All is a gift.

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
#1
Ok, so on the "Not of Grace" thread, I have been called a liar, a scripture twister, a deceiver, a false teacher, and a host of other names. For saying this...

Me- Post 83,878- Salvation is a big pile of presents. Open one box, WOW, regeneration/Holy Spirit. Open another, WOW! Justification. Another, adoption papers! Thank you God! Fellowship with God! Another. Sanctification! I love it. Another, hope! On and on and on. Then another. Open the package. It contains the purpose of God for your life. The good works which God has chosen for us to walk in...Good works are not a merit, they are one of the gifts included in our endowment. Ephesians 2:10[/QUOTE]

I said WE HAVE NOTHING that we did not receive from God. Therefore it is ALL OF GRACE. And if it is all of grace, it is all a gift.

Is this heresy, deceiving, scripture twisting, deceiving, or being a false teacher?
 

Hevosmies

Well-known member
Sep 8, 2018
3,612
2,631
113
#2
Bro you know I love you.. but it was a great idea to make a separate thread about this instead of going on about it on the 'not of works' thread!

I PERSONALLY believe in PREDESTINATION so that means, I believe God has FOREORDAINED good works that we should walk in them. THATS WHAT I BELIEVE!
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
41,243
16,252
113
69
Tennessee
#3
Ok, so on the "Not of Grace" thread, I have been called a liar, a scripture twister, a deceiver, a false teacher, and a host of other names. For saying this...
I am not sure at all what you mean by good works not being a merit but rather a gift. I did find your outline of salvation to be a bit cloying but that's just me. I have been called a few things also in the BDF but that just goes with the territory. You need a thick skin to survive in that forum. I would not let the labels that others attach to you to discourage you from posting your perceptions and estimations.
 

Adstar

Senior Member
Jul 24, 2016
7,417
3,468
113
#4
Ok, so on the "Not of Grace" thread, I have been called a liar, a scripture twister, a deceiver, a false teacher, and a host of other names. For saying this...
Maybe the one who responded was a bit extreme in their response.. But i also believe you have blended in A persons walk with God.. ( their growth in faith and knowledge) with salvation and that's where i believe you have it wrong..

Salvation is being saved from the eternal judgement of God that is due upon all who have sinned. We are saved by trusting in the Atonement Jesus secured for us by his death on the cross.. This is what is covered by the term Salvation..

salvation is not all the other gift boxes you talked about.. They can be called gifts of the Spirit. Ones Walk in their life with the LORD ( fellowship ) and things like Hope come as a result of knowing that one is saved.. But hope is a fruit of salvation it is not a part of actual salvation..

Anyway i would not have accused you of being all those things you say you where accused of being.. I would have simply responded as i have done here and let you process my thoughts and move on..
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
#5
Maybe the one who responded was a bit extreme in their response.. But i also believe you have blended in A persons walk with God.. ( their growth in faith and knowledge) with salvation and that's where i believe you have it wrong..

Salvation is being saved from the eternal judgement of God that is due upon all who have sinned. We are saved by trusting in the Atonement Jesus secured for us by his death on the cross.. This is what is covered by the term Salvation..

salvation is not all the other gift boxes you talked about.. They can be called gifts of the Spirit. Ones Walk in their life with the LORD ( fellowship ) and things like Hope come as a result of knowing that one is saved.. But hope is a fruit of salvation it is not a part of actual salvation..

Anyway i would not have accused you of being all those things you say you where accused of being.. I would have simply responded as i have done here and let you process my thoughts and move on..
Which of the things that are listed are not included in salvation? Let me know

And I did not say they saved. I said they were gifts, see my sig.
 

Adstar

Senior Member
Jul 24, 2016
7,417
3,468
113
#6
Which of the things that are listed are not included in salvation? Let me know

And I did not say they saved. I said they were gifts, see my sig.
I think my post was clear enough.. Please read it again, this time put your mind in a calm state.. You are probably in a defensive and upset state of mind at the moment and this is effecting you adversely..
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
#7
I think my post was clear enough.. Please read it again, this time put your mind in a calm state.. You are probably in a defensive and upset state of mind at the moment and this is effecting you adversely..
I am calm. It's a question. Is sanctification part of salvation? Adoption?
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
#8
I am not sure at all what you mean by good works not being a merit but rather a gift. I did find your outline of salvation to be a bit cloying but that's just me. I have been called a few things also in the BDF but that just goes with the territory. You need a thick skin to survive in that forum. I would not let the labels that others attach to you to discourage you from posting your perceptions and estimations.
They are a gift because they are the work of the Grace of God. Without Him we can do nothing.
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,173
113
#9
Maybe its like one of those pass the parcel gifts that when you open it has other gifts inside under another layer? Salvation is the main gift but everyone receives a different gift of the spirit according to how God distributes them.
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
41,243
16,252
113
69
Tennessee
#10
They are a gift because they are the work of the Grace of God. Without Him we can do nothing.
Seems to me that since the works are accomplished through the blood, sweat, and tears through the individual performing them, with the grace of God, they are not gifts. The work performed may be an answered prayer for others and considered a gift, but the one doing the actual work probably would not consider them a gift and I don't believe that scripture supports the works as being a gift from God either. Of course, I could be wrong about this but only offering my own perspective. Some of these so-called gifts (works) take months or years of sacrifice, toil, pain, and suffering to accomplish. If these are really gifts than perhaps it would be wise to pass on receiving such gifts depending on your tolerance for pain.
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
#11
Seems to me that since the works are accomplished through the blood, sweat, and tears through the individual performing them, with the grace of God, they are not gifts. The work performed may be an answered prayer for others and considered a gift, but the one doing the actual work probably would not consider them a gift and I don't believe that scripture supports the works as being a gift from God either. Of course, I could be wrong about this but only offering my own perspective. Some of these so-called gifts (works) take months or years of sacrifice, toil, pain, and suffering to accomplish. If these are really gifts than perhaps it would be wise to pass on receiving such gifts depending on your tolerance for pain.
Philippians 1:29

I and many other Christians, see my sig, believe works are a gift because they are wrought of grace. Mary suffered much in bearing Jesus, but Gabriel said she received Divine Favor, and Mary recognized being a handmaiden of the Lord was a blessing and a gift. See Luke 1
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
#12
Maybe its like one of those pass the parcel gifts that when you open it has other gifts inside under another layer? Salvation is the main gift but everyone receives a different gift of the spirit according to how God distributes them.
That's part of it.
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
#13
I think my post was clear enough.. Please read it again, this time put your mind in a calm state.. You are probably in a defensive and upset state of mind at the moment and this is effecting you adversely..
Everything I put in the post was part of order salutus except works. Works are the only point of contention

Good works are of grace because we have no goodness in ourselves to do good works except what is given by God

This takes away all grounds of boasting. Not only we can't boast about salvation, we can't boast about works either. Because God prepared for us before we were born.

Works do not save, I'm not saying that. People got tripped up thinking that's what I meant

As far as works being something we do. Faith is something we do but is a gift. We are saved through faith, work come after salvation. But they are still a gift, for we have nothing good that we did not receive.
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
41,243
16,252
113
69
Tennessee
#14
Philippians 1:29

I and many other Christians, see my sig, believe works are a gift because they are wrought of grace. Mary suffered much in bearing Jesus, but Gabriel said she received Divine Favor, and Mary recognized being a handmaiden of the Lord was a blessing and a gift. See Luke 1
The verse you supplied does not refer to a gift but refers to belief in Christ and to suffer for Him. I don't believe that the Heavenly Father thought that it was a gift given to the Son dying on the cross for our sins but it was His death and resurrection that made possible the gift of salvation. Jesus willingly accomplished what was the will of the Father. Perhaps He considered, despite being innocent of sin, the savage beating, taunting, crucifixion, and having His heavenly father turn His back on Him as He was hanging on the cross to be a gift and not a work that was without merit.
 

Nehemiah6

Senior Member
Jul 18, 2017
24,167
12,764
113
#15
Ok, so on the "Not of Grace" thread, I have been called a liar, a scripture twister, a deceiver, a false teacher, and a host of other names. For saying this...
Since you stated what is true, you were dealing with enemies of the truth (if they called you all those things). So the best thing is to move on and move forward.

We should always keep in mind that Christ and the apostles has such negative reactions to the truth also. Which tells us that a spiritual battle has been raging since creation, and will only end with the establishment of the Kingdom of God on earth by Christ Himself.
 

unclesilas

Active member
Feb 6, 2019
483
170
43
#16
Ok, so on the "Not of Grace" thread, I have been called a liar, a scripture twister, a deceiver, a false teacher, and a host of other names. For saying this...
To be honest, there seems to be a hard core of people on this website who accuse you of being a judaizer, phariseeically minded, preaching works based salvation etc if you even quote a scripture they feel threatens the only thing they appear to care about. Getting to Heaven by faith apart from works. Jesus and all the apostles in their letters gave warnings to people about wrong behaviour, but it seems this is not allowed for a hard core of members here. One can only wonder why.
You have my deepest sympathies
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
#17
The verse you supplied does not refer to a gift but refers to belief in Christ and to suffer for Him. I don't believe that the Heavenly Father thought that it was a gift given to the Son dying on the cross for our sins but it was His death and resurrection that made possible the gift of salvation. Jesus willingly accomplished what was the will of the Father. Perhaps He considered, despite being innocent of sin, the savage beating, taunting, crucifixion, and having His heavenly father turn His back on Him as He was hanging on the cross to be a gift and not a work that was without merit.
Thanks. There is a group over there that think that if you disagree with the premise that "it takes a Christian YEARS to bear fruit" then you are a legalist, judgemental, and a fruit inspector.
 
U

UnderGrace

Guest
#18
Thanks. There is a group over there that think that if you disagree with the premise that "it takes a Christian YEARS to bear fruit" then you are a legalist, judgemental, and a fruit inspector.
I have not read all that thread lately but are you arguing it does take years or it does not take years?
 
Dec 27, 2018
4,170
876
113
#20
I have not read all that thread lately but are you arguing it does take years or it does not take years?
I am saying that it is false to say that it takes years to bear fruit. Every branch in Christ bears fruit, even the new ones

Blessings.