I find it odd that it is difficult to believe man can be born gay, even though we now know people can be born schizophrenic, born sociopaths, born with diseases, born with mental illnesses, born deaf, born blind, born deformed of flesh, and born mentally handicapped.
Born WITH diseases, not born as an actual disease ourselves.
Homosexuality is a disease -
you are not a disease. You experience this disease in the form of gay urges, but you are NOT gay. This is precisely what I'm trying to get across to newb. Even the born "with" diseases I would eventually like to see hard proof of, but since it doesn't take away from what we've all known and understood as our "fallen nature", as vague a term "born" is, I can accept it without proof for now.
And though what I've said may seem like I'm splitting hairs, the differentiation truly is a matter of (eternal) life or (spiritual) death. Why? Because if you believe that you
are gay (and that God made you that way), then
some people won't find a reason to change, like newb. But if you realize that you are not gay, but that gay urges (for whatever reason) spring up from within you, then as a believer, you will desire to resist those temptations.
For example, if someone believes that they are born a sociopath, and that God created them that way, why then should they change something our infinitely wise God created? The proper thing to do would be to accept acting and living like a maniac, right?
"It's who I am - I AM a sociopath." To continue in your sociopathic ways is the right, just, Scriptural thing to do? Even if people are born with a sociopathic tendency (which I don't believe to be the case), you know in your heart that it would be downright insane of anyone to accept such a thing, yet many,
many people (not you, it seems, but newb, for instance) accept it with regard to homosexuality, which is truly marveling to me.
That being said, I'll ask you the same question I asked newb, which I'm hopeful you'll answer: when exactly are people born? When does life begin? Can you please answer this question for me? You are life, remember? Nephesh/soul/breath of life - that's
you! That doesn't happen when a child exits his mothers womb, so since you also seem to be very certain that "people are born gay", even though science itself has not boldly proclaimed such a thing, then please explain to me what exactly "born" means and when life truly begins.
We oftentimes carelessly label ourselves saying "I am 'this'" and "I am 'that'", but the Saints who were enlightened by the inner light of Christ, knew exactly who they were and trust me when I tell you, the image they portrayed with words (of that "I" that is within all of us) was an ineffable one without the stain of sin attached to it. But only "the pure of heart" will see that everything beyond that "I" is merely a label and not "I" itself.
If we are born with a sinful nature, and we are, don't you realize that this is by far one of the signs of that sinful nature having so corrupted mankind since the Fall.
I'm glad that you realize that homosexuality is a part of a fallen state and that it's
not who God intended you to be. You differ in that respect from newb, which is good, because he's fully accepted the lie that that's who he is and it's how God made him.
However, one problem remains: you need to understand that there is a difference between being born with an instinctive desire to DO evil and being born EVIL. Our natural self is not evil, my friend, but evil arises in the presence of our natural state. To say otherwise would imply that God is evil. If we are created in His image, our true selves are like God - perfect - not an abomination, but the opposite is precisely what you and other like-minded individuals would have us believe. That God
is an abomination and that we, also, are abominations and detestable beings as well, which couldn't possibly be further from the truth.
This tendency we have towards evil is what we consider the "fallen nature." "Nature" does not mean our natural state - our natural selves - it means the current state which surrounds our true state. Everything around us (evil desires, greed, unrighteous anger, etc), if you will, but
not us. Newb has confused a
possible predisposition towards homosexuality for a
predetermination by God and his job, like the rest of us, to resist evil temptations, has been shunned by newb since he thinks that that's who he is. As a result, he will not resist this disease and thus will deprive himself entrance into the kingdom. But like you admitted: it is part of a FALLEN state - which fully contradicts that God MADE him (or you or anyone) that way or that it's God's intention that "since this is who I am", this is who you will always be and that there's nothing to be delivered from.
There are two reasons why some Christians don't want to accept that some of us are born gay. Because it would mean their treatment of us who are SSA has been abominable AND because they believe the inherent lie of, "Well if you are born that way, then it can't be evil."
For starters, there's more than two reasons. That aside, I don't quite understand the part about treatment. Care to explain? By "treatment", do you mean something (prayer, etc) to help you overcome (or "treat") homosexuality? If so, I can't imagine any believer in their right state of mind thinking such a thing is abominable, but if you don't mind, please do explain.
Also, I'm glad to hear that even though you believe you're born gay, that you still think homosexuality is evil. Which really makes me think. Considering you know it's evil, I really don't know how important it is to argue about whether or not you're born gay. To be honest, I don't think we need to argue about that. I mean, yes, it would be great for you to know that you're not born that way, but the most important thing here is that I believe (according to what you've said, anyway) that we are in agreement that homosexuality is, in fact, evil. Which means that even though you have the urge to engage in homosexual behavior, I take it that you don't and never will engage in such sinful behavior?