"A white man's perspective"

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
G

GaryA

Guest
#1
The catalyst and trigger for this thread comes from the thread 'Georgia couple sentenced for terroristic threats towards children':

How can anyone criticize someone for being black? What "constructive intent" is there?
As for your question of "how can anyone criticize someone for being black?" I can answer that. Because some people are extremely ignorant...
I do not mean to put either of these people "on the spot"; rather, I thought this exchange might be a good place to start a very serious but hopefully worthwhile "conversation" that -- if handled properly by everyone who posts -- just-might-possibly help "bridge the gap" in some very long-running misconceptions involving "race-relations" of the past.

Although the foremost "examples" of this original post involve "white-black issues", the topic and discussion is intended to be "across-the-board" in terms of hoping to help all people understand - from another's perspecive - [ whatever ] "race issues" there are that need answers...


DO NOT post in this thread if you are not mature enough to discuss the topic objectively.



I am not trying to start anything or dig anything up out of the past!!!

DO NOT go there!!!



( We may talk about past events and issues, but there is no need to "re-live" the past. )


This thread is about helping people who have matured beyond the stupidity-of-the-past - that all [ groups of ] people touched by this topic have been guilty of - to have a better understanding of why these things are the way they are -- so as to try to enable them to "reconcile" these things by their Christian Faith in a God Who loves all of us the same and is "no respecter of persons"...


*** More than anything, I am trying to help non-white people to understand a white-people point-of-view. ***


My perspective certainly may not match exactly that of other white people.

I am going to be very candid here -- for the sake of clarity and understanding.

Please don't anyone get mad at me for trying to open a very honest and candid dialog that hopefully will be used to clear up a great deal of misunderstanding among people with long-unanswered questions. Keep in mind that what I say in this original post is strictly based on my personal experiences and observations.

It is not - in any way - intended to insult, belittle, or ridicule anyone.

If, at any point in time, you get the impression that I am - in any way - a 'racist' -- then, I would like to suggest that you have severely misunderstood my perspective and my intentions.

My intent is strictly and only to open an honest dialog whereby different people can come to understand each other's perspective on the topic.

Everyone - please be kind and considerate toward all others in this discussion.

I am sincerely trying to do a good thing here --- please don't destroy it...

I am willing to "step out on a ledge", here --- just to try to "do some good"...

If you really want this effort to become truely useful --- don't cause the thread to be locked because of your bad behavior...

Let me repeat:


DO NOT post in this thread if you are not mature enough to discuss the topic objectively.


~~~~~

"A white man's perspective"

~~~~~


How can anyone criticize someone for being black? What "constructive intent" is there?
As for your question of "how can anyone criticize someone for being black?" I can answer that. Because some people are extremely ignorant...
What you have to understand is --- what it really comes down to is not actually about skin color itself. Rather, it is about the "uniquely identifiable culture and characteristics" of a group of people "at-large" - as a group. Whether it is blacks, hispanics, Italians, Russians - whoever - there are certain things that come to be known, considered, or thought about concerning the group as a whole -- in such a way that these things get "uniquely associated" with the skin color, nationality, etc. - whatever identifying 'icon' may be attributable to that group of people. From there it becomes a 'label' for every individual in the group. This is the part that is in error.

All white people are not "the enemy" of black people -- although, a lot of black people have apparently been taught this while growing up. (+)

All black people are not ignorant, selfish, and uncaring -- although, a lot of white people have apparently been taught this while growing up. (+)

Based on my life-long experiences regarding black people...

~ "As a 'race' of people, I do not trust them any further than I can throw them..."

( as the saying goes... )

This is probably because -- where-and-when I grew up -- the vast majority of black people [ where-and-when I grew up ] seemed to have an 'attitude' about-and-towards white people such that - they would "just as soon" slit your throat - and not think anything of it - than to even look at you. This is "how bad" it really was - or, at least, seemed to be.

At the same time, however -- my parents taught me to "give every individual a clean slate" - i.e. - not to judge any individual "prematurely" without cause. In effect, my parents taught me:

"Be careful not to trust [ certain people * ] too readily -- but, don't be a 'racist'... Every individual is a human being, and should be treated as such -- at least until they give you a sufficient reason to do otherwise..."


* - blacks, hispanics, [ whoever ] - who were thought to have an 'attitude' and 'agenda' against white people ( outright, without cause )

In other words, don't be quick to label everyone in the group because of what some - or even most - of them do.

But, at the same time, don't be afraid to recognize or speak the truth about the group-as-a-whole if that-is-what-it-be. ( whatever it might be )

Now -- I should say at this point that I believe that 'race' is somewhat of a misnomer; according to the Bible, there is one 'race' - the human race...

To talk about "the white race" or "the black race" - or any other 'race' of people in this sense -- has its good use as an identifier for the group, but is basically incorrect according to the biblical definition of 'race' where humans are concerned.

~ In the course of time, while growing up, I discovered that -- it was certainly not the skin color of anyone that determined their 'attitude' and 'outlook' on life, other people, etc. Rather, it was:

~ What people were taught by their parents, neighborhoods, teachers, churches, etc. while they are growing up.

~ The extent that the 'inborn' "sin-nature" that we were all born with ( selfishness, etc. ) affected their thinking.

~ What kind of 'attitude' and 'disposition' that the person decided to have 'inside' based on their experiences.

~ After sufficient Bible study, while growing up, I came to realize that -- God loves all people the same.

Whites, Blacks, Everybody...



Do I think there are some really 'ignorant' black people out there? Absolutely!

There are also some really 'ignorant' white people out there.

( But, it is not because of their skin color that any of these people are that way... )


There are two things that I would like to say to all non-white people out there - each one being an "extension", of sorts, to the two statements marked with (+) above. Because of the expected length of the words that will be required to get each point across most effectively --- I will post them separately - a post for each idea I wish to present.

I believe that it would probably be best if you can wait for the other two posts before getting too deep into a reply to what I have written so far.

( You should understand what I mean by this after reading the other two posts. )

If you cannot wait that long, then - by all means - please politely post whatever thoughts you wish to add to the discussion at this point...

:)
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#2
I think we all already know racism in America is not really about skin color.

It is about our perceived (conditioned or taught... or even experienced) expectations of the other group. And this is almost entirely personal, and always comes from our pasts. So to state you want to talk without addressing those points kind of negates the whole issue of resolving the things that really cause division.

It's like saying we are, or should be "color-blind." This is insulting to both races. We very definitely should see and recognize the very obvious differences. But that should be no more our primary focus with the other group than it would be with members of our own ethnic group.
 

maxwel

Senior Member
Apr 18, 2013
9,324
2,413
113
#3
GaryA,

We live in a society where it is NOT possible to have this kind of discussion.

It isn't possible.



Have fun.
 
G

GaryA

Guest
#4
I think we all already know racism in America is not really about skin color.

It is about our perceived (conditioned or taught... or even experienced) expectations of the other group. And this is almost entirely personal, and always comes from our pasts. So to state you want to talk without addressing those points kind of negates the whole issue of resolving the things that really cause division.

It's like saying we are, or should be "color-blind." This is insulting to both races. We very definitely should see and recognize the very obvious differences. But that should be no more our primary focus with the other group than it would be with members of our own ethnic group.
You are "jumping ahead"... ( haha - that is okay )

( So many words still left to write - just to "begin the conversation"... )

I do not mean "talk without addressing those points"; I mean "let's not get caught up in the 'stupidity' that can come from addressing those points" ( i.e. - let's be very mature in our discussion - and - let's not "re-live" any past mistakes that have been made by people who have tried to have a constructive dialog on this topic and failed miserably because of those mistakes ).

Thank you for adding your comments; all of the points you make are definitely good material for discussion in this thread. I actually agree with what you are saying. That is what this thread is ultimately about, in terms of the discussion that may be had.

Unfortunately, it will take me some more time just to "finish" the "opening thoughts" that I intended for the thread. And, much more than that to complete an all-around view of my perspective on this topic. But - in time - Lord willing - I will get there...

:)
 
G

GaryA

Guest
#5
GaryA,

We live in a society where it is NOT possible to have this kind of discussion.

It isn't possible.



Have fun.
I think it could be if people wanted it badly enough...

And, one of my questions is -- how badly do people want it?

Is a platform of [ what should be ] - Christian love - enough?

We shall see...

:)
 

PennEd

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2013
12,923
8,654
113
#6
Division... division.... division.... I REFUSE to play the division game.

There are the saved, and the unsaved. I'd like there to be more saved. I'll preach the Gospel and love people. That's the ONLY healing I've EVER seen to be effective.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#7
I believe that it would probably be best if you can wait for the other two posts before getting too deep into a reply to what I have written so far.

( You should understand what I mean by this after reading the other two posts. )

If you cannot wait that long, then - by all means - please politely post whatever thoughts you wish to add to the discussion at this point...

:)
For everyone jumping the gun, Gary did ask for time to add two more posts.

To Gary, (for next time), suggestion: Write it all out in your word processing program, and then post all at once. Easier that way to stop people from jumping the gun. :)
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#8
GaryA,
We live in a society where it is NOT possible to have this kind of discussion.
It isn't possible.
Have fun.
No, it probably isn't possible if your intentions are to include ALL of our society in the discussion. Trying to get the Klan to see the Panther's POV is futile... and vice versa.

That's possibly why the OP said that if you are irreconcilably prejudiced of either view, to just pass this thread by.
 
G

GaryA

Guest
#9
For everyone jumping the gun, Gary did ask for time to add two more posts.

To Gary, (for next time), suggestion: Write it all out in your word processing program, and then post all at once. Easier that way to stop people from jumping the gun. :)
A very good suggestion, indeed... ;)

:)
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#10
For everyone jumping the gun, Gary did ask for time to add two more posts.

To Gary, (for next time), suggestion: Write it all out in your word processing program, and then post all at once. Easier that way to stop people from jumping the gun. :)
To be honest, if that stream of consciousness was but one-third of what he intends, as only a "starter", to get into, then this thread is possibly doomed to failure before it even begins. It is quite difficult to ask people to answer what amounts to a small book with thirty or forty points, in just a post or two in a forum.
 
G

GaryA

Guest
#11
Division... division.... division.... I REFUSE to play the division game.

There are the saved, and the unsaved. I'd like there to be more saved. I'll preach the Gospel and love people. That's the ONLY healing I've EVER seen to be effective.
I am not trying to create division between people; rather, the exact opposite.

If you wait long enough, and I get enough words written, you may just see how that this is a true statement...

:)
 
Dec 9, 2011
13,715
1,723
113
#12
GaryA,

We live in a society where it is NOT possible to have this kind of discussion.

It isn't possible.



Have fun.
:)Its possible If people will be brutally honest and the other side even though,offended,would be willing to accept the pain knowing that what they don't like about the other side Is true In their mind,then the starting point of the dicussion would be from ground zero and starting from truth,but I understand what you mean because most people can not stand truth that Is brutally honest without getting upset,but when people are allowed to say what they feel then I would rather start discussion from truth rather than someone telling me what they think I want to hear but It Is not true what they feel on the Inside.True progress can be made from that point and would benifit the children.

:)But then again things seem to better than they were so maybe time will right wrongs.
 
G

GaryA

Guest
#13
To be honest, if that stream of consciousness was but one-third of what he intends, as only a "starter", to get into, then this thread is possibly doomed to failure before it even begins. It is quite difficult to ask people to answer what amounts to a small book with thirty or forty points, in just a post or two in a forum.
But, isn't that precisely the problem with topics such as this one?

If no one is willing to make-or-hear sufficient dialog to gain a more full perspective before bringing in Judge, Jury, and Execution-of-a-sentence --- why should we not expect failure from the start?

This isn't supposed to be a poll; rather, it is supposed to be an ongoing discussion -- but, one that may require a bit more information than a one-joke-per-post thread in order to "set the stage" for the discussion...

And, I now have come to the conclusion that I must wait until later to write the other two posts... :(

"Work calls..."

So -- y'all will have to wait even longer...

"Oh, well..."

:)
 
Last edited:
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#14
But, isn't that precisely the problem with topics such as this one?

If no one is willing to make-or-hear sufficient dialog to gain a more full perspective before bringing in Judge, Jury, and Execution-of-a-sentence --- why should we not expect failure from the start?

This isn't supposed to be a poll; rather, it is supposed to be an ongoing discussion -- but, one that may require a bit more information than a one-joke-per-post thread in order to "set the stage" for the discussion...

And, I now have come to the conclusion that I must wait until later to write the other two posts... :(

"Work calls..."

So -- y'all will have to wait even longer...

"Oh, well..."

:)
Yes........... But a bit at a time, with back-and-forth interaction alternating between people. Starting with a multi-point lecture, you force anyone replying, to flood back with their own essay refuting (or even agreeing with) so many points in one post, that any true dialogue gets lost.
 
S

Susanna

Guest
#15
Too many lengthy posts:(.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#16
To be honest, if that stream of consciousness was but one-third of what he intends, as only a "starter", to get into, then this thread is possibly doomed to failure before it even begins. It is quite difficult to ask people to answer what amounts to a small book with thirty or forty points, in just a post or two in a forum.
Less than 2% of the world population has ever bought a Harry Potter book.

That weird factoid teaches me something. Not everyone is interested on any given subject, and yet, enough are interested that it doesn't matter if the majority aren't.

You don't like long post. Not a problem. Why do you then assume if you don't like it then...?

He did give if you don't have the time or desire, don't bother.
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#18
Less than 2% of the world population has ever bought a Harry Potter book.

That weird factoid teaches me something. Not everyone is interested on any given subject, and yet, enough are interested that it doesn't matter if the majority aren't.

You don't like long post. Not a problem. Why do you then assume if you don't like it then...?

He did give if you don't have the time or desire, don't bother.
Hide and watch. LOL
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
#19
I have had friends who are black, indian, Sri Lankan, Singaporian, Malysian, Australian, Japanese,
Korean, Eastern European, German, French, Portuguese, Chinese etc.

But in reality they are all individuals with different cultural heritages.
It takes time to understand the heritage and the emotional differences, but it can be learnt.

What is really the problem is cultural identity and what is accepted as the group role as a
member of one group against another. Once this polarises, conflict easily errupts.

I do not once hatred and hurt is buried deep in any social group it can leap generations and
work like cancer, eating away at people. It is this hatred that poisons many wells.

I knew a guy who grew up hating catholics and became a terrorist. He murdered people because
of this hatred. And that is were such hatred leads. It is so evil and so embedded it is only through
love and repentance can it be finally resolved.
 

RickyZ

Senior Member
Sep 20, 2012
9,635
787
113
#20
I've always found it interesting that we fight racism by promoting racism. And that those who most decry the separation of races are those who most fiercely refuse assimilation.