The whole "redline" dept of Saturn was "sporty" and As for Scion the The FR-S/Subaru BRZ, I would rather have as the Subaru. Scion is the Company of the Brave yet Ugly Toaster and the Chic little X-a.
Yes, the Sub is a sveet ride. There are truely sweeter cars out there than anything Subaru or any incarnation of Toyota or GM has built, and I do not intend to say any one car mentioned is the apex of automobilia. I must have somehow missed the intensity of the "sportiness" you refer to from their redline. Sadly, the changes they were wisely making at Saturn were too late.
Alas, Saturn, you were just coming into your own at such an untimely death.
Love me some Toaster. the coolest boxy car readily available since the demise of the 240 - the car that taught us that Sweeds main automotive design tool was the Etch-a-Sketch. I think the Toaster achieved thing that the Cube failed (blatant personal preference)... and surpassed the Element in some respects, though I'd not normally compare the xB and the Element. That's like comparing UPS boxes with USPS boxes: they get you there, but the journey is not the same.
And I rented a Solstice in 2009. I was not thoroughly impressed but, I will say it didn't have a Standard and there wasn't any room for more than a Backpack.
What isn't better with a 3rd pedal?
A car like that was not meant for getting groceries in, but sadly it seems they may have performed like one. I felt it died as a fledgling that could have one day flown. Nice lines, but not sufficiently adept at leaving two black ones on the tarmac.
I like that we can disagree. If everyone agreed with me, would I ever learn and grow?