Why I now believe in Predistination/Election

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
D

Depleted

Guest
The sky is blue...

Jesus said to seek first the kingdom of God and "His righteousness". Self-justification is the opposite of Christ's righteousness.

God "predestined" us to be made the righteousness of God in Christ and not try to live by our own D.I.Y. self-righteousness. D.I.Y. self-righteousness is trying to live by the law - the law being your own self-effort to achieve and maintain righteousness.

Self-righteousness mindsets always stumble at the righteousness of God in Christ and think by what they do or don't do - they become righteous. Get this wrong and we create a religion of self-works trying to justify ourselves and thus nullify the very grace of God in Christ from operating in our lives like it should.

God "predestined" us to receive the "gift of righteousness" which only comes by grace through faith in Christ's finished work on our behalf.

There are fruits of righteousness but they do not make one righteous. The fruit of righteousness comes because we are already righteous in Christ.

Christ alone makes us righteous. Works-based religion always thinks that if they can "mimic" righteousness - then they will be righteous.

Romans 10:2-5 (NASB)
[SUP]2 [/SUP] For I testify about them that they have a zeal for God, but not in accordance with knowledge.

[SUP]3 [/SUP] For not knowing about God's righteousness and seeking to establish their own, they did not subject themselves to the righteousness of God.

[SUP]4 [/SUP] For Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to everyone who believes. ( The law is self-effort in doing things to create our own righteousness )

[SUP]5 [/SUP] For Moses writes that the man who practices the righteousness which is based on law shall live by that righteousness.

God has "predestined" us to live by faith for righteousness which only comes in Christ's work - not works-righteousness. That is simply the eating of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil and it is the world's system. Come out from amongst the world and be separate because Christ has made you righteous.
BUT "choose Jesus" IS work-based salvation.
 

1ofthem

Senior Member
Mar 30, 2016
3,729
1,912
113
Here is your repeated lie:

Want to repeat it again because "I don't believe in predestination?" Which just so you know we get what you're saying (which, at least means we've read and comprehended what you've said -- something you refuse to do in return), is the same thing as saying, "I only believe what I want to believe about God. Not like I'm bound to believe everything the Bible says about him. I am free to pick and choose."
You can repeat what I said all you want sweetheart because it's definitely not a lie...And I'm glad you get what I'm saying too.

As far as reading and comprehending what you or anyone else on here has stated...that's where the disagreement comes in, and because I disagree does not mean I am choosing to believe only what I want to believe. The same can be said for you and anyone else here who does not comprehend the verses that have been brought against it. I have not called you a liar, I simply said I don't agree with you.

As the old saying goes you say potato, I say "tater"...lol

That's how disagreements work...It is what it is.
 

1ofthem

Senior Member
Mar 30, 2016
3,729
1,912
113
No. Really. Many people have defined the word, and yet you keep misrepresenting it at best, lied about it at worse, reinvented it somewhere in between, so, yes, you really are ignoring.

You cannot disagree with something when you absolutely refuse to acknowledge what it is or absolutely refuse to understand what it is first. And therefore, you simply keep repeating yourself as if it can't possibly be you, it's everyone else. These are the tactics of a toddler. Didn't work back then, doesn't work now.

So which will it be? Will you take the time to learn what it is first, or keep going on and on with invented definitions and then blaming everyone else but you? (And I have no intention on teaching you what has already been taught fine on this thread. If you decide to learn what it is, then you do the homework to catch up.) That I really do give you as your choice. I merely ask to see where this goes from here. You keep playing this game, and then I make my decision -- whether to get off this merry-go-round you're on or not. That choice depends on your choice.
Sounds like good advice...How about taking it yourself?

I've read the scripture for myself and I believe how I believe. There is no way you or anyone else is going to persuade me to believe anything to the contrary.

Now you are free to believe as you will. I'm not trying to make you believe anything...I am disagreeing with you. And that is what it is.
 
B

BeyondET

Guest
Here it is, took me forever! That verse as it is written fits with what I think. This is why you were wishing the verse had been reworded differently, because if it had been, I would not think as I did. But because it is written as it is, that is WHY I think as I do. :)

I'll check out your new thread when I return later. :)
I didn't say or wish it needed rewording for I never did reword it... :)
 
B

BeyondET

Guest
You can repeat what I said all you want sweetheart because it's definitely not a lie...And I'm glad you get what I'm saying too.

As far as reading and comprehending what you or anyone else on here has stated...that's where the disagreement comes in, and because I disagree does not mean I am choosing to believe only what I want to believe. The same can be said for you and anyone else here who does not comprehend the verses that have been brought against it. I have not called you a liar, I simply said I don't agree with you.

As the old saying goes you say potato, I say "tater"...lol

That's how disagreements work...It is what it is.
Sadly that's the norm among folks, if you disagree it because a lie in their mind to them, there's no truth in it at all...
 

1ofthem

Senior Member
Mar 30, 2016
3,729
1,912
113
Now I don't care to discuss scripture with anyone, but I don't stand for anyone trying to "bully" someone into believing something.

If you can show me something in scripture then do it, but don't get on here and give me a verse or two and throw out the rest of scripture and demand I swallow it down. I'm sorry it just don't work that way for me.
 

1ofthem

Senior Member
Mar 30, 2016
3,729
1,912
113
Sadly that's the norm among folks, if you disagree it because a lie in their mind to them, there's no truth in it at all...
Yeah, I can see that....Folks are one sided...They see what they want to see and then if you don't agree with it then you must be some type of liar or just picking and choosing scripture.

But it's ok for them to throw a verse or two out and just skip over the rest.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I guess you could argue that Paul could have refused Jesus when he encountered Him on that road...but I don't think that's how encountering God works. I think the knee just bows when one encounters God. Some men have said they could not stand and were as if they had fainted until He gave them strength and put them on their feet. I know I myself couldn't stand. I thought I would never be able to get up and that my husband would soon come home and call the men in the white coats to come and get me because I was just shattered man. There wasn't even an attempt to get up. I knew I couldn't.

All I have to say is you are a one time case. I have known hundreds of believers. And your the ONLY person I ever met that said they went fr5om rejecting God pone second to believing the next. Everyone i knew spent months sometimes even years believing in God,. But afraid to take that step of faith, for whatever reason.

But hey, As I said, if you want to believe the way I do. Your free too.. I am done trying to explain myself. And why I believe the way I do over and over to the same people. It is not worth it..
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
If we take this debate to the end, it comes down to ONE question. Do you REALLY believe Christ paid for ALL sin?

Yes He DID. He removed the barrier from men. So ALL men can come to Christ. He paid for ALL sin and the veil was torn. ALL men can come to Him, because He tore the veil for men. He did something about our depravity.......He threw us a life preserver that ALL can see and grab a hold of.


What he did NOT pay for was our evil or human good.......self righteousness. And at the GWTJ, unbelievers are judged according to their WORKS of self righteousness. Mankind goes to hell based upon their deeds, if they never believed that Christ died for their SINS.
Amen,, Which leaves us with a few important points.

1. People are delivered to Christ for the GWT, Not resurrected by him, and taken there (believers are not present at this judgment seat)
2. They are judged for works, not sin, And found wanting
3. This is apposed to the judgment seat of Christ (BEMA) where we as believers are judged, and given reward for our work (gold silver precious stone, wood hay straw)

this is where people do not understand.. Jesus told the Pharisees (for all we know a man names Saul, and Nicole OSU was there at that time) that they were in danger of committing the unpardonable sin, Even though thy just committed it by attributing the work of the HS to Satan. He basically said they all had a chance to repent.. He would not say this if they were predestined to hell.. He would tell then flat out. Because you have blasphemed the HS, you are condemned.. .
 
D

Depleted

Guest
You can repeat what I said all you want sweetheart because it's definitely not a lie...And I'm glad you get what I'm saying too.

As far as reading and comprehending what you or anyone else on here has stated...that's where the disagreement comes in, and because I disagree does not mean I am choosing to believe only what I want to believe. The same can be said for you and anyone else here who does not comprehend the verses that have been brought against it. I have not called you a liar, I simply said I don't agree with you.

As the old saying goes you say potato, I say "tater"...lol

That's how disagreements work...It is what it is.
Then you are free to go on your way. I will pray that God chooses his Way for you, so you can finally get the real God and the joy in being his child.

And should I call you, Honey Child? Since you're in to such nonsense as calling anyone "sweetheart?" (I would think a woman, of all people, would understand the derogative nature of the word "sweetheart" to another woman.)
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Now I don't care to discuss scripture with anyone, but I don't stand for anyone trying to "bully" someone into believing something.

If you can show me something in scripture then do it, but don't get on here and give me a verse or two and throw out the rest of scripture and demand I swallow it down. I'm sorry it just don't work that way for me.
Sometime it is just better to ignore people.. I think some are here to to egg others on.. Because that seems to be all they do day after day..
 
D

Depleted

Guest
Sadly that's the norm among folks, if you disagree it because a lie in their mind to them, there's no truth in it at all...
No, lying is when I use the word "blue" to mean cleaning, stairs, poptarts, or anything else, but what it means. And, yeah, maybe I didn't know what "blue" meant, but then many people defined the word "blue" to me, (and I really am capable of looking the word up if I don't understand it), but I keep saying it means cleaning.

One of two choices: Either I'm lying or I have absolutely no comprehension skills. And yet, here I am writing full sentences, which proves I have comprehension skills, so, yeah. I'm lying.

THIS is a lie:

Originally Posted by 1ofthem

The thing about it is that predestination is saying some folks will be condemned to hell just because that's what God wanted for them and no other real reason.
I know this because she has comprehension skills.

Either that or I have to blue my dishes and you can't call that a lie because in my mind there is truth to that? Silly game!
 
D

Depleted

Guest
Now I don't care to discuss scripture with anyone, but I don't stand for anyone trying to "bully" someone into believing something.

If you can show me something in scripture then do it, but don't get on here and give me a verse or two and throw out the rest of scripture and demand I swallow it down. I'm sorry it just don't work that way for me.
If you're not into bullying people into what to think then quit telling your lie. We HAVE shown you scripture. (Not a verse or two, which is another lie.) You ignore them. Instead you come back to lying about what you want the Bible to say.
Originally Posted by 1ofthem

The thing about it is that predestination is saying some folks will be condemned to hell just because that's what God wanted for them and no other real reason.
 

Grandpa

Senior Member
Jun 24, 2011
11,551
3,189
113
God chose the Hebrews over the Egyptians. It doesn't matter that the theology of the Egyptians says that God chooses everyone equally. Their theology is just wrong.

Why didn't God choose the Caananites? Or the Amalekites?

God chose the weak to overcome the strong so all would know who He Is and how He Works. Opposite of how our world works.

Election and predestination are biblical facts. If you say you don't believe in them or you disagree with it then you are just disagreeing with the bible.

But its a silly disagreement. Its a disagreement with carnal what-ifs. Its not a spiritual understanding.


A spiritual understanding says that if it is a requirement for Salvation then it didn't come from us, it came from God. Otherwise, if it came from us then we could boast and we would be sharing in Gods Glory.

John 6:44 [FONT=&quot]No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day.

[/FONT]
No one can boast. No one can share in His Glory. Because its all a gift. Faith, Grace, Righteousness, Salvation, Good Works, Fruit... All these are blessings from God.

Religion denies this. They want to teach you that there is something you must do to earn what is the blessing from God. Its a real easy trick because no one believes they can get anything for free. There has to be something they must do.

Yes. Read your bible and ask God for His Blessings.
 

Marano

Senior Member
Dec 7, 2011
398
32
28
29
God chose the Hebrews over the Egyptians. It doesn't matter that the theology of the Egyptians says that God chooses everyone equally. Their theology is just wrong.

Why didn't God choose the Caananites? Or the Amalekites?

God chose the weak to overcome the strong so all would know who He Is and how He Works. Opposite of how our world works.

Election and predestination are biblical facts. If you say you don't believe in them or you disagree with it then you are just disagreeing with the bible.

But its a silly disagreement. Its a disagreement with carnal what-ifs. Its not a spiritual understanding.


A spiritual understanding says that if it is a requirement for Salvation then it didn't come from us, it came from God. Otherwise, if it came from us then we could boast and we would be sharing in Gods Glory.

John 6:44 No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day.

No one can boast. No one can share in His Glory. Because its all a gift. Faith, Grace, Righteousness, Salvation, Good Works, Fruit... All these are blessings from God.

Religion denies this. They want to teach you that there is something you must do to earn what is the blessing from God. Its a real easy trick because no one believes they can get anything for free. There has to be something they must do.

Yes. Read your bible and ask God for His Blessings.
Amen faith is a gif of God so that no one should boast.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
God chose the Hebrews over the Egyptians. It doesn't matter that the theology of the Egyptians says that God chooses everyone equally. Their theology is just wrong.

Why didn't God choose the Caananites? Or the Amalekites?

God chose the weak to overcome the strong so all would know who He Is and how He Works. Opposite of how our world works.

Election and predestination are biblical facts. If you say you don't believe in them or you disagree with it then you are just disagreeing with the bible.

But its a silly disagreement. Its a disagreement with carnal what-ifs. Its not a spiritual understanding.


A spiritual understanding says that if it is a requirement for Salvation then it didn't come from us, it came from God. Otherwise, if it came from us then we could boast and we would be sharing in Gods Glory.

John 6:44 No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day.

No one can boast. No one can share in His Glory. Because its all a gift. Faith, Grace, Righteousness, Salvation, Good Works, Fruit... All these are blessings from God.

Religion denies this. They want to teach you that there is something you must do to earn what is the blessing from God. Its a real easy trick because no one believes they can get anything for free. There has to be something they must do.

Yes. Read your bible and ask God for His Blessings.


i think or at least hope everyone believes it is true, They just have a different opinion of what it means..
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
John 6:44 No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day.

No one can boast. No one can share in His Glory. Because its all a gift. Faith, Grace, Righteousness, Salvation, Good Works, Fruit... All these are blessings from God.

Religion denies this. They want to teach you that there is something you must do to earn what is the blessing from God. Its a real easy trick because no one believes they can get anything for free. There has to be something they must do.

Yes. Read your bible and ask God for His Blessings.
Some religions teach to gain salvation you must balance you good deeds against your bad
deeds to get a balance in favour of good, which means you go to heaven and not hell.

God declares He blesses the righteous.

Surely, Lord, you bless the righteous; you surround them with your favor as with a shield.
Psalm 5:12

The Lord’s curse is on the house of the wicked, but he blesses the home of the righteous.
Proverbs 3:33

Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, for they will be filled.
Matt 5:6

There is great blessing from the Lord to walk in His ways and follow the Saviour of
all and believe in His cross and sacrifice. Do this and you will gain eternal life.

I am sure this is what you meant, as this is the message of the Lord of Hosts.
 

notuptome

Senior Member
May 17, 2013
15,050
2,538
113
Great thing about predestination is that if you are elect you are going to heaven. Bad news is if you are not you are not. Nothing you can do in either direction. Why worry about accepting Christ when God has predetermined all this about you well in advance of you even existing? No need to testify of the goodness of God since its all about election.

Don't allow Gods foreknowledge to become predetermination.

Ro 11:32 For God hath concluded them all in unbelief, that he might have mercy upon all.

For the cause of Christ
Roger
 
B

BeyondET

Guest
No, lying is when I use the word "blue" to mean cleaning, stairs, poptarts, or anything else, but what it means. And, yeah, maybe I didn't know what "blue" meant, but then many people defined the word "blue" to me, (and I really am capable of looking the word up if I don't understand it), but I keep saying it means cleaning.

One of two choices: Either I'm lying or I have absolutely no comprehension skills. And yet, here I am writing full sentences, which proves I have comprehension skills, so, yeah. I'm lying.

THIS is a lie:


I know this because she has comprehension skills.

Either that or I have to blue my dishes and you can't call that a lie because in my mind there is truth to that? Silly game!
Blue, when did I mention anything about you mentioning blue? If you had a conversation with another person about Blue that has nothing to do with me, you do comprehend that right? Silly game!
 

1ofthem

Senior Member
Mar 30, 2016
3,729
1,912
113
Then you are free to go on your way. I will pray that God chooses his Way for you, so you can finally get the real God and the joy in being his child.

And should I call you, Honey Child? Since you're in to such nonsense as calling anyone "sweetheart?" (I would think a woman, of all people, would understand the derogative nature of the word "sweetheart" to another woman.)
That's cool, but I already know the real God. Thanks anyhow though sugar...

Oh and excuse my language, I'm from the south and that's how we talk...It's just a southern thing, I guess, sorry if it offended you.