Leadership or Manipulation?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
S

sevenseas

Guest
#61
thanks for the reps Joanie and EG

appreciate it
 
Dec 2, 2016
1,652
26
0
#62
We are all different, I am not into manipulating or controlling, maybe it was the way I was raised. I certainly have my issues but manipulating or controlling another human is repugnant to me to the extreme. I don't want to be in control of anyone, and I don't like anyone trying to control me. So, I don't really understand the manipulation and control game.
 
W

wsblind

Guest
#63
We are all different, I am not into manipulating or controlling, maybe it was the way I was raised. I certainly have my issues but manipulating or controlling another human is repugnant to me to the extreme. I don't want to be in control of anyone, and I don't like anyone trying to control me. So, I don't really understand the manipulation and control game.
IMO anyone who teaches loss of salvation or implies judgement for a believer doing ANYTHING.......is the epitome of manipulation and controlling.

Use fear as a tactic to manipulate or control what a believer is doing or thinking.
 
S

sevenseas

Guest
#64
Hi Seven: I think we are all somewhat confused about what you were referring to(I know I am). Since Satan dominates this world it is full of manipulation, mostly for power so one can acquire what they want. When I did my taxes this year I did something I usually never do, that was I trusted the woman doing the work, and, da dah, she cheated me out of some money. Maybe there is a reason you were not specific, however it would help if you gave a hint of what kind of manipulation you are referring to. You said, using the bible as the hand of God, in a very real sense the bible IS the hand of God, at least most Christians believe it to be so. How could using the bible as the hand of God harm people because the bible is the hand of God? Now manipulating the bible is a grievous sin that is rampant in our time, is that what you were describing.
Hi Samuel

I agree that the devil is well able to manipulate people and influence thought and from that point, behavior

I think we can get some help recognizing that, and exhibiting self control as Galatians tells us

22 But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness,23 gentleness and self-control. Against such things there is no law.
22-23

you are right when you say manipulation is about asserting power. that is exactly what it is for and it can devolve into a demonic stronghold if people keep giving in to it

which is where the fruit of the Holy Spirit comes in. we don't arrive at this point instantly, but as we grow in Christ and we mature. I guess you know that though but sometimes age does not matter. it is the heart that responds to God and the leading of the Holy Spirit and who submits to the word and understands that we need to try and please God. I am not talking about salvation here as some seem to confuse the issue of salvation and sanctification

following is the last paragraph in my op:

this is a behavior that is sadly very often tolerated in church and called 'authority' but it is a false authority. we are not to be ruled over by people. every single Christian is supposed to be under authority and that includes the person at the top. no one should be god in your life and the reason Christians should submit to one another and take counsel from each other is to disallow the sad fact of sinful behavior (and the human desire to be god in their own life and the lives of others), to be active as any sort of power play over others

I was trying to distinguish between those who manipulate to gain power and what actual authority is.

I did not really define authority though.

sorry if I was not clear enough. I can see how I might have left out some things to make it clearer.

referring to the Bible, I actually meant those who berate others by USING the Bible. there is a difference. the Bible is not a tool to cow people down or make them fearful of both God and the person who twists what is says in order to make it say something to seem to back up their own sinful behavior

hope that clears it up?

thanks very much for asking questions. always glad to answer questions rather then deflect angry words
 
Last edited:
S

sevenseas

Guest
#65
IMO anyone who teaches loss of salvation or implies judgement for a believer doing ANYTHING.......is the epitome of manipulation and controlling.

Use fear as a tactic to manipulate or control what a believer is doing or thinking.
Hi wsblind

hang on a minute there

many of these people do live in fear of loosing their salvation and are dead set on being 'good', forgetting that we are never 'good' enough

while behavior management is often used to try to control, many, and I do mean many, sincere Christians are focused on behavior and trying to be good

I agree that fear, threats, accusations and so on, are all part of the tools of those who wish to dominate others
 
Dec 2, 2016
1,652
26
0
#66
Hi Blind, To you anyone who teaches the truth of the word of God that you do not like to believe, is a rascal of some sort, you need to drop your arrogant attitude and actually study the bible for a change. You have this great perception of your biblical abilities that is bogus, in other words, you are no bible scholar, just someone who likes to mouth off.
 
W

wsblind

Guest
#67
Hi wsblind

hang on a minute there

many of these people do live in fear of loosing their salvation and are dead set on being 'good', forgetting that we are never 'good' enough

while behavior management is often used to try to control, many, and I do mean many, sincere Christians are focused on behavior and trying to be good

I agree that fear, threats, accusations and so on, are all part of the tools of those who wish to dominate others
I Agree.:)
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#68
thanks for the reps Joanie and EG

appreciate it
sorry your thread is getting sidetracked, Hope we cna get it back on This is an important subject.. And is real..
 
W

wsblind

Guest
#69
Hi Blind, To you anyone who teaches the truth of the word of God that you do not like to believe, is a rascal of some sort, you need to drop your arrogant attitude and actually study the bible for a change. You have this great perception of your biblical abilities that is bogus, in other words, you are no bible scholar, just someone who likes to mouth off.
Hi Sam......why did my post garner this type of reaction? My guess is it got a little to close to the truth for ya.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#70
Hi wsblind

hang on a minute there

many of these people do live in fear of loosing their salvation and are dead set on being 'good', forgetting that we are never 'good' enough

while behavior management is often used to try to control, many, and I do mean many, sincere Christians are focused on behavior and trying to be good

I agree that fear, threats, accusations and so on, are all part of the tools of those who wish to dominate others
The sad part, I do believe some are blind to the fact they are doing it.. Saul thought he was doing Gods will when he would do his part of a pharisee (which had the jews scared because of their power. and obedience to the law. Everyone knew, when it came to the law. who were the most righteous, and it was not the sinner, so who could argue against them? (Even Mary was afraid,, for her son.. thats why she lied and said he was sick)

That religious mindset it so strong,, and sounds so good. and so godly, it is easy to be entrapt by it.. and not even know what your doing.
 
Nov 22, 2015
20,436
1,431
0
#72
Hi wsblind

hang on a minute there

many of these people do live in fear of loosing their salvation and are dead set on being 'good', forgetting that we are never 'good' enough

while behavior management is often used to try to control, many, and I do mean many, sincere Christians are focused on behavior and trying to be good

I agree that fear, threats, accusations and so on, are all part of the tools of those who wish to dominate others
Well said!

These are what the manipulators and leaders can get into - some I think with good intentions although misguided and others not with good intentions. They are just taken over by malice, bitterness and thus take up slandering others in the body of Christ.

Condemnation guilt and shame are not tools
of the kingdom of God and the Lord does not sub-contract them out to the devil to use on us. They are the tools of the religious spirit that uses them to try to force others to conform and try to mimic the life of Christ.

Condemnation is the sub-conscious confession that your life is worthy
of judgment.

Guilt is the sub-conscious confession that you are not forgiven.

Shame is the sub-conscious confession that the thing you are condemned over is still who you are.

All 3
of these are anti-Christ and anti- the finished work of Christ beliefs.

They are not tools
of heaven. The Holy Spirit is NOT called the Spirit of guilt - but He the Comforter is called the Spirit of grace.


 
Last edited:
Dec 1, 2014
9,701
252
0
#73
I cannot praise and honor our heavenly Father.
Many times had people manipulated me, be it family, friends, colleagues or fellow church members.

God was always given me scripture to encourage me. When people abuse or misuse our goodness God will repay us double for the trouble. We need not to be so concern when people manipulate us. God will fight on our behalf.
What's up with that first sentence?
 
Dec 1, 2014
9,701
252
0
#74
I totally agree. I hear so much blaming others about being malicious, hating, calling other folks "legalists", & telling others such folks aren't going to heaven & doing antichrist work.

Being an "always right" answer man to the folks on CC & saying such things above is manipulation at its finest.
Does G777 manipulate you into stalking him in every thread?

If you have a crush on the brother, just say so.
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
#75
I have been in and out of forums for years, I have yet to see anyone manipulated into believing anything. Most folks have their minds made up and would not change even if the Lord Himself incognito pointed out to them the error of their belief. I have been proclaiming the false pre-trib gathering since 1985 and I could count on the fingers of one hand the people who honestly checked the scriptures to see if what I had said was true. Now if this is about manipulation in churches and TV Ministries, I have seen plenty of it. I was invited to an Oral Roberts meeting one time, I realized later that I was invited because I had sent him a lot of money(a lot to me anyway), they obviously thought I was wealthy so I was invited in order to get some more money out of me. At the time I thought all Christian ministries were totally good, so it was not until later that I realized the truth. Anyway, we are in this meeting of several thousand and Richard stands up and says, the Lord just told me that there is someone here who needs to give 24,000$(that would be like 100,000 today). A long silence and then a lady stood up and gave the money. At the time I felt so embarrassed, I had taken out all of my savings and given it to them because I thought I was doing God's will, and I realized I was not their for spiritual reasons but to get more money out of me, by then I was almost broke...at least it was a learning experience.
The sad thing is the groups who are best at getting money out of their people,
are the ones who create the TV networks and slick operations to continue the money train.
Rather than the money going to the poor it buys these guys massive life styles tax free,
which is unusual for most pastors find it hard to keep thing together.

From the enemies perspective by making these guys superstars they curse the church with
the false advertising it is about influence and power, not love and service.
And you know who loves influence and power, because no one would buy his story without it?
The way I look at is that where I do give money, I am satisfied with... and have been for the thirty or forty years I have been supporting some of them. If other people choose to give money out of guilt or some other reason, seriously, don't blame the people who suckered you out of the money. Blame yourself. They certainly never held a gun to your head.

You already know you were giving for the wrong reason, so simply take responsibility for having done it. Calling them names won't correct what you choose to respond to.
 
W

wsblind

Guest
#76
The way I look at is that where I do give money, I am satisfied with... and have been for the thirty or forty years I have been supporting some of them. If other people choose to give money out of guilt or some other reason, seriously, don't blame the people who suckered you out of the money. Blame yourself. They certainly never held a gun to your head.

You already know you were giving for the wrong reason, so simply take responsibility for having done it. Calling them names won't correct what you choose to respond to.
This is key isn't it Willie? If we stay the victim, nothing will ever get resolved.

And In reality, we get worse..........bitterness,resentment wells up.
 

PennEd

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2013
13,413
8,945
113
#77
Thanx for the compliment! Everybody knows those the OSAS's & Hyp******ers go after are the ones that poses the biggest threat to their heresy empire.

Our readers can take a good look at what people like you do & read between the lines to see how your group constantly degrades those that don't agree with you.....

That's what this thread is all about..... manipulation.

Thanx again for the good example.:)
Stephen. I was just moved with sadness at your posts. I promise you, I am not writing this as a backhanded jab at you. I don't know why you are so angry.
You are loved Stephen. Not just by God, but those who are your brothers, and sisters in Christ. Can't you forget about the differences of Grace vs. works for a while and just show that you love as well? That is what our Lord has told us will distinguish us as His.

Peace to you brother. In Jesus Name.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#78
first, let's take a look at what manipulation is. we have probably all heard the expression 'guilt trip', meaning someone makes you feel guilty about yourself whether it be what you say, do or even think.

a manipulator will try to twist things around, turn the tables and is very skillful at dodging straight forward questions

if you are not aware or have not been around a manipulator, you will not know what hit you until you find yourself feeling guilty over something you did not do and apologizing to the manipulator and in so doing, you expose yourself further and make yourself even more vulnerable to their unapologetic scheming to put you right where they want you, which is under their control

we see people attempting this in the Bible forums on a regular basis.

an example is, you ask a question or have a contradictory response to something someone posts. they come back at you with a Bible verse they are using to attempt to become 'god' in your life. the verse will be designed as a rebuff or a rebuke and and they use this verse in a way never intended by God and this is not something anyone has to fear

there are pastors who will give an entire sermon intended to manipulate the congregation; an example is a pastor who wants to build some big extension to the church. I have literally heard a pastor say 'God has put it on my heart that some of you will take out a second mortgage on your house to help out with the project. God bless you. God will greatly reward you. This is not God and people fall for it and want to please God but they are not pleasing God at all; they are allowing themselves to be manipulated by the human being standing in front of them.

thousands of examples of manipulation could be given as it occurs through all spectrums of life. even children manipulate.

but this thread is about the manipulation of Christians by other Christians and how harmful it is to place yourself under false authority. it will wreck havoc in your life.

I don't know. maybe this thread will pass into obscurity like so many do, but I just wanted to bring this into the light and talk about it if anyone wants to

I'm not pointing anyone out. I don't have to do that. Quite a few people on here use this tactic and I don't want to argue with any of you. But if you recognize yourself, perhaps you will stop. You are hurting others and yourself as well.

this is a behavior that is sadly very often tolerated in church and called 'authority' but it is a false authority. we are not to be ruled over by people. every single Christian is supposed to be under authority and that includes the person at the top. no one should be god in your life and the reason Christians should submit to one another and take counsel from each other is to disallow the sad fact of sinful behavior (and the human desire to be god in their own life and the lives of others), to be active as any sort of power play over others

thanks
If it helps any, I don't really tolerate it. I more go with "they won't hear anyway, so why say anything?" And then I do this: :rolleyes:

And then I move on.

When someone is out to prove themselves, why bother? Do I really care if they do or don't? When it comes to God, it tends to work out that people out to prove themselves don't, so nothing to learn. Nothing to edify. No God, so no caring.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#79
Is it right to manipulate? No.
But, does any manipulative behavior on the part of another "make" us do anything?
No, again.
We, alone, choose for ourselves how to react and also how to act.
It really does "make" us do stuff, until we realize it's happening. And only experience teaches us it is happening.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#80
I cannot praise and honor our heavenly Father.
Many times had people manipulated me, be it family, friends, colleagues or fellow church members.

God was always given me scripture to encourage me. When people abuse or misuse our goodness God will repay us double for the trouble. We need not to be so concern when people manipulate us. God will fight on our behalf.
God gave us mercy over our sins by dying on the cross in our stead. He promises to be with us always, and that we get to enjoy him forever.

What's double or triple that?