I think it's pretty appalling that Kiwi_OT has received offensive messages from men on this subject, I disagreed but I did it publicly and in a civil way, behave that way and all you do is reinforce a negative sterotype about men that we are all immature and incapable of mature discussion, let's not go that way PLEASE!.
That said the opening post did come across a little harsh, it read like tough love and it was basically telling men on here to just grow up, the hostile reactions aren't justified but I can understand why some guys were offended as a more delicate approach generally avoids the hurt but retains the message.
I think there's something for everyone to learn from this.
Excellent point Matt, and yes you are very correct.
I am tough love. Im tough love with my girlfriends and Im tough love with my guy friends. Believe or not, my boyfriend and friends do think Im a very kind and gentle person. I just chose not to be gentle this time.
Ive noticed 3 types of guys in this thread. One being a man who can take constructive criticism, accept it, can disagree or compromise respectfully, is humble yet still shows backbone. Then theres the male who gets overly defensive and angry and tries to throw it back to justify their position and put down the other person because they cant handle a little rebuke. Then theres the male who is just plain abusive and remind me of the type of man who when frustrated likes to kick people and animals in private and think they can get away with it.
What is wrong with telling 20-30 year old boys who dont want to grow up yet whine about lack of females to grow up?
Those of you, who have made the effort to grow as a man under Christ, you have nothing to hide. You have no reason to be defensive with me. You can give me loving constructive critism back by all means. Matthew and Ironic are the only ones who have done this. I respect that so much. If you are defensive and angry towards me and sending me abusive mail - ask yourself why. Because your only proving my point that men out there need to mature.
Timing is everything. Guys here have "Oh but what about girls - their just as bad!!" Well hello.. We're all sinners here joining under the love of Christ. As I tell tons of women and girls, you teach people how to treat you. If your dating history shows men/women being inconsiderate to you, what kind of behaviour are you allowing exactly?
I wouldnt even bother doing the rebuking. Older godly men are to rebuke and correct younger men and teach them. How can they do that if a guy isnt even going to church? Older women are to do the same for girls. And one piece of advice I always tell girls - stay well away from a guy who enjoys criticising yet cant handle and improve from an honest rebuke himself. For guys I say, if a woman enjoys gossiping with her girlfriends more than being open and honest with you - run for your life and keep looking and praying.
I want to change my tack a bit here. Lets change the topic. Im a female, and I know all about females obviously so I shall regress from giving male advice (despite its good intentions). Does any guy here have a question about maybe how to get a certain girl theyre trying to pursue? Or maybe men would like to know all the litle subtle feminisms we ladies do which you just dont have a darn clue about and want to learn and get confidence. I love my brothers in Christ so lets help each other a bit.