Delicate situation with a friend

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
M

Miri

Guest
#1
So i have this married friend lets call her A

She has a daughter who started to develope scholiosis when she was about 14.
This is a condition where the spines twists and causes hunchback as the spine,
shoulders and pelvis are pushed out of alignment.

So something like this.

scoliosis2.jpg


She has been offered surgery to correct it multiple times and the above images show
that it can be corrected. Obviously there are risks and it is drastic surgery which involves
fixing, for want of a better word, scaffolding and rods to the spine to correct it.

The thing is my friend A and the husband who are both Christians, wanted to wait and
see and pray about the situation and look into the surgery and the condition first. They are
both really good down to earth people I would add.

This was a reasonable thing to do when the initial diagnoses was made. But then they came
to the conclusion that God was going to heal their daughter and told the daughter this and
everyone else they came across that God was going to heal her and surgery was not necessary.


Fast forward a few years, the daughter is now 18, the curvature of the spine is so bad she can't sit
straight up and has to lean to one side. She can't stand or walk for long periods of time. She has
breathing problems. She is very self conscious of her posture and wears very baggy loose clothing.
She is also very shy and hardly ever socialises with other people. With each passing year
as she is growing and her skeleton is maturing, it means that the surgery will be more drastic with
a longer recovery time than if she had it aged 14.

She is absolutely fantastic at art, very gifted you won't believe the stuff she is capable of drawing.
She did start at art college when she was 17, but had to drop out after a few months as she
could not sit for very long without pain. So now she just stays at home and hardly goes
anywhere. Sometimes she comes to church but always is very self conscious and she is just
miserable.

But her parents just tell everyone God is going to heal her.

Various people including me and others and the church pastors have said that while God can and
does heal, that God also uses medical staff and surgery in that healing process. But the parents
have just criticised everyone else for their unbelief.


The thing is the daughter on a few occasions has had a few visions in the past in
which an envelope with wings came flying by the daughter's bedroom window but something was
blocking it from getting in.

I also have another friend we will call her friend B (See I do have real friends :)).
Recently she had a similar vision of an envelope with wings which could not enter the
house but then it got inside and landed on the daughter's bed. My friend B said she
felt it was to do with the offer of surgery and that it was the right time to accept it.
She sent this by text to the whole family parents and daughter etc and there ended up
being a massive argument and lots of upset. With my friend A accusing my friend B of
being insensitive and not having faith.


The arguments have been sorted out now, but as a result of sorting out the argument, it
has now come to light that the hospital has been sending letters out for follow
up appointments but my friend A and her husband have been keeping these letter from the
daughter. They still haven't told her, only me and friend B know about this.

Friend B who found out about this told friend A she can't do that it is illegal to withhold another
person's mail and now the daughter is 18 anyway so she is old enough to make her own decisions.
It all makes perfect sense now that these visions were about hospital letters and aappointments
not reaching the daughter!


However my friend A is still adamant that God will heal her daughter and that it is riduculous to
think otherwise. Although she now says she will pass on any further letters.

The daughter poor thing is just going along with what her parents have been saying for the past
4 years. I think they have told her so much about the surgery that she is scared to even think about
having it and even more scared she will disappoint her parents by having the surgery.

Me and friend B are praying that when the next hospital appointment comes along that the daughter
will go and have the surgery and that the parents will understand and see the problems they are
causing.

Friend A and hubby are adamant their daughter will be healed, that it is going to be a wonderful
testimony for the entire church and that it will bring revival and floods of people into the church.
I would add that we already have revival and a flood of people coming into the church.

Sorry long story.

So how would you handle this, am I wrong for thinking surgery is one way in which God heals
and that there is nothing wrong with praying for a good outcome via surgery.

Whenever we mention surgery to friend A it causes more upset she gets very annoyed.
The poor daughter is caught in the middle in constant pain, shy, self conscious but does not
want to go against her parents by going for surgery.

I just feel this is a situation where the whole word of faith doctrine has gotten way out of
hand. It has not come from my church it is things the parents have seen on TV.

Or am I at fault for not believing in outright healing?

The thing is in the UK we are blessed to have totally free medical care, is that not
a miracle and part of God's provision also and what about those visions of envelopes
not reaching the daughter which were absolutely spot on. Was this not from God.

A whole young person's life could be ruined if surgery continues to be refused
and the older she gets the harder the surgery will be and the more complications
will be caused, damage to lungs, ligaments, muscles etc. :(
 

blue_ladybug

Senior Member
Feb 21, 2014
70,924
9,673
113
#2
God definitely uses surgery to heal us. He also uses doctors and medicine. I commend these people for their faith, but they're subjecting their daughter to needless suffering. They need to get proactive and let her have surgery. God does NOT help those who don't help themselves..
 

peacenik

Senior Member
May 11, 2016
3,071
26
38
#3
First, withholding of mail in the USA and in the UK is illegal. Contact your local postal inspector for instructions on how to handle this.

If the young lady is now 18 years of age, no one can make a medical determination for her. She is free to consent to surgery if she pleases, no one can deny her that privilege. Based upon what you have written, it is time for her to go forward with the needed correction. If you can, get her grandparents to intercede. That should go a long way towards fixing this problem.
 
K

kaylagrl

Guest
#4
So i have this married friend lets call her A

She has a daughter who started to develope scholiosis when she was about 14.
This is a condition where the spines twists and causes hunchback as the spine,
shoulders and pelvis are pushed out of alignment.

So something like this.

View attachment 149445


She has been offered surgery to correct it multiple times and the above images show
that it can be corrected. Obviously there are risks and it is drastic surgery which involves
fixing, for want of a better word, scaffolding and rods to the spine to correct it.

The thing is my friend A and the husband who are both Christians, wanted to wait and
see and pray about the situation and look into the surgery and the condition first. They are
both really good down to earth people I would add.

This was a reasonable thing to do when the initial diagnoses was made. But then they came
to the conclusion that God was going to heal their daughter and told the daughter this and
everyone else they came across that God was going to heal her and surgery was not necessary.


Fast forward a few years, the daughter is now 18, the curvature of the spine is so bad she can't sit
straight up and has to lean to one side. She can't stand or walk for long periods of time. She has
breathing problems. She is very self conscious of her posture and wears very baggy loose clothing.
She is also very shy and hardly ever socialises with other people. With each passing year
as she is growing and her skeleton is maturing, it means that the surgery will be more drastic with
a longer recovery time than if she had it aged 14.

She is absolutely fantastic at art, very gifted you won't believe the stuff she is capable of drawing.
She did start at art college when she was 17, but had to drop out after a few months as she
could not sit for very long without pain. So now she just stays at home and hardly goes
anywhere. Sometimes she comes to church but always is very self conscious and she is just
miserable.

But her parents just tell everyone God is going to heal her.

Various people including me and others and the church pastors have said that while God can and
does heal, that God also uses medical staff and surgery in that healing process. But the parents
have just criticised everyone else for their unbelief.


The thing is the daughter on a few occasions has had a few visions in the past in
which an envelope with wings came flying by the daughter's bedroom window but something was
blocking it from getting in.

I also have another friend we will call her friend B (See I do have real friends :)).
Recently she had a similar vision of an envelope with wings which could not enter the
house but then it got inside and landed on the daughter's bed. My friend B said she
felt it was to do with the offer of surgery and that it was the right time to accept it.
She sent this by text to the whole family parents and daughter etc and there ended up
being a massive argument and lots of upset. With my friend A accusing my friend B of
being insensitive and not having faith.


The arguments have been sorted out now, but as a result of sorting out the argument, it
has now come to light that the hospital has been sending letters out for follow
up appointments but my friend A and her husband have been keeping these letter from the
daughter. They still haven't told her, only me and friend B know about this.

Friend B who found out about this told friend A she can't do that it is illegal to withhold another
person's mail and now the daughter is 18 anyway so she is old enough to make her own decisions.
It all makes perfect sense now that these visions were about hospital letters and aappointments
not reaching the daughter!


However my friend A is still adamant that God will heal her daughter and that it is riduculous to
think otherwise. Although she now says she will pass on any further letters.

The daughter poor thing is just going along with what her parents have been saying for the past
4 years. I think they have told her so much about the surgery that she is scared to even think about
having it and even more scared she will disappoint her parents by having the surgery.

Me and friend B are praying that when the next hospital appointment comes along that the daughter
will go and have the surgery and that the parents will understand and see the problems they are
causing.

Friend A and hubby are adamant their daughter will be healed, that it is going to be a wonderful
testimony for the entire church and that it will bring revival and floods of people into the church.
I would add that we already have revival and a flood of people coming into the church.

Sorry long story.

So how would you handle this, am I wrong for thinking surgery is one way in which God heals
and that there is nothing wrong with praying for a good outcome via surgery.

Whenever we mention surgery to friend A it causes more upset she gets very annoyed.
The poor daughter is caught in the middle in constant pain, shy, self conscious but does not
want to go against her parents by going for surgery.

I just feel this is a situation where the whole word of faith doctrine has gotten way out of
hand. It has not come from my church it is things the parents have seen on TV.

Or am I at fault for not believing in outright healing?

The thing is in the UK we are blessed to have totally free medical care, is that not
a miracle and part of God's provision also and what about those visions of envelopes
not reaching the daughter which were absolutely spot on. Was this not from God.

A whole young person's life could be ruined if surgery continues to be refused
and the older she gets the harder the surgery will be and the more complications
will be caused, damage to lungs, ligaments, muscles etc. :(


There is a difference between faith and foolishness. I believe its Gods will to heal,that is what the Bible says. But I dont believe its Gods will for this girl to suffer the way she is. If anything the parents are turning her away from faith. God does not want her suffering. Jesus touched a person and they were healed. If they had that type of faith the girl would be healed by now. Talking about it and having the faith to see it happen are two different things. The girl should get the surgery and let the parents deal with their own issues.
 
M

MadParrotWoman

Guest
#5
Totally agree with comments #2 & #3. God heals in many different ways, guiding a skilled surgeon's hands is just one.
 
M

Miri

Guest
#6
Thanks for the comments everyone. It's such a frustrating situation.

Kaylagirl I agree with you , yes God does heal I've experienced that
myself but I have also seen God heal via medical staff.

With my aunt the medical staff did their bit and God did what they could not do.

Peacenik unfortunately the grand parents aren't an option.

Blue she is suffering needlessly that's a crying shame as she is so talented.

I just worry now that she has been influenced for so long by her parent, who are
still adamant God will heal her, that she doesn't want to disappoint them. But there again
if they were so sure, why did they withhold her mail.

I think they all need to clear out any preconceived ideas and look at this with
fresh eyes. Plus have a good long chat with the hospital, especially the daughter.

You cant tell my friend anything though as she just accuses everyone of unbelief.
The other thing is the daughter recently became interested in learning Japanese.
So friend A has now got it into her head that God will heal the daughter who will then
go and be a missionary to Japan.

Maybe, maybe not but it shows the massive ill thought out assumptions being made.

We need a good dose of Godly wisdom and common sense in this situation.
 
Feb 28, 2016
11,311
2,974
113
#7
a very hard lesson we have learned is that we cannot step into another family's business, unless
we are invited to give our opinion or experience in a particular situation,.,.

many years ago, I did subject myself to surgery for a broken-neck, but I was also abused during this time,
in the hospital and out at the doctor's office...at this time, I was not a member of the Body of Christ...

fast-forward, in my NOW situation, I have been told that I must have surgery NOW in order to have
any kind of quality of life...but upon researching this particular operation, the statics were so negative
that we, my husband and myself, with the guidance of the Holy Spirit, have decided to NOT have the
surgery...we certainly would NOT entertain anyone else's advice in this personal, bodily,
delimma...
when you find out that several so called experts are not giving you the 'whole picture', 'down-side' or
the 'worst scenario', and that you have figured out that there is going to be a HUGE amount of $$$
going into their pockets, then, it is your personal-choice, just who to Trust...

we chose to Trust in The Lord....is it a roller-coaster-ride?? yes, but the benefits of TRUSTING in The Lord,
have so out-weighted the ups-and-downs of the roller coaster ride...!!!

PRO. 3:5-6. -
Trust in the LORD with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding.
In all thy ways acknowledge Him, and He shall direct thy paths.
 

sandtigeress

Senior Member
Apr 29, 2013
526
16
18
#8
God will heal through the operation. There is nothing on this earth that is not made by our god. So the hospital procedure that helps and heals this condition is made by god and so that is a way that god will heal.

I do not understand why people are so unbelieving in god, that they want to limit his ways of fulfilling their prayers :(
Sorry may be you can get them, by telling them the unbelief is theirs, in not believing that god can bring success and healing through the doctors.

Many blessings to the young woman and may all of them find a better communication with our almighty god.
 
M

Miri

Guest
#9
a very hard lesson we have learned is that we cannot step into another family's business, unless
we are invited to give our opinion or experience in a particular situation,.,.

many years ago, I did subject myself to surgery for a broken-neck, but I was also abused during this time,
in the hospital and out at the doctor's office...at this time, I was not a member of the Body of Christ...

fast-forward, in my NOW situation, I have been told that I must have surgery NOW in order to have
any kind of quality of life...but upon researching this particular operation, the statics were so negative
that we, my husband and myself, with the guidance of the Holy Spirit, have decided to NOT have the
surgery...we certainly would NOT entertain anyone else's advice in this personal, bodily,
delimma...
when you find out that several so called experts are not giving you the 'whole picture', 'down-side' or
the 'worst scenario', and that you have figured out that there is going to be a HUGE amount of $$$
going into their pockets, then, it is your personal-choice, just who to Trust...

we chose to Trust in The Lord....is it a roller-coaster-ride?? yes, but the benefits of TRUSTING in The Lord,
have so out-weighted the ups-and-downs of the roller coaster ride...!!!

PRO. 3:5-6. -
Trust in the LORD with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding.
In all thy ways acknowledge Him, and He shall direct thy paths.

Sorry to hear of your troubles and yes it is completely the case that at times we
need to trust in God and reject man's opinion.

I did that myself a few years back when I had Graves disease (over active thyroid)
and the doctors wanted to subject me to radio iodine treatment. I refused after
careful consideration and prayer and it wasn't a cure any way it would just have
made be under active and destroyed my thyroid gland. So sometimes we need
to make our own choices.

This situation feels so different though, there is deception going on with the
parents withholding medical letters intended for their daughter. That can't be right.

Plus their decision has already caused 4 years of pain, increased problems and distress
to their daughter. I think they need to stop imposing their views on the daughter now
and help her to see all the facts and information available and make it clear that whatever
she decides, they will support her.

Unfortunately that isn't happening they are still vermontly against any medical
intervention and imposing their decision on the daughter.

She has been so deeply effected by all this, she is sinking into depression with it all.

Praying for you :)
 
N

NewWine

Guest
#10
This reminds me a of a story I heard once......There was a reported hurricane coming, and massive flooding. People were evacuation and buses were going around for those who had no transportation. The bus stopped at a man's house and he waved the bus on saying, "Go on without me, God will save me!".

The storm came and the floods entered his house....the man raced upstairs praying for God to save him.....and a boat came by and offered to take him to safety. He replied, "No. go on. God will save me."

The floods got worse and the man was on his roof, praying, God come save me. Along came a helicopter, offering to save the man. Again he refused, saying "God will save me!". The helicopter left.
A short while later a huge wave crashed, sweeping the man off his roof, and he drowned. When he met God, he said God, why didn't you save me?
God replied, " I sent a bus a boat and a helicopter....what more did you need?

We can't force this family to change, and while legally, this girl IS old enough to choose, she is still dependent on her family, and this weighs on her heavily. Be careful in how you proceed here. Prayers for all involved. Peace.
 
F

Faithful_Fay

Guest
#11
Interestingly enough, I was reading an article a few weeks ago about this very topic. A girl who was born with a treatable heart condition was denied surgery when she was younger by her parents who are the sort of Christian who believed God would heal her only through faith. Fast forward years and her health has deteriorated so badly that she is awaiting a heart transplant. Again, this whole mess originated from a treatable condition. Her situation was in the news because she decided to take her parents to court.

When my mother was diagnosed with liver cancer, there were folks who tried to sway her towards the no medical intervention route, too. Thank God she was a mature enough Christian to consult God and not be influenced too easily. I can tell you of another woman my mother was taking care of who was diagnosed with breast cancer. Unfortunately, she was a newer believer. Her prayer group included someone who told her to stop treatment because God would heal her. I'm guessing that charlatan was not interested in attending her funeral after she had passed.

Spreaking from the perspective of a person who has worked in a few hospitals, I wish I could say I haven't seen something similar with parents but I can't. I just find people who are willing to sacrifice others for their beliefs to be interesting people. Their version of faith is something that I'd rather distance myself from. I find a distinct lack of logic, compassion, foresight, empathy, and so on. The arrogance in demanding/expecting God to work only in a manner that they deem appropriate is mind boggling.
 
Jan 24, 2012
1,299
15
0
#12
So i have this married friend lets call her A

She has a daughter who started to develope scholiosis when she was about 14.
This is a condition where the spines twists and causes hunchback as the spine,
shoulders and pelvis are pushed out of alignment.

So something like this.

View attachment 149445


She has been offered surgery to correct it multiple times and the above images show
that it can be corrected. Obviously there are risks and it is drastic surgery which involves
fixing, for want of a better word, scaffolding and rods to the spine to correct it.

The thing is my friend A and the husband who are both Christians, wanted to wait and
see and pray about the situation and look into the surgery and the condition first. They are
both really good down to earth people I would add.

This was a reasonable thing to do when the initial diagnoses was made. But then they came
to the conclusion that God was going to heal their daughter and told the daughter this and
everyone else they came across that God was going to heal her and surgery was not necessary.


Fast forward a few years, the daughter is now 18, the curvature of the spine is so bad she can't sit
straight up and has to lean to one side. She can't stand or walk for long periods of time. She has
breathing problems. She is very self conscious of her posture and wears very baggy loose clothing.
She is also very shy and hardly ever socialises with other people. With each passing year
as she is growing and her skeleton is maturing, it means that the surgery will be more drastic with
a longer recovery time than if she had it aged 14.

She is absolutely fantastic at art, very gifted you won't believe the stuff she is capable of drawing.
She did start at art college when she was 17, but had to drop out after a few months as she
could not sit for very long without pain. So now she just stays at home and hardly goes
anywhere. Sometimes she comes to church but always is very self conscious and she is just
miserable.

But her parents just tell everyone God is going to heal her.

Various people including me and others and the church pastors have said that while God can and
does heal, that God also uses medical staff and surgery in that healing process. But the parents
have just criticised everyone else for their unbelief.


The thing is the daughter on a few occasions has had a few visions in the past in
which an envelope with wings came flying by the daughter's bedroom window but something was
blocking it from getting in.

I also have another friend we will call her friend B (See I do have real friends :)).
Recently she had a similar vision of an envelope with wings which could not enter the
house but then it got inside and landed on the daughter's bed. My friend B said she
felt it was to do with the offer of surgery and that it was the right time to accept it.
She sent this by text to the whole family parents and daughter etc and there ended up
being a massive argument and lots of upset. With my friend A accusing my friend B of
being insensitive and not having faith.


The arguments have been sorted out now, but as a result of sorting out the argument, it
has now come to light that the hospital has been sending letters out for follow
up appointments but my friend A and her husband have been keeping these letter from the
daughter. They still haven't told her, only me and friend B know about this.

Friend B who found out about this told friend A she can't do that it is illegal to withhold another
person's mail and now the daughter is 18 anyway so she is old enough to make her own decisions.
It all makes perfect sense now that these visions were about hospital letters and aappointments
not reaching the daughter!


However my friend A is still adamant that God will heal her daughter and that it is riduculous to
think otherwise. Although she now says she will pass on any further letters.

The daughter poor thing is just going along with what her parents have been saying for the past
4 years. I think they have told her so much about the surgery that she is scared to even think about
having it and even more scared she will disappoint her parents by having the surgery.

Me and friend B are praying that when the next hospital appointment comes along that the daughter
will go and have the surgery and that the parents will understand and see the problems they are
causing.

Friend A and hubby are adamant their daughter will be healed, that it is going to be a wonderful
testimony for the entire church and that it will bring revival and floods of people into the church.
I would add that we already have revival and a flood of people coming into the church.

Sorry long story.

So how would you handle this, am I wrong for thinking surgery is one way in which God heals
and that there is nothing wrong with praying for a good outcome via surgery.

Whenever we mention surgery to friend A it causes more upset she gets very annoyed.
The poor daughter is caught in the middle in constant pain, shy, self conscious but does not
want to go against her parents by going for surgery.

I just feel this is a situation where the whole word of faith doctrine has gotten way out of
hand. It has not come from my church it is things the parents have seen on TV.

Or am I at fault for not believing in outright healing?

The thing is in the UK we are blessed to have totally free medical care, is that not
a miracle and part of God's provision also and what about those visions of envelopes
not reaching the daughter which were absolutely spot on. Was this not from God.

A whole young person's life could be ruined if surgery continues to be refused
and the older she gets the harder the surgery will be and the more complications
will be caused, damage to lungs, ligaments, muscles etc. :(
This isn't a delicate situation. It's called child neglect and I'm appalled that nobody from your church called child protective services.

Or maybe stupid parents can abuse their children in the UK. WHAT IN THE WORLD?

Child NeglectChronic Child Neglect – Understanding the definition and impact of neglect
 
E

ember

Guest
#13
how old does the girl have to be before she can proceed without her parents consent?

IMO, those parents are not hearing from God...and they are playing with the girl's condition

there is a big difference between presumption and faith...

the fact they keep the letters from the hospital from her is bothersome IMO...just not right
 
M

Miri

Guest
#15
It wasn't child neglect, just a bad decision.

They did seek medical advice, but just decided surgery was not the option
they wanted to take at that time. Then their decision later impacted on their
daughter who was 14, now 18.

Social services we call them over here, can't force a teen to have surgery even if
they may have been unduly influenced by the parents. Doctors would also have
reported them if they felt there was some sort of parental neglect.

I agree though that when making a decision on behalf of someone who is under age,
that great care has to be taken. Only they seem to think it was the right decision.

They are both professional people the mum being a maths teacher and dad is
currently a driver for the out of hours doctor home visit services. So they are not
uneducated or neglectful, just mis guided.
 
M

Miri

Guest
#16
how old does the girl have to be before she can proceed without her parents consent?

IMO, those parents are not hearing from God...and they are playing with the girl's condition

there is a big difference between presumption and faith...

the fact they keep the letters from the hospital from her is bothersome IMO...just not right
Hi Ember, she could in theory have requested the surgery herself right from the start, from age 14
providing doctors were certain she understood the full implications and was mature enough to
make that decision. Although I think her parents would have had to sign the actual consent form
on her behalf until she reached the age of 16.

So now she is 18 there is nothing to stop her making all the decisions all by herself.
But parental influence and not wanting to disappoint them is a big thing for an 18 year
old to over come. She is also a young 18 year old and has been sheltered a lot.
 
Jan 24, 2012
1,299
15
0
#17
It wasn't child neglect, just a bad decision.

They did seek medical advice, but just decided surgery was not the option
they wanted to take at that time. Then their decision later impacted on their
daughter who was 14, now 18.

Social services we call them over here, can't force a teen to have surgery even if
they may have been unduly influenced by the parents. Doctors would also have
reported them if they felt there was some sort of parental neglect.

I agree though that when making a decision on behalf of someone who is under age,
that great care has to be taken. Only they seem to think it was the right decision.

They are both professional people the mum being a maths teacher and dad is
currently a driver for the out of hours doctor home visit services. So they are not
uneducated or neglectful, just mis guided.
No way. That kid is going to be in a wheelchair or dead when shes 30 because of what they are choosing to do. That's neglect. Call it misguided or ill informed or stupid. It's neglect
 
Jan 24, 2012
1,299
15
0
#18
You need to call Social Services on them. It doesn't matter whether or not they are able to do anything. You can't get in trouble and the parents need to at least know that people are noticing what neglectful idiots they are. I know they're your friends or w/e but you need to take the higher priority. If I found out my friend was molesting kids or raping/killing people because he was "misguided", he better know I would call him in.

0808 800 5000
 
Last edited:
M

Miri

Guest
#19
It's hardly the same thing, rape, molestation never was the issue, you are
letting your imagination run away with you. The web site you posted also
only intervened on medical neglect cases in certain circumstsnces but not all.
So even in the US there are limitations as to when child services will get involved
if you scroll down and take a look in regards to medical issues.

Besides I think there is an age difference between the UK and USA.

At age 16 over here, you can leave home, get a job, get married with parental
consent etc. The daughter is now 18 so she is already at the age of consent
separate from her parents decision making.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
D

Depleted

Guest
#20
So i have this married friend lets call her A

She has a daughter who started to develope scholiosis when she was about 14.
This is a condition where the spines twists and causes hunchback as the spine,
shoulders and pelvis are pushed out of alignment.

So something like this.

View attachment 149445


She has been offered surgery to correct it multiple times and the above images show
that it can be corrected. Obviously there are risks and it is drastic surgery which involves
fixing, for want of a better word, scaffolding and rods to the spine to correct it.

The thing is my friend A and the husband who are both Christians, wanted to wait and
see and pray about the situation and look into the surgery and the condition first. They are
both really good down to earth people I would add.

This was a reasonable thing to do when the initial diagnoses was made. But then they came
to the conclusion that God was going to heal their daughter and told the daughter this and
everyone else they came across that God was going to heal her and surgery was not necessary.


Fast forward a few years, the daughter is now 18, the curvature of the spine is so bad she can't sit
straight up and has to lean to one side. She can't stand or walk for long periods of time. She has
breathing problems. She is very self conscious of her posture and wears very baggy loose clothing.
She is also very shy and hardly ever socialises with other people. With each passing year
as she is growing and her skeleton is maturing, it means that the surgery will be more drastic with
a longer recovery time than if she had it aged 14.

She is absolutely fantastic at art, very gifted you won't believe the stuff she is capable of drawing.
She did start at art college when she was 17, but had to drop out after a few months as she
could not sit for very long without pain. So now she just stays at home and hardly goes
anywhere. Sometimes she comes to church but always is very self conscious and she is just
miserable.

But her parents just tell everyone God is going to heal her.

Various people including me and others and the church pastors have said that while God can and
does heal, that God also uses medical staff and surgery in that healing process. But the parents
have just criticised everyone else for their unbelief.


The thing is the daughter on a few occasions has had a few visions in the past in
which an envelope with wings came flying by the daughter's bedroom window but something was
blocking it from getting in.

I also have another friend we will call her friend B (See I do have real friends :)).
Recently she had a similar vision of an envelope with wings which could not enter the
house but then it got inside and landed on the daughter's bed. My friend B said she
felt it was to do with the offer of surgery and that it was the right time to accept it.
She sent this by text to the whole family parents and daughter etc and there ended up
being a massive argument and lots of upset. With my friend A accusing my friend B of
being insensitive and not having faith.


The arguments have been sorted out now, but as a result of sorting out the argument, it
has now come to light that the hospital has been sending letters out for follow
up appointments but my friend A and her husband have been keeping these letter from the
daughter. They still haven't told her, only me and friend B know about this.

Friend B who found out about this told friend A she can't do that it is illegal to withhold another
person's mail and now the daughter is 18 anyway so she is old enough to make her own decisions.
It all makes perfect sense now that these visions were about hospital letters and aappointments
not reaching the daughter!


However my friend A is still adamant that God will heal her daughter and that it is riduculous to
think otherwise. Although she now says she will pass on any further letters.

The daughter poor thing is just going along with what her parents have been saying for the past
4 years. I think they have told her so much about the surgery that she is scared to even think about
having it and even more scared she will disappoint her parents by having the surgery.

Me and friend B are praying that when the next hospital appointment comes along that the daughter
will go and have the surgery and that the parents will understand and see the problems they are
causing.

Friend A and hubby are adamant their daughter will be healed, that it is going to be a wonderful
testimony for the entire church and that it will bring revival and floods of people into the church.
I would add that we already have revival and a flood of people coming into the church.

Sorry long story.

So how would you handle this, am I wrong for thinking surgery is one way in which God heals
and that there is nothing wrong with praying for a good outcome via surgery.

Whenever we mention surgery to friend A it causes more upset she gets very annoyed.
The poor daughter is caught in the middle in constant pain, shy, self conscious but does not
want to go against her parents by going for surgery.

I just feel this is a situation where the whole word of faith doctrine has gotten way out of
hand. It has not come from my church it is things the parents have seen on TV.

Or am I at fault for not believing in outright healing?

The thing is in the UK we are blessed to have totally free medical care, is that not
a miracle and part of God's provision also and what about those visions of envelopes
not reaching the daughter which were absolutely spot on. Was this not from God.

A whole young person's life could be ruined if surgery continues to be refused
and the older she gets the harder the surgery will be and the more complications
will be caused, damage to lungs, ligaments, muscles etc. :(
Someone I love dearly grew up like this. He wasn't the child with the illness. He was the brother of that child. But the child did have real health problems that were deadly, (and he did due from them), but their mother gained great satisfaction because if it and caused more problems than helped. (Worse yet, when the child did die, she became a nurse to do the same thing to other patients.) She didn't poison the kid or mistreat him, but health issues did help her mislead everyone while controlling the situation to suit her. She was a monster, and there aren't many people I'd ever call that.

Try reading up on Munchausen by Proxy Syndrome, because the parents are abusing the girl, and the girl trust them while being abused. They're also controlling you and all their other friends by keeping this a secret, so it's far worse than you think.

I think the only thing to do is to get the 18 year old away from them in a hurry. Yes, I heard you say they're down to earth kind people. No, they aren't. They just seem that way.