D
Because woman do not place a mans beauty as a high factor in their considerations when it comes to their selection of a man..
Granted, we can also define "beauty" in as many ways as we can define the color purple, but there really has to be something beautiful about the guy, or it's not working for us. (Ruggedly handsome, eyes twinkle when laughs, and laughs easily, boyishly handsome, beautiful heart, football playerly handsome, doeful eyes when he's "really listening," "just the right height," passionate, plays guitar/video games/music/frisbee/innocent just like I like, etc.) It may not be something visual that others catch, but trust me, it is very visual.
Just like there is a gal that makes you go dink when you first see her, some guys make us go dink. (Dink -- when we sit up and take notice instantly.)