old Earth vs. young Earth

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
P

Phillipy

Guest
#1
I'm an old Earther myself, I have some understanding of radiometric dating methods, but it's mostly that I consider myself to understand that the universe is definitely old, since we can see for billions of light years.
Discussion & thoughts?
 
Last edited:
N

nathan3

Guest
#2
Genesis 1

King James Version (KJV)

1 In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.


( that is a complete statement .
It says He created them in the beginning, but doesn't give you a time, as to when the beginning was. )

Isaiah 45

King James Version

18 For thus saith the Lord that created the heavens; God himself that formed the earth and made it; he hath established it, he created it not in vain, he formed it to be inhabited: I am the Lord; and there is none else.

19 I have not spoken in secret, in a dark place of the earth: I said not unto the seed of Jacob, Seek ye me in vain: I the Lord speak righteousness, I declare things that are right.


So yeah I can see its old, because God's creation speaks for itself . And so does His words.
 
Oct 12, 2012
1,563
929
113
68
#3
Scientist aren't my favorite people when it comes to God; their not good theologians nor do most of them know much about God. But their not stupid either! Old earth creation! The creation story in Genesis is true, but it is a 7 day prophecy in Adam of the past , present and future; it was never meant to be taken as a literal 7 days of any kind. This doesn't leave those who say they don't believe in God, but believe in an old earth, much wiggle room! Stop letting them off the hook by trying to tell them the earth is only 6000 years old! Adam and Eve were placed in the Garden about 6000 years ago, there is a difference!
 

gert

Banned
Apr 3, 2013
42
0
0
#4
Scientist aren't my favorite people when it comes to God; their not good theologians nor do most of them know much about God. But their not stupid either! Old earth creation! The creation story in Genesis is true, but it is a 7 day prophecy in Adam of the past , present and future; it was never meant to be taken as a literal 7 days of any kind. This doesn't leave those who say they don't believe in God, but believe in an old earth, much wiggle room! Stop letting them off the hook by trying to tell them the earth is only 6000 years old! Adam and Eve were placed in the Garden about 6000 years ago, there is a difference!
i think the problem you have is if your saying that he bible is not literal for one fact then which facts are literal?
are they the ones you agree with or not ?
then your just left with a book of multiple choice
 
W

wdeaton65

Guest
#5
Scientist aren't my favorite people when it comes to God; their not good theologians nor do most of them know much about God. But their not stupid either! Old earth creation! The creation story in Genesis is true, but it is a 7 day prophecy in Adam of the past , present and future; it was never meant to be taken as a literal 7 days of any kind. This doesn't leave those who say they don't believe in God, but believe in an old earth, much wiggle room! Stop letting them off the hook by trying to tell them the earth is only 6000 years old! Adam and Eve were placed in the Garden about 6000 years ago, there is a difference!
Are you saying that the earth wasnt created in 6 24 hour days as told in Genesis
 
P

Phillipy

Guest
#6
Are you saying that the earth wasnt created in 6 24 hour days as told in Genesis
I'd say that, I think the bible is divinely inspired but that doesn't make it inerrant, I think it's revelations were interpreted by the understanding and comprehension of the day
 
W

wdeaton65

Guest
#7
Does that mean 6 24 hour days yes or no thanks and blessings
 
P

Phillipy

Guest
#8
In my opinion no, I accept the scientific model of billions of years :) I don't see why God can't do it that way, and I think there's sufficient evidence to think He did.
I think the Genesis account isn't meant to be taken literally. But I'm fallible of course :)
 
P

Phillipy

Guest
#9
But I think he means you ProphetExcalibur :)
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#10
as far as science goes. Much of the scientific method is inaqurate, because we can not know what was happening preflood.

Peter warned us in the last days mean will be mocking God saying things have gone as they have since the beginning of time.

carbon dating could only be accurate until the flood. It assumes the rate of decay has always been the same as today.

a good book to read is Earth's catostrophic past.. He goes into alot of this.. also much other stuff..
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#11
In my opinion no, I accept the scientific model of billions of years :) I don't see why God can't do it that way, and I think there's sufficient evidence to think He did.
I think the Genesis account isn't meant to be taken literally. But I'm fallible of course :)

Why would God have moses write down what he stated happened, only to not take it literally? this makes no sense (to me)
did he want to confuse us?

 
P

Phillipy

Guest
#12
as far as science goes. Much of the scientific method is inaqurate, because we can not know what was happening preflood.

carbon dating could only be accurate until the flood. It assumes the rate of decay has always been the same as today.
Yeaah I'm not very convinced by carbon dating anyway because I don't understand it, I can see that we probably can't check radioactive decay rates were the same in the past. I do however find the intergalactic distances, billions of light years, convincing proof that the universe is old, regardless of the age of the Earth.
Do you feel an old universe conflicts with Christianity?
 
W

wdeaton65

Guest
#13
In my opinion no, I accept the scientific model of billions of years :) I don't see why God can't do it that way, and I think there's sufficient evidence to think He did.
I think the Genesis account isn't meant to be taken literally. But I'm fallible of course :)
Ok thanks. I will share this with you. The scientific model of billions of years is in reality a kabalistic teachings they say and have said all the way back then 15 billion years and so on all part of the LIE Genesis tells us 6 24 hour days no grey area in the hebrew. I would say just trust GOD HE knows what HE is doing. Thanks
 
May 9, 2012
1,514
25
0
#14
Why limit God to man's 24-hour day? The concept of a 24-hour day was not adopted until way later on. A day in the Jewish concept was just from sun-up to sun-down. Also, you cannot judge God's time to the standards of man. He is outside of the time man is in. You cannot put God into a box. I've heard the arguments that God does not go against things that he creates...but he defeated death itself! Do not put God's standards on the same scale as the standards of man. They are DIFFERENT.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#15
Yeaah I'm not very convinced by carbon dating anyway because I don't understand it, I can see that we probably can't check radioactive decay rates were the same in the past. I do however find the intergalactic distances, billions of light years, convincing proof that the universe is old, regardless of the age of the Earth.
Do you feel an old universe conflicts with Christianity?
I feel scripture shows the earth to be about 6 million years old..If Adam was created in the beginning, which I have seen no reason not to believe.

as for billions of light years. God, who has the power) to put planets and suns where they are, who created the laws of science, and who placed the stars in the sky. could have made it so the light was already showing in earth when he created them no matter how far they are.. Also. we know the universe is expanding. we can only assume they were that far away when created and not much closer..

to much data which is really unknown. No one was there..lol
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#16
Why limit God to man's 24-hour day? The concept of a 24-hour day was not adopted until way later on. A day in the Jewish concept was just from sun-up to sun-down. Also, you cannot judge God's time to the standards of man. He is outside of the time man is in. You cannot put God into a box. I've heard the arguments that God does not go against things that he creates...but he defeated death itself! Do not put God's standards on the same scale as the standards of man. They are DIFFERENT.
true.. but why limit it to something longer than 24 hours? to make the day longer would make the earth rotation slower. I think science has shown what would happen if this occured. not to mention.. how slow would the earth move? and how long were the days (think about this)
 
May 9, 2012
1,514
25
0
#17
true.. but why limit it to something longer than 24 hours? to make the day longer would make the earth rotation slower. I think science has shown what would happen if this occured. not to mention.. how slow would the earth move? and how long were the days (think about this)
I agree with you. My point is that we simply just can't limit it to a 24-hour day because that's what WE adopt. It could easily be both. We could ALL be wrong. Our time is not God's time. He created time and is outside of it. We can't subject God to something he himself created.
 
P

Phillipy

Guest
#18
The scientific model of billions of years is in reality a kabalistic teachings they say and have said all the way back then 15 billion years and so on all part of the LIE
Kabalistic teachings are like, Jewish theology, right?
That's only a coincidence that they believe and science believes it, scientists don't believe the universe is billions of years old because it's a kabalistic teaching, but because of evidence :)
There are pleeenty of Christian astronomers, all of them accept an old universe (not that that proves it's true, it just shows they aren't considered mutually exclusive ideas from a scientist's perspective)
 
O

OceanGrl

Guest
#20
From my limited understanding, Adam and Eve were created as adults and therefore wouldn't the earth be created in the same way? Therefore, it would appear to be billions of years old because it was created as an "adult".