Would You Feel Uncomfortalble If A Young Person Saw You As A Parental Figure?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

seoulsearch

OutWrite Trouble
May 23, 2009
14,943
4,584
113
#1
Hey Everyone,

As I wrote in another post, I recently had some issues with a 20-year-old male here who persistently asking me some very personal questions without ever conversing with me before.

When I wrote that I didn't feel that what he was asking me was appropriate, he wrote back saying that he was a young man looking for a wife and that he wanted me to tell him what kind of woman to marry. "Please," he said, "You are such an intelligent woman. Advise me as you would a son."

I wrote him that there are several other wiser, more experienced women here who DO have children and that he would be much better off asking them (Banana, please forgive me but I told him to PM you.) I am certainly not trying to throw anyone under the bus, but I figured that if his questions were sincere, you'd have a lot better advice to give him. And if his motives aren't so pure (because the implication and nature of his questions were very sexual), I know you'll put an end to any riff raff faster than it takes to cook up a good Mooseburger. :)

However, this whole situation also made me take an honest look in the mirror. I'm getting older. And it's quite possible that a young person in the future may want to view me as a parental figure. I don't have children of my own but was very much a mother to an ex's young children. Their own mother had passed away, and so for a few years, I was all they knew, and I failed miserably in pretty much every area.

I. Am. Not. Comfortable At All. With the thought of someone seeing me as a Mom to them. It doesn't mean I wouldn't feel completely honored by this privilege or that I wouldn't love them with all my heart, but I am much more comfortable in the role of Auntie or Big Sister, and that's how I would ask them to see me, if possible.

To me, the role of "mother" or "father" is so sacred and so hard-earned... that I just don't feel at all right about stepping into that role or title without having earned it myself. But I also realize, God may have other plans, and at some point, there are others He may very well want me to be a "mother" to.

However, as I said, unless it was a very young child, or God worked out some major changes in my heart, I would forever plead to be seen as an aunt or sister, regardless of whether it was a young man or young woman.

What do the rest of you think about being seen as a "Mom" or "Dad" to someone else?

Everyone is welcome to post--I realize that for those of you who are parents already, it probably won't seem like a big deal.

But I am especially interested to hear from those who have ran into situations in which someone HAS wanted to see you as a surrogate or substitute parent--and how you have responded.
 

seoulsearch

OutWrite Trouble
May 23, 2009
14,943
4,584
113
#2
P.S. The other reason that being asked to see someone as my "son" creeps me out is because as I've become older, the singles groups and Bible studies of the churches I've attended are always split into the following groups: 20-30's; Marrieds and/or People With Kid's; 50 And Above.

People almost always assume I'm around 28-30 and I have always been a part of the 20-30-something groups, whom I've come to see as peers and/or younger siblings and most definitely NOT my children! I tend to relate to this group the most because some don't have kids and are in a place of trying to figure out what God's next step is for their life ("Should I get married? Go to school? Pursue such-and-such career?") which is often how I see myself as well.
 
S

sassylady

Guest
#3
Not crazy about it. I've been a single mom for 10 years and don't need anymore than I already have to be responsible for. But if one of my kids' friends needs some advice I don't have a problem with that as long as it's not a hang around everyday, looking for help/advice.
 
Sep 6, 2013
4,430
117
63
#4
I've adopted a somewhat motherly role to friends of my daughters in the past. They didn't have a good family life and needed influence and guidance, and I was thankful to be able to provide those in small amounts for them. I've mentored younger ladies as well, though that seems more of a "big sister" role to me. No problem for me with any of these roles, but they all involved girls.

A boy past a certain age needs to speak to a male parental figure about anything of a sexual nature.
 
Aug 2, 2009
24,579
4,268
113
#5
I think it would be awesome!! Until they start demanding a raise in their allowance...

 
M

MissCris

Guest
#6
I've talked about this with my mom before. Growing up, my sister, brother, and I had friends over constantly. A lot of the time, a couple of them would be there on a daily basis- first thing in the morning during the summer and on weekends, and every day after school, and they'd stay the night any time our mom would allow it (which was often). It was sort of like having extra siblings.

These friends...mine, my sister's, my brother's...they didn't call our mom "Mom", but they loved her and respected her and behaved better for her than they did their own parents. They simply gravitated to our house, these kind of lost kids who all came from unstable and broken homes. They knew exactly what to expect as far as the rules went (which were sort of strict), they knew they could count on sitting down at the table with everyone for dinner, they knew there was someone there who would be happy to help with homework or school projects or even just the random things we'd decide to make/build/cook/bake.

They knew that staying over on a Saturday night meant they also had to attend church with us the following morning.

All these years later, these lost kids are now adults, and a few of them have mentioned how grateful they are to my mom for being sort of a foster parent to them, for letting them escape their own homes to be with a family like ours for a while.

The weird part to me is that our home, our family, was totally dysfunctional. My parents were divorced, I had a crazy step-dad (I guess it was a funny kind of crazy though, as all our friends thought he was awesome), we fought, we argued, we yelled...to me, it was a place *I* wished I could escape from (though admittedly that wasn't until I was 14 or 15).

So, I've asked my mom how she felt about having all these "extra" kids when we were younger. She was honestly surprised to hear that any of them felt gratitude for her simply allowing them to hang out at our house. But she said "If it kept even one of them from going too far down the wrong road, then I'm glad, and would do it again. It was a pain sometimes, having six or seven teenagers raiding the fridge or lounging on my couch. It was a little awkward when they'd want to call me Mom, or if they compared me to their own parents. But those kids were desperate for someone to be the boss. I'm glad I was able to help them that way." (sort of paraphrased, since I can't remember every single word exactly, but yeah)

So for me, while I've never had anyone wanting me to be a parental figure (aside from my own munchkins), at some point, I'll probably face that situation. And I hope that I can do so without feeling put upon or burdened. I can imagine it may feel uncomfortable- even having "practice" as a parent, it would probably feel odd, awkward, uncomfortable to have someone else's child regarding me as a mother.

I'm okay with that. I would rather have somebody looking to me as a mother and asking for help than to see them floundering around because their own parent/s are unable or unwilling to be there for them.

I do think, however, that should that situation arise, I would want to be very clear with the person that I cannot fill their mother's role, that I am Not their mom, but that I am willing to do what I can to help them out.

And I don't see anything at all wrong with preferring to be seen as more of an aunt or a sister- if that's what makes you feel more at ease with helping somebody, or being an example for them, then I don't see why you should feel forced into a more parental role.

For most people who are growing up or have grown up without strong parental guidance, what they're really looking for is simply someone who cares, and some type of stability and boundaries. Those things don't have to come from a mom, or a dad (though of course that's the ideal, but then, this world is messed up and that doesn't happen so often as it should). Anyone who can show them love, and be reliable, and also offer correction when needed...that's what these people need. You don't have to have the title of "Mom" or "Dad" to offer those things.

P.S.- sorry if my post is sort of all over the place, I wanted to respond with something helpful here but I've also got a circus happening in my living room.
 

gypsygirl

Senior Member
Sep 19, 2012
1,394
60
48
#8
as i've mentioned many times in here, i am very involved with a girls' jr. high group as a volunteer in the schools, and over time, tend to cultivate rather personal relationships with many of them. they all have my phone number and often touch base with me over the week (in addition to seeing them once a week) with questions, .


i really can't define the relationships though. it's possible that a few see me as quasi-parental, but i don't know whether they see me as all that responsible.

it wasn't all that long ago that i was scolded by one of the girls and informed that cart wheels aren't allowed in the hallway. : )

i certainly feel a protective, nurturing sense toward them, but i don't really care whether they view me as a "big sister", aunt, teacher, maternal, or just some random chick who loves them. the label doesn't really concern me.
 

Liamson

Senior Member
Feb 3, 2010
3,078
69
48
#9
there is something really attractive about this though.....

 
Jun 30, 2011
2,521
35
0
#10
Hey Everyone,

As I wrote in another post, I recently had some issues with a 20-year-old male here who persistently asking me some very personal questions without ever conversing with me before.

When I wrote that I didn't feel that what he was asking me was appropriate, he wrote back saying that he was a young man looking for a wife and that he wanted me to tell him what kind of woman to marry. "Please," he said, "You are such an intelligent woman. Advise me as you would a son."

I wrote him that there are several other wiser, more experienced women here who DO have children and that he would be much better off asking them (Banana, please forgive me but I told him to PM you.) I am certainly not trying to throw anyone under the bus, but I figured that if his questions were sincere, you'd have a lot better advice to give him. And if his motives aren't so pure (because the implication and nature of his questions were very sexual), I know you'll put an end to any riff raff faster than it takes to cook up a good Mooseburger. :)

However, this whole situation also made me take an honest look in the mirror. I'm getting older. And it's quite possible that a young person in the future may want to view me as a parental figure. I don't have children of my own but was very much a mother to an ex's young children. Their own mother had passed away, and so for a few years, I was all they knew, and I failed miserably in pretty much every area.

I. Am. Not. Comfortable At All. With the thought of someone seeing me as a Mom to them. It doesn't mean I wouldn't feel completely honored by this privilege or that I wouldn't love them with all my heart, but I am much more comfortable in the role of Auntie or Big Sister, and that's how I would ask them to see me, if possible.

To me, the role of "mother" or "father" is so sacred and so hard-earned... that I just don't feel at all right about stepping into that role or title without having earned it myself. But I also realize, God may have other plans, and at some point, there are others He may very well want me to be a "mother" to.

However, as I said, unless it was a very young child, or God worked out some major changes in my heart, I would forever plead to be seen as an aunt or sister, regardless of whether it was a young man or young woman.

What do the rest of you think about being seen as a "Mom" or "Dad" to someone else?

Everyone is welcome to post--I realize that for those of you who are parents already, it probably won't seem like a big deal.

But I am especially interested to hear from those who have ran into situations in which someone HAS wanted to see you as a surrogate or substitute parent--and how you have responded.

Nope, I try to model a stable man, to my nephews all the time
 

seoulsearch

OutWrite Trouble
May 23, 2009
14,943
4,584
113
#11
I think part of what would make me uneasy is whether or not certain lines of expectation were crossed.

For instance, if someone saw me as a "Mom" whom they could talk to and spend time with, maybe take them out to lunch and to the movies, etc. I love all the stories here of people who have become adopted parents to those in dysfunctional homes, even if their own home life was less than perfect.

But if they expected me to take on the responsibility of a parent--for instance, if a younger person then EXPECTED me to take them to or make every sacrifice to attend all their events (it's not that I wouldn't go, it would be about the expectation), be a cornerstone for moral decisions (let's say a young girl who was raised in a non-Christian home and didn't have a mother figure told me she was having sex and then expected me to help her with birth control choices), I would definitely feel that this is way, way out of my league.

I was once friends with a family... and started to spend time with a younger teenage daughter of the family. The mother specifically took me aside and told me, "If she starts to talk to you about 'personal things' (i.e., whether or not she's sexually active), be sure to come to me and let me know."

I was HORRIBLY, TERRIBLY uncomfortable with that. And for the better or worse, grew apart from both the girl and the family.
 
Last edited:
S

Shouryu

Guest
#14
I deal with it quite a bit, considering the nature of my profession, and the disheartening state of some children's homes these days. My students are always welcome to stay as long as I am present, and if they are allowed to do so...but I avoid being 'parental,' as keeping the relationship as professional as possible is necessarily simply to protect myself. (In this day and age when every adult is suspected of the intent of harming a child, I won't even let a student call me their friend.)

I can still give moral guidance and set a good example, but I have to do so at arms length, no matter what the student expects of me. At least in THAT role, I have definitely grown comfortable.
 
K

kenthomas27

Guest
#15
I've adopted a somewhat motherly role to friends of my daughters in the past. They didn't have a good family life and needed influence and guidance, and I was thankful to be able to provide those in small amounts for them. I've mentored younger ladies as well, though that seems more of a "big sister" role to me. No problem for me with any of these roles, but they all involved girls.

A boy past a certain age needs to speak to a male parental figure about anything of a sexual nature.

What's the cutoff age, ya think?
 
R

Refs-Andinn

Guest
#16
Hello young woman - getting older.

Your dilemma is very understandable. For reasons I think you realize yourself. But it is like this; humans are human - they do wrong, get ill, die, collaps. And all without any malice. The parental role SHOULD be sacred. But it is not. For sometimes the parents are the ones that do a person most harm. We must never trust or be obidiant to anybody - just because of his/her -supposed- role. We must evaluate anybody that enters our lives and jugde them on our own tearms.
One must earn trust and respect. People that are ,,supposed,, to help you and ,,know better,, are not always such.

I say to you then; do not be so worried about how others might or might not see you. Be thankful if you feel able to help anyone. And you know people are not so clear - cut ; not you either. A person that has past adoulesence might have missed out on having parental guidence al togeather in their life. That means a big whole is unfilled. Give the best advice to anybody who seeks it -that you can. Tell them though to think and decide everything for themselfs in the end. You have very strong motherly talents - and if you even do never have a child of your own - this might give your life more purpose. If you give the guide lines right away - how the connection is going, and not - going to be for you and a brother or sister you help. They will respect that. And the more motherly u are to them - the less romantic interest they will have in you.


Bless you my sister, and be happy;

RA
 

jogoldie

Senior Member
Mar 20, 2014
1,616
48
48
#17
My sister soul.........I think you are exactly what God made you to be............we all have differant roles God gives us........and the one you feel comfortable with is just that...........made for you and designed by God......this young man was out of line......you were right to respond as you did..
I love your posts...........compassionate and kind.........you give solid advice..........
Don't let some creep let you second guess who you are...........if he had come to me ...as I feel like I'm every bodies mom......I would have pm..one of our strong brothers here .......and get him to ask them the same questions............I'm sure they would have shut it down.............don't let them steal your joy
my friend.............cause we all love you............peace...jo
 
Jan 19, 2013
11,909
141
0
#18
Hey Everyone,

As I wrote in another post, I recently had some issues with a 20-year-old male here who persistently asking me some very personal questions without ever conversing with me before.

When I wrote that I didn't feel that what he was asking me was appropriate, he wrote back saying that he was a young man looking for a wife and that he wanted me to tell him what kind of woman to marry. "Please," he said, "You are such an intelligent woman. Advise me as you would a son."

I wrote him that there are several other wiser, more experienced women here who DO have children and that he would be much better off asking them (Banana, please forgive me but I told him to PM you.) I am certainly not trying to throw anyone under the bus, but I figured that if his questions were sincere, you'd have a lot better advice to give him. And if his motives aren't so pure (because the implication and nature of his questions were very sexual), I know you'll put an end to any riff raff faster than it takes to cook up a good Mooseburger. :)

However, this whole situation also made me take an honest look in the mirror. I'm getting older. And it's quite possible that a young person in the future may want to view me as a parental figure. I don't have children of my own but was very much a mother to an ex's young children. Their own mother had passed away, and so for a few years, I was all they knew, and I failed miserably in pretty much every area.

I. Am. Not. Comfortable At All. With the thought of someone seeing me as a Mom to them. It doesn't mean I wouldn't feel completely honored by this privilege or that I wouldn't love them with all my heart, but I am much more comfortable in the role of Auntie or Big Sister, and that's how I would ask them to see me, if possible.

To me, the role of "mother" or "father" is so sacred and so hard-earned... that I just don't feel at all right about stepping into that role or title without having earned it myself. But I also realize, God may have other plans, and at some point, there are others He may very well want me to be a "mother" to.

However, as I said, unless it was a very young child, or God worked out some major changes in my heart, I would forever plead to be seen as an aunt or sister, regardless of whether it was a young man or young woman.

What do the rest of you think about being seen as a "Mom" or "Dad" to someone else?

Everyone is welcome to post--I realize that for those of you who are parents already, it probably won't seem like a big deal.

But I am especially interested to hear from those who have ran into situations in which someone HAS wanted to see you as a surrogate or substitute parent--and how you have responded.
I think the person who contacted you was a troll.
 

seoulsearch

OutWrite Trouble
May 23, 2009
14,943
4,584
113
#19
I think the person who contacted you was a troll.
I'm pretty sure as well, but I usually try to turn any experience here, whether negative or positive, into an idea for a thread and hopefully, a good discussion. ;)