How would you help?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
T

TemporaryCircumstances

Guest
#41
Well, first I'd ask why, because until I know the story, I don't know if the person needs help.
I don't agree....
Momiji knew I needed help before she even knew what was wrong.


I don't know about others but most of the time I can see if someone needs help. Whether or not I know the story I can try to make them see that I'm a safe person to come to, I will listen, I will always be there if anyone needs me. Whether or not I know what's wrong
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#42
I don't agree....
Momiji knew I needed help before she even knew what was wrong.


I don't know about others but most of the time I can see if someone needs help. Whether or not I know the story I can try to make them see that I'm a safe person to come to, I will listen, I will always be there if anyone needs me. Whether or not I know what's wrong
This is the OP --
If someone told you they wanted to die how would you help them?
This is what I've heard/seen in my life:
-- "These streaks are so awful I want to die." (My cousin decided to put streaks in her dark hair. She did it wrong, so she had a top layer of white over very dark hair at the ripe age of 17. lol)

-- "What did we do so wrong that we are still alive and yet all our family and friends have died? Why are we still here?" (Said by my 94 year old great-uncle to his baby sister -- my grandmother -- when she was 90.)

-- The horrified face of my mother when she saw me the last time. Watching her walk into the bathroom and seeing agonizing pain at ever muscle moved to do just that.

So, seriously, first I'd ask why, because unless I know the story, I don't know if the person needs help.

Your mom didn't ask. I'm the kind of person who has to ask. Just because someone wants to die, doesn't mean they really want to die, nor does it mean they're suicidal. None of those people I mentioned wanted to commit suicide.

I know because I asked them how they were.

The assumption on this thread was someone wants to commit suicide. Without first finding out what's up with that person, how does anyone know?

And, frankly, since the person who asked this question asked it as first post and never said anything since, I'm guessing it was a matter of her checking in if strangers were okay with her killing herself, (at best.)

There is a time I won't ask, and that was then. The internet is no place for real counseling and it is a great place to pretend to be so much, that I won't chance someone else's life over my online hunches.
 
T

TemporaryCircumstances

Guest
#43
This is the OP --


This is what I've heard/seen in my life:
-- "These streaks are so awful I want to die." (My cousin decided to put streaks in her dark hair. She did it wrong, so she had a top layer of white over very dark hair at the ripe age of 17. lol)

-- "What did we do so wrong that we are still alive and yet all our family and friends have died? Why are we still here?" (Said by my 94 year old great-uncle to his baby sister -- my grandmother -- when she was 90.)

-- The horrified face of my mother when she saw me the last time. Watching her walk into the bathroom and seeing agonizing pain at ever muscle moved to do just that.

So, seriously, first I'd ask why, because unless I know the story, I don't know if the person needs help.

Your mom didn't ask. I'm the kind of person who has to ask. Just because someone wants to die, doesn't mean they really want to die, nor does it mean they're suicidal. None of those people I mentioned wanted to commit suicide.

I know because I asked them how they were.

The assumption on this thread was someone wants to commit suicide. Without first finding out what's up with that person, how does anyone know?

And, frankly, since the person who asked this question asked it as first post and never said anything since, I'm guessing it was a matter of her checking in if strangers were okay with her killing herself, (at best.)

There is a time I won't ask, and that was then. The internet is no place for real counseling and it is a great place to pretend to be so much, that I won't chance someone else's life over my online hunches.
She's not my mom.

Second,
I get what your saying, try spending a day in high school and you hear "I'm going to kill myself" more than 10 times a day.

But,
I've run into Ad---,
Who just needed someone to talk to, and I need not ask him why he wants to end his life, but I tell him that I'm here if he ever needs someone
Tre---,
Who I don't know why he has suicidal thoughts but still comes to be when he needs to
Zal----,
Who is the same

Personally,
When people ask me "Why do you want to end your life, kill yourself, or however else you want to put it"
My first thought is "Does this really matter? I've made it apparent that I don't want to be here, the reason won't matter once I'm gone why does it matter now?"

I knew a guy in middle school who tried to kill himself in class.
Have I ever found out why? Nope. Have I always been there for him? Yep.
 

blue_ladybug

Senior Member
Feb 21, 2014
70,869
9,601
113
#44
We don't know if they go to hell. Only God knows that..WE are not to speculate about that..

The fear of eternal damnation is a pretty good encouragement to me, I guess everyone is different in that respect.
 
T

TemporaryCircumstances

Guest
#45
I just think simply letting someone know that when they talk to you they are safe, life isn't always awful even though it may seem like it, people will miss you of you're gone ect. Helps more than people know
Just letting them know you're there whether or not they want to tell you what's wrong