Response to Critique of Calvinism

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,706
3,650
113
#21
I would like to understand why anyone would want to study isms? Isn’t it enough trying to understand the spiritual realm of God, and isn’t that in scripture and how our history has reflected how God operates?

Scripture says we see darkly, as through a glass. That applies to all men. Seems to me I have enough trouble handling my own bias without taking on another person’s.
AH, you have just expressed some 'RedTentism', thanks.
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
#22
:rolleyes:
Drew, as you are already aware, the head knowledge bludgeon will come out.
it's good to study 'isms', once you've understood there are isms.

because deny though they might, people who claim to ignore/not want to know 'isms' will yet feel qualified to discuss them.

go figger.

btw: i love Confessional Lutheranism.
consider it's "isms" as well.

haha
love zone
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#23
I never got the impression from the bible alone to take sides in this debate.
When the war starts up i see both sides fudging:pand usually mangle the
bible and each other.

If someone needs to take sides, thats not my business. Ill stay where it seems
to me the bible is and to me it teaches both. And i dont feel the need to jam
in puzzle pieces where they dont fit, or make statements or give answer questions
the bible doesnt.

I do see the importance of systematic theology. Until it comes to forcing philosophical
questions into the exegesis. thats my opinion.

I think what you will find is in systematic theology, you have a bunch of people who are united in the gospel. but do not agree 100 % on other things.

Say like

we agree with the gospel of faith, we agree with how one is sanctified by growing in Christ, we agree with our future glorification etc etc. Then when it comes to other doctrines, Like prophesy, we start to grow apart.

This in my mind tears the church apart.. We should be united on the redeemable things./. And admit we may not agree on other things, but we are still brothers and sisters.

it is when we put a line in the road and say i will not cross this at any means (on non salvic issues) that we become bumbling fools and look tot he world like we are not united, and who wants what they have?
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,706
3,650
113
#24
A message to our calvinists friends: IF you want to gather sentiment for the heretics
and give them place and make them look like the innocent underdogs and in the contrast
of their patient endurance and love make them appear like the godly ones then just attack
them harshly and call them alot of names. And dont stop, keep it up till you look like the heretic.
Then have your friends "like" your post and high five in pride. Yup thatl kill truth real fast....good going!:p

Was that a pre-emptive strike? :cool:
 
C

cfultz3

Guest
#25
But then again, who needs the bias of another man when you have what God says in His book called Holy Bible. It is when your heart is full of His words and not the isms of another man that it makes one qualify to content the isms held above that Holy Word.

Ism = this is my opinion
Bible = this is what it is
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
#26
we could figure out how men are saved.
that's usually the best place to start.

1 Corinthians 11:25
In the same way, after supper he took the cup, saying, "This cup is the new covenant in my blood; do this, whenever you drink it, in remembrance of me."
 

tribesman

Senior Member
Oct 13, 2011
4,612
274
83
#27

I think what you will find is in systematic theology, you have a bunch of people who are united in the gospel. but do not agree 100 % on other things.

Say like

we agree with the gospel of faith, we agree with how one is sanctified by growing in Christ, we agree with our future glorification etc etc. Then when it comes to other doctrines, Like prophesy, we start to grow apart.

This in my mind tears the church apart.. We should be united on the redeemable things./. And admit we may not agree on other things, but we are still brothers and sisters.

it is when we put a line in the road and say i will not cross this at any means (on non salvic issues) that we become bumbling fools and look tot he world like we are not united, and who wants what they have?
Could you unite yourself to people who believe that salvation can be lost?
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#28
Could you unite yourself to people who believe that salvation can be lost?
nope..

but there are many different people groups/denominations and churches who believe salvation can not be lost..

so whats your point?
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#29
But then again, who needs the bias of another man when you have what God says in His book called Holy Bible. It is when your heart is full of His words and not the isms of another man that it makes one qualify to content the isms held above that Holy Word.

Ism = this is my opinion
Bible = this is what it is

although remember, som isms may line up with the word.. or have a mix of truth and lie

we should not disount all isms, just find out which ones, or parts of ones, line up with the word
 

tribesman

Senior Member
Oct 13, 2011
4,612
274
83
#30
nope..

but there are many different people groups/denominations and churches who believe salvation can not be lost..

so whats your point?
Well if you say "nope", and I agree with that btw, then some people (who think eternal security is non-salvic) will say:

"it is when we put a line in the road and say i will not cross this at any means...".
 
Oct 31, 2011
8,200
182
0
#31
here is the problem. God has led many people into truth, that is why he gives us the HS. What we see (I have witnessed it many times) is that these people come together, having all come up with the same conclusion, and formed a body. It is how the church started, it is how the church grows, and it is how it should continue to be.

Litening to men, and trying to decide who is right and who is wrong when all you get is "my church is right, no my churhc is right.. We have history to back us,, blah blah blah is dangerous, and leads to following men, not the word of God.

Paul commended a church who did not take him at his word blindly, but studied the scripture and tested everything paul said. This is what we all should do. Not by reading church history. Or studying other works of men. But listening to men, Studying, Testing each gospel and doctrine, and see if why they say is truth or not. Our guide is the bible not men, that is why God spent thousands of years putting his word together.. so we would not be left alone not know who to distinguish truth from mens ideas of what truth is.
Right!! Except I think we can learn about God through seeing how he works in history. The OT teaches through history.

I think we can learn by listening to how others who have the Holy Spirit sees. But the trouble with these ism is that many people who study them look to them as truth. My pastor does this. When we are discussing bible truths, he tells us of the way our denomination thinks, and gives that as truth. Or people give a whole system of thought as truth, like Monergism. This goes beyond Isaiah telling us to reason together, and Paul telling us to test against scripture. There is truth in monergism and truth in my denomination, but it is the bible that gives that truth to us, we are to test the other.
 
A

Abiding

Guest
#33
I remember something about The Spirit of Unity in Ephesians.

I also remember what Jesus thought of pomp. And what He taught
about the good Samaritan.

How many people here got their theology right first day on?
Were you shunned until you did? Jesus had 12 who never seemed to learn.
He didnt just let what they thought slide, but He didnt toss em out.

Its sad to see that happen....they have to be good enuf theologically or i
wont be a friend thing. How will they learn?
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#34
Well if you say "nope", and I agree with that btw, then some people (who think eternal security is non-salvic) will say:

"it is when we put a line in the road and say i will not cross this at any means...".
lol and?? does it mean we agree with everything we all believe other than this point?

The was the point I was trying to make.


a line in the sand would be I believe in eternal security, and so do you.. so I will believe everything you believe no matter what.. if you do not believe in eternal security, I will disagree with everything you believe no matter what. i will not even listen to you. in ANYTHING
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#35
Right!! Except I think we can learn about God through seeing how he works in history. The OT teaches through history.

I think we can learn by listening to how others who have the Holy Spirit sees. But the trouble with these ism is that many people who study them look to them as truth. My pastor does this. When we are discussing bible truths, he tells us of the way our denomination thinks, and gives that as truth. Or people give a whole system of thought as truth, like Monergism. This goes beyond Isaiah telling us to reason together, and Paul telling us to test against scripture. There is truth in monergism and truth in my denomination, but it is the bible that gives that truth to us, we are to test the other.
I grew up baptist.. I was told many times, unless your baptist your not going to heaven, everyone else was wrong, i actually believed this for years..

Oh how wrong I was..
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#36
I remember something about The Spirit of Unity in Ephesians.

I also remember what Jesus thought of pomp. And what He taught
about the good Samaritan.

How many people here got their theology right first day on?
Were you shunned until you did? Jesus had 12 who never seemed to learn.
He didnt just let what they thought slide, but He didnt toss em out.

Its sad to see that happen....they have to be good enuf theologically or i
wont be a friend thing. How will they learn?
yeah, but that is sure a powerful tool used by satan to cause discord in the church.. And he uses it well. has been for 200 years now.. (actually he even did if for all the time before Christ also!
 
A

Abiding

Guest
#37
lol and?? does it mean we agree with everything we all believe other than this point?

The was the point I was trying to make.


a line in the sand would be I believe in eternal security, and so do you.. so I will believe everything you believe no matter what.. if you do not believe in eternal security, I will disagree with everything you believe no matter what. i will not even listen to you. in ANYTHING
I didnt get this..do you mind resaying?
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#38
I didnt get this..do you mind resaying?
you mean this?

I think what you will find is in systematic theology, you have a bunch of people who are united in the gospel. but do not agree 100 % on other things.

Say like

we agree with the gospel of faith, we agree with how one is sanctified by growing in Christ, we agree with our future glorification etc etc. Then when it comes to other doctrines, Like prophesy, we start to grow apart.

This in my mind tears the church apart.. We should be united on the redeemable things. And admit we may not agree on other things, but we are still brothers and sisters.

it is when we put a line in the road and say i will not cross this at any means (on non salvic issues) that we become bumbling fools and look tot he world like we are not united, and who wants what they have?
 
A

Abiding

Guest
#39
Yes i remember my early days as a mixed up messed up believer.
And im still a tad messy. Another reason for thankfulness and praise
for a Keeper or id be lost, save a few kind folk He sent my way.
Who were patient and longsuffering.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#40
Yes i remember my early days as a mixed up messed up believer.
And im still a tad messy. Another reason for thankfulness and praise
for a Keeper or id be lost, save a few kind folk He sent my way.
Who were patient and longsuffering.
I think we all have had those kind folk.. and just pray we can return the favor to another lad or lasse one day