How Jewish should a Christian be?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

tanakh

Senior Member
Dec 1, 2015
4,635
1,040
113
76
#21
In this thread I thought I'd throw a couple of issues I've pondered for sometime.
Please don't bring your swords to this thread only your convictions and what the Lord has shown you.
Now we know that christian roots are found in Judaism, our God is the Hebrew God.
Jesus is the son of David, born a Jew...etc and Jesus was the final sacrifice.
We can't escape the fact that most of what is associated with jesus is found in Judaism, baptism, last supper, etc. So how Jewish should a Christian be?


2nd Where do you think the old testament ended or should of ended.
Do you think that the book of Malachi is proper or did it end with the beheading of John the baptist? Or did it end at the book of acts?
Since the promise of the messiah is in the old some say the birth of Jesus is proper but it wasn't untill his death and resurrection that the new covenant was established.

I hope you understand what this post is asking as I have a hard time expressing my thoughts in type so don't beat me up to bad and be kind to others.


The Jewish Bible, (Tanakh) doesnt end with Malachi. Their arrangement of the OT books centre around three main divisions that we call the Law, The Prophets and the Writings. According to Paul we are Jews spiritually because we have the faith of Abraham. We are not bound to follow every commandment given to Israel (There are 613 of them), nor are we obliged to keep the festivals but some do as they point to Jesus. This is a long and complex subject but if you accept Christ as lord and Saviour the Holy Spirit will guide you.
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,707
3,650
113
#22
The Church is one New Man in which is neither Jew nor Gentile...

Ephesians 2:14-15 KJVS
[14] For he is our peace, who hath made both one, and hath broken down the middle wall of partition between us ; [15] Having abolished in his flesh the enmity, even the law of commandments contained in ordinances; for to make in himself of twain one new man, so making peace;
 
Jul 27, 2011
1,622
89
0
#23
Jesus made a way, by His life, with His truth. We have a choice in following Jesus or not. Some follow man and his traditions, while some are looking deeper into what Jesus says. So if i get told doing what Jesus tells me, is being jewish then so be it(Jesus is still king of the jews), and anybody else that chooses Jesus as King of kings And Lord of lords.
 
F

FreeNChrist

Guest
#24
Jesus made a way, by His life, with His truth. We have a choice in following Jesus or not. Some follow man and his traditions, while some are looking deeper into what Jesus says. So if i get told doing what Jesus tells me, is being jewish then so be it(Jesus is still king of the jews), and anybody else that chooses Jesus as King of kings And Lord of lords.
Jesus is the Truth, and makes the Way by His life.
 
B

Biblelogic01

Guest
#25
Why on earth would you wish to be Jewish? To what possible end???
Why say it like it's a bad think to be Jewish?

Jesus was Jewish
Paul was Jewish
The majority of th disciples were Jewish


I'm Jewish and I accept Jesus as the Messiah, and I find Hannukah rather fun. :p
 

oldhermit

Senior Member
Jul 28, 2012
9,143
612
113
70
Alabama
#26
Why say it like it's a bad think to be Jewish?

Jesus was Jewish
Paul was Jewish
The majority of th disciples were Jewish


I'm Jewish and I accept Jesus as the Messiah, and I find Hannukah rather fun. :p
That is not at all what I meant to imply. I simply meant that it is of no advantage for a Gentile Christian to seek to be Jewish.
 
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
689
113
#27
weather or not you want to believe, your faith and the practice of it is very jewish.
Now think about it if you have a never changing God that started with the Jewish people then what changed? Only the covenant all the rest has been fulfilled or is about to.
GOD 'started' with gentiles.
 
Feb 21, 2012
3,794
199
63
#28
I am a Christian and I am not Jewish. I am a child of God. I belong to the body of Christ being baptized and given the gift of holy Spirit - given to us from the Father through faith in Jesus Christ. . . . which began on the day of Pentecost. I believe the OT ended with the gospel of John - with Christ's resurrection/ascension and the availability of the new birth.
 

Grandpa

Senior Member
Jun 24, 2011
11,551
3,189
113
#29
Hebrews 7:11 If therefore perfection were by the Levitical priesthood, (for under it the people received the law,) what further need was there that another priest should rise after the order of Melchisedec, and not be called after the order of Aaron?

Good question...

Hebrews 7:18-19
[SUP]18 [/SUP]For there is verily a disannulling of the commandment going before for the weakness and unprofitableness thereof.
[SUP]19 [/SUP]For the law made nothing perfect, but the bringing in of a better hope did; by the which we draw nigh unto God.

I suppose I share Oldhermits sentiments pretty much exactly.

Do you think on the Jewish forum they wonder how Christian they should be???
 
P

pottersclay

Guest
#30
This thread is not about converting to Judaism but acknowledging and showing that the practices of the Christian faith were found in Judaism.
A lot of you already know this, but for some they never heard of such a thing.
There are even those that believe that God is done with Israel, that the church replaces the temple and that antisemitism is God punishing the Jews. That Jesus and Christianity is a new thing a new religion that has nothing to do with the old testament.
I often heard this as I taught bible study or witnessed to people. about christ.
When I first got saved I was fascinated with the gospels, to read about my Lord was the best thing ever but I had trouble understanding some of the responses and events taking place. Using commentarys it was a little better but not quite there. As I thought I had a grasp on The Bible I read the rest of the N.T. only to become lost. When I prayed about it I asked the Lord to show Me what I'm missing I told him I'll open my bible up and that page is where I will start reading. Never failed every time I opened it up to the O.T. No matter how forward I placed my fingers lol. Talk about not getting it wow.
That was some years ago. By attending church regularly, attending 2 to 3 bible studies a week being involved with ministries and a whole lot of grace and guidance from God I consider myself dangerous at best with the word lol.
Which brings me to this thread and the purpose of it. I see a lot of fellow Christians being misled and frankly bullied by others in here as well as other places I've been. Some of the responses I have got to this thread shows there is a lack of knowledge. The christian roots run very deep in Judaism make no mistake about that
In fact Jesus never wavered from the customs and traditions that were of the day. Why?
God had purposed Israel as an example to all nations that he is the one true living God.
It is extremely important to know the O.T. As well as the new, you would be surprised at what you find.

More to come.
 
Jan 15, 2011
736
28
28
#31
The Jewish people are the original branches that God instructs us not to boast against. For if they do not continue in unbelief, they shall be re-grafted back in and there is great glory in that. Let us also heed when God says that if He did not spare the original branches, He may not spare us either. Let us continue in belief :)

As the Old Covenant is a shadow and type of the New Covenant to come, we as Christians should have a good understanding of the Old Covenant, not to abide by the letter of the law, but to understand how it applies spiritually in our lives. The 7 feasts for example had a prophetic application to Christ's ministry for both the 1st coming and His 2nd coming. The Ritual and Ceremonial Law have been written into our hearts and minds, but the Moral Law very much is in effect today. What God told His people before about what not to touch due to it being unclean now applies for us not to partake in what is spiritually unclean.

In essence, we are not called to live by the letter of the law, but we do have the Law and the Prophets as an admonition for the Church today to learn from and not repeat the same mistakes that the OT Israelites unfortunately fell under and were judged for their sin. God says there is nothing new under the sun and what has been shall be. God specifically tells the NT Church that the OT prophets were ministering to the Church. Let us have a good understanding of the Law and the Prophets and see how they spiritually apply to the Church today.
 
Last edited:
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#32
weather or not you want to believe, your faith and the practice of it is very jewish.
Now think about it if you have a never changing God that started with the Jewish people then what changed? Only the covenant all the rest has been fulfilled or is about to.
Do you realize your faith our religion (how ever you look at it) has matured through the centuries proving the promises of God and proving that he is a living God? The one and only God. This should excite you and bring you joy.
From the alter of Abraham to the temple of Jerusalem to the promise of messiah God has brought you this far and what a journey it's been.
Have you forgotten you are grafted into the seed of Abraham?
As for the feasts and celebrations of the Jews commanded by God what would it have to do with us?
You cannot deny that Jesus's favorite passtimes were to eat and fellowship.
Now the Jews of old priests and Pharisees saw it a burden for the people to present the sacrifice missing the example of the suffering messiah God had given them.
Furthermore they concluded that by the following of the law and the circumcision were there righteousness in short but, what else was happening when these practices took place? Fellowship, intimacy with the Lord , iron sharpening iron, prayer, confession, being in one accord before the one God. We have no use for the temple any more nor the offerings of old for Jesus was the perfect and excepted sacrifice for forevermore.
But we need the fellowship that intimacy in one accord with the lord that these celebrations provided and instilled. You see we are missing a example the Lord has given us. This is just a little of the posting I will be doing on this thread, your viewpoints are much appreciated remember be kind.

Actually my faith and my "religion" as many call it, started in Gen 3: 15, not with Moses, Moses was just one of th emany characters used by God in his "plan of the ages"
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#33
This thread is not about converting to Judaism but acknowledging and showing that the practices of the Christian faith were found in Judaism.
A lot of you already know this, but for some they never heard of such a thing.
There are even those that believe that God is done with Israel, that the church replaces the temple and that antisemitism is God punishing the Jews. That Jesus and Christianity is a new thing a new religion that has nothing to do with the old testament.
I often heard this as I taught bible study or witnessed to people. about christ.
When I first got saved I was fascinated with the gospels, to read about my Lord was the best thing ever but I had trouble understanding some of the responses and events taking place. Using commentarys it was a little better but not quite there. As I thought I had a grasp on The Bible I read the rest of the N.T. only to become lost. When I prayed about it I asked the Lord to show Me what I'm missing I told him I'll open my bible up and that page is where I will start reading. Never failed every time I opened it up to the O.T. No matter how forward I placed my fingers lol. Talk about not getting it wow.
That was some years ago. By attending church regularly, attending 2 to 3 bible studies a week being involved with ministries and a whole lot of grace and guidance from God I consider myself dangerous at best with the word lol.
Which brings me to this thread and the purpose of it. I see a lot of fellow Christians being misled and frankly bullied by others in here as well as other places I've been. Some of the responses I have got to this thread shows there is a lack of knowledge. The christian roots run very deep in Judaism make no mistake about that
In fact Jesus never wavered from the customs and traditions that were of the day. Why?
God had purposed Israel as an example to all nations that he is the one true living God.
It is extremely important to know the O.T. As well as the new, you would be surprised at what you find.

More to come.
Again, thats wrong too.

Christianity was found on God, not on jews.. Why do you want people to be jewish? You want to puff them up like the jews did?


what about all of Gods people who came before the jews. they mean nothing, they had "less" of a relationship with God because God held back on them?
 
F

FreeNChrist

Guest
#34
In fact Jesus never wavered from the customs and traditions that were of the day. Why?
Galatians 4:3-5

"...When we were underage, we were in slavery under the elemental spiritual forces of the world. But when the set time had fully come, God sent his Son, born of a woman, born under the law, to redeem those under the law, that we might receive adoption to sonship."
 
F

FreeNChrist

Guest
#35
The Jewish people are the original branches that God instructs us not to boast against. For if they do not continue in unbelief, they shall be re-grafted back in and there is great glory in that. Let us also heed when God says that if He did not spare the original branches, He may not spare us either. Let us continue in belief :)

As the Old Covenant is a shadow and type of the New Covenant to come, we as Christians should have a good understanding of the Old Covenant, not to abide by the letter of the law, but to understand how it applies spiritually in our lives. The 7 feasts for example had a prophetic application to Christ's ministry for both the 1st coming and His 2nd coming. The Ritual and Ceremonial Law have been written into our hearts and minds, but the Moral Law very much is in effect today. What God told His people before about what not to touch due to it being unclean now applies for us not to partake in what is spiritually unclean.

In essence, we are not called to live by the letter of the law, but we do have the Law and the Prophets as an admonition for the Church today to learn from and not repeat the same mistakes that the OT Israelites unfortunately fell under and were judged for their sin. God says there is nothing new under the sun and what has been shall be. God specifically tells the NT Church that the OT prophets were ministering to the Church. Let us have a good understanding of the Law and the Prophets and see how they spiritually apply to the Church today.
What you promote would be to not learn from and to repeat the same mistakes the OT Israelites unfortunately fell under. It is one thing to study what came before in order to deepen our understanding of the new that has now come...it is another thing altogether, and illegitimate, to then bring those things of the old over into the new and apply them to new covenant Christians.
 
I

Is

Guest
#36
In this thread I thought I'd throw a couple of issues I've pondered for sometime.
Please don't bring your swords to this thread only your convictions and what the Lord has shown you.
Now we know that christian roots are found in Judaism, our God is the Hebrew God.
Jesus is the son of David, born a Jew...etc and Jesus was the final sacrifice.
We can't escape the fact that most of what is associated with jesus is found in Judaism, baptism, last supper, etc. So how Jewish should a Christian be?


2nd Where do you think the old testament ended or should of ended.
Do you think that the book of Malachi is proper or did it end with the beheading of John the baptist? Or did it end at the book of acts?
Since the promise of the messiah is in the old some say the birth of Jesus is proper but it wasn't untill his death and resurrection that the new covenant was established.

I hope you understand what this post is asking as I have a hard time expressing my thoughts in type so don't beat me up to bad and be kind to others.


Malachi is placed in the OT just where God wanted it. Acts is a transitional book that takes the reader from Matt. to Romans showing him the development of of the early church, and the development of Chrisitan doctrine.

Gentile believers are not grafted into the Judaism of the Mosaic Covenant; they are grafted into the seed and faith of Abraham, which preceded the Law and Jewish customs.

They are fellow citizens with the saints (Ephesians 2:19), but they are not Jews. Paul explains this clearly when he tells those who were circumcised (the Jews) "not to seek to be uncircumcised" and those who were uncircumcised (the Gentiles) "not to become circumcised" (1 Corinthians 7:18).

There is no need for either group to feel they must become what they are not. Instead, God has made Jews and Gentiles into "one new man" in Christ Jesus (Ephesians 2:15). This "new man" is referring to the Church, the body of Christ, which is made up of neither Jew nor Gentile (Galatians 3:27-29).

It's important for Jews and Gentiles to remain authentic in their own identity. In this way a clear picture of the unity of the body of Christ can be seen as Jews and Gentiles are united by one Lord, one faith, one baptism.

If Gentiles are grafted into Israel, becoming Jews, the purpose and picture of both Jew and Gentile, coming together as one new man, is lost. God never intended Gentiles to become one in Israel, but one in Christ.
 

tanakh

Senior Member
Dec 1, 2015
4,635
1,040
113
76
#37
That is not at all what I meant to imply. I simply meant that it is of no advantage for a Gentile Christian to seek to be Jewish.
You would have a better chance of starring in Fiddler on the Roof and be able to tell Jewish Jokes without causing offence.
 

KohenMatt

Senior Member
Jun 28, 2013
4,021
223
63
#38
I don't think Christians should try to be more "Jewish" because there are a lot of extra non-Biblical practices that come with that. I do believe Christians should be more Hebrew than anything, by keeping the commandments found in the Torah/Law like keeping the Sabbath, Feast Days, etc. God gave those instructions for Israel to be blessed so those commandments are inherently good when used the right way.
 
P

pottersclay

Guest
#40
The Jewish Roots of Christianity, Part I | Day of Discovery

Please view this video as it is one of the study guides I have used in this study.
Perhaps the title of this thread has thrown some people off of what I am trying to convey.
In the church today as well in my own assembly the study of the first church has been watered down some what and I believe that is where a lot of diversity comes from. My quest is that the church comes once again before God in one accord.