Man, i really wouldn't want to protect myself or kids from non-christian influences at all. I think as a parent, i would want to be more of a guide then someone who is just throwing down rules. We are commanded to be in the world, but not of it. Take in mind that i don't plan on letting my kids do whatever they do, but the reality is if you are sheltered from reality all your life, once you are exposed, you won't be able to handle it. I hope for my kids is that they are well rounded individuals.
I don't forsee them being well rounded if they only know one half of life.