Give up *EVERYTHING*?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Bookends

Senior Member
Aug 28, 2012
4,225
99
48
#41
Luke 14:33, "In the same way, any of you who does not give up everything he has cannot be my disciple." (you can read the whole chapter in context, just didn't feel like typing it all out).

If Jesus means give up all of our wants, then I don't know of a single Christian (including myself) in my church that's going to heaven, as we're not disciples of God. If he literally means give up everything, including the shirt from our back and our food and water that we bought from the job that we have, which we also should give up, then I don't know of a single person (other than missionaries and some pastors) that would be considered disciples. Therefore most Christians on this earth are deceiving themselves.

Where is the line? What does Jesus really mean by "everything"? In theory I would even give up the last shirt that I have for Jesus, but practically that kind of seems absurd.

The second question is: Was this question directed to people who could talk to Jesus face to face? They literally would give up everything to follow him at that time. But now that we can't physically follow the man Jesus, is this commandment slightly different now that Jesus is not physically as a man on this earth? What should we give up today to truly be disciples of God?

This is something that I am uneasy about. I really want to follow God with my whole heart, but I know that I am not there yet. I'm still trying to get past certain habitual sins, so I do feel I am walking in darkness yet. But also, if I'm supposed to give up everything... that almost seems impossible unless I become a homeless street preacher who nobody listens to, or I become a missionary which I don't feel that's my calling. Any answers to help me out here is greatly appreciated. Also, if you can give references to your answers to back up what you are saying, that will also help a lot as well. Thanks in advance!

I'm just trying to do some honest soul searching here.
[SUP]26 [/SUP]“If anyone comes to Me and does not hate his father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, yes, and his own life also, he cannot be My disciple.

The Hebrew and Greek understanding the word hate here does not caring the same meaning in our language and culture. What Jesus is conveying is that if one is not willing to part from their family, for the sake of Christ, the savior of the world, then they are not worthy to be called a disciple. The word hate really means "to have less priority then" or "to prefer less". We can see this clearly seen with the OT story of Jacob, Rachael and Leah. The story says that Jacob hated Leah, Gen. 29:31, most translations translate this word "hate" as "not loved" or "unloved", which is a correct translation of the word IMO. However, the Hebrew word being translated "hate" is H8130 "sane". Clearly Jacob did not hate Leah, but preferred her less then Rachael (If he really hated her, he probably wouldn't have laid with her) (see some of the different translations and commentaries on this here).

You must try to understand the culture in which Jesus said this too, those who followed Jesus were seen by their own Jewish families as apostate and shunned, cast out from that family and community, and often killed. They were seen as a cult, much like how a Muslim who defects from their faith and becomes a Christian. Thus the pressure to stay with ones family and traditions was much greater then to follow Christ. Maxwel is correct, it is about priority, do we love Jesus more then our family, our things the Lord gives us, our life even? Are we willing to give things up for Christ. Psycomom is also correct in saying everything we have belongs to the Lord, and everything we have belongs to him. The responsibility we have is how we prioritize these things in relation to what Jesus tells us to do, it's about being stewards or managers of what God has entrusted to us.
 
Last edited:
J

jeff_peacemkr

Guest
#42
maybe already posted. doesn't hurt to repeat:
[h=3]Revelation 12:11 - Bible Gateway - BibleGateway.com: A ...[/h]... and they loved not their life even unto death.

Acts 4:32 All the believers were one in heart and mind. No ...
No one claimed that any of their possessions was their own, but they shared ... No one called any of his possessions his own. ... common. the multitude. Acts 1:14 ...biblehub.com/acts/4-32.htm


Aramaic Bible in Plain English
“But my life is esteemed nothing to me, so that I may finish my race course and the ministry which I have received from our Lord Yeshua, to testify of The Gospel of the grace of God.”

for the apostles, and ANY /? >
[h=3]Luke 14:25-34 NIV - The Cost of Being a Disciple - Large ...[/h]The Cost of Being a Disciple ... even their own life—such a person cannot be my disciple. 27 And whoever does not carry their cross and follow me cannot be my ...

not just sometimes>>
a. Acts 2:46: ‘And day by day, devoting themselves with one heart in the Temple, and eating from house to house, they shared food with joy and simplicity of heart.’

and try to 'protect' ones own life ? >
[h=3]Acts 20:24 However, I consider my life worth nothing to me ...[/h]But I don't place any value on my own life. ... sacrifice of my life I count as nothing, .
 
J

jeff_peacemkr

Guest
#43
not just in "Jesus'" time. today, if someone becomes a believer, born again, in ekklesia, they are often shunned by their family, whether rcc , lutheran, baptist (they forbid russian ministers from reading the bible from the pulpit in tulsa - they said it's not baptist doctrine) , or Jewish.... around the world. (oh, yes, islamic or other also - just kill the whole family of believers) (today) 2014.
 
Mar 12, 2014
6,433
29
0
#44
Luke 14:33, "In the same way, any of you who does not give up everything he has cannot be my disciple." (you can read the whole chapter in context, just didn't feel like typing it all out).

If Jesus means give up all of our wants, then I don't know of a single Christian (including myself) in my church that's going to heaven, as we're not disciples of God. If he literally means give up everything, including the shirt from our back and our food and water that we bought from the job that we have, which we also should give up, then I don't know of a single person (other than missionaries and some pastors) that would be considered disciples. Therefore most Christians on this earth are deceiving themselves.

Where is the line? What does Jesus really mean by "everything"? In theory I would even give up the last shirt that I have for Jesus, but practically that kind of seems absurd.

The second question is: Was this question directed to people who could talk to Jesus face to face? They literally would give up everything to follow him at that time. But now that we can't physically follow the man Jesus, is this commandment slightly different now that Jesus is not physically as a man on this earth? What should we give up today to truly be disciples of God?

This is something that I am uneasy about. I really want to follow God with my whole heart, but I know that I am not there yet. I'm still trying to get past certain habitual sins, so I do feel I am walking in darkness yet. But also, if I'm supposed to give up everything... that almost seems impossible unless I become a homeless street preacher who nobody listens to, or I become a missionary which I don't feel that's my calling. Any answers to help me out here is greatly appreciated. Also, if you can give references to your answers to back up what you are saying, that will also help a lot as well. Thanks in advance!

I'm just trying to do some honest soul searching here.

Lk 18:22 the rich man was told to "sell all thou hast...and come, follow Me."
Yet the next chapter Lk 19:1-10 Zacchaeus was 'rich' but was not told to go and sell all he had.

The difference between the two was the rich ruler was going to allow his possessions to stand between himself and following Christ and Zacchaeus was not. One would need to get rid of anything, everything that stands between himself and serving Christ.
 

Jon4TheCross

Senior Member
Oct 19, 2012
1,864
7
38
#45
Ok... One more example, even though there's already plenty of good examples in this thread.
Acts 4:30 is an example of Peter calling the hand of the adopted priesthood the property of God.
"By stretching out Your hand to heal, and that signs and wonders may be done through the name of Your holy Servant Jesus."

Definitely part of a prayer that is approved by God.
 
Dec 1, 2014
9,701
251
0
#46
Luke 14:33, "In the same way, any of you who does not give up everything he has cannot be my disciple." (you can read the whole chapter in context, just didn't feel like typing it all out).

If Jesus means give up all of our wants, then I don't know of a single Christian (including myself) in my church that's going to heaven, as we're not disciples of God. If he literally means give up everything, including the shirt from our back and our food and water that we bought from the job that we have, which we also should give up, then I don't know of a single person (other than missionaries and some pastors) that would be considered disciples. Therefore most Christians on this earth are deceiving themselves.

Where is the line? What does Jesus really mean by "everything"? In theory I would even give up the last shirt that I have for Jesus, but practically that kind of seems absurd.

The second question is: Was this question directed to people who could talk to Jesus face to face? They literally would give up everything to follow him at that time. But now that we can't physically follow the man Jesus, is this commandment slightly different now that Jesus is not physically as a man on this earth? What should we give up today to truly be disciples of God?

This is something that I am uneasy about. I really want to follow God with my whole heart, but I know that I am not there yet. I'm still trying to get past certain habitual sins, so I do feel I am walking in darkness yet. But also, if I'm supposed to give up everything... that almost seems impossible unless I become a homeless street preacher who nobody listens to, or I become a missionary which I don't feel that's my calling. Any answers to help me out here is greatly appreciated. Also, if you can give references to your answers to back up what you are saying, that will also help a lot as well. Thanks in advance!

I'm just trying to do some honest soul searching here.
If you always keep God first in your life He will bless the fruits of your faith and your labor. Jesus challenged the young rich man to put God first in his life. The fact that you're struggling with this shows you're in a good place with God. No worries, my brother! Be at peace!