How to prove that the Earth is flat, and not a sphere...

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Dude653

Senior Member
Mar 19, 2011
12,688
1,102
113
#61
flat earth was disproven a few thousand years ago
 
C

CharlieGrown

Guest
#62
Not even sure what that means. Tesla definitely believed the earth to be a globe
Yeah, I shouldn't have dragged Nikola into this. I don't know what i'm doing on this thread. That death ray thingy would've been terrifying if proven to exist.
 

breno785au

Senior Member
Jul 23, 2013
6,002
767
113
39
Australia
#63
Can't wait until space tourism becomes mainstream. Then we can all see it for ourselves and stop this nonsense.
 
C

CharlieGrown

Guest
#64
Can't wait until space tourism becomes mainstream. Then we can all see it for ourselves and stop this nonsense.
so you don't buy the NASA pix wholesale either?
 

Dude653

Senior Member
Mar 19, 2011
12,688
1,102
113
#66
airforce has plane that flies around 80,000 feet. It requires pressurized suits. From this height the curvature of the earth is visible...flat earth debunked
 
B

BeyondET

Guest
#67
What kind of beacon you talking about both light and radio beacons move differently depending on the intended direction of that beacon rather it be on point or a 360 degree radius or anything in between.
 
P

prodigal

Guest
#68
How to prove beyond-a-shadow-of-a-doubt that the Earth is flat, and not a sphere...

Position, somewhere on the Equator, a stationary reference "beacon" that sends out a signal in all directions -- or, at least - either East or West - with an angular range from North to South ( i.e. - 180 degrees with East / West in center - albeit, only the North 90 degrees will be significant ).

Position, on a ship / airplane, a directional receiver - such that, it can be determined with sufficient accuracy the angle ( relative to the Equator - or, directly behind ship / airplane ) the reference beacon is being detected.

Using a directional transmitter-receiver at both points would be even better.

Make sure that the signal - of whatever type - is of sufficient strength to reach a very long distance - and cannot be "blocked" by anything that might happen to come between the reference beacon and the ship / airplane.

As the ship / airplane moves away from the beacon, while staying on the equator:

~ If the Earth is a sphere, the signal will be lost soon enough because of the curvature of the earth; however, the angle from reference will never waiver from 0 degrees -- the beacon will always be directly behind the ship / airplane.

~ If the Earth is flat, the signal will be sustained for whatever distance it is capable of being detected; and, the detection angle will increase with the distance between the reference beacon and the ship / airplane.

Why? Because the ship / airplane will actually be following a circular path over the face of the Earth.

This will only work on the Equator - because, from a perspective regarding the angular part of the above suggested experiment - it is the only lattitude that is supposed to be a continual straight line all the way around the globe. And, that is why - if the results of the latter case are obtained - the Earth cannot possibly be a sphere.

:)
a lesson on wavelengths may be called for here, long-waves defract with solid objects that can cause them to bend, whereas short-waves generally go a shorter distance but go straight, unless reflected.


  • Ground waves: At lower frequencies, in the medium wave and longwave bands, due to diffraction vertically polarized radio waves can bend over hills and mountains, and beyond the horizon, traveling as surface waves which follow the contour of the Earth. This allows mediumwave and longwave broadcasting stations to have coverage areas beyond the horizon, out to hundreds of miles. As the frequency drops, the losses decrease and the achievable range increases. Military very low frequency (VLF) communication systems can communicate over most of the Earth, and with submarines hundreds of feet underwater.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio_wave
 
Last edited:

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
27,362
9,375
113
#69
*reads the OP...

Sounds simple enough. So... why have you not yet done it? Why has nobody yet done it?

And if someone did it and found results you did not like, would you believe the results anyway? Or would you claim they were faked... while still refusing to do them yourself?

And by the way, if there are no satellites in space then we sure have a lot more stars than we used to have. And some of them move awfully fast and blink. Ever used a telescope before?
 
C

CharlieGrown

Guest
#70
And if someone did it and found results you did not like, would you believe the results anyway? Or would you claim they were faked... while still refusing to do them yourself?
That is a great precept. One which has many applications, whether considering the shape of the earth or other matters.
 

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,786
2,957
113
#71
To the OP:

Since I am a geography major, long time ago in undergrad, I like maps. A lot!

So could you please publish a map here, or a link to one, of exactly what the earth would look like flat. Obviously, a Mercator projection would not work, as the Pacific Ocean is rather divided.

Since my son and his wife and our two grandchildren just flew to Hong Kong across the Pacific three weeks ago, and arrived safely, not falling off the "edge" of the earth, Mercator will not work.

Not seeing how any "flat" projection of the earth would work. (Probably because the earth is a sphere!) But surely it would be much easier to map a flat earth, than all the issues that come up with trying to fold a flat piece of paper around a globe model of the earth?

Awaiting your map illustration.
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
27,362
9,375
113
#72
To the OP:

Since I am a geography major, long time ago in undergrad, I like maps. A lot!

So could you please publish a map here, or a link to one, of exactly what the earth would look like flat. Obviously, a Mercator projection would not work, as the Pacific Ocean is rather divided.

Since my son and his wife and our two grandchildren just flew to Hong Kong across the Pacific three weeks ago, and arrived safely, not falling off the "edge" of the earth, Mercator will not work.

Not seeing how any "flat" projection of the earth would work. (Probably because the earth is a sphere!) But surely it would be much easier to map a flat earth, than all the issues that come up with trying to fold a flat piece of paper around a globe model of the earth?

Awaiting your map illustration.
Ah, a geography major. I have something you might enjoy.

 

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,786
2,957
113
#73
I only said Mercator, because I thought most people were familar with it. The problem remains, and the really creative alternatives are attempts to solve the old - how do you flatten an orange to a 2D surface?

Great comments, generally!

But I'm still waiting for the 2 D map which allows you to fly around the globe and not fall off. Partly because I want my grandchildren to come home safely, and if this flat earth stuff is true..... Well, you know!
 
G

GaryA

Guest
#74
Angela,

These two images represent basically-and-essentially what is available today:



FlatEarthMap-grid-800x800.jpg



Gleason1892map.jpg
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
27,362
9,375
113
#75
I only said Mercator, because I thought most people were familar with it. The problem remains, and the really creative alternatives are attempts to solve the old - how do you flatten an orange to a 2D surface?

Great comments, generally!

But I'm still waiting for the 2 D map which allows you to fly around the globe and not fall off. Partly because I want my grandchildren to come home safely, and if this flat earth stuff is true..... Well, you know!
I can't take credit for the comments - it's an old xkcd comic. But personally I prefer the Plate Carree version for simplicity, though I can see how the Dymaxion map would appeal to people who value accuracy highly.

GaryA your wall of ice is much smaller than you think. And we can send jets right over it, and they never have found an edge. And you still haven't told me what all those lights are in the sky that weren't there 20 years ago. I was alive 20 years ago and there weren't nearly as many incredibly fast, blinking stars in the sky back then.
 
B

BeyondET

Guest
#76
These forum titles are so amusing it quite humorous indeed :)
 
R

RachelBibleStudent

Guest
#77
I only said Mercator, because I thought most people were familar with it. The problem remains, and the really creative alternatives are attempts to solve the old - how do you flatten an orange to a 2D surface?

Great comments, generally!

But I'm still waiting for the 2 D map which allows you to fly around the globe and not fall off. Partly because I want my grandchildren to come home safely, and if this flat earth stuff is true..... Well, you know!
my favorites are the robinson projection...the winkel-tripel projection...the goode homolosine projection...and the equirectangular projection...in no particular order...
 
R

RachelBibleStudent

Guest
#78
Angela,

These two images represent basically-and-essentially what is available today:



View attachment 159234



View attachment 159235
is there supposed to be some kind of non euclidean miracle at the edges of the map so that anyone whose travel intersects with the edge and keeps moving immediately zaps to somewhere else on the edge and starts moving away from it?
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
27,362
9,375
113
#79
is there supposed to be some kind of non euclidean miracle at the edges of the map so that anyone whose travel intersects with the edge and keeps moving immediately zaps to somewhere else on the edge and starts moving away from it?
I've played some video games like that. Sinistar, Asteroids, Pac-Man...
 

breno785au

Senior Member
Jul 23, 2013
6,002
767
113
39
Australia
#80
is there supposed to be some kind of non euclidean miracle at the edges of the map so that anyone whose travel intersects with the edge and keeps moving immediately zaps to somewhere else on the edge and starts moving away from it?
Lol no one knows because helicopters and stuff guarding the ice wall.