LORDSHIP SALVATION

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
well yes

there are direct excerpts from his book in my posts...again, if the link does not work as pilgrim said it does not, please
let me know because it works fine for me

thanks

anyway, you can just google MacArthur and lordship salvation....there are also youtube vids of him speaking these things

he does have some good things to say, but this teaching is not one of them

the links work I think, they take me to a link where someone else writes about what MacArthur supposedly said?

I was looking for actual quotes from himself. Not from someone else..

Your link says he said this, His link says he said that.. Who are we to believe?
 
E

ember

Guest
MacArthur is no even alive anymore. Why are we following him? And not God.

I do not get why people in the church have to follow these men who did not even live when Christ lived or in NT or OT times..

MacArthur may have said some very good things, worthy of rereading, It does not mean everything he said is ok. We should never put our eternity in the hands of any man..

I feel like I am living in a young and immature church like paul had to deal with.

I am of calvin, I am of arminian, I am of MaCarther, I am of " insert the name of some reformer"

I mean really??


I don't think he's dead

nothing I have read indicates that...he's in his 70's
 
P

P1LGR1M

Guest
MacArthur is no even alive anymore. Why are we following him? And not God.

I do not get why people in the church have to follow these men who did not even live when Christ lived or in NT or OT times..

MacArthur may have said some very good things, worthy of rereading, It does not mean everything he said is ok. We should never put our eternity in the hands of any man..

I feel like I am living in a young and immature church like paul had to deal with.

I am of calvin, I am of arminian, I am of MaCarther, I am of " insert the name of some reformer"

I mean really??

Got an obituary on MacArthur?

It is news to me that he died.

As far as the "church" you feel you are part of, keep in mind you are one who helps characterize it, lol.


God bless.
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,742
3,670
113
All you are exposing is great ignorance of a great many things.

Are you a Charismatic or not? You say I am dodging, I have responded to everything.

And I have suggested you are a disgruntled Charismatic with a vendetta, and that is why you are bearing false witness.

You lied about not charging MacArthur as works-based, now you mount a full attempt to prove that.






You are not going to be able to do that. You cannot quote MacArthur teaching in opposition to Sola Fide, so you might as well give it up.

And have to get going, so will get back to this when I can.


God bless.
FOUL!! AD HOMINEMS :)
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Here it is again, taken directly from his site:






An Introduction to Lordship Salvation

What follows is from the Grace Community Church Distinctive on Lordship Salvation . It was adapted from John MacArthur's material on the topic of lordship salvation, and serves as an excellent introduction to the subject.

I do not want something adapted from. I want his actual words.


What you gave me is some churches interpretation of what MaCarther said. thats all.
 
E

ember

Guest

the links work I think, they take me to a link where someone else writes about what MacArthur supposedly said?

I was looking for actual quotes from himself. Not from someone else..

Your link says he said this, His link says he said that.. Who are we to believe?
..there are actual quotes from MacArthur

it's a bit of a read for sure, but it's all there

or, you can youtube him...google...tons of info on the whole thing
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Got an obituary on MacArthur?

It is news to me that he died.

As far as the "church" you feel you are part of, keep in mind you are one who helps characterize it, lol.


God bless.
lol, So we are talking about a different macarther.

So why can no one show me his actual words if he is still alive.

I am not going to judge a person based on hearsay..

 
P

P1LGR1M

Guest

the links work I think, they take me to a link where someone else writes about what MacArthur supposedly said?

I was looking for actual quotes from himself. Not from someone else..

Your link says he said this, His link says he said that.. Who are we to believe?
And I quote:


John MacArthur coined the phrase and was the main proponent. Get it from the horses mouth.

And by the way, still waiting for someone to verify the false witness being presented and actually quote MacArthur teaching works-based salvation.

Funny you ask for what MacArthur actually teaches just a few posts after it has been posted. Four times this has been given, and at the very least those accusing him of works-based salvation should present at least one quote of MacArthur's teaching that supports this charge.

Okay, have to get going, have fun, and if your attempts to get me banned fail, lol, I will see you at the next appointed time.

;)


God bless.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
..there are actual quotes from MacArthur

it's a bit of a read for sure, but it's all there

or, you can youtube him...google...tons of info on the whole thing
Hey sis I am just trying to make a point.

Your quoting a church which states they quoted what he said.

Pilgrim does the same.

Instead of posting interpretations of what he said, (even if they caim they quote him, can we prove it?) Lets just go to the horses mouth otherwise You and Pilgrim will just continue to go and nothign will be resolved.
 
P

P1LGR1M

Guest
..there are actual quotes from MacArthur

it's a bit of a read for sure, but it's all there

or, you can youtube him...google...tons of info on the whole thing
No quotes from MacArthur, simply quote of people saying "MacArthur says..."


God bless.
 
P

P1LGR1M

Guest
Fine, consider yourself on report..

and I do not report people. but your refusal to admit you are in error is for the birds
, I have proved it more than enough yet you stilll refuse to admit.
Do what you feel you have to do.


God bless.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
No quotes from MacArthur, simply quote of people saying "MacArthur says..."


God bless.

so your source is different? How can we prove that??


why do we have to go there, why can;t we just go to the source himself. MaCarther does not have a anythign in writing?
 
P

P1LGR1M

Guest

I do not want something adapted from. I want his actual words.


What you gave me is some churches interpretation of what MaCarther said. thats all.
It's his church. lol

Everything in there is under MacArthur's supervision.

Now show me what you have a problem with.

God bless.
 
E

ember

Guest
Hey sis I am just trying to make a point.

Your quoting a church which states they quoted what he said.

Pilgrim does the same.

Instead of posting interpretations of what he said, (even if they caim they quote him, can we prove it?) Lets just go to the horses mouth otherwise You and Pilgrim will just continue to go and nothign will be resolved.
I understand

short of buying the man's book, dunno?

here's a link to a vid ... I don't agree with calling him a heretic...that's a bit over the top...again, there are no prequels for salvation

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGwXIoMnNgg
 

PennEd

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2013
13,575
9,093
113
Experientally, or better subjectively people may THINK they are receiving Him only as Savior, but if they are truly born again He objectively regenerates and abides in them both as Savior and Lord.
This is a fantastic point. Once we accept Jesus the Holy Spirit, will work in us to conform us to be more and more Christ-like. Some of us, like me, are stubborn, and had to learn, that it is Him who changes me. I can't stop Him even if I wanted to. THANK GOD!!
 
P

P1LGR1M

Guest

so your source is different? How can we prove that??


why do we have to go there, why can;t we just go to the source himself. MaCarther does not have a anythign in writing?
It's his site, lol.

Don't try to make it a matter of now you are talking about someone else.

It has been John MacArthur from the start, beginning with the link provided in an early thread.

So address the error in His own statement about Lordship Salvation.


God bless.
 
P

P1LGR1M

Guest
No, P1LGR1M does not do the same...it is John MacArthur's site.

But you are right in pointing out that she has avoided addressing MacArthur's teaching on the subject, as well as failed to show from his teaching that he teaches works-based Salvation.


God bless.
 
E

ember

Guest
While this topic seems to be new here, I have seen it hotly debated elsewhere which is where I actually learned about it

These sources name the book, page etc...now you can't do that if you are making things up...it's far too easy to refute lies like that...I am surpised that folks here seem to be vague on the concept as this is actually a teaching that is still hotly debated


Dr. MacArthur’s teaching on the
one nature of the believer is related to his teaching on Lordship. If the believer really only has one nature, the new nature in Christ [as MacArthur teaches in The MacArthur N.T. Commentary--Ephesians, p. 164], then we would expect such a person to be totally surrendered to the Lordship of Christ. In the words of Dr. MacArthur: "Listen! No one who is saved will fail to repent, will fail to submit or fail to obey...True faith results in an absolutely and totally transformed life" (Tape GC 90-21 on Lordship). Would we not expect this from a person who does not have an old nature?

Dr. MacArthur’s position on Lordship Salvation has been made very clear in his published book, THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO JESUS. He has also made statements in some of his other published writings and tapes that relate to this subject, some of which are quoted below:
"The Greek word translated 'belief' is not referring merely to intellectual attainment or mental acquiescence but a wholehearted acceptance of everything that is implied in the claims of Christ. You need to believe that Jesus is God and that He died for your sins, committing your whole life to Him in sacrifice and serving Him as Lord." (Assurance of Victory--1 John 5, Moody Press, p.12).
"Submission to the will of God, to Christ’s lordship, and to the guiding of the Spirit is an essential, not an optional, part of saving faith" (EPHESIANS, p. 249).
"Saving faith is a placing of oneself totally in submission to the Lord Jesus Christ" (Romans 1-8, p. 205).


John MacArthur's Position on Lordship Salvation

 
P

P1LGR1M

Guest
I understand

short of buying the man's book, dunno?

here's a link to a vid ... I don't agree with calling him a heretic...that's a bit over the top...again, there are no prequels for salvation

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGwXIoMnNgg

There are some great Catholic resources you could draw from as well.

They too are confused about Sola Fide.

Still waiting for a quote of MacArthur teaching Works-Based Salvation.


God bless.
 
E

ember

Guest
It seems to me that if someone is copy/pasting from MacArthur' site, the results will be a very whitewashed version

A critique is actually what is needed ... one can buy his book I guess, but scholars have rebutted his teachings many times over