Is it logical to assume that nothing created the universe?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Aug 5, 2013
624
2
0
The fool in his heart says there is no God.
God laughs them to scorn.
They fear death.
God's justice awaits.
The almighty hammer comes down, and they are no more.
Why do you threaten atheists with assertions from a book that they don't believe?

punchaura.jpeg
 

Attachments

Last edited:
C

CoooCaw

Guest
Why do you threaten atheists with assertions from a book that they don't believe?

View attachment 56205
the joke is one day you will get to meet this god you do not believe in

his name is Jesus and he will expect you to account for what you did with the life He gave you

and you will bow your knee to him and acknowlege he has the right to judge you
 
Aug 22, 2013
83
0
0
the joke is one day you will get to meet this god you do not believe in

his name is Jesus and he will expect you to account for what you did with the life He gave you

and you will bow your knee to him and acknowlege he has the right to judge you
That's not a very good joke.
 
Aug 24, 2013
55
0
0
the joke is one day you will get to meet this god you do not believe in

his name is Jesus and he will expect you to account for what you did with the life He gave you

and you will bow your knee to him and acknowlege he has the right to judge you
At that point I would ask him why he helped Margaret, The Christian from California, and answered her prayers to find a banker to reduce her mortgage repayments but allowed Thousands of innocent children to die every day of AIDS and Starvation.

I would ask him why he would be cruel enough to orchestrate millions and millions to be born into the Hindu culture, causing them to be brought up and to believe it for the rest of their lives, then pass it down to their children to live the same Hindu life.. then create a place of punishment for them after death because they never believed in Him.

I would ask him where he was when my sister was the victim of Domestic violence for 12 years, causing her 2 miscarriages and now leaving her mentally scared for life.

And then I would watch as all the murderers, paedophiles and rapists walked in to heaven and wonder why members of my family, who did no wrong to anyone would be sent to hell.

In the impossible event that Jesus came to me after death, I would certainly want from answers from him and certainly wouldn't go down on my knees.
 
Aug 24, 2013
55
0
0
And what's even more worrying is that not a single Christian would ask him any of those questions, they would just happily walk in with no regard to how everyone else has been treated.
 
C

CoooCaw

Guest
At that point I would ask him why he helped Margaret, The Christian from California, and answered her prayers to find a banker to reduce her mortgage repayments but allowed Thousands of innocent children to die every day of AIDS and Starvation.

I would ask him why he would be cruel enough to orchestrate millions and millions to be born into the Hindu culture, causing them to be brought up and to believe it for the rest of their lives, then pass it down to their children to live the same Hindu life.. then create a place of punishment for them after death because they never believed in Him.

I would ask him where he was when my sister was the victim of Domestic violence for 12 years, causing her 2 miscarriages and now leaving her mentally scared for life.

And then I would watch as all the murderers, paedophiles and rapists walked in to heaven and wonder why members of my family, who did no wrong to anyone would be sent to hell.

In the impossible event that Jesus came to me after death, I would certainly want from answers from him and certainly wouldn't go down on my knees.

the subject at hand will be you; not some hypothetical person you do not know

Jesus will call an unimpeachable witness to convict you - and these words will come back and haunt you
 
Aug 24, 2013
55
0
0
the subject at hand will be you; not some hypothetical person you do not know

Jesus will call an unimpeachable witness to convict you - and these words will come back and haunt you
No hypothesis. Are you saying any of my statements are false?
 
Jun 30, 2011
2,521
35
0
Scientific Method is a logical fallacy

Big bang cosmogony doesn't believe nothing created the universe, but it came from another universe, and so on like the Who created God argument.

who created God - a bigger God, a bigger bigger God, a bigger bigger bigger God

it's the eternal universe bit that tripped up Newton, and people in his day
 
Aug 24, 2013
55
0
0
the subject at hand will be you; not some hypothetical person you do not know

Jesus will call an unimpeachable witness to convict you - and these words will come back and haunt you
Where is this said, anyway?
 
D

danschance

Guest
Originally Posted by CoooCaw

the subject at hand will be you; not some hypothetical person you do not know

Jesus will call an unimpeachable witness to convict you - and these words will come back and haunt you

Wow, aren't we ready to kill the infidels. COO COO why not be nice. If he is being nice we can be nice back and all can have a nice time. :cool:
 
C

CoooCaw

Guest
Originally Posted by CoooCaw

the subject at hand will be you; not some hypothetical person you do not know

Jesus will call an unimpeachable witness to convict you - and these words will come back and haunt you

Wow, aren't we ready to kill the infidels. COO COO why not be nice. If he is being nice we can be nice back and all can have a nice time. :cool:
the nicest thing i can do for him is give him fair warning

this is known as the great white throne judgement
and each person will be given a new body just for his court appearance
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,707
3,650
113
If there is God the concept of nothing is impossible.
If there is nothing then there is no God nor anything else.
Something and nothing cannot coexist.
 
D

danschance

Guest
the nicest thing i can do for him is give him fair warning

this is known as the great white throne judgement
and each person will be given a new body just for his court appearance
To me? It sounded like you were condemning him to hell.
 
Aug 24, 2013
55
0
0
people condemn themselves to hell
Why, because they have difficulty believing something based on absolutely no Evidence?

Just take a moment to think of the reasons why you don't believe in Thor, Odin or Zeus etc and you'll soon understand why I don't believe in your god.
 
May 15, 2013
4,307
27
0
Why, because they have difficulty believing something based on absolutely no Evidence?

Just take a moment to think of the reasons why you don't believe in Thor, Odin or Zeus etc and you'll soon understand why I don't believe in your god.

[video=youtube_share;frJpThIims8]http://youtu.be/frJpThIims8[/video]
 
Aug 25, 2013
2,260
10
0
Some people want to believe nothing created the universe. It all just magically happened. Nothing made it all happen.
Is that logical? Please explain.
Hi DansChance, I think this is the first I've responded to one of your posts. This particular question you've raised I find quite interesting.

I'm an atheist. I certainly don't think the universe began by magic. Honestly I don't know how it began, but taking the secular view I can only assume that its origin was natural and not magical, or supernatural. The problem I have with the religious explanation is that it is really no explanation at all. Saying God created the universe is very nice but is not at all informative. It tells me nothing. Physicists talk about the universe beginning with a quantum singularity. They are also quite adamant that this singularity did not need God to give it a push. My saying that the universe formed by a natural event is no more informative than saying it formed by God's intervention. At least the introduction of a quantum singularity is a step to providing an actual cause and does one better than saying simply that God did it. Some may want to argue that God produced the singularity, but proving it is the hard part.
 

Huckleberry

Senior Member
Aug 25, 2013
1,698
96
48
Some people want to believe nothing created the universe. It all just magically happened. Nothing made it all happen.
Is that logical? Please explain.
A creation is evidence of a Creator.
 
D

danschance

Guest
Hi DansChance, I think this is the first I've responded to one of your posts. This particular question you've raised I find quite interesting.

I'm an atheist. I certainly don't think the universe began by magic. Honestly I don't know how it began, but taking the secular view I can only assume that its origin was natural and not magical, or supernatural. The problem I have with the religious explanation is that it is really no explanation at all. Saying God created the universe is very nice but is not at all informative. It tells me nothing. Physicists talk about the universe beginning with a quantum singularity. They are also quite adamant that this singularity did not need God to give it a push. My saying that the universe formed by a natural event is no more informative than saying it formed by God's intervention. At least the introduction of a quantum singularity is a step to providing an actual cause and does one better than saying simply that God did it. Some may want to argue that God produced the singularity, but proving it is the hard part.

Congrats on answering to my post and sorry you are an atheist. Maybe that can change?

I used the word "magically" in sarcasm not in literal magic.

If you are looking for facts, I suggest you not search for them in a faith based forum. As I mentioned previously fact and faith are not exactly co-dependent. Still you are here at a Christian forum as an atheist discussing fact and faith.

I have had 5 semesters of physics, 3 semesters of Chemistry and math classes beyond calculus in college. That doesn't make me an expert on anything but still, I have a decent grasp of science. I have always enjoyed the sciences. I also, for a time was an atheist until God made it very clear to me that He is real. No, I can't prove it to you as you would simply label it as being anecdotal.

It is a pivotal issue how the universe was formed and here is where science leaves us in the dark. Was matter and energy always here? If they were always here then they have been here infinitely long or they have an origin. Or matter and energy has an origin. The theories about the big bang and origins of the universe are complex. I am not qualified to delve too deep into this subject as I have never studied quantum physics.

Some leading physicists do in fact believe that matter can spontaneously exist and they believe this is the case based on quantum physics. The big bang theory is that space actually stretched out along with matter. Beyound this, who knows? At some point it comes down to faith. Faith in some sort of singularity which happened by itself or that something external from our space-time continuum caused it to happen.

Keep trying to work out an answer and let me know if you ever reach one and how you came to accept it. I believe The Bible. The Hebrew suggests God stretched out the heavens. Ins't that interesting as it seems to actually fit current theory.
 
G

Guffy

Guest
The Holy Bible must be the ultimate resource for the answers to this or any other question. Can something come out of nothing?
Please don't be mislead here by circular reasoning. Remember--"In the beginning God created...." The Bible said it, and that settles it. :)