What was the language spoken before Babel

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Mar 4, 2013
7,761
107
0
#81
Fair enough, i felt it necessary to speak what was posted by me here. Have a nice day, and best wishes for you and those involved in this discussion to get the most out of this discussion :)
Thank you for your contributions that gave me a more expanded view concerning this quest relating to scripture, and how it was intended to be understood. It was nice to converse with you in a most decent way. You have done what was in your heart. :)
 
D

didymos

Guest
#83
What does ש mean?
What, you don't know the alphabet? Maybe this video is helpful.

[video=youtube;783EsrHchXA]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=783EsrHchXA[/video]
 

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,784
2,955
113
#85
Great stuff, Angela! You make some very good points. What do you make of these papers concerning the ancient Hebrew language, the tower of Babel and the names of Noah's grandsons? It all strikes me as interesting, but I think it's rather speculative and probably not true. I mean, I'm well aware that are well-meaning, but strange beliefs out there, even amongst some biblical creationists.

http://www.w-rocs.org/stones/Magog_and_Javan_Descendants.pdf

http://www.w-rocs.org/stones/Genesis_10_Names_Describe_Volcanic_Activity.pdf
I looked at these links, and unfortunately, they do not use the Hebrew letters, but the transliterated ones. So basically how you say it in English.

But I do know that the names do all mean things, and they do tell a story! The question is, were the names listed originally Hebrew, or translated to Hebrew when the Bible was written? Just as Jesus in Greek is ὁ Ἰησοῦς - Iasous, and in Hebrew is Yeshuah, yet we have translated his name to Jesus, these ancient names could easily be translated to Hebrew for easier reading and understanding in those times. Or not!

Because no manuscripts survive from those days, it is impossible to say whether Biblical Hebrew was the actual language used. I still have very strong doubts that Hebrew was the original language, because it is derivative. There are so many exceptions to the rules, so many strange rule changes, it is just not logical that it was the language God created. Even a language like Spanish, which has one sound per one letter, and that is pretty much in every word seems like a language that was created with purpose, rather than slowly evolving and a huge array of strange changes in verb forms, added things, and exceptions to the rules, like Hebrew. I cannot think that God would have created such a mixed up language.

Sorry to all the HRM people.
 
D

didymos

Guest
#86
Hebrew, not English. It would be helpful if you read the thread title.

You commented on my post with the ds sholom font alphabet though.

In hebrew it could either be a 'sin' or a 'shin' depending on the position of the niqqud.
 

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,784
2,955
113
#87
What does ש mean?
This is an "S" character letter. Depending upon where you put the dot on top, it is either sin (pronounced seen) or shin (pronounced sheen). It is a stylized version of the letter which was in the quote above.

As for it's proto Hebrew meaning, I think we have already discussed in several threads that the meanings of the letters are not really profitable for learning - it is the words and passages that we find our meaning in the Old Testament.

http://hebrew4christians.com/alphabetchart.pdf

The above link is a good chart of the Hebrew Alphabet and a good place to start. Memorize and learn how to write the alphabet, then move to nouns and then verbs, which are the bulk of Hebrew language.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#88
If Abraham Is identified in the Bible as a Hebrew, what other language could, or would he have spoken since Hebrew is an identified dialect attributed to Abram and not a nationality. Abraham wasn't a nation. Jacob i.e. Israel was.

thats just it, Hebrew is not attributed to Abraham. If it was. His sons (all) would have spoken it. And we would have many hebrew speaking peoples not just one.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#89
The way Hebrew is written, it can and does give deeper spirirual meaning and understabding more than English language ever could or can because of its dimensions that are more than our language.
That would account for Hebrew and greek, English is one of the worst languages as for as understainding what a person is trying to say. The largest example is the word love. Many greek words, all translated in the same english word (love)

If Hebrew was so easy and so concise, I think God would have had the NT written in it, Instead of having the OT translated into Greek,
 
Dec 1, 2014
1,430
27
0
#90
Eve would not have had a reason to be scared of snakes..there was NO sin, no shame, no evil, no past history of snakebites. I have a pet bunny and a kitten, who should be natural enemies, but our fully grown cat, now, sits on top of the bunny cage and guards my bunny and sleeps near it, although he chases wild rabbits in our yard and kills them. My bunny rubs his nose against the whiskers of our cat as they face each other. These two creatures do not share any emnity between them. My little grandson picks up snakes, lizards and worse and plays with them because there is NO developed fear or reason for him to NOT do it at this point in his life...same thing for Eve at that time.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#91
I looked at these links, and unfortunately, they do not use the Hebrew letters, but the transliterated ones. So basically how you say it in English.

But I do know that the names do all mean things, and they do tell a story! The question is, were the names listed originally Hebrew, or translated to Hebrew when the Bible was written? Just as Jesus in Greek is ὁ Ἰησοῦς - Iasous, and in Hebrew is Yeshuah, yet we have translated his name to Jesus, these ancient names could easily be translated to Hebrew for easier reading and understanding in those times. Or not!

Because no manuscripts survive from those days, it is impossible to say whether Biblical Hebrew was the actual language used. I still have very strong doubts that Hebrew was the original language, because it is derivative. There are so many exceptions to the rules, so many strange rule changes, it is just not logical that it was the language God created. Even a language like Spanish, which has one sound per one letter, and that is pretty much in every word seems like a language that was created with purpose, rather than slowly evolving and a huge array of strange changes in verb forms, added things, and exceptions to the rules, like Hebrew. I cannot think that God would have created such a mixed up language.

Sorry to all the HRM people.

Exactly, as was explained many months ago. Moses wrote in Hebrew. to his people Any thing he would have wrote, included names, would have been translated to its hebrew meaning and name

This does not prove that hebrew was the origional language,
 
Mar 4, 2013
7,761
107
0
#92
This is an "S" character letter. Depending upon where you put the dot on top, it is either sin (pronounced seen) or shin (pronounced sheen). It is a stylized version of the letter which was in the quote above.

As for it's proto Hebrew meaning, I think we have already discussed in several threads that the meanings of the letters are not really profitable for learning - it is the words and passages that we find our meaning in the Old Testament.

http://hebrew4christians.com/alphabetchart.pdf

The above link is a good chart of the Hebrew Alphabet and a good place to start. Memorize and learn how to write the alphabet, then move to nouns and then verbs, which are the bulk of Hebrew language.
Would you accept this chart?
 
Mar 4, 2013
7,761
107
0
#93
You commented on my post with the ds sholom font alphabet though.

In hebrew it could either be a 'sin' or a 'shin' depending on the position of the niqqud.
I asked if you knew what it meant, not the name of it or what it sounded like. One of the attributes of the language is a pictorial representation.

my question to you was on this post
 
Last edited:

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,784
2,955
113
#94
Would you accept this chart?
To put the word meanings next to the late Hebrew is an intellectually dishonest as putting them next to Latin, Greek or English. It only applies to early Hebrew, not the late, for sure.

The Bible was written in late Hebrew. The texts which have survived are all late Hebrew, including the Dead Sea Scrolls. While there is nothing wrong with the chart, if you put the letter meanings next to early Hebrew, it is merely something you grabbed off of Google.

Once again, I urge you, with your interest in Hebrew to actually learn the language, instead of dabbling with these rabbit trails. Hebrew is a wonderful language when used properly to read the Old Testament. Using meanings of letters simply does not apply to the Bible. If you became some kind of linguist, and read Ugarit and Sanskrit and Phoenician, etc, then learning the meanings of the pro-Hebrew might also have some value. There are scholars who learn the ancient languages and study them for language development.

This link takes you to a far more instructive chart of Biblical Hebrew, which is what you want to be studying. Not something that has no relevance to your study of the Old Testament.

http://hebrew4christians.com/alphabetchart.pdf

Or this one: (Of course, the vowel points are a whole different story, which you seem to have left out!)

letterchart.gif
 
W

weakness

Guest
#95
1 Corinthians 14 Emphasize "with"

God doesn't need or want a mediator other than Jesus Christ Himself. I am at peace knowing that I will never have that responsibility, it is just too hard to even comprehend taking on that enormous responsibility. God doesn't need us to pray to Himself cause He doesn't pray to Himself. If we Babble, it doesn't mean we are special intellectually, or Spiritually, even though it might be a special case in an obtuse way when that happens.[/QUOTEAs you probably know but did not say, is that it is not "us" praying ,but the Spirit, Christs' Spirit within us that is making intercession or what ever.I under stand by what you say "babble"But there is a real pitch of sarcasm toward others and God in your words. God praying to himself? well I guess a study of the trinity would be necessary. Unless you think that in a special way that would be obtuse also.
 
T

Tintin

Guest
#96
i don't think gilgamesh was nimrod...more likely nimrod was an earlier king called enmerkar...some scholars believe that 'kar' meant 'hunter'...so his name could be translated to say 'nmr the hunter'

according to sumerian tablets enmerkar's father was meshkianggasher...the 'gash' in that name may correspond to the biblical cush...

enmerkar's successor was lugalbanda...one of his generals... lugalbanda's successor was dumuzid who appears to have been a fortunate commoner who rose to his position... gilgamesh was lugalbanda's son and dumuzid's successor...

there are lots of other details in the sumerian texts that support identifying nimrod with enmerkar...more than i have time to write about right now...
Wow, Rachel. You're good! That makes a lot more sense. Thanks, my sister. :)
 
T

Tintin

Guest
#97
I looked at these links, and unfortunately, they do not use the Hebrew letters, but the transliterated ones. So basically how you say it in English.

But I do know that the names do all mean things, and they do tell a story! The question is, were the names listed originally Hebrew, or translated to Hebrew when the Bible was written? Just as Jesus in Greek is ὁ Ἰησοῦς - Iasous, and in Hebrew is Yeshuah, yet we have translated his name to Jesus, these ancient names could easily be translated to Hebrew for easier reading and understanding in those times. Or not!

Because no manuscripts survive from those days, it is impossible to say whether Biblical Hebrew was the actual language used. I still have very strong doubts that Hebrew was the original language, because it is derivative. There are so many exceptions to the rules, so many strange rule changes, it is just not logical that it was the language God created. Even a language like Spanish, which has one sound per one letter, and that is pretty much in every word seems like a language that was created with purpose, rather than slowly evolving and a huge array of strange changes in verb forms, added things, and exceptions to the rules, like Hebrew. I cannot think that God would have created such a mixed up language.

Sorry to all the HRM people.
Many thanks, my dear sister! I suspected as much. Do you know where I could find the meanings of the names from early Genesis (Chapters 1-11)? Thanks, Angela!
 
P

popeye

Guest
#98
Pre- post- or a-Bab? lol (lol Sorry, but this may be the first post in this whole thread I completely understood. lol)
Although theologens are divided on this topic,most believe that the "Bab" dialect consisted of one placing their index finger across the lips,moving it rapidly up and down,while doing a 'sing-song" monodrone utterace.

Bab-el came later and used two fingers.

No wonder new dialects were mandated

On a side note,this technique is still used extensively in "auctioneer" training
 

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,784
2,955
113
#99
Many thanks, my dear sister! I suspected as much. Do you know where I could find the meanings of the names from early Genesis (Chapters 1-11)? Thanks, Angela!

Here is a link I found:

The Bible and Interpretation

Of course, you could get a Hebrew Lexicon and look up the names. I downloaded a PDF copy of Brown-Driver-Briggs which I can't seem to find on-line. But it is there if you search. And comprehensive! All 1185 pages of it!
 

RickyZ

Senior Member
Sep 20, 2012
9,635
787
113
Can I share a story? I have a theory, based on years of observing and hearing private prayer tongues from all races, sexes, etc. I believe it is the pure unadulaterated language spoken pre-towel of Babel. No matter where I am at, the actual words sound the same when someone is caught up in the spirit during their prayers where the holy Spirit takes over their moanings and groanings. Perry Stone, a known evangelical minister with various prophetic gifts, etc, was at a local college that I had attended. The service had not yet begun. An elderly couple was sitting on the front role with a recording device. Perry Stone was on the stage, over to the side, praying next to the curtain. They had already switched on the recorder and it picked up his prayer, in tongues. After the service, they were listening to it and thought it was interesting that Perry had not used English. They took it to a language professor who listened and asked "Where did you get this?" He declared that what he was hearing was an ancient language no longer used in this world that he knew of, and got very excited. He could translate most of it and it was a sincere message of hope and encouragement from a Godly source.

Another reason I have this theory is that I was online in a private chat, praying with a dear minister's wife, a saintly holy spirit filled person. As we were typing, she went into prayer tongues. What occured went into hyper speed and my screen was filled with this ever flowing language that was beautiful to see and behold, although I could not understand it. The wording looked like some ancient navaho or language that was not filled with huge words. I wish that I had thought of printing it out but I was so amazed at "seeing' tongues". My friend was not aware that it was happening at all on my screen. Her speed, the agility and the sudden flow of wording had to be Supernatural. Yes, it edified her and and was a blessing to me. She did not have to translate this, because it was the Holy Spirit taking her meakly, humbled words from her heart directly to the throneroom of GOD Himself. God was showing me just another mystery, a growth moment that I will never forget.
You are very discerning. Man had a singular pure language from creation until the Tower of Babel (it was one of the few spiritual perks he kept after the fall). When the Messiah/Christ returns to restore all that was lost, one of the things He will restore is that pure singular language. My understanding is that Christ has indeed regained the authority to perform such restoration, and that tongues is our ability to tap into that here and now thru the Holy Spirit until He returns to make it permanent. Where it talks about tongues ceasing, what it really means is that it will cease to be known as a tongue, since it will at that time be our native language.