Hopefully it is obvious that I love my children dearly. That's the point! Because I wanted a family, I invited these little wonders to take part in the curse. Statistically, most are never going to choose Christ. The question may have been better stated, since there is so much pain around, should I have mentored someone already born and could have put my resources into that child? By having my own, I added sin, because people are sinful? I'm trying to look at this logically, not emotionally. My children bring me great joy, but also, they suffer naturally because this world sucks. If they had never been born, they would not be faced with the decision to choose Christ. It is possible that one day my children may reject the gift of salvation. There may be one that I love dearly, tormented for eternity because I chose to be a dad.
FreeNChrist has knocked the nail on the head.
It is God who chose to give you children.
In fact I would say that it is God who gives life full stop.
John 1:3-4
All things were made through Him, and without Him nothing was made that was made. In Him was life, and the life was the light of men.
I have 4 kids, 2 were planned. We lived in a nice cosy house that was just the right size.
We were not trying for another. When my wife told me she was pregnant with our 3rd I went into deep depression.
Our house was just big enough, finances were tight.
After a while a close friend took me to task. They did not mince their words either. They told me not to be selfish, pull myself together and did I not realise that only God gives life, when he speaks life is formed, now start praising God for him trusting you with HIS child. That I did.
When my wife told me we were having our 4th, I laughed out loud and praised God and thanked him.
I wouldn't change a thing.
There are many people who try for children and do not have children, and vice versa.
Why I don't know but at the end of the day it's up to God and not us.
You didn't choose to be a dad, yes you wanted to be a dad but the truth is GOD CHOSE YOU TO BE A DAD.
By having children you have not added sin. Sin is already present. If you bring logic into it you may start to control the way you parent and not the way God wants you to parent. You will try to control rather than let go and let God do his stuff.
We need to trust God and give our kids back to him. I suffered the same anxieties you have and have found myself often giving my kids back up to God. Praying and crying out, help me to be the dad you want me to be, to be the dad that you are to me and help me to leave them in your hands.
You ask should I have mentored someone already born, that is someone else's child, not yours. As you mentor your own children who is not say that God would not use your children to mentor the child that you think you could put your resources into.
Be encouraged, trust God, he knows what he is doing.