Please Vote for the Book You Want to Read

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Which book would you most like to read and discuss?

  • 1984 by George Orwell

    Votes: 4 20.0%
  • Brave New World by Aldous Huxley

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • The Giver by Lois Lowry

    Votes: 1 5.0%
  • The Idiot by Fyodor Dostoyevsky

    Votes: 3 15.0%
  • It Can't Happen Here by Sinclair Lewis

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • L'Mort D'Arthur - by Thomas Malory

    Votes: 3 15.0%
  • The Odyssey by Homer

    Votes: 3 15.0%
  • Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen

    Votes: 4 20.0%
  • Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Strong Poison by Dorothy Sayers

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    20
  • Poll closed .

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,021
26,149
113
#81
I'm thinking about it... if I could hire a maid I would have time and patience to read it. IDK, we'll see. :rolleyes:
Neil Young sang, A Man Needs A Maid. But I need one, too LOLOLOL :D

Ahem. A maid, not a man. Just to clarify. Since a woman needs a man like a fish needs a bicycle :D
 
Feb 1, 2017
586
3
0
#82
There are many lessons in Brave New World and 1984. Not the least of which is making government your God- this falls in line with "whatsoever things are true". I remember in Brave New World about the fact that people no longer could stand any pain, and were forever breathing in clouds of soma (I think the drug was called) pumped into their houses to tranquilize them all, and about the constant need for entertainment- two things that are a cautionary tale to us and go along with Christian truth. What is the message of Big Brother? It is conform, or else. The message of Christ is to NOT conform. There are a lot of Christian truths in both these books if we have eyes to see them. I think it will be an interesting discussion.

To compare the beauty of Austen to the trash of Gray (I don't even know the name of the author, so called)- is like comparing a diamond to a dollar store ring. I am going to trust that you are joking.

The Odyssey is Greek mythology, and I know some people who have qualms about reading mythology- BUT, I think it is good to compare- to compare the excellency of our God to the pettiness of the Greek gods. Our God, by comparison is worthy of worship.

I don't know that librarians and poets have such different tastes and opinions. It would depend upon the librarian and the poet, of course. You are a past master at making sweeping generalizations.
Well then you see, ain't so different from rap music excepting that the rappers, the illustrious poets of the modern age, actually have some bearing to the truth in their verses lol.

Lol no joke on Jane Austen and Fifty Shades of Gray. I mean they're written to the same audiences for the same purposes. Just different female fantasies is all.

As for the works of the greeks, I confess I have read them up and down and all around. I've been reading the stories of the inglorious white forefathers since the 1st grade. I actually quite agree with your assessment, to which I'd add even stripping away their daemonic religion that inside their tales contains all the sins still common to the Western races even in today's time. Some things just never change.

Oh I know the librarians and the poets have much different tastes and opinions. My sister was a librarian lol. The librarians and the highly educated elite find their tastes in our works ever looking for perfection in aestheticism. The poets are so much different, living inside their poems, breathing in and out the sordid tales of people most base and common in a tragic ugly world. A cathartic people they are indeed. Oh Dante, oh Sophocles, oh Poe! I'd wager a hefty sum the elite uppercrust that loves their poems so wouldn't even look sideways at those tortured vagrants if they ran into their souls.

Yet I see and agree somewhat how their differences compliment and feed each other. How God makes the opposites attract it seems. Why does the poor rapper verse about how he wants his riches to grow? Why does the elite delight in the plight of the poor man's woes? The wealthy reader craves a base man's prose. The lowly poet takes inspiration in his muse!
 
Feb 1, 2017
586
3
0
#83
Neil Young sang, A Man Needs A Maid. But I need one, too LOLOLOL :D

Ahem. A maid, not a man. Just to clarify. Since a woman needs a man like a fish needs a bicycle :D
Lol, that was a either a hilarious feminist joke, or quite the innuendo. Either way I thought it was hilarious and insightful.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,021
26,149
113
#84
Lol no joke on Jane Austen and Fifty Shades of Gray. I mean they're written to the same audiences for the same purposes. Just different female fantasies is all.
No, writing to the flesh to stir it to perversions of passion as if to say, hey we can all do this it ain't so bad, cannot truly be compared to writing (to the female fantasy as you call it) of living to one's highest ideal of love in seeking all that is good in life. My goodness, you talk as if there is no demarcation nor difference between bondage and a purity of mind that seeks to live well above gutter level :(
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,021
26,149
113
#85
Lol, that was a either a hilarious feminist joke, or quite the innuendo. Either way I thought it was hilarious and insightful.
Thank you heh, it was Bono sang that second line, though whom he was quoting is not certain :)
 

mar09

Senior Member
Sep 17, 2014
4,927
1,259
113
#86
I hate to disagree with you, but The Old Man and the Sea was one of the most boring books I have ever read. :( I think it is because I am from an area that makes its living from seafood, and a family that made its living from seafood- and it was just too unbelievable to me that a poor Cuban would starve himself in order to catch one fish. Not to down Hemingway, but that is a rich man's attitude toward fishing (a sports fisherman). A commercial fisherman would not be that impractical.
I see where you are coming from. But we are not rich -- and the old man had other qualities not many now can appreciate esp knowing how to talk with himself as the psalmist who said, 'Why so downcast O my soul... put your hope in God.' We also happen to have had a pastor before who was a (poor) fisherman (he said), not a rich commercial one. A small handsome man, you can admire how he teaches tho, and notice how dark he is having been in the sea so often.
 
Feb 1, 2017
586
3
0
#87
No, writing to the flesh to stir it to perversions of passion as if to say, hey we can all do this it ain't so bad, cannot truly be compared to writing (to the female fantasy as you call it) of living to one's highest ideal of love in seeking all that is good in life. My goodness, you talk as if there is no demarcation nor difference between bondage and a purity of mind that seeks to live well above gutter level :(
Lol so that's why the female fantasies novels are so popular with the older women lol. I don't know though, being a male virgin all their sexy tales seems all the same to me. I guarantee my ideal of love is much different than you might think.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,021
26,149
113
#88
Lol so that's why the female fantasies novels are so popular with the older women lol. I don't know though, being a male virgin all their sexy tales seems all the same to me. I guarantee my ideal of love is much different than you might think.
I would not call 50 shades love though, nor any kind of seeking after one's highest ideals, and to think I did misses the point. Jane Austen observed the foibles of the human condition quite penetratingly and had a decided knack for working all shades of human folly into her characters and storylines, but there was nary a foul word in P&P and nobody undressed anyone either LOLOLOL. For the record, I did not read 50 shades. I did read a few chapters to see what all the fuss was about, but I call it trash because that is what I found it to be and I have never had a liking for writing of that sort.
 
Feb 1, 2017
586
3
0
#89
I would not call 50 shades love though, nor any kind of seeking after one's highest ideals, and to think I did misses the point. Jane Austen observed the foibles of the human condition quite penetratingly and had a decided knack for working all shades of human folly into her characters and storylines, but there was nary a foul word in P&P and nobody undressed anyone either LOLOLOL. For the record, I did not read 50 shades. I did read a few chapters to see what all the fuss was about, but I call it trash because that is what I found it to be and I have never had a liking for writing of that sort.
I mean I have never read it either, yea, not even a word of it, so it could be or it could not be. Clearly your female curiosity took you into knowing more about Gray than me lol. I just find it a recurring peculiarity the audience is the same people.

As far as deeming a book trash or not, I have no real discrimination in the ever-changing arbitrary list of "foul words". To me a good book touches the soul. A trash book comes out of the cookie cutter, written for the sheer sake of money, written by tools.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,021
26,149
113
#90
I mean I have never read it either, yea, not even a word of it, so it could be or it could not be. Clearly your female curiosity took you into knowing more about Gray than me lol. I just find it a recurring peculiarity the audience is the same people.

As far as deeming a book trash or not, I have no real discrimination in the ever-changing arbitrary list of "foul words". To me a good book touches the soul. A trash book comes out of the cookie cutter, written for the sheer sake of money, written by tools.
Then 50 shades fits your definition of trash :) The audience of books is always readers, yes. Ha. I don't even know how I got my hands on that book, for it is not like I went looking for it. My daughter may have been given it from a friend of hers, though she would never be interested in anything like that, either. She reads very little literature actually, sadly. She was a consummate consumer of manga, though, and taught herself Japanese as a result of her love of it :)
 
Feb 1, 2017
586
3
0
#91
Then 50 shades fits your definition of trash :) The audience of books is always readers, yes. Ha. I don't even know how I got my hands on that book, for it is not like I went looking for it. My daughter may have been given it from a friend of hers, though she would never be interested in anything like that, either. She reads very little literature actually, sadly. She was a consummate consumer of manga, though, and taught herself Japanese as a result of her love of it :)
Lol well I can guess how your hands came to possess Gray lol, the audience is the reader indeed, the female readers for those smutty romance novels. As a male I feel ashamed, is my gender not fulfilling their sacred marriage duties?

As for your daughter, yes that's very common for both girls and guys alike of my generation, though I'd think your daughter be older than me. As for me I've always been the ugly duckling of my generation of swans. Though I never got too far into anime and manga, I do have a particular fondness for the Japanese language in music, it is quite beautiful. I also like their history, though its as bloody and perverse as Japheth's children's macabre tales. Such a shame that just like the ancient whites the Asians are largely daemon worshippers, Japan notably of Shem's brood.
 
Last edited:

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,021
26,149
113
#92
Lol well I can guess how your hands came to possess Gray lol, the audience is the reader indeed, the female readers for those smutty romance novels.

As for your daughter, yes that's very common for both girls and guys alike of my generation, though I'd think your daughter be older than me. As for me I've always been the ugly duckling of my generation of swans. Though I never got too far into anime and manga, I do have a particular fondness for the Japanese language in music, it is quite beautiful. I also like their history, though its as bloody and perverse as Japheth's children's macabre tales. Such a shame that just like the ancient whites the Asians are largely daemon worshippers, Japan notably of Shem's brood.
Smutty romance novels? And that is how you see the literature of Jane Austen? Truly you surprise me, and we shall never see eye to eye if that is the case. Oh, yes, someone could give you a stinking foul dish of rot and putrescence to eat for your supper, but that does not mean you would consume it nor even have ever thought to wish for such a foul dish to sit on your table for your sustenance. My daughter despises trash, and reads but little, whereas I have a great appetite for well written well told stories, with humanity well represented underbelly and all, but certainly replete with redeeming qualities; I will even read a bit of the trash occasionally to satisfy myself that it really is trash. I do know the difference. It is not that trash appeals to me, Gosh. I could barely stand to read the one book of Danielle Steel's that was lent to me. I forced myself to in order not to insult my friend, who had lent it to me, just as I had lent her the last book I had read at the time.
 
Feb 1, 2017
586
3
0
#93
Smutty romance novels? And that is how you see the literature of Jane Austen? Truly you surprise me, and we shall never see eye to eye if that is the case. Oh, yes, someone could give you a stinking foul dish of rot and putrescence to eat for your supper, but that does not mean you would consume it nor even have ever thought to wish for such a foul dish to sit on your table for your sustenance. My daughter despises trash, and reads but little, whereas I have a great appetite for well written well told stories, with humanity well represented underbelly and all, but certainly replete with redeeming qualities; I will even read a bit of the trash occasionally to satisfy myself that it really is trash. I do know the difference. It is not that trash appeals to me, Gosh. I could barely stand to read the one book of Danielle Steel's that was lent to me. I forced myself to in order not to insult my friend, who had lent it to me, just as I had lent her the last book I had read at the time.
Lol never heard of Danielle Steele, but I can only guess lol, and if I sweep the dust in my generalizations I'd bet my guess wouldn't be too far wrong.

As for eating putrescence, clearly you never tried my mother's cooking lol. No, just joking she has become much better with age at that craft, but for real back in the day when you're fed freezer burn and ash or you starve you will learn not to complain too much, but to find humor and insights in all things. Yea just as it is written, they gave him gall to drink!

The entire world is pretty dark and dank and full of filth, that's just a fact. We'll find that out surely in 1984. As far as fictions are false, this paradigm they can never escape. That's why of all books I have read high and low, ancient and modern, The Bible comes out on top clearly. It is very cathartic, but it is nevertheless true.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,021
26,149
113
#94
PS my daughter is thirty :D We watched a lot of anime together :) When I say she reads but little, I mean books in general. She reads an incredible amount from time to time online, learning how to fix or replace something on her cell phone or computer, and fan fiction etc. She is given books from friends and they sit on the table unread. I have picked up a few over the years, reading some of the True Blood series a number of years ago, and then a couple of years ago a few chapters of the filthy shades, and last year a lovely book by Richard Wagamese called Indian Horse. I had not read anything for a while before reading that, and I found it lovely despite some of the subject matter...
 
Feb 1, 2017
586
3
0
#96
PS my daughter is thirty :D We watched a lot of anime together :) When I say she reads but little, I mean books in general. She reads an incredible amount from time to time online, learning how to fix or replace something on her cell phone or computer, and fan fiction etc. She is given books from friends and they sit on the table unread. I have picked up a few over the years, reading some of the True Blood series a number of years ago, and then a couple of years ago a few chapters of the filthy shades, and last year a lovely book by Richard Wagamese called Indian Horse. I had not read anything for a while before reading that, and I found it lovely despite some of the subject matter...
Oh okay, so your daughter is just passing her youth. Sounds very typical then of the people my age, especially of the more introverted sort. Lol yes they read and write a lot of texts. This is another thing I have always been an ugly duck in regards to my generation, but I find your generation indulges in the new technologies more than mine. Lol a funny story. Back in highschool my dad was steaming at paying the overcharges for texts. I was profusely apologizing for I reckoned I used 25 of them of the monthly 100. He said oh it's not me and handed me the bill. Dad used the least with 6. I used the 2nd least with 21. Sister went to 200 some. Then there was my mom, unbeknownst to all of us she racked up over 600!
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,021
26,149
113
#97
Lol never heard of Danielle Steele, but I can only guess lol, and if I sweep the dust in my generalizations I'd bet my guess wouldn't be too far wrong.

As for eating putrescence, clearly you never tried my mother's cooking lol. No, just joking she has become much better with age at that craft, but for real back in the day when you're fed freezer burn and ash or you starve you will learn not to complain too much, but to find humor and insights in all things. Yea just as it is written, they gave him gall to drink!

The entire world is pretty dark and dank and full of filth, that's just a fact. We'll find that out surely in 1984. As far as fictions are false, this paradigm they can never escape. That's why of all books I have read high and low, ancient and modern, The Bible comes out on top clearly. It is very cathartic, but it is nevertheless true.
The Bible delivers the unvarnished truth of human nature, yes, we must love it for its unflinching portrayal of who we are under the thin veneer of civility and manners we have acquired and that can fall off so readily if easily provoked, and yet there is also love and idealism, and a plan that He has that includes us if we but co operate with Him, and I have come to think and to feel and to truly believe that despite some of the terrors and traumas and trials of my life that I am fortunate indeed, and have much to be grateful for despite all my failings and folly and despite all the failings and folly of others, for I comprehend the love of God and cherish it in my heart and wish to share it with others, and what greater treasure in all the world is there than that?
 
Feb 1, 2017
586
3
0
#98
The Bible delivers the unvarnished truth of human nature, yes, we must love it for its unflinching portrayal of who we are under the thin veneer of civility and manners we have acquired and that can fall off so readily if easily provoked, and yet there is also love and idealism, and a plan that He has that includes us if we but co operate with Him, and I have come to think and to feel and to truly believe that despite some of the terrors and traumas and trials of my life that I am fortunate indeed, and have much to be grateful for despite all my failings and folly and despite all the failings and folly of others, for I comprehend the love of God and cherish it in my heart and wish to share it with others, and what greater treasure in all the world is there than that?
Oh I'd quite agree. Though as far as thin manners go, I find the masters of etiquette are some of the foulest inside. I do believe the Bible says much the same but in starker words. I agree on sharing though, and share I do with boldness. I find the people of the baser sort to be more accepting of those purely written words, but when I talk to the high browed people, behold they are repulsed! They cannot believe the words are not what they teach in church. The parable of the nobles being invited to the wedding and excusing themselves and refusing to come and all the people they hold to be the scum of the highways are invited instead with joy comes to my mind.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,021
26,149
113
#99
Oh I'd quite agree. Though as far as thin manners go, I find the masters of etiquette are some of the foulest inside. I do believe the Bible says much the same but in starker words. I agree on sharing though, and share I do with boldness. I find the people of the baser sort to be more accepting of those purely written words, but when I talk to the high browed people, behold they are repulsed! They cannot believe the words are not what they teach in church. The parable of the nobles being invited to the wedding and excusing themselves and refusing to come and all the people they hold to be the scum of the highways are invited instead with joy comes to my mind.
Yes, the King has invited all to the wedding supper of His beloved Son, and the high and mighty are too busy with their own affairs to be bothered to attend. However, we are all vagabonds until we accept the invitation. I remember as a young Christian not so many years ago thinking about the proper clothes to wear to such a feast, but of course there is only one acceptable robe :)
 
Feb 1, 2017
586
3
0
Yes, the King has invited all to the wedding supper of His beloved Son, and the high and mighty are too busy with their own affairs to be bothered to attend. However, we are all vagabonds until we accept the invitation. I remember as a young Christian not so many years ago thinking about the proper clothes to wear to such a feast, but of course there is only one acceptable robe :)
Indeed, a good parable.