Half sister hates me; my mom wants me to fix it.

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Jun 30, 2013
35
0
6
#1
My half-sister has always hated me. She always find ways to blame me for almost everything. She hates my Dad when he came to my mom's life. Although her dad left them, and my dad was there in everything she needed. She's 10 years older than me. She worked abroad and felt the need to shoulder and support the family, though no one asked her to do that. It was such a burden for her to support the family and she never liked the idea. When she was pregnant with her daughter and the father of her daughter just left her, she would call me from overseas just to torture me and tell me that she hates me and that it's all mine and my brother's fault. She always blamed me of her miseries although I had known nothing about it as I was just young back then. And then she got my mom to Europe so that my mom can provide for the family. And then later on, my mom was able to bring us over to move with them. Me and my brothers never liked the idea of moving to Europe from Asia. But my sister always proudly say that it's thanks to her we have the kind of life we have. Don't mistake me, I am thankful to her and I always told her that. But I never ask her to sacrifice herself for the family, especially when she actually hated the idea of helping the family. As the eldest responsible sibling, she felt the need to help and provide for the family, because my mom always asks for her help. We would've been okay. Not that well off, but okay. But my mom wanted more so my sister provided more. She hates my mom for having us and having my dad added to her life.

My mom is very manipulative to the point that she'd always use the word to make us do what she wants. I'd always obey her because I thought that was the right thing to do, even though sometimes what she asks is not right in my heart and in the word of the Lord. "Honor your father and mother." The most abused scripture ever! Later on, when I went to college, it got a lot busier because of studying. It's double the effort for me because it's a foreign language. I also got bullied in school because I'm a foreigner. But I never told my problems to my family because I never wanted to add to their worries. I was always the jolly one at home, so I always make sure I make them laugh. At one point it became so heavy for me I can't keep up with the appearances. The stress from school, the stress at home, my mom being manic-depressed. Her problems have to be our problems as well, eventhough her problems are not really problems, she just like worrying. I exploded. My mom and I had a huge fight. I had never been angry in my entire life because I was taught that being angry is a sin. I was shocked. All these things happening at home plus my own problems just weighed too much. My mom, instead of helping me, was the biggest problems. She'd be like why am I always studying. Studying is not that important. Am I just showing off with my friends? She always throws those stuff to me. I have always been an A-student back in my country. My life revolved around, school, home, church. I wanted to do my extra best when we moved to Europe but it required a lot of effort because of the language barrier. And then I got bullied too. I come home to a mom who complains about every single thing. I couldn't study at home so it got me very frustrated because I wanted to do my best at school but I was failing because I couldn't study at home. If I go to a library, she'd be wanting me to go home immediately. It all weighed too much for me that I answered back at my mom for the first time. She slapped me, threw everything I was doing. I was 21. I got really angry so I also slapped her back and called the police on her. After that, she kept on trying to have the whole family talk to me because she says I'm rebelling. I said I wanted to go, but she begged me not to leave her so I didn't. I apologize for what I did from the bottom of my heart. I was shocked myself because I have never been that angry in my entire life. And slapping her was the nightmate of my life. I really apologized and asked for forgiveness. But my mom's definition of forgiveness is, "Yes, I forgive you. But you have to suffer first. You have to be on your knees." So she called for family intervention and for weeks they have all been treating me as if I'm the worst person alive.

My brothers and sister have always had issues with my mom. My mom and my sister would fight a lot and she would always say a lot of bad stuff to my mom, and making my mom feel like my sister is the boss because she's the one who provides. My dad is left in our country because my mom and my sister both hate him. My dad is a very good man, not perfect but he raised us up to be good people. My mom was always away working abroad while we were growing up. To live with her and my sister wasn't really a dream.

Anyway, things got worse in the house because of how everyone is treating me. Even after I asked for forgiveness and was really sorry for what I've done. There was totally no way I could study at home. My mom stopped going to church and would just stay in her room with nothing but just candles on. She use to practice witchcraft she said before she came to the Lord. And whenever she would get angry or she would get a fight with someone, she would go back to witchcraft. I don't think she is totally delivered because she herself doesn't want to let go of her demons. It was such a fight at home also spiritually. I would always seek for advice for my pastors and they would pray for me. But my family, especially my mom, really turned very negative towarda me. They even blamed the church and said I am brainwashed. At one point, I couldn't take it anymore. I ran away. I left them all and cut the connection with them for less than a year. I was so hurt with everything they did. I was praying if it was okay to leave, and a brother in the church, talked to me and confirmed what I had in my heart. So I left. And that brother came to my family and said that he stopped me from leaving! It made it all worse because that brother painted me black to my family. Even though he doesn't really know me. The church leaders wanted to discipline my mom and they have been trying, but my mom submits to no one. She has had the same problem from our previous churches. She never listen to the leaders, especially when the leaders are younger than her.

Later on, I made a move to fix it with my family and ask for forgiveness. I did everything I can and even more to fix it all. But things won't come back to the way they were. They want me back home. But I don't want to. Everything's fine with me now. We could still be family even though I don't live there. I'm 22 now and I want to live my own life. Something that my sister hated because she said she wasn't able to live her life because she was a slave to the family to provide. I don't really understand her, because if it was such a hard thing and a burden for her to help the family, why did she do it? And she makes us all feel that we owe everything to her. Before my fight with my mom, she always tells me, "It's your turn now. Your turn to suffer. I can go now and live my life with my daughter. You have to suffer. You have to experience the same thing." She always use to tell me those stuff. I ran away and chose to live my life. So she hates me more for doing that and for not suffering like she did. What can I do? I live my life and I wouldn't do things my heart doesn't want to do and especially if the Lord doesn't ask me to suffer. And ever since I left until now, she never talk to me. She has forbidden her daughter to see me. My niece was very close to me because I basically babysitted her for 5 years. And she tells my niece I am a bad person. They saw me once when they went to a cafe near my place. She just death-stared me as if she was ready to kill me. I greeted them and smiled because I was so happy to see them. But she clearly was not. She just stared at me with a really bad face and didn't even greet me back. So I just decided to walk on since she was pretty angry. She later told the incident to my mom and said that I ignored her and didn't greet her, which was the exact opposite of what happened.

I wrote a letter to her and apologized for whatever I did to hurt her. She blocked me from all the communications so there's no way I could contact her. My emails would go back to me because she blocked me also. But I felt like I had to write a letter and ask for her forgiveness if she was hurt that I left. But her problem with me is not suffering that way she did. And now, Christmas is near and my mom is constantly asking me and manipulating me that the only thing that will make her happy this Christmas is if I fix it with my sister.

I feel like it's unfair because I did everything I could. My sister clearly doesn't want to talk to me and see me because I am forbidden to go there and visit there if my sister is there. And now, my mom wants me to fix it with her? I have forgiven my sister and I set her free and gave it all to God. If she didn't want it fixed, what more can I do? My mom is scared at my sister because she's really bossy so my mom constantly ask me to fix it with my sister because she can't ask my sister to forgive. In my opinion, the only thing I did that could probably hurt her was leaving and cutting connections. But she apparently wasn't that hurt when I did that. Her problem was more me not suffering like she did.

What more can I do? In the eyes of the Lord, I have forgiven her and I also ask for her forgiveness and the Lord's for what I did. But further? I can't keep on running after a person who doesn't want me in her life. As much as I want my mom happy, I can't do more that what I did. Reconciliation requires both parties. I can't do it on my own.

So what to do? My mom won't accept any answer from me other than "I will fix it with my sister."
 

violakat

Senior Member
Apr 23, 2014
1,236
21
38
#2
I think the only thing you can do is choose is to pray for your family. I would also suggest talking to a pastor or older woman at your church who might could advise you what to do. Make sure they know the whole situation. In fact, print off what you wrote here and show it to them.
 
T

TemporaryCircumstances

Guest
#3
Geez....
Alright, well,
About your sister, and why she helped provide, I am (assuming) probably because she felt she had to. You mentioned your mom always asking for help, and so, while you didn't expect her to help, she may have thought your mother did. And what she has said to you, blaming you for not helping and "suffering" like she did, well, it was probably trying on her to try and support the family, and so that was her way of venting, is it a good way?
Definitely not, but her way nonetheless so don't take too much offense and don't let it weigh on you.

You seem to have a good head on your shoulders,
and while it probably could've been solved better on your part at times it is COMPLETELY understandable as to why you got angry and acted out. Anyone would get angry if they were in your spot, you have a lot to deal with.
Now, with the letters, that is an excellent idea I think, but, you do also have to be careful as to what you write in the letter. Be careful to not make it seem like you are blaming her and the family but (simply because it's the right thing to do) you can NOT just blame yourself for what happened.

Also, who checks the mail over there? Do you know?
And perhaps send an email to your mom, (very carefully, and patiently) planned out email, and ask her if she could make your sister read it.
Or do the same thing over phone, if you can call your mom and ask her to let you talk to your sister that would be great.

But, before doing anything I recommend coming up with a simple draft of what you'll say. When you speak it is never scripted, but planning beforehand may give you more confidence and help you to be more prepared and calm.

I am praying for you ♡
 
S

sunandbutterflies

Guest
#4
Conflict is not fun. Sorry to hear of the challenges that you have faced along the way.
Forgiving and asking for forgiveness are certainly important-God has forgiven us so great a debt, how can we do any less for others? I would also encourage you to pray for your mom and sister. You may also find it helpful to talk to a licensed counselor about what you have experienced and creating healthy boundaries. Remember that as much as it depends on us, we are to live at peace with all men. Sometimes, the knowing how much depends on me part gets to be a challenge. May God grant you wisdom, healing, and His grace for this situation
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#5
Generosity is giving more than you can, and pride is taking less than you need.
— Khalil Gibran
 

Dan58

Senior Member
Nov 13, 2013
1,991
338
83
#6
So what to do? My mom won't accept any answer from me other than "I will fix it with my sister."
Tell your mother that your half of the relationship with your sister isn't broken, and that you can't fix her half. Since your sister is angry and won't communicate, she's inconsolable. You can't very well fix someone who don't want fixing. Your mother is talking to the wrong daughter, your not the source of the problem. Sometimes its just best to leave all the hate and anger alone.
 

hornetguy

Senior Member
Jan 18, 2016
6,646
1,397
113
#7
I apologize if this sounds abrupt, but I think you need to move somewhere away from your immediate family, and start building your own life, with your own group of close, Christian friends.

Some relationships cannot be "fixed", and from reading your descriptions of your mom and sister, I'd say this is one of them. Especially, witchcraft???
You need to leave, and only be in distant communication with them, and only when YOU want to be. You need to take control of your life.... which is a difficult road at your age, but you can certainly do it, with God's help.
 
W

workinprogress

Guest
#8
Sounds to me like time would be the most helpful in your situation. Time goes by and things become a bit more clear for everyone involved and the dust settles so to speak.
 

Silverwings

Senior Member
Jul 27, 2016
1,368
495
83
#9
Difficult, difficult, indeed. Take care of yourself, give it to God, and read all you can find on dysfunctional families. My prayers
are with you.
 
A

AmmaBev

Guest
#10
I'm sorry you have been put in the middle of this dysfunctional family. It is not right for a child to "fix the family" as it seems your mother wants you to do.. Parents are to raise a child to function in the world independently from them. I hope your mother is getting counseling for her bi-polar. You must remember she has a mental illness and can't relate normally to you or the others. Congratulations on getting your college degree now so you can get employed and live elsewhere. You need not feel guilty. I noticed you said anger was a sin. The Bible says BE ANGRY but don't sin. Don't let sun go down on your anger. Ephesians 4. Jesus was angry when he saw the hypocrisy of the Pharisees in the temple when he overturned the tables. That anger was thought out, intentionally executed to make a point. It sounds like at times you become the one who is bullied. Is that right? no, you are redeemed and forgiven of all your sins Colossians 1:14. member of Christ's body 1 Cor. 12:27, adopted as God's child Eph. 1:5, free from condemnation Romans 8:1-2, cannot be separated from the love of God Romans 8:35-39, seated in the heavenly realm with Christ Eph. 2:6, can do all things through Christ who strengthens me Phil. 4:13http://family.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/26758/kw/26758 This article has to do with a controlling mother.
Grown Woman’s Mother Is Jealous and Possessive Not sure if the article came through but try both. AmmaBev
 
A

Ariel82

Guest
#11
Have you offered to pay your sister back for your plane ticket, room and board and other expenses used to get you set up in Europe she could have just saved for herself and her daughter?

Don't move back in with your mom or sister. That is a trap you are good to escape. I would examine your life and see what sacrifices your sister might have made you can repay her for. It might not mend the relationship but it's might be a start. Maybe help her learn how to stand up and say no to your mom also.

Witchcraft isn't a good thing and why isn't your father more in your lives?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Jun 30, 2013
35
0
6
#12
Hello you all, thank you for all the advices and prayers. I am still going through the same. I forgave them and released them already. But it's just very hard to cut ties from them because after all, they are still my family. I visit them every week for a couple of hours. But a lot of times, it doesn't really feel like I'm appreciated for doing what I do. I try to show my support to them, not because I should, but I want because after everything that has happened, I still want to show them that they matter to me and I want to show kindness even though a lot of times I don't think they deserve it. But I just really want to honor the Lord in my life in obeying the word about honoring my mom. It just really gets hard at times when I hear stuff from her that is not true or really offending. Something in me boils again and reminds me of what she did to me. Sometimes, makes me wonder if I have really forgiven her. Because I really do my best not to be annoyed and get frustrated with her, but it's her who keeps on looking back at the past, giving her comments to it, telling me what to do and so on. How can I honor her without disrespecting her? Because she thinks that I disrespect her when I don't listen to what she wants me to do. I am a firm believer of whatever you do, do it with your whole heart. And so if I don't do something out of my heart, aren't I sinning? That's how I look at it. And it gets so hard when she forces me to do something and I don't want to. I don't live there anymore, but whenever I come and visit, it always feels like, "Here's the rebel again. If you want to make things right, come back here and listen to everything I say." But for me, why can't we live in harmony and stay as a family without me having to go back there? And why can't she respect my decisions? It's not that I'm doing things wrong. She just wants me to do what she wants. Up until now, she's trying to manipulate me by making me feel guilty because she's unhappy that I am outside of the family just because I don't live there and don't listen to what she says. Whenever I visit, I always feel like a visitor, not a family. But I do that not just for her but also for my brothers who are stuck in there. I want to reach out to them and show them that I am not a bad person just because I left the house. I don't know... It gets really hard at times. I want to always do the right thing and I try to, but it always feel like I'm getting abused. And when I don't make an effort to visit them or contact them, they don't do anything. I always have to make the move.
 
Jun 30, 2013
35
0
6
#13
Yes. I do talk to my pastor in the church. They pray for me and they admire the kindness I give to my family even though I always just get abused in return. They are always open to hearing me out and giving me advices. But what other else to do but to pray for my family? Sometimes, I feel obligated to do more than just pray. That's why I keep on visiting them and spending time with them even though it feels like I'm not part of the family anymore... I really hope someday, they will see out of the box.
 
Jun 30, 2013
35
0
6
#14
I think the only thing you can do is choose is to pray for your family. I would also suggest talking to a pastor or older woman at your church who might could advise you what to do. Make sure they know the whole situation. In fact, print off what you wrote here and show it to them.
Yes. I do talk to my pastor in the church. They pray for me and they admire the kindness I give to my family even though I always just get abused in return. They are always open to hearing me out and giving me advices. But what other else to do but to pray for my family? Sometimes, I feel obligated to do more than just pray. That's why I keep on visiting them and spending time with them even though it feels like I'm not part of the family anymore... I really hope someday, they will see out of the box.
 
Jun 30, 2013
35
0
6
#15
Geez....
Alright, well,
About your sister, and why she helped provide, I am (assuming) probably because she felt she had to. You mentioned your mom always asking for help, and so, while you didn't expect her to help, she may have thought your mother did. And what she has said to you, blaming you for not helping and "suffering" like she did, well, it was probably trying on her to try and support the family, and so that was her way of venting, is it a good way?
Definitely not, but her way nonetheless so don't take too much offense and don't let it weigh on you.

You seem to have a good head on your shoulders,
and while it probably could've been solved better on your part at times it is COMPLETELY understandable as to why you got angry and acted out. Anyone would get angry if they were in your spot, you have a lot to deal with.
Now, with the letters, that is an excellent idea I think, but, you do also have to be careful as to what you write in the letter. Be careful to not make it seem like you are blaming her and the family but (simply because it's the right thing to do) you can NOT just blame yourself for what happened.

Also, who checks the mail over there? Do you know?
And perhaps send an email to your mom, (very carefully, and patiently) planned out email, and ask her if she could make your sister read it.
Or do the same thing over phone, if you can call your mom and ask her to let you talk to your sister that would be great.

But, before doing anything I recommend coming up with a simple draft of what you'll say. When you speak it is never scripted, but planning beforehand may give you more confidence and help you to be more prepared and calm.

I am praying for you ♡

Yes, I understand that she felt she had to do those things. It's just that I think it's unfair to put all the blame in me and make me suffer just because she did. And because I didn't, I am a bad person already, that I do not care for our family.

I wrote her a letter and was just very general. I told her that I actually greeted her when I saw her near my place, contrary to what she was spreading that I ignored her and just didn't greet her. Because she was actually the one who completely ignored me and just stared at me as if she's killing me in her head. I put that in that letter just to make it clear, because she's telling the whole family a very different story than what happened. But actually, because I'm not living there anymore, I am no longer part of the pack. So whatever I say and do wouldn't matter because family comes first. And according to them, I left the family, so they wouldn't listen to me.

I am just wondering if I should stop pushing myself into the family, since they make me feel like I lost my membership. No matter what I do and no matter how hard I try, they just can't release me and forgive me. It is so unfair because everything would've not happened had they not pushed me to my limits. Besides, I left the house when I was 20, so it's not that I was so underage and just rebelled like what they think.

Anyways, thank for the prayers! I need them! :) God bless!
 
Jun 30, 2013
35
0
6
#16
Conflict is not fun. Sorry to hear of the challenges that you have faced along the way.
Forgiving and asking for forgiveness are certainly important-God has forgiven us so great a debt, how can we do any less for others? I would also encourage you to pray for your mom and sister. You may also find it helpful to talk to a licensed counselor about what you have experienced and creating healthy boundaries. Remember that as much as it depends on us, we are to live at peace with all men. Sometimes, the knowing how much depends on me part gets to be a challenge. May God grant you wisdom, healing, and His grace for this situation

Yes! I am trying very, very, very hard to live in peace with them. And I really belive in the power of forgiveness. I forgave them and released them. The thing is, they make me feel that I don't have to forgive them because they're not the ones at fault: I am the one at fault. And they can't just give their forgiveness until I come back, be on my knees. And when they see that I've suffered enough, then and only then can they forgive me. But I don't want to do that because that's not how God forgives. That's not how it works. And I am not going to admit the things they accuse me for doing, when I didn't not do or say those things. Why should I ask forgiveness for something I did not do? They actually reversed the whole story to a point that I was actually the bad guy and they were the victim. It is so hard because for me, if you want to forgive then do and then forget it. Don't come back to it and count it again. But also, if you want clarification, then let's talk. But when we do, you should listen as well. Not just they talk and talk and I do what they want to do. Besides, they want to talk about how the whole thing happened, who was right and who was wrong. That's a tough game, because apparently, there are two different stories: mine and theirs. And because they're the family and I'm the outcast, I'm the liar. I am not speaking the truth. It hurts so much because I was the victim in all of these family drama, and I ended up because the liar and the rebel. My dad always taught me not to lie, because he hates it so much! That's why I don't do that. And something boils in me when I am accused of things I did not do or say. I want to fight and tell them the truth, but I am not heard. But in all of these, I really want to honor the Lord and just be kind. But even being kind is so hard, especially when you are being abused. You give them a hand, they take the whole arm...
 
Jun 30, 2013
35
0
6
#17
Generosity is giving more than you can, and pride is taking less than you need.
— Khalil Gibran

I am doing my utterbest to give them generosity in all aspects. I am just not appreciated in the end and thrown out of the family.
 
Jun 30, 2013
35
0
6
#18
Tell your mother that your half of the relationship with your sister isn't broken, and that you can't fix her half. Since your sister is angry and won't communicate, she's inconsolable. You can't very well fix someone who don't want fixing. Your mother is talking to the wrong daughter, your not the source of the problem. Sometimes its just best to leave all the hate and anger alone.
Exactly what I told my mom! But she always tells me, since I'm the younger one, I have to do the everything and be the better person. She thinks I'm just full of pride by not fixing it with my sister. But what can I do? I can't force her. If I come there, I'll just hear things that are not true, and then I'll end up defending myself, and then they will say, "See? You are really full of pride. Don't come here if you are not going to own up to everything." But not everything was my fault..
 
Jun 30, 2013
35
0
6
#19
I apologize if this sounds abrupt, but I think you need to move somewhere away from your immediate family, and start building your own life, with your own group of close, Christian friends.

Some relationships cannot be "fixed", and from reading your descriptions of your mom and sister, I'd say this is one of them. Especially, witchcraft???
You need to leave, and only be in distant communication with them, and only when YOU want to be. You need to take control of your life.... which is a difficult road at your age, but you can certainly do it, with God's help.

I did that. I left. That's why I'm an outcast to the family now. I still visit them and try to reach out to them. You know, just being the better person. But it drains me. Because I know, whatever I do, if I don't go back there, it won't matter. They still can't forgive me and accept me as the person I am today. So hard when it's your own family who's stabbing you and hurting you.
 
Jun 30, 2013
35
0
6
#20
Sounds to me like time would be the most helpful in your situation. Time goes by and things become a bit more clear for everyone involved and the dust settles so to speak.
I do hope it will get better someday. But my mom and sister are known to hold grudge as long as they can; they'd even carry it to their death. They have had so many conflicts with so many people in their life. They just always ran away and hold the grudge. They never confront, they never settle things down. They just let it as it is and never give people a chance.