The difference between discipline and punishment

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
S

Sirk

Guest
#41
Besides. You wormed your way out of answering the question. Can one be in fellowship with God without Christ?
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#42
Like I said, if it works for you to teach that God hates us unless we hear about Jesus... go right ahead. I just can't do that anymore.
You added the word hate. No where did I say to my son that God hates us.
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#43
You may as well just wait for the paint to dry and then you can just walk out of the corner of false doctrine you painted yourself into.
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#44
Besides. You wormed your way out of answering the question. Can one be in fellowship with God without Christ?
A Christian is never OUT of fellowship with God unless that person chooses not to live in God's never-ending love.
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#45
You added the word hate. No where did I say to my son that God hates us.
What do you call telling a child God has separated Himself from them? Love?
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#46
What do you call telling a child God has separated Himself from them? Love?
Sin/disobedience creates disconnection. You don't even have to use the bible to connect the dots to that truth. You're glitching out and forgetting the reparation part.
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#47
I child who isn't given the opportunity for reconnection and reparation is the one that is damaged. I doubt you'll watch the video but I'll post it for you anyway.

[video=youtube;apzXGEbZht0]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=apzXGEbZht0[/video]
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#49
I wish I had thought if saying something like this to my kids, esp. the two that are not following God. Good work, Sirk!
Exactly! I wish I had been more consistent.
I am sure you both are fine parents. Parenting is really a series of management decisions anyway. We do the best we can but the truth is that we all will screw up our kids in some way that they will need to work thru. I do know that my son will never question his value to me. I've made it my mission in life to get that one right.
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#50
I child who isn't given the opportunity for reconnection and reparation is the one that is damaged. I doubt you'll watch the video but I'll post it for you anyway.

[video=youtube;apzXGEbZht0]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=apzXGEbZht0[/video]
Who initiated the "reconnection?" The mother (God) did by letting the child know that she had not really ever "separated" herself from the child. She shows "love" without the child doing anything but being confused and frustrated. This is exactly how God always shows us He has not stopped loving us (separated himself from us.) Not by stolidly waiting until we prove our worthiness.

If they performed this same experiment the next day, the same things would have happened... the child would fuss and cry. And then if they kept doing it day after day, it would be repeated each time they tortured the child with this doubt and insecurity.

What "lesson" has been taught to this child? None. It is just repeatedly being frustrated.
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#51
Who initiated the "reconnection?" The mother (God) did by letting the child know that she had not really ever "separated" herself from the child. She shows "love" without the child doing anything but being confused and frustrated. This is exactly how God always shows us He has not stopped loving us (separated himself from us.) Not by stolidly waiting until we prove our worthiness.

If they performed this same experiment the next day, the same things would have happened... the child would fuss and cry. And then if they kept doing it day after day, it would be repeated each time they tortured the child with this doubt and insecurity.

What "lesson" has been taught to this child? None. It is just repeatedly being frustrated.
Oh willie. Life is full of the good and the bad. The ugly is when there is no reconnection. Now you're just arguing for the sake of arguing....and out of ignorance no less. The video was an illustration of what happens to a person when there is no reconnection. I can't help you see outside of your tunnel.
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#52
Someone told me privately this morning that you could not let this rest until you had gotten in the last word. I could hardly believe what they said. But, now that I have tried to let you have the last post, some three times now, I see that they just might be right. So make your reply to this, and unless you just insist on a come-back, I will let you content yourself with believing you are right in everything. Let's just hope it works out that way.
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#53
Someone told me privately this morning that you could not let this rest until you had gotten in the last word. I could hardly believe what they said. But, now that I have tried to let you have the last post, some three times now, I see that they just might be right. So make your reply to this, and unless you just insist on a come-back, I will let you content yourself with believing you are right in everything. Let's just hope it works out that way.
Now you're being a crybaby. You couldn't argue on the merits of the OP from the get go. Then you wouldn't answer direct questions about who Jesus is. Gimme a break.
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#54
I see a counselor twice a month. Not only does he specialize in restorative therapy for adults but he is also a child counselor. I brought this to him with with all of the details as to how the op went down...because I always use his extra set of eyes with not only my struggles and trials but with my parenting as well. It should be noted that he is also a Christain man. He told me that this was fantastic parenting. There is nothing to be undone with how I taught my child and that this was great discipleship.

For the record Willie...I believe you took a low view of me when you said I posted this for a pat on the back. The truth is...I posted this as an example of what real discipleship looks like and I am very good at discipling my son.
 
Last edited:
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#55
Interesting. But, shouldn't you have told him the true reason Adam and Eve had to leave the garden? He's going to get enough mixed-up "explanations" in his life without you starting him out with mistakes he will later have to correct on his own.
And I simply told you that I cannot, with a clear conscience, get behind telling our children inaccuracies about the Bible, even if we do feel doing so makes a good story lesson. You, not me, are the one who took that one plain statement and turned it into somehow being an affront to your parenting skills.
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#56
And I simply told you that I cannot, with a clear conscience, get behind telling our children inaccuracies about the Bible, even if we do feel doing so makes a good story lesson. You, not me, are the one who took that one plain statement and turned it into somehow being an affront to your parenting skills.
So why didn't you just share this supposed inaccuracy?
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#57
Let's just do it like this. What was scripturally innacurrate about the lesson I taught my son in the op?
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#58
Let's just do it like this. What was scripturally innacurrate about the lesson I taught my son in the op?
The beauty of the lesson you COULD have taught him is just what I posted, Genesis 3:22-24.

God had already given them the immediate punishment of the childbirth pain and the sweat-of-the-brow, working the soil. The true love came when He blocked their continued access to the Tree of Life. By doing what appeared (to them... and I guess, you, too) to be even more punishing, He was actually putting them in line to one day be able to receive even more gloriously ETERNAL life than that which they enjoyed in the garden when Jesus finally came and took care of the punishing law they were now going to have to live under.

My only question was that you would withhold the most wondrous part of the Garden Story by saying God kicked them out of the home he provided for them because they disobeyed. No, they got their "spanking", as it were, in the curses pronounced on them. The expulsion was, though they didn't recognize it, the "leading" of God into the plan of redemption.

And the "separating Himself" from them was totally contrary to what is shown in the story, in which He remained right there with them, first, searching them out when THEY were separating themselves from Him by hiding, then talking with them, then clothing them, etc. And Eve even said, later when her child was born, that this "was the child God had given her."

This is the kind of love I think a child needs to understand.... not a Father-figure who runs His kids off in anger, barring the way for them to return home with a flaming sword. I think a child needs to see, that right from the very first sin, that God set up a plan to bring them home to Him.
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#59
The beauty of the lesson you COULD have taught him is just what I posted, Genesis 3:22-24.

God had already given them the immediate punishment of the childbirth pain and the sweat-of-the-brow, working the soil. The true love came when He blocked their continued access to the Tree of Life. By doing what appeared (to them... and I guess, you, too) to be even more punishing, He was actually putting them in line to one day be able to receive even more gloriously ETERNAL life than that which they enjoyed in the garden when Jesus finally came and took care of the punishing law they were now going to have to live under.

My only question was that you would withhold the most wondrous part of the Garden Story by saying God kicked them out of the home he provided for them because they disobeyed. No, they got their "spanking", as it were, in the curses pronounced on them. The expulsion was, though they didn't recognize it, the "leading" of God into the plan of redemption.

And the "separating Himself" from them was totally contrary to what is shown in the story, in which He remained right there with them, first, searching them out when THEY were separating themselves from Him by hiding, then talking with them, then clothing them, etc. And Eve even said, later when her child was born, that this "was the child God had given her."

This is the kind of love I think a child needs to understand.... not a Father-figure who runs His kids off in anger, barring the way for them to return home with a flaming sword. I think a child needs to see, that right from the very first sin, that God set up a plan to bring them home to Him.
Ok. Now I understand what you were trying to say.
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#60
Thank you. And, my wife just read these last few posts. She tore me up!

She said.... "You're a therapist with a quarter of a century of experience, and you were stupid enough to use the inflammatory "YOU" word when discussing this kind of subject?

She's right. I just wasn't thinking of replying in clinical mode. I'm sorry.