyondET

Guest
The general consensus seems to be they were looking at living by their own ideas of good instead of following the principles of God, Who is Himself the embodiment of good from Whom all blessings flow. That remains the problem to this very day. The pride of life has dictated man's rejection of God; man puts himself on the throne. The only thing that has changed between then and now is the fact that the solution in Christ has come and gone. Human nature is the same.
Do you believe the solution in Christ has come and gone?
 
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
God says if you will, I will. If you repent, I will forgive you and cleanse you and give you a new heart. Our response is repentance through faith and I see no other way to God through the scriptures except by grace through faith.
So, salvation is a reward for doing a few things, like repenting, forgiving others, and it's you first, if you "will" then God "will too?" Kind of like "you go first?"
 

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,780
2,943
113
It seems to me that some people on this thread are glorifying "freedom" 'free will" and "choice" over God.

I am not American, so, like I could not truly understand the ending of Braveheart with his "FREEDOM" I do not understand why our will even matters?

Salvation is not about me! It is about Christ! He is the one who sacrificed himself for me, and each person. He is the one who has predestined us for adoption! That is what the Bible says.

Instead of some people getting deeper into that truth, they are slavishly devoted to some non-Biblical idea that free choice or free will is the ultimate good. In fact, so important, we have been discussing it for 20 pages.

Poeple need to come back to their senses, and think about the fact that the gospel, or good news, is that Jesus died on the cross as the final sacrifice for sin. God calls us, he changes us, and he moves us to share his good news with others!

We are just lost in a fallen world, until God calls us. I actively fought God for many years as he moved people to share the good news with me. But then, he just swooped down, and saved me in spite of myself.

I wonder how many people here truly believe that it was their personal choice that saved them? And if that is what they believe, are they truly saved? (Not addressing anyone in particular, just thinking out loud!)

Of course, some people might believe they made the choice, when in fact, it is just social conditioning and bad preaching that makes them think that the solemn moment when God touched their hearts and lives, that they initiated it. Must be nice to have God at the beck and call of every sinner!
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
55,819
25,996
113
Do you believe the solution in Christ has come and gone?
Where is Jesus now? Last I checked, He was not walking this world in the flesh :D

God spent centuries preparing the stage for Jesus' incarnation,
and it has been thousands of years since He incarnated.
 
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
It seems to me that some people on this thread are glorifying "freedom" 'free will" and "choice" over God.

I am not American, so, like I could not truly understand the ending of Braveheart with his "FREEDOM" I do not understand why our will even matters?

Salvation is not about me! It is about Christ! He is the one who sacrificed himself for me, and each person. He is the one who has predestined us for adoption! That is what the Bible says.

Instead of some people getting deeper into that truth, they are slavishly devoted to some non-Biblical idea that free choice or free will is the ultimate good. In fact, so important, we have been discussing it for 20 pages.

Poeple need to come back to their senses, and think about the fact that the gospel, or good news, is that Jesus died on the cross as the final sacrifice for sin. God calls us, he changes us, and he moves us to share his good news with others!

We are just lost in a fallen world, until God calls us. I actively fought God for many years as he moved people to share the good news with me. But then, he just swooped down, and saved me in spite of myself.

I wonder how many people here truly believe that it was their personal choice that saved them? And if that is what they believe, are they truly saved? (Not addressing anyone in particular, just thinking out loud!)

Of course, some people might believe they made the choice, when in fact, it is just social conditioning and bad preaching that makes them think that the solemn moment when God touched their hearts and lives, that they initiated it. Must be nice to have God at the beck and call of every sinner!
I'm with you on the false gospel of free will.

Somehow those who believe this believe that they came to God out of a genuine love they had for Him.

Well CONGRATS, aren't you special? ;)

They say this is because God gave us all free will and He did so because He wants us to love Him genuinely, so then, all those great people just decided one day they were going to go to God because in their heart they genuinely love Him. That is a drummed up bunch of nonsense and a fairy tale story. It sounds like it came out of Hollywood.

Contrary to Scripture testifying the lost are hostile toward God, are at enmity with Him, and that a leopard can't change it's spots, nor an Ethiopian the color of his skin, they found a loophole, they free willed themselves into change, and voila they loved God genuinely. Well, they should boast, they've done what other humans simply didn't do, they didn't defy the revelation of Scripture in their lost state and choose to love God genuinely. The former is an utterly arrogant position.
 
B

BeyondET

Guest
Where is Jesus now? Last I checked, He was not walking this world in the flesh :D

God spent centuries preparing the stage for Jesus' incarnation,
and it has been thousands of years since He incarnated.
Hmm interesting I gather your theory is if Jesus isn't here in the flesh then his gone,,,

one breath, six days, 14.4 billion years,,
 

Marano

Senior Member
Dec 7, 2011
398
32
28
29
I'm with you on the false gospel of free will.

Somehow those who believe this believe that they came to God out of a genuine love they had for Him.

Well CONGRATS, aren't you special? ;)

They say this is because God gave us all free will and He did so because He wants us to love Him genuinely, so then, all those great people just decided one day they were going to go to God because in their heart they genuinely love Him. That is a drummed up bunch of nonsense and a fairy tale story. It sounds like it came out of Hollywood.

Contrary to Scripture testifying the lost are hostile toward God, are at enmity with Him, and that a leopard can't change it's spots, nor an Ethiopian the color of his skin, they found a loophole, they free willed themselves into change, and voila they loved God genuinely. Well, they should boast, they've done what other humans simply didn't do, they didn't defy the revelation of Scripture in their lost state and choose to love God genuinely. The former is an utterly arrogant position.
I some times wonder myself if the free will gospel and its god people talk about isn't an idol people make, so that they feel a good about themselves choosing Christ and have an excuse and justification for others who didn't saying well I chose well they didn't, isn't that placing an idol where God should be? We were dead in sins, it was nothing God saw in us that led Him to choose us, it's His sovereign mercy that did it, and we are just the recipients of His grace, that should humble ourselves in my opinion, especially since scripture says faith is a gif of God so that no one should boast.
 
May 12, 2017
2,641
65
0
I some times wonder myself if the free will gospel and its god people talk about isn't an idol people make, so that they feel a good about themselves choosing Christ and have an excuse and justification for others who didn't saying well I chose well they didn't, isn't that placing an idol where God should be? We were dead in sins, it was nothing God saw in us that led Him to choose us, it's His sovereign mercy that did it, and we are just the recipients of His grace, that should humble ourselves in my opinion, especially since scripture says faith is a gif of God so that no one should boast.
So God's love has nothing to do with his wanting to have relationship with us.

Then why did he even bother creating us!?!?!?
 

Marano

Senior Member
Dec 7, 2011
398
32
28
29
So God's love has nothing to do with his wanting to have relationship with us.

Then why did he even bother creating us!?!?!?
Where did I ever say that? The reality is that men dead in sin can't see God's love, much less love God back, we love Him, because He first loved us.
 
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
I some times wonder myself if the free will gospel and its god people talk about isn't an idol people make, so that they feel a good about themselves choosing Christ and have an excuse and justification for others who didn't saying well I chose well they didn't, isn't that placing an idol where God should be? We were dead in sins, it was nothing God saw in us that led Him to choose us, it's His sovereign mercy that did it, and we are just the recipients of His grace, that should humble ourselves in my opinion, especially since scripture says faith is a gif of God so that no one should boast.
People have heard this so long that they believe it's the Gospel. Thanks to Finney, Sandeman, Pelagius and others it has been popularized. They don't realize that decisional regeneration in this country is not that old, but it is a heresy. There is no way around it, these who believe in this false gospel believe they came to God because of their genuine love for Him, and others just didn't muster up some genuine love for God or they'd get their ticket stamped too.

Then there is the misunderstanding of repentance, and faith, as if they also attained these on their own innate ability, and because they had inherent faith.

Scripture says faith comes from Christ, Romans 10:17, and believing comes from the power that raised Him from the dead, Ephesians 1:19. I suppose these also had resurrection power residing in them as well.
 
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
Where did I ever say that? The reality is that men dead in sin can't see God's love, much less love God back, we love Him, because He first loved us.
I'm always amazed how they can twist words and assert things person's have never said. Then I recall what they do with Scripture, so it makes perfect sense.
 

Desertsrose

Senior Member
Oct 24, 2016
2,824
207
63
So, salvation is a reward for doing a few things, like repenting, forgiving others, and it's you first, if you "will" then God "will too?" Kind of like "you go first?"
Hi preacher,

In Acts 16.........

“Sirs,
what must I do to be saved?”
They said, “Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved, you and your household.

In Acts 2......
Now when they heard this, they were pierced to the heart, and said to Peter and the rest of the apostles, “Brethren, what shall we do?”Peter said to them, “Repent, and each of you be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins; and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.
 

Marano

Senior Member
Dec 7, 2011
398
32
28
29
I'm always amazed how they can twist words and assert things person's have never said. Then I recall what they do with Scripture, so it makes perfect sense.
Yeah, it's unfortunate, but we keep telling them the truth, because what else are we to do?
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
55,819
25,996
113
I some times wonder myself if the free will gospel and its god people talk about isn't an idol people make, so that they feel a good about themselves choosing Christ and have an excuse and justification for others who didn't saying well I chose well they didn't, isn't that placing an idol where God should be? We were dead in sins, it was nothing God saw in us that led Him to choose us, it's His sovereign mercy that did it, and we are just the recipients of His grace, that should humble ourselves in my opinion, especially since scripture says faith is a gif of God so that no one should boast.
Yes and amen, it is a gift of God, not forced on us against our will.

 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
55,819
25,996
113
Hmm interesting I gather your theory is if Jesus isn't here in the flesh then his gone,,,

one breath, six days, 14.4 billion years,,
Theory? No. Scriptural fact. Jesus has ascended to the Father.