Rebuttal:
1. You cannot legislate the poor into prosperity by legislating that all prosperity belongs to the wealthy.
2. True, and
3. True... but then, when you took all the cookies from the plate and left none for your brother, your mom made you put some back
4. You can multiply poverty by adding to wealth
5. True, but also true is the fact that when 1% of the people get the idea they should have 90% of the stuff that 100% of the people work to produce, that is also the beginning of the end of any nation.