Romans 9:13-23 Do we even have a choice?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

KIT1776

Guest
#41
parkinsons disease
 
K

KIT1776

Guest
#43
we will go through one half of the great tribulation
 
K

KIT1776

Guest
#44
i thessalonians 4 says not to be deceived, the antichrist must revealed first then the day of the Lord will begin
 
M

Maddog

Guest
#45
@greatkraw.
Free will contradicts the sovereignty of God. we have a will in a sense but it is more prone to sin than to want God.
Um. if Christ died for the whole world. why are there people in hell? it is like what happened to the thief on the cross. one was saved to show Gods's Mercy and the Other sentenced to Hell to show His Just Wrath.

The only thing is i am not saying things like "only calvinists go to heaven" or anything like that.
I'm not saying that Arminians are Heretics. Christ prayed for unity and I do not want to cause division.
But what i am saying is that it makes so much sense with everything in the world. I look outside and i see destruction I know why there is destruction.
I know things don't happen by chance because God is Sovereign.
I know he chose me because My heart is to wicked and prone to sin to choose Him.
I know that Christ will Hold me even if i begin to stray away He will Bring me back.
I know that my God Sends people to Hell and people to heaven because it is in His Good Pleasure.
I know that sin has corrupted every human being in the World.
I have an admiration for Calvinism in the way it is very logical and internally consistent. I think it's wrong though.

I'm not saying that Arminians are Heretics.
Just out of interest, how can you hold to a Calvinistic soteriology and not think that Arimianism is heresy, given it's different teaching of the roles of God and man in salvation?
 
G

greatkraw

Guest
#46
Calvin did not invent Calvinism. His disciples did. Calvin never heard of TULIP.
 
Apr 23, 2009
2,253
5
0
#47
we will go through one half of the great tribulation
i thessalonians 4 says not to be deceived, the antichrist must revealed first then the day of the Lord will begin
There is a thread for that discussion, but it is not this thread, check out the ''should we prepare for the rapture or tribulation'' thread
 
K

KIT1776

Guest
#48
if we don't have a choice as to our personal salvation, then God cannot judge us for our sins
 
K

KIT1776

Guest
#49
any bible scholars here?
 
P

Phoenix

Guest
#50
I'm sorry watchmen i feel like i have lost my respect for you.
I have not shown anything heretical like that Jesus is not God or that He did not die on the cross or like the mormons who say that they will become gods.
The only thing different between me and you is how we view man's responsibility in his salvation. so are you saying that i am going to hell for being a calvinist. please pull that verse out for me
@greatkrw Calvin did come up with tulip. from the scriptures. @maddog i feel that there is no need to divide the body of Christ. can two arms that bicker be any good?
 
Apr 23, 2009
2,253
5
0
#51
I'm sorry watchmen i feel like i have lost my respect for you.
Thats ok they al do sooner or later, but I will keep telling the truth whether that truth is holy living, the post trib rapture, or that calvinism is not only false but anti scriptural. I will not shrink down and let fallacy win because someone might loose respect for me. The truth has and always will be hated.
 
P

Phoenix

Guest
#52
Well I do not hate to be rebuked brother. But i hate it when i am brought forth false claims and i have no fault.
 
Apr 23, 2009
2,253
5
0
#53
I'm sorry watchmen i feel like i have lost my respect for you.
I have not shown anything heretical like that Jesus is not God or that He did not die on the cross or like the mormons who say that they will become gods.
The only thing different between me and you is how we view man's responsibility in his salvation. so are you saying that i am going to hell for being a calvinist. please pull that verse out for me
#1 Presestination is only one point of calvinism all 5 point are false, so the responsibility of man in salvation is not the only thing I believe differently than calvinist.
#2 No I do not think you are going to Hell for being a calvinist. I believe you truly love God, and are doing your best to serve him


I believe you are young but very knowledgeable in scripture and doctrine. I also believe if you will study out the New Testament listen to others like myself with an open mind, you will come to realize one day that calvinism is false, and certain nothing to be stood up for.

God bless you Phoenix, I hold no hard feeling toward you nor blame you for your beliefs. However I do not think that Calvinism is a trivial matter that should be ignored but a strike against the truth that disparages the character of God, and needs to be exposed for what it is.
 
Apr 23, 2009
2,253
5
0
#54
Well I do not hate to be rebuked brother. But i hate it when i am brought forth false claims and i have no fault.
No it is not your fault it is you parents, your pastors, your sunday school teachers ect... but I trust you will find the truth if you search for it honest seek it out.
 
P

Phoenix

Guest
#55
My brother. We agree on many things. This is the one thing we disagree on. Doctorine. My church is reformed and so is most of my family. God bless you too brother. But I am not defending Calvinism I am defending scripture. Sola scriptura. You may not agree with me and I am completely fine with that. I am sorry though that I said that I lost my respect for you. That was more out of anger. And I apolagize for that. May God keep you grounded in His word watchmen
 

DinoDillinger

Senior Member
Jul 28, 2009
839
19
18
#56
The part of your post I emboldened tells me you do not have enough knowledge on this subject to have an intelligent conversion about it. Further more although I do believe as Arminius did, he nor I believe that everyone who asks Jesus in their heart is automatically saved.
So am I wrong that calvinism came before armenism or that the accept Christ in your heart thing started about 40 years ago?

So you also don't believe in total depravity?
No limited atonement? I didn't know you were a univeralist.

The reason I believe we don't have a choice is because that was one of the first things I noticed when I started reading the bible.

Come on people, you can't choose to love God. Do you know why? Because you love sin. Jesus made it clear that you can't love both. He also said that if the SON makes you free, you will be free indeed. Also you have a harden heart. a heart of stone. Can we decide to make our heart flesh? Umm no.

If you believe that the verse says God desires the whole world to come to repentance then you would have to believe in universalism because the scriptures also say that God does all that He pleases.

The only thing a man can do is decide that life sucks and maybe God can fix his life. I don't know if you can even credit that to the man and not actually him being lead by the Holy Spirit to seek God. Because the scriptures also say that none seek God, all have went astray, each to their own way.


I wonder how many people believe that they should do what they hate to do so God doesn't throw them in hell.
 
Jan 8, 2009
7,576
23
0
#57
God does desire all to come to repentance that's why scripture says:

1Ti 2:4 who wants everyone to be saved and to come to know the truth.

And this is written in the context of praying for rulers and governing authorities.

The language used in scripture is always general, not specific. It says Christ died for the world, not Christ died for the elect. Calvinism/predestination is a subtle twist on scripture but it is 100% wrong. The word for elect has no special meaning, other than those who have accepted Christ.

1Jn 2:2 And he is the propitiation for our sins: and not for ours only, but also for thesinsof the whole world.

And predestination is always in context of God's plan of salvation in Jesus Christ, again, the meaning is general, it does not refer to specific choice of individuals for salvation, except in cases with those whom God has called to serve Him in the ministry like Paul.
 
P

Phoenix

Guest
#58
wow. dude let me tell you arminiasim did not come and twist that scripture until wesley came along. we were actually a calvinist nation in the beginning of the U.S. if you don't believe me look up Puritan beliefs.
 
D

Definition_Christ

Guest
#59
wow. dude let me tell you arminiasim did not come and twist that scripture until wesley came along. we were actually a calvinist nation in the beginning of the U.S. if you don't believe me look up Puritan beliefs.
Yeah! We are this because our fathers were!...

You may learn God doesn't go with the majority of people. The amount of people in a group doesn't determine if it is true or not.

I can give you many modern day examples like the Roman Catholic Church or we can go back to the days of Noah and God found ONE FAMILY righteous in His eyes and destroyed the rest of the world.

Population doesn't equal truth.
 
Apr 23, 2009
2,253
5
0
#60
My brother. We agree on many things. This is the one thing we disagree on. Doctorine. My church is reformed and so is most of my family. God bless you too brother. But I am not defending Calvinism I am defending scripture. Sola scriptura. You may not agree with me and I am completely fine with that. I am sorry though that I said that I lost my respect for you. That was more out of anger. And I apolagize for that. May God keep you grounded in His word watchmen
Thank you brother water under the bridge, you are a good brother in Christ. I thank God for men like yourself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.