Poll: On what day of the week was Jesus Crucified?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

On What Day of the Week Was Jesus Crucified?


  • Total voters
    38
Jul 16, 2013
87
1
0
#81
the Chinese calendar when a new moon happens it's called the dark moon in their calendar might not be the same thing as the other poster was mentioning. Psalms 81:3 has some info on the Passover feast, actually at every feast during the year the same thing is done.
The particular feast is not mentioned, so it can't be assumed which one it is. What is interesting in Psalms 81:3 is that it directly correlates "New Moon" with "full moon" https://www.blueletterbible.org/kjv/psa/81/1/t_conc_559003 From the list of words, go to "Kece" or H3677. Some will argue that the root of this word means to cover and therefore conceal. However, that is an assumption of bias. It could just as well mean "cover with light", and as the word also means "to clothe" it could just as well mean "to clothe with light".
 
L

LPT

Guest
#82
The particular feast is not mentioned, so it can't be assumed which one it is. What is interesting in Psalms 81:3 is that it directly correlates "New Moon" with "full moon" https://www.blueletterbible.org/kjv/psa/81/1/t_conc_559003 From the list of words, go to "Kece" or H3677. Some will argue that the root of this word means to cover and therefore conceal. However, that is an assumption of bias. It could just as well mean "cover with light", and as the word also means "to clothe" it could just as well mean "to clothe with light".
That depends on what bible translation your reading, I prefer the KJV but I do like afew others. On this verse alone the KJV has it alittle different.

KJV Psalm 81:3
Blow up the trumpet in the new moon, in the time appointed, on our solemn feast day.

im not a expert on Jewish festivals but it might that it's done at all the yearly feast festivals and the Passover I presume is a feast day.

a new moon is the first visible sign of the moon crescent. a full moon is fully visible I think the two are quite different.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
L

LPT

Guest
#83
Sorry I posted before going to the site you posted, in which you referred the KJV version. That's a handy site indeed thanks for posting the link I've never been there.
 

MarcR

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2015
5,486
183
63
#84
In order to prove this, to me at least, you will need to find a passage in the bible that shows it specifically. Either "new moon" is defined internally as a dark moon, or the presence of a full moon on the 14th/15th of any lunar month which would also prove it. I am not interested in Rabbi or Jewish commentary as authority. It should be provable from the text.
There is NO VERSE that states this, however:

we have many verses that say that the passover is on the 14 of Abib [Nisan].

It is easy to observe that the moon is consistently full at Passover.

The moon is new on the first of the month because that is when the month starts.

The moon is always dark on the first day of any Biblical Calendar month.

If this doesen't satisfy you you are quite welcome to be wrong if that is what you choose.
 
L

LPT

Guest
#85
There is NO VERSE that states this, however:

we have many verses that say that the passover is on the 14 of Abib [Nisan].

It is easy to observe that the moon is consistently full at Passover.

The moon is new on the first of the month because that is when the month starts.

The moon is always dark on the first day of any Biblical Calendar month.

If this doesen't satisfy you you are quite welcome to be wrong if that is what you choose.
question do they blow a trumpet at the beginning of the month and as well in the middle of the month.
i ask because I see most bible translation have at the new moon and full moon but the KJV and just afew others don't have it.
I'm alittle perplexed about that.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,295
26,332
113
#86
In order to prove this, to me at least, you will need to find a passage in the bible that shows it specifically. Either "new moon" is defined internally as a dark moon, or the presence of a full moon on the 14th/15th of any lunar month which would also prove it. I am not interested in Rabbi or Jewish commentary as authority. It should be provable from the text.
Are you really disputing whether a full moon is two weeks after a new moon???
 
Jul 16, 2013
87
1
0
#87
There is NO VERSE that states this, however: we have many verses that say that the passover is on the 14 of Abib [Nisan].
No argument there.
It is easy to observe that the moon is consistently full at Passover.
The reason for this is church practice and tradition, both Jewish and Christian. Traditions and practices, especially when they are found outside the text, do not necessarily a truth make. Christ had something to say about this to the Jews of His time.
The moon is new on the first of the month because that is when the month starts.
No argument here. The side topic we are discussing is the definition of "new moon" - full or dark, not that it starts the lunar month, which we agree on.
The moon is always dark on the first day of any Biblical Calendar month.
But that is not in the Bible. As mentioned before, it is likely the opposite. During the Exodus on the 15th, the escaping Israelites needed a light source to see by: Exodus 13:21. This strongly implicates a dark moon during that first passover.
If this doesen't satisfy you you are quite welcome to be wrong if that is what you choose.
It doesn't satisfy but I am quite happy to be mistaken in someone else's eyes. :)
 

MarcR

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2015
5,486
183
63
#88
question do they blow a trumpet at the beginning of the month and as well in the middle of the month.
i ask because I see most bible translation have at the new moon and full moon but the KJV and just afew others don't have it.
I'm alittle perplexed about that.
The shofar is blown just after sundown of the last day of the month.

It is not blown on the Passover 14Abib; but it is blown at the beginning of any Levitical Sabbath including 15 Abib. I would be blown just after sundown of 14 Abib, etc.

Traditionally the shofar is blown on 21 occasions throughout 1 Ethanim [Tishri] (the day of trumpets [NOT THe NEW YEAR]) the seventh month.

Tradition is WRONG! The silver trumpet is called for. [this is a long tube of rolled silver foil with a flared upcurved cup like an alpenhorn.
 
Jul 16, 2013
87
1
0
#89
Are you really disputing whether a full moon is two weeks after a new moon???
I think it's fairly clear that the discussion now underway is the definition of what the term "new moon" means. I've already given a few reasons why I strongly lean towards the New Moon being a full moon and not a dark moon or first visible crescent.
 

MarcR

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2015
5,486
183
63
#90
Why do you think the moon is new in the middle of the month?
 
L

LPT

Guest
#91
The shofar is blown just after sundown of the last day of the month.

It is not blown on the Passover 14Abib; but it is blown at the beginning of any Levitical Sabbath including 15 Abib. I would be blown just after sundown of 14 Abib, etc.

Traditionally the shofar is blown on 21 occasions throughout 1 Ethanim [Tishri] (the day of trumpets [NOT THe NEW YEAR]) the seventh month.

Tradition is WRONG! The silver trumpet is called for. [this is a long tube of rolled silver foil with a flared upcurved cup like an alpenhorn.
hmm wow thank you very much I did not know that, now that really throws me a curve then why does all the English bibles say at the feast day, strange indeed. I'm logging off for the night but I'll surely read your response.

God Bless brother
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,295
26,332
113
#92
No argument there. The reason for this is church practice and tradition, both Jewish and Christian. Traditions and practices, especially when they are found outside the text, do not necessarily a truth make. Christ had something to say about this to the Jews of His time. No argument here. The side topic we are discussing is the definition of "new moon" - full or dark, not that it starts the lunar month, which we agree on. But that is not in the Bible. As mentioned before, it is likely the opposite. During the Exodus on the 15th, the escaping Israelites needed a light source to see by: Exodus 13:21. This strongly implicates a dark moon during that first passover. It doesn't satisfy but I am quite happy to be mistaken in someone else's eyes. :)
Right there in Exodus 13:21 says a pillar of fire guided them by night to give them light. You gave the verse number. Did you not read what it actually says? It is not always bright on a full moon.
 
Jul 16, 2013
87
1
0
#93
Right there in Exodus 13:21 says a pillar of fire guided them by night to give them light. You gave the verse number. Did you not read what it actually says? It is not always bright on a full moon.
Right. A pillar of fire to give them light. Not the moon. Remember this is the first passover. If the moon was full, they wouldn't need an extra light source so they could see, now would they?
 

MarcR

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2015
5,486
183
63
#94
hmm wow thank you very much I did not know that, now that really throws me a curve then why does all the English bibles say at the feast day, strange indeed. I'm logging off for the night but I'll surely read your response.

God Bless brother
In Lev 23, in the Hebrew, the days to be observed are all called (Moaday) Appointed Times. In the English Bible, they are all called feasts even though one of them is a fast. The Passover 14Abib is one appointed time [feast]. The Appointed Time [Feast] of unleavened bread is an 8 day observance of which the first day, 15 Abib [Nisan] and the 8th day 22Abib are Levitical Sabbaths. The intervening Sunday [first day of the week] is the Appointed Time [feast] of Firstfruits (the first fruits of the Barley harvest). 50 days later we have the Appointed Time [feast] of Shavouot [Weeks] {Pentecost} which celebrates the Firstfruits of the wheat harvest.

The feast day you refer to in your question is the Levitical Sabbath of 15 Abib.
 
Jul 16, 2013
87
1
0
#95
Do you really expect me to read your responses to other people as if they were part of my discussion with you when they are not part of my discussion with you?


If you want to understand the position I take, then yes.


It would be a lot easier and faster for you to simply answer the question.


I'm not a big fan of reiterating myself when people choose not to read the relevant discussions.


Unless your intention is simply to dismiss me. I met another guy on this site who has many times told us how long he has studied the Bible (forty years!) and yet it had always escaped his attention that Passover was on a full moon. Some men hate being told something they do not know by a woman. The pride of life caused the fall of mankind and all creation.
Do you honestly expect me to bow to your opinion simply because you are female and to disagree is to exercise pride? LOL. I find this highly amusing. Thank you for a good laugh.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,295
26,332
113
#96
I'm not a big fan of reiterating myself when people choose not to read the relevant discussions.
The relevant discussion as you define it on your one way street? Why not just answer my question? It would not have taken long, and if you had already answered you could have pointed me to it or copy and pasted it back to me instead of taking a dismissive attitude and acting all high and mighty.


Do you honestly expect me to bow to your opinion simply because you are female and to disagree is to exercise pride? LOL. I find this highly amusing. Thank you for a good laugh.
No. I was simply pointing out a fact which again you do not seem to like. But you are welcome for the laugh. Your attitude is fairly typical.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,295
26,332
113
#97
Right. A pillar of fire to give them light. Not the moon. Remember this is the first passover. If the moon was full, they wouldn't need an extra light source so they could see, now would they?
You wrongfully assume that a full moon is always visible.
 

Yahshua

Senior Member
Sep 22, 2013
2,758
715
113
#98
The particular feast is not mentioned, so it can't be assumed which one it is. What is interesting in Psalms 81:3 is that it directly correlates "New Moon" with "full moon" https://www.blueletterbible.org/kjv/psa/81/1/t_conc_559003 From the list of words, go to "Kece" or H3677. Some will argue that the root of this word means to cover and therefore conceal. However, that is an assumption of bias. It could just as well mean "cover with light", and as the word also means "to clothe" it could just as well mean "to clothe with light".
If we look at the Hebrew words used in this passage, note that there are two different words used:

Hodesh = "new moon" or "month" (used over 280 times)

and

Keseh = "full moon" (used only 2 times)


Also, if we read Psalm 81, it's structure is poetry, not necessarily correlating the two words together but actually contrasting them as different moments in time. For example, imagine singing the first four verses to a 6/8 (doo-wop or fast waltz) beat for the effect:

[1 2 3 4 5 6...]
[1 2 3 4 5 6...]

"Sing-for-joy, to, God-our-strength;
Shout-joyfully-to-the-God-of-Ja, cob.

Raise a song,
strike the timbrel,
The-sweet-sounding-lyre, with the harp.

Blow the-trumpet at-the-new moon,
At-the-full moon,
on-our-feast day.


For-it-is-a-statute-for-Is-ra-el,
An, ordinance of-the-God-of-Ja, cob."



Verse 2 is a direct mirror in structure to verse 3, contrasting different instruments to be played. Then verse 3 follows through by contrasting different times to play those instruments: at the new moon, at the full moon, and on feast days (all three of which were times when Israel would celebrate), completing the poetic structure.

So a new moon (hodesh) is different from a full moon (keseh)...But is a new moon a dark moon (unseen) or a visible moon (seen)?

Well Genesis 1:14 says "let [the lights in the heavens] be for signs, appointed times, days, and years." So this tells us we're meant to see them so that they can indicate for us moments in time. A dark moon can't be seen because it gives off no visible light and thus bears no indication of what time it is per Genesis 1:14. But as soon as the moonlight is seen it satisfies God's commandment in Genesis and we can begin a new count of days until we see the moonlight again.

God never gives signs that are invisible. Signs are meant to be seen as "witnesses" to glorify Him.

So from the first instance of moonlight, when the barley crop is matured, we count 14 days to Passover, with the feast of Unleavened Bread being on the 15th day as instructed by God.
 

Yahshua

Senior Member
Sep 22, 2013
2,758
715
113
#99
I think it's fairly clear that the discussion now underway is the definition of what the term "new moon" means. I've already given a few reasons why I strongly lean towards the New Moon being a full moon and not a dark moon or first visible crescent.
Consider for a moment how the sun separates the day from the night...

This world would have us believe that the new day begins in the middle of the night...but again, following the instructions of genesis 1:14, as soon as the light from the sun breaks through the darkness it is no longer night but day. So likewise as soon as the sun sets it's no longer day but night.

Darkness and light are separated from each other (genesis 1:4). And it's the distinction between light and dark that marks change because "what communion hath light with darkness?" (2 Corinthians 6:14). So:

Light =/= Dark

Day =/= Night

Moon (visible) =/= No-Moon (dark)

Moonth =/= No-Moonth
 
Jul 16, 2013
87
1
0
If we look at the Hebrew words used in this passage, note that there are two different words used:


Hodesh = "new moon" or "month" (used over 280 times)


and


Keseh = "full moon" (used only 2 times)




Also, if we read Psalm 81, it's structure is poetry, not necessarily correlating the two words together but actually contrasting them as different moments in time. For example, imagine singing the first four verses to a 6/8 (doo-wop or fast waltz) beat for the effect:


[1 2 3 4 5 6...]
[1 2 3 4 5 6...]


"Sing-for-joy, to, God-our-strength;
Shout-joyfully-to-the-God-of-Ja, cob.


Raise a song,
strike the timbrel,
The-sweet-sounding-lyre, with the harp.


Blow the-trumpet at-the-new moon,
At-the-full moon,
on-our-feast day.


For-it-is-a-statute-for-Is-ra-el,
An, ordinance of-the-God-of-Ja, cob."




Verse 2 is a direct mirror in structure to verse 3, contrasting different instruments to be played. Then verse 3 follows through by contrasting different times to play those instruments: at the new moon, at the full moon, and on feast days (all three of which were times when Israel would celebrate), completing the poetic structure.


So a new moon (hodesh) is different from a full moon (keseh)...But is a new moon a dark moon (unseen) or a visible moon (seen)?
Your whole argument here rests on putting the Psalm to music and then getting creative with how they relate to each other because you think it fits better. I find this very unconvincing.



Well Genesis 1:14 says "let [the lights in the heavens] be for signs, appointed times, days, and years." So this tells us we're meant to see them so that they can indicate for us moments in time. A dark moon can't be seen because it gives off no visible light and thus bears no indication of what time it is per Genesis 1:14. But as soon as the moonlight is seen it satisfies God's commandment in Genesis and we can begin a new count of days until we see the moonlight again.


God never gives signs that are invisible. Signs are meant to be seen as "witnesses" to glorify Him.


So from the first instance of moonlight, when the barley crop is matured, we count 14 days to Passover, with the feast of Unleavened Bread being on the 15th day as instructed by God.

If one were to go by the first visible crescent this month, it is March 19, at 3.1%. Since division of days are reckoned from evening to evening, New Moon day (the daylight portion) is March 20th. Day 1 of new lunar month. Counting to 14 places Passover on the evening of the 2nd of April, which is a Monday.
You can go back and redefine your New Moon even two days when there isn't one. Even if you do this, at the very earliest passover would fall on a Saturday.


Anyway, for those who insist a New Moon is Dark or first visible crescent, you can believe that, but count 14 days and you'll wind up later than Friday the 30th, the day you are celebrating passover. .