Reformed Only: Does Man have Free Choice?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Does Man have Free Choice


  • Total voters
    14
Jul 23, 2017
879
31
0
#41
Hey!! Lifelong Lakers fan here. BTW, just because you choose which clothes you wear, where you go to, what you eat, &c, doesn't mean you have a free will. That is free choice, something entirely different.
whats the difference between free will and free choice.

im still about that chicago bulls. tough times
 

notmyown

Senior Member
May 26, 2016
4,698
1,129
113
#42
the Lakers and the Bulls had Phil Jackson as a coach, so you're both wrong. :p
 

SovereignGrace

Senior Member
Dec 28, 2016
5,455
236
63
#43
whats the difference between free will and free choice.

im still about that chicago bulls. tough times
Man in his fallen state can not choose God because his heart hates God. His mind is hostile towards Him.[Romans 8:7]
 

preacher4truth

Senior Member
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
#46
Again, one major reason the Reformed are accused of not believing in free choice is due in part, and against Scriptural evidence otherwise, by the non-reformed, anti-Calvinists &c, is the belief they've chosen themselves into the kingdom, that salvation is a result of their choosing or decision. Scripture proves this is not the case.

They also implement this error in saying they are not chosen (elected) by God (most of them) -- thus, they've chosen themselves into the kingdom, while dead in sin, enemies of God, hostile toward God; "Out of their own free choice and love for God which proves they weren't forced (one or their favorite word choices) or robots (another fave word choice)!!!"

In other words, they've rewritten the narrative and have a different gospel than that of Scripture.
 

notmyown

Senior Member
May 26, 2016
4,698
1,129
113
#47
Again, one major reason the Reformed are accused of not believing in free choice is due in part, and against Scriptural evidence otherwise, by the non-reformed, anti-Calvinists &c, is the belief they've chosen themselves into the kingdom, that salvation is a result of their choosing or decision. Scripture proves this is not the case.

They also implement this error in saying they are not chosen (elected) by God (most of them) -- thus, they've chosen themselves into the kingdom, while dead in sin, enemies of God, hostile toward God; "Out of their own free choice and love for God which proves they weren't forced (one or their favorite word choices) or robots (another fave word choice)!!!"

In other words, they've rewritten the narrative and have a different gospel than that of Scripture.
it's been so long since i believed it, i can't recall how my brilliant decision making isn't a 'work', either. something i can take credit for.

*remembers the only brilliant decision she ever made was marrying Mark* ;)
 

Grandpa

Senior Member
Jun 24, 2011
11,551
3,188
113
#48
It does seem like we have complete free will until we come to Christ and study the bible and our own salvation.

Then we find out even our fallen will was being contained.

We don't really know by how much or to what extent.

We still don't know.
 
Jul 23, 2017
52
8
0
#49
i think u can have free will and election and predestination.

just because God predestines doesnt mean He predestines what t-shirt u choose to buy. thats how i look at it
especially if u buy a lakers t-shirt, then soemthing is wrong for sure.
I have a couple Lakers jerseys in my closet. Come on. The Showtime Era. Who can NOT love that stuff?
 

NayborBear

Banned Serpent Seed Heresy
#50
If one believes that one was bought with a price, and one's life is not their own? Kinda answers the question of free choice. The "choice", is how long it takes one to come to that belief....And there are consequences! Both, fleshly, and spiritually, as the clock ticks.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#51
whats the difference between free will and free choice.

im still about that chicago bulls. tough times
The example that won me to the difference, (and I can't remember where it comes from.)

Cats, by nature, are omnivores. They need to eat meat, carbs, and fiber. But they only think of meat. (And they die early because of their choice.)

Put a starving lion in a field of wheat too weak to hunt. It will starve to death, despite having food all around it. Yes, it could have chosen to eat the wheat, but it never considers it.

Yes, we could have chosen sinlessness. If we did not have that choice, than we cannot be held accountable for our actions. But it never dawned on us to do that. We were stuck thinking we were carnivores instead. We did not eat the wheat. God filled us with his bread. AND, once full, we thought, "Wow! Yummy! Glad I decided to eat it."
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#52
As for the NBA? I'm in Philadelphia. Let that explain all it means in even wanting to like basketball. (I did back when people knew names like Dr. J, Moses Malone and Sir Charles Barkley. Sadly, it's been so long, many don't remember those names. They just know to laugh at the Sixers of today.)
 

JairCrawford

Senior Member
Oct 31, 2017
107
6
0
#53
Hmm... well I attend a Non-Denominational church that if I had to use a label, probably would be best described as "Bapticostal". I attend a revivalist group in my city on Fridays as well.

So my theology is probably best described as mostly Pentecostal, a little bit of Baptist, and a fresh garnish of New Apostolic Reformation (le gasp!) over the top.

So... probably not reformed enough to participate in the poll. XD

Still, a very interesting discussion that I'm curious to keep my eye on.
 
Feb 28, 2016
11,311
2,972
113
#54
after being born into this 'fallen-world, all of our choices are put before us by satan,
remember, we are/were slaves to his will'; unless you are 'set apart, separated' by God,
for His special purpose...
and so, no one has a 'free choice' to do anything in goodness and grace, accordance to God's WiLL...

after 'Conversion', this is a 'whole different story and outcome for our lives, for we only desire
to serve and honor Him in all of our actions/thoughts/deeds in humble thankfulness...

(BIG DIFFERENCE, HUH??)
 
Jun 6, 2015
171
0
0
#55
The word choose in Hebrew is BACHAR and it means to select or decide, if you can make a decision you made a choice.
 

rstrats

Senior Member
Aug 28, 2011
723
42
28
#56
celib,
re: "The word choose in Hebrew is BACHAR and it means to select or decide, if you can make a decision you made a choice."

A person can decide that they would like to believe something, but unfortunately they cannot then go ahead and consciously engender the belief.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#57
Hmm... well I attend a Non-Denominational church that if I had to use a label, probably would be best described as "Bapticostal". I attend a revivalist group in my city on Fridays as well.

So my theology is probably best described as mostly Pentecostal, a little bit of Baptist, and a fresh garnish of New Apostolic Reformation (le gasp!) over the top.

So... probably not reformed enough to participate in the poll. XD

Still, a very interesting discussion that I'm curious to keep my eye on.
I really have nothing against nonreformers. The reason I only asked Reformers though is because too many nonreformers keep telling us we don't believe Man has choice. I wanted to see if there was an inkling of truth to that.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#58
after being born into this 'fallen-world, all of our choices are put before us by satan,
remember, we are/were slaves to his will'; unless you are 'set apart, separated' by God,
for His special purpose...
and so, no one has a 'free choice' to do anything in goodness and grace, accordance to God's WiLL...

after 'Conversion', this is a 'whole different story and outcome for our lives, for we only desire
to serve and honor Him in all of our actions/thoughts/deeds in humble thankfulness...

(BIG DIFFERENCE, HUH??)
Even when I wasn't a believer sometimes I chose good.
-- Helping Mom with dishes.
-- Taking care of my little brother when the phone rang.
-- Helping another brother catch minnows and worms for his turtles.
-- 2 AM feedings (in summertime) for little brother, and then spending hours entertaining him during potty training later on.

We can and did choose good at times. What we wouldn't choose is God.
 
Jun 6, 2015
171
0
0
#59
celib,
re: "The word choose in Hebrew is BACHAR and it means to select or decide, if you can make a decision you made a choice."

A person can decide that they would like to believe something, but unfortunately they cannot then go ahead and consciously engender the belief.
Thats a choice made freely by that man. God bless
 
Jun 6, 2015
171
0
0
#60
celib,
re: "The word choose in Hebrew is BACHAR and it means to select or decide, if you can make a decision you made a choice."

A person can decide that they would like to believe something, but unfortunately they cannot then go ahead and consciously engender the belief.
Thats a choice made freely by that person. God bless