Losing your salvation

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
G

greatkraw

Guest
So pickles I agree with everything you said , except that I don't deny the importance and existance of the self, which unfortunately comes from gnosticism or buddhism, that the self is somehow evil and bad. I sometimes hear some christians say it's all of God and none of us. But we're not puppets with God pulling the strings, and the self is not evil and bad when it has been regenerated and made into a new creation. The surrendered and new-natured self is quite capable of doing what God requires in the new image of Christ He made it to be. So I can see an issue if I told a non-Christian to go and study the bible and come to understanding about God by themself. But I see no issue saying that to a Christian who God has already empowered and enabled and has the Holy Spirit, and you shouldn't be so concerned and worried about doing things in your own strength because if you are honestly wanting to do the right thing the Spirit is going to be right there for you the moment you decide to move.
Snail, would you describe us as having An Old Sin Nature or A Human Nature?
 
G

greatkraw

Guest
ahh human nature I guess.
Thought so from your quote.;)

Definitely NOT Calvinistic. I know a pastor who got into a mess because he did not believe in Total Depravity. (T in tulip (yes MS, I know you know what it stands for))
 
Jan 8, 2009
7,576
23
0
Today there's about 10 misunderstandings of what total depravity really means as few can truly fathom it as it was originally intended. I believe in total depravity, just not the 10 or so misunderstandings of it. Total depravity is not only a Calvinist concept you know. As long as we realise it comes from Augustinian thought, yes the same guy who thought the original sin was Adam and Eve having sex. That guy was a loony. Total depravity to me is as simple as recognising that all are under and born into sin and no one themself can measure up to the righteousness which God requires. But I will not treat people to be more wicked than they really are, or call good evil, as God put some good in every person.
 
Last edited:
S

shad

Guest
Today there's about 10 misunderstandings of what total depravity really means as few can truly fathom it as it was originally intended. I believe in total depravity, just not the 10 or so misunderstandings of it. Total depravity is not only a Calvinist concept you know. As long as we realise it comes from Augustinian thought, yes the same guy who thought the original sin was Adam and Eve having sex. That guy was a loony. Total depravity to me is as simple as recognising that all are under and born into sin and no one themself can measure up to the righteousness which God requires. But I will not treat people to be more wicked than they really are, or call good evil, as God put some good in every person.
You need to study more of the scriptures instead of relying upon commentaries and church history all the time. They both have their place but they are compliments and not the source of authority that we get from the God's word. One of the first things that the Holy Spirit guides us into is the doctrine of total depravity so that we will learn the importance of depending upon the grace of God and not the arm of the flesh / Jer 17:5-9. There is a big difference between morality and spirituality. I am not going to condemn morality but you can't trust it for salvation, for grace and it has no power to make you spiritually minded. Morality is commendable from human viewpoint, but as far as being accepted by God in relationship to righteousness, it is but vanity. Man is his best state before God is vanity / Ps 39:5. That does not mean that we do not live with a pure heart before God.

There is a boat load of scriptures, old and new testament, that we can put together line upon line and precept upon precept, here a little and there a little, comparing spiritual with spiritual and understand the true condition of man before God. The true condition of man's head, his heart, his hands, his feet, his bowels, his tongue, his ways, his thoughts and imaginations all reveal his depravity and it is all right there in the scriptures. I know the scriptures, I've studied them, have seen them in practice in my life and the life of others, they are true and trustworthy and let God be true and every man a liar, not the spiritual man that is after life and peace but the carnal and natural man that can not discern the things of God. Read Ps 53:1-3

Rom 3:10-12 'As it is written, There is none righteous, no, not one:

11There is none that understandeth, there is none that seeketh after God. 12They are all gone out of the way, they are together become unprofitable; there is none that doeth good, no, not one.
 
G

greatkraw

Guest
I am of Paul, I am of Appollos, I am of Calvin, I am of Cup, I am of Snail...........
 
S

shad

Guest
Then it's very simple Shad - don't depend upon Calvin.
If those guys like Calvin and all the others, who ever they may be, loved God and studied the word, I commend them. I never put myself under any of them or anything they taught. If they contributed to others and they were blessed by what was taught, I have nothing against that, but they contributed nothing to me. We have the apostle's doctrine that was given to us in the scriptures. They have laid the foundation and we build on that foundation and we should be very careful how we build.

We have every word of God that is inspired and given to us for doctrine, instruction in righteousness, for any correction needed, for edification so that we can be thoroughly furnished unto all good works. It takes the rest of our life to grow in grace and knowledge of Christ and live by every word as we worship God in Spirit and truth. I thank God for the supply that comes from every believer whose heart is established in grace and is filled with the Holy Spirit and the love of God. They are the ones that we comprehend the love of God with because they have been sealed by the Holy Spirit and have the life of God in them.

We grow together, we fellowship with one another, we pray and forgive one another, we exhort one another and we walk in the light and when a brother fails we give them grace and restore them through mercy and the love of God. We don't think evil, we are patient and kind and are thankful in everything and for everything, because that is the will of God in Christ Jesus. We esteem one another and edify one another and build one another up into Christ. We don't condemn, slander, malign or judge one another. We are not perfect but we go on to perfection because Christ is making us become what He has already made us to be in Him.

We depend on Christ, His grace and mercy, His written and revealed word and the friendship we have in Christ with other believers who we are members one of another, not Calvin or Gertrude or even Tony Soprano for that matter. We are one body hid with Christ in God and sealed until the day of redemption. Isn't it good of God to do all these things for us when we did not deserve a single one of them. I think so and so do others that believe.
 

pickles

Senior Member
Apr 20, 2009
14,479
182
63
Today there's about 10 misunderstandings of what total depravity really means as few can truly fathom it as it was originally intended. I believe in total depravity, just not the 10 or so misunderstandings of it. Total depravity is not only a Calvinist concept you know. As long as we realise it comes from Augustinian thought, yes the same guy who thought the original sin was Adam and Eve having sex. That guy was a loony. Total depravity to me is as simple as recognising that all are under and born into sin and no one themself can measure up to the righteousness which God requires. But I will not treat people to be more wicked than they really are, or call good evil, as God put some good in every person.
Im not sure if Im getting this right as I have never studied calvin, cal or any other.
I have always relied on the word and the Holy Spirit.
I mentioned this before, That God Our Father showed us his understanding of both our great abuility to sin, thus Jesus on the cross. He also knew our great abuility to love, thus he trusted his son as an infant to our care.
But what I know I see in myself. I can do good works yet I still recongnise that even in doing good I have to trust in God to keep me from wanting the glory. Not that it is what I look for but one can be seduced easly. Even when I pray I can see a selfish nature trying to overtake me. I believe man is capable of eather good or bad. But I believe that having God Our Father at my right hand is my best hope for success.
I watch people doing great good, yet when I really see, there can be great sin in what they do.
And we all know that what looks bad can often be good.
I believe that is one of the many reasons Jesus said keep your eyes on me. Because with out his love and leading us, we may become so overwhelmed by the sin and evil within the world that we would become discouraged.
With Jesus we can see his great love in all that is, thus becoming stronger in him.
Any way thats my take from the word.
Smiles and God bless, pickles
 
C

charisenexcelcis

Guest
The Protestant Reformation proposed the "Priesthood of the Believer". It did not ask that we abandon all the study that others have put into scripture. While the most essential things are easy enough to understand, our own conversations prove that ther is much that requires depth of study as well as a willingness to listen to others.
 
A

Ash_JFF

Guest
Wow, my first thread and I start a HUGE debate. That really surprised me. I didn't know that THAT many people doubts the solidity of the Salvation of Jesus.
 
S

shad

Guest
The gall of some, that start a thread and become so controversial and such a trouble-maker. You certainly take the cake. lol
 

phil36

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2009
8,260
2,111
113
51
Ash_JFF,

I can not emphasize enough how important it is to have grace in our thinking and to have our hearts established in grace / Heb 13:9. If we are saved by grace and we are to grow in grace / 2Pt 3:18, then grace must be pretty important to God and to the believer. Grace has always been undeserved favor from God. The only one that God is unable to give grace to, is a person filled with pride / James 4:6, 1Pt 5:5, but if they humble themselves, God will give them grace. The person that believes they can lose their salvation is someone who has never been built up in the word and Spirit of grace / Acts 20:32, Col 3:16. The word that we preach and speak to one another must be grace, so that the hearer is edified and ministered to / Eph 4:29. There is nothing edifying when you speak and teach things that get people to lose hope in the salvation they received by grace through Christ. That is a form of slander against the finished work of Jesus Christ and the blood that was shed for the remission of sins.

There is a song that goes like this, 'There's nothing more that I can do for Jesus did it all, for we are complete in Him'. Jesus said while he was on the cross having taken all our sins upon His body, 'It is finished' / John 19:30. When we believed we were placed in Christ, hid with Christ in God and we are complete in Him / Col 2:10, 3:3, Eph 2:13. This is our position in Christ, which is (locative of sphere) meaning that we can not be removed from a set position that has been sealed / Eph 1:13,14, 4:30. In this position we have not been given a spirit of fear but a spirit of power, of love and a sound mind / 2Tim 1:7.

Fear is what dominates the mind and emotions of those that believe their salvation can be lost. Some project an attitude of holiness but do not understand the grace and mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ. Those that teach this continue to put others in bondage again to fear / Rom 8:15, Heb 2:15 and they cause division and strife because they live contrary to what the grace of God teaches us / Titus 2:11,12. The strength of sin is in the law / 1Cor 15:56, so the law has no power to teach us how to live / Gal 3:24, but the grace of God does. If we lived by the law and we failed the law, the law would condemn us as transgressors / James 2:9,10. But we are not under the law but under grace / Rom 6:14, so if sin abounds grace abounds much more toward us to keep us from continuing in sin / Rom 5:20,21, Rom 6:15.

We are in Christ (86 times in the book of Ephesians) and because of being placed their by God through grace there is no condemnation / Rom 8:1. In this verse the last part was added in the KJV because of verse 4 in Rom 8, but the original manuscripts do not include that. The last part of that verse has been used by many to put a condition upon 'no condemnation'. Unfortunately, the KJV translated it incorrectly in this case and should have left it off and could have translated Rom 8:1 in just two words, NO CONDEMNATION, because it is a continuation of chapter 7. However, if you understand your position in Christ you have no problem with the KJV even as it is written, because there is no conditional clause in that verse except being in Christ.


Shad that was an excellent piece :)

Kind regards

Phil
 

phil36

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2009
8,260
2,111
113
51
Wow, my first thread and I start a HUGE debate. That really surprised me. I didn't know that THAT many people doubts the solidity of the Salvation of Jesus.

Ash you hit the nail on the head, so many have fears and doubts and this leads them to live in fear that they may lose theyre salvation.

Kind regards

Phil
 
A

Aliciaforjesus

Guest
Those who call upon the name of Jesus shall be saved.
 
L

Lauren

Guest
Ash you hit the nail on the head, so many have fears and doubts and this leads them to live in fear that they may lose theyre salvation.

Kind regards

Phil
Indeed. I pray that those that are new in Christ that come to this site are protected in their hearts and minds from some of the spirits that fly around these forums.

Phil 1:6 Being confident of this very thing, that He which has begun a good work in you will perform it until the day of Jesus Christ.

Amen!
 
L

Lauren

Guest
If we are saved then we will feel and know the chastening hand of our God, the Father, and if we sin after we are saved; He reproves, rebukes and even whips us but does not kick us out of the family, if we walk away from that chastisement, without repenting we lose our fellowship with the Lord our Father but not the relationship, He is still our Father, and has promised that He is able give life everlasting and to keep us!!!!!
Two thumbs up! :)
 
Jan 8, 2009
7,576
23
0
if we walk away from that chastisement, without repenting we lose our fellowship with the Lord our Father but not the relationship, He is still our Father, and has promised that He is able give life everlasting and to keep us
That's the only part that doesn't agree with scripture, or early church belief.
There's one early church writer, and I can't find it now, who wrote about God disowning His children. He did it with many of Israel, don't be mistaken that he can't do it with Christians.
The scripture teaches that disobedient children suffer the same fate as unbelievers.
Although thaddeus and others may all agree with one another and nod there heads that such and such is correct, if you do an honest to God search of early christian beliefs and certain bible passages that too often get ignored, you won't come away with the same impression.