The Social Structure of our Networks

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Rachel20

Senior Member
May 7, 2013
1,639
105
63
#1
Here’s an exercise. Think about all the people that you talk to/correspond within the last 2 months and with repetitive frequency.

How similar are they to you? Do they share the same profession, have the same interests and how well do they get along with your personality quirks?

These people form the “network” you associate with and they are in sum total your social capital.
Your social capital and network will also increase if you increase the length of time of correspondence. However this thread is not to measure the worth of your social capital.

This is to ask about our affiliation and affinity patterns.

According to Burt Reynolds, (author of Structural Holes) our networks are marked by their similarity.
That would seem like common sense too.

Without going into much depth in this, there are individuals who seek out people different to them and their networks are more vast and efficient.

I, too have consistently strived to do so – seek people with different opinions, hear people out from different walks of life and broaden my perspective on life.

However, lately, I realize that there comes a certain barrier with education and social classes. Even in terms of generational gaps.

It might sound elitist, but it is a waste of time to discuss things with narrow-minded people and what’s more giving them an opportunity to give you their feedback, gives them a chance to be invested in your decisions.

I am more a fan of inner circles than ever. I trust my family the most – and I have no problem correlating with them.
My real life church family too is fantastic. I have no issues with confiding with them and growing with them.
I do notice we have a thread of similarity – we all come from a certain socio-economic background.

So the question is – is it possible to move past this in Christianity? Are churches also clustered in a similar fashion – similar people go to worship together. Similar people cluster in similar denominations and so forth.

Even those who are missionaries congregate and seek people in the same missions.
Unity in churches is in clusters. I do know that the Kingdom of God has people from all different backgrounds so does this clustering of similarity go against that principle?

Should we consciously be seeking out those who are different than us?
 

Rachel20

Senior Member
May 7, 2013
1,639
105
63
#2
I do want to add that similarity in terms of socio-economic background is one example.

Any interests that brings us together should suffice as a condition for similarity.

As an inference, all Christians have a base condition of similarity.
 
C

CallmeQ

Guest
#3
Quote i love: Want to see yourself in 5 years, look at your closest freinds.
 

Huglife

Senior Member
Aug 15, 2016
2,543
50
48
#4
In social media, such as facebook, they purposefully surround us with people who think similar thinks to the user. They do this so that it seems more people have a lot in common with that user.

Personally, I do think we should look for people different then us. For one, it widens our view of the world. Allows to see it from their eyes. I have a friend who is literly the exact opposite from me. She's optimistic, energetic, LOUD. I am none of these things. But it is interesting to see the world from her eyes, from one with views like her.

If we do not seek others that are different then us, then we slowly build a wall around ourselves, separating us from other views of the world.
 

Rachel20

Senior Member
May 7, 2013
1,639
105
63
#5
In social media, such as facebook, they purposefully surround us with people who think similar thinks to the user. They do this so that it seems more people have a lot in common with that user.
That is true! Networks are built on affinity and social media strives to find similarity points. :) {its can be mutual friends, geographic location etc}

Personally, I do think we should look for people different then us. For one, it widens our view of the world. Allows to see it from their eyes. I have a friend who is literly the exact opposite from me. She's optimistic, energetic, LOUD. I am none of these things. But it is interesting to see the world from her eyes, from one with views like her.

If we do not seek others that are different then us, then we slowly build a wall around ourselves, separating us from other views of the world.
I agree. Well said.

I do want to ask you about your friend though - where did you meet her?
 

Huglife

Senior Member
Aug 15, 2016
2,543
50
48
#6
That is true! Networks are built on affinity and social media strives to find similarity points. :) {its can be mutual friends, geographic location etc}



I agree. Well said.

I do want to ask you about your friend though - where did you meet her?
She was in my class a few years back.
 
Aug 2, 2009
24,580
4,268
113
#7
Here’s an exercise. Think about all the people that you talk to/correspond within the last 2 months and with repetitive frequency.

How similar are they to you? Do they share the same profession, have the same interests and how well do they get along with your personality quirks?

These people form the “network” you associate with and they are in sum total your social capital.
Your social capital and network will also increase if you increase the length of time of correspondence. However this thread is not to measure the worth of your social capital.

This is to ask about our affiliation and affinity patterns.

According to Burt Reynolds, (author of Structural Holes) our networks are marked by their similarity.
That would seem like common sense too.

Without going into much depth in this, there are individuals who seek out people different to them and their networks are more vast and efficient.

I, too have consistently strived to do so – seek people with different opinions, hear people out from different walks of life and broaden my perspective on life.

However, lately, I realize that there comes a certain barrier with education and social classes. Even in terms of generational gaps.

It might sound elitist, but it is a waste of time to discuss things with narrow-minded people and what’s more giving them an opportunity to give you their feedback, gives them a chance to be invested in your decisions.

I am more a fan of inner circles than ever. I trust my family the most – and I have no problem correlating with them.
My real life church family too is fantastic. I have no issues with confiding with them and growing with them.
I do notice we have a thread of similarity – we all come from a certain socio-economic background.

So the question is – is it possible to move past this in Christianity? Are churches also clustered in a similar fashion – similar people go to worship together. Similar people cluster in similar denominations and so forth.

Even those who are missionaries congregate and seek people in the same missions.
Unity in churches is in clusters. I do know that the Kingdom of God has people from all different backgrounds so does this clustering of similarity go against that principle?

Should we consciously be seeking out those who are different than us?
That is why I loved chatting with you. You're a deep thinker and I'm a deep thinker too, and you're not obsessed with some extremist view like a lot of deep thinkers do. Now there's no one to talk to... :(
(did I just rhyme?)
 

Rachel20

Senior Member
May 7, 2013
1,639
105
63
#8
That is why I loved chatting with you. You're a deep thinker and I'm a deep thinker too, and you're not obsessed with some extremist view like a lot of deep thinkers do. Now there's no one to talk to... :(
(did I just rhyme?)
Aww we are friends! We can always talk! Sorry, I have been super busy.

Yes that did rhyme... it would be a good song chorus!:p
 
Aug 2, 2009
24,580
4,268
113
#9
Aww we are friends! We can always talk! Sorry, I have been super busy.

Yes that did rhyme... it would be a good song chorus!:p
I was going to end it with.... "So I'll just stare at my shoe.." :p

I know you're busy. I just haven't had anyone to talk to for awhile. :/
 
Last edited:

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
24,909
8,162
113
#10
Quote i love: Want to see yourself in 5 years, look at your closest freinds.
My best friend is married. He's been my best friend for a good 17 years now.

...

...

My wife must have been delayed somehow.