A boy is born and grows with an innate connection to aviation. It leads him to hang out at airports, where he meets people and ends up snagging rides in people's planes. Of course the people mentor and allow him to handle the controls, and before long he's flying the planes as if it were his second nature.
The boy decides that to round out his experience he needs to read some pilot manuals. So he reads and as he does he thinks 'gee yes according to what I've done this is what this paragraph means' and 'oh hey I never would have understood this page if I hadn't had the practical experience with it'. The pilots manual comes together and makes perfect sense by virtue of his already having worked the controls.
So the boy joins a pilots group. But he finds among the group that there are those who have studied in depth, and memorized, every single page of the manual. But they've never actually been in a plane, much less handled the controls, and somehow in that lack of experiencial understanding they have decided that planes can't fly. And so they spend their time quoting the manual and relating that to their misconception that planes can't fly.
So who's right here? Those who ignore the buzzing going on over their heads and insist that the maual says you can't fly, or the boy who understands the manual by virtue of having actually put it's concepts to work?
The boy decides that to round out his experience he needs to read some pilot manuals. So he reads and as he does he thinks 'gee yes according to what I've done this is what this paragraph means' and 'oh hey I never would have understood this page if I hadn't had the practical experience with it'. The pilots manual comes together and makes perfect sense by virtue of his already having worked the controls.
So the boy joins a pilots group. But he finds among the group that there are those who have studied in depth, and memorized, every single page of the manual. But they've never actually been in a plane, much less handled the controls, and somehow in that lack of experiencial understanding they have decided that planes can't fly. And so they spend their time quoting the manual and relating that to their misconception that planes can't fly.
So who's right here? Those who ignore the buzzing going on over their heads and insist that the maual says you can't fly, or the boy who understands the manual by virtue of having actually put it's concepts to work?