Redeeming God Article: Tithing $50 BN. Should Tithes be Better Spent?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Nov 26, 2021
1,125
545
113
India
#1
This article mentions the total sum of tithes in America. Could Tithes be better spent? Both on World Evangelism/Gospel Causes as well as fighting hunger, poverty, disease, thirst etc? Thoughts?

From: https://redeeminggod.com/tithing-50000000000/

"There are about 10 million tithing Christians in America who give an estimated $50,000,000,000 annually to their churches and other charitable causes. That’s $50 billion!
Arthur Sido at The Voice of One Crying Out in Suburbia alerted me to this study, which was originally reported on Christianity Today, and he asks how churches spend this money. He says this:
This gets back to the broader of issue of our love and indeed worship of money in the church, an idolatry that is a near perfect reflection of the broader American cultural obsession with money. I absolutely affirm that we have a serious problem with how money and the church relate but I don’t think it is the same problem we hear about so often. We don’t so much have a giving problem in the church, what we really have is a spending problem. Where is our spending as the church focused? Is it outward or inward and which is more Biblical?​
The New Testament church was outward focusing in….​
  • Caring for the needy, such as widows among the church.
  • Concerned for the welfare of Christians in other locations that were suffering.
  • Supporting the evangelistic work of apostles/missionaries/evangelists who were traveling and preaching the Gospel.
The New Testament church was not concerned with…​
  • Mortgages, interest payments, building projects, utilities.
  • Salaries for religious employees.
  • Material and curriculum for Sunday school.
  • Supporting the hierarchy of religious organizations like denominations and seminaries.

That is right on target! (Go read the rest of the article here: Are We Outward Focused or Inward Focused? Follow The Checkbook To Find Out)
Tithing and Money
I have written similar ideas before about how the church spends money it receives from tithing, and what could be done with this money instead (e.g., How the Church Can Solve the World Water Crisis, Liquidating our Property, and Money, Missions, and Ministry.
What if the churches around the country took JUST ONE TENTH of the tithing money they bring in in tithes every year, and put it toward rescuing young girls caught in human trafficking? If we tithed on our tithing income, we could give $5 billion every single year to some cause. What sorts of causes?
This is $1 billion in $100 bills
Though there are thousand things we could do with this tithing money, just take one example that has been heavy on my heart in recent years… rescuing girls from human trafficking.
A rescue center was recently started in Seattle called “The Genesis Project.” (It is featured in the movie, Rape for Profit.) As far as I can tell from their financial statements, they started the project and funded it for well under $1 million (2011 Tax Return, 2012 Balance Sheet). To date, they have rescued 87 human trafficking victims.

So imagine with me…. if churches around the country decided to use just 10% of the money they bring in to help start and run other centers like The Genesis Project, we could start 5000 of these centers…. in just one year!
There are only about 600 cities with populations of over 50,000 people, which means we could put one center in every single city with a population of over 50,000, and still have 4,400 centers that could be started in cities with larger populations.
This is just one example. Obviously, there are large number of worldwide needs that could be addressed. World hunger. Water needs. Health and humanitarian disasters. Schools. Orphanages.
Churches often look at these worldwide problems and say, “It’s too large!” But then we go spend billions of dollars on buildings, parking lots, and soundboards.
I am convinced that most of the world’s problems could be solved if we in the church just spent our tithing money in different ways.
Imagine what the church could do with $50 billion if we decided that nicer buildings, better parking lots, and newer soundboard were not a priority? If Jesus had $50 billion every year, how would He spend it?"
 

maxwel

Senior Member
Apr 18, 2013
9,432
2,512
113
#2
Arthur Sido & Tithing:

Arthur Sido, who wrote this article, refers to himself as a "radical", and admits his views are regressive.

I would contend the article above is primarily based on Sido's personal views on church methodology, his own preconceptions, rather than anything actually in scripture.

I think we could go through his arguments, point by point, and easily show their problems: that they are gross overgeneralizations, reductionistic, and frequently straw men. I think we could counter his reductionist arguments fairly quickly and handily.



Conclusion:

1.) I am quite confident there ARE many churches which do NOT spend their tithing money very responsibly.

2.) However, when Arthur Sido tries to smear all churches with this irresponsible behavior, I think he's entirely out of line. He makes terrible arguments that are extremely reductionist, and which are not supported by scripture. And he does this to discredit ALL modern churches, simply because of his own preconceptions, and not because of scriptural support.

3.) I feel confident there are many churches which DO spend their tithes biblically and responsibly, along with many churches which do not. But when Sido tries to smear all modern churches, and tries to claim evil intentions behind PERFECTLY NORMAL EXPENDITURES... I think he's just being a nut.

.
 

Dude653

Senior Member
Mar 19, 2011
12,347
1,045
113
#3
There are plenty of churches who give back to the community but sadly some of them don't.
You see this a lot in the charismatic churches, the preachers get Rockstar treatment while many people in the congregation are just living paycheck to paycheck
I remembered some years agoi had visited a local church for their pastors appreciation service.
This was pre covid so the place was packed
It was 114° that day and no air conditioning in the building. I stayed about 10 minutes and left. Imagine being a preacher and taking everyone's tithe money but letting them sit and burn up with no air conditioning