SALVATION ONLY POSSIBLE WITHOUT WORKS!

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,396
113
in closing, your entire argument is found here:

"Christ keeps His promise, but does man. Can man guarantee HIS FAITH? Find the text that guarantees man's faith. Then you will have made a point."

your works guarantee your faith, right?

i'll go with Paul, and the Holy Spirit being the guarantee of my inheritance. i received that seal when i heard the word of truth and believed in Christ.

Ephesians 1
13 In him you also, when you heard the word of truth, the gospel of your salvation, and believed in him, were sealed with the promised Holy Spirit, 14 who is the guarantee[a] of our inheritance until we acquire possession of it,[b] to the praise of his glory.

so long.
No doubt to this one and I agree with this as well.......works will NEVER gain or keep one secure in their salvation....EVER!
 
Aug 15, 2009
9,745
179
0
I don't know if you know it or not, but Wal-Mart sells bottles and diapers if you need to go buy some...maybe you can WORK for it!
I'd go to Walmart if they sold razorstraps & I was close to where you lived. Somebody needs a woodshed experience.

BTW, I have a full - time job, thank you.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
yes, there were many Jews of the OT that were saved, Abraham, Jacob, David, etc.

what does this have to do with timothy, who was a NT believer?

Talk about walking on thin ice. Better be carefull, it may break and you will be lost forever.


not when you extract the original meaning from it. That is what sola scriptura means.
No, Sola scriptura means scripture ALONE. Nice try, but you need to study.


The early Church never even had the Bible as you have it. They were taught orally.
Actually yes they did. Peter spoke of pauls letters and called it scripture. You should study real history some. They had paid scribes then who would make copies of all the letters and take them to all the churches.

It was th oral teaching that was held inviable until the 4th century when certain letters were Canonized as the NT with the OT added. Paul did not just write a letter and send it to some place like Corinth. He was actually there for almost three years. It was later that he wrote to them the letters we have in the Bible. The Corinthians knew and understood what he was saying without "interpreting it". They already knew and understood the gospel. The Apostles established the Churches, gave them the Gospel which was to be guarded and kept unified by the Holy Spirit through the Body with Christ as Head.
Wrong. As shown above, People had scripture as it was written, It did not take 400 years for the bible to get to all the churches, as already shown, All the people who read peters letters (which was written to EVERY church) already had pauls letters. and they were already considered scripture.

Not to mention. Paul quotes a passage of Luke and calls it scripture.


1 Timothy 5:18 For the Scripture says, “You shall not muzzle an ox while it treads out the grain,” and, “The laborer is worthy of his wages.”

found here


Luke 10:7
[SUP]7 [/SUP]And remain in the same house, eating and drinking such things as they give, for the laborer is worthy of his wages. Do not go from house to house

How could these thing be considered scripture already read and understood by these people if scripture was yet 400 years from being completed?



Yes, and it is the what you call the extra bibical that confirms what scripture has always meant. The Body through the ages has accepted these writings because they were faithful to the original teaching, the teaching they all knew for the oral.
You mean the same teaching PAUL called scripture. PETER called scripture?

Your listening to men, They had to write these things in stone ONLY because scripture did not support their belif, they did the same thing the jews did. WHen men adds to the word of God. you should run, for if scripture supported their beliefs in whole. then they would not need to make anything outside the word of God, they could rely on scripture alone.


The same scripture like timothy had written by Luke which made him wise for salvation?


Paul is not a sola scripturist. He lived only up to about 70 and only his letters existed at that time. He would not have thought that they might become Scripture as you understand it.

Yes he was. If you would read his writings you would see this.


2 Timothy 3:16 All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, [SUP]17 [/SUP]that the man of God may be complete, thoroughly equipped for every good work.

Paul would not teach that scripture is fully capable of making a man of God complete and fully equipped for any good work if he did not teach scripture alone.


Sola scriptura is a slogan right out of the Reformation, though the RCC uses the principle but never gave it a name. Protestants simply employed the method and set themselves up as individual Popes and declared their interpretation of scripture. The consequence thousands of gospels all derived by man, all based on scripture, but according to their own personal interpretation. The fact that there are thousands, we can know that all are false, except one, if that were possible, because there has only been ONE meaning to scripture.

Sola scriptura is a 4th century made up term because the roman church could not make scripture equal their own deformed and perverted doctrines, so they had to write things, and have things orally added to the word of god in order for their doctines to be believable.

Then they used the iron fist of rome to force everyone to believe their way or else.
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,396
113
Grace is not an attribute of God, it is the means by which a sinner is saved and not the source of his salvation and it comes through faith. The source of our salvation is in the blood of the cross that was shed by the Son of God. Mercy is God taking away what we deserve and grace is the means by which God gives to man what he does not deserve. The sinner is saved through the mercy and grace of God that comes to him by faith through our Lord Jesus Christ, who obtained eternal redemption for us.
Amen and double amen...I agree
 
J

jakester8194

Guest
If your a real disciple of Christ you will obey his commands he gives us grace because he knows we are not perfect and will fail. While I agree we are saved by grace alone if it were not so we would all be screwed. Myself included. However grace is not an excuse to do whatever you want, but is given as a gift to show how much he loves us. We still need to obey that allows him to work through us leading to greater works.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I agree with this as well and it seems that he does not understand that the guy who has works of wood (HAY) and stubble is a saved man who did not live his life as biblical as he should have and yet is still saved, but without the inheritance he could have had!
Not only will he miss out on that, But he missed out on the many blessings, and the huge amount of joy he would have had while alive on earth if he just trusted Christ with more parts of his life. And the many people they could have spent eternity with who would be gratefull to them for allowing god to work through them.
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,396
113

You have proven over and over you do not understand scripture at all. only your twisted version of it.

Anyone who states all men are saved is a universalist. there are many types. I guess you are one of them.



there was only one incarnation. that was God becoming man. so not what sure what that has to do with everyone being saved.



Yeah I do.

He accomplished the one thing that you and I can never do. He took our penalty in our stted. And because of it, THE OFFER of salvation can be given to all men.

Not like you say, and all men are saved.



more attack.. do you have anything real to say, You have no idea what I know and understand..


Well this goes to show you do not have a comprehension of what is said.

In adam all die. Yes this is correct. In Christ, everying is given th eopportunity to be saved.

This is what happens when you do not study the word of God, but take bits and peaces of it and form your own (or you believe an already formed) doctrine of men.

The penalty of sin is death, The gift of God is eternal life, to ALL WHO BELIEVE.

If one does not recieve the gift, they are still DEAD. there is NO LIFE. NO LIFE equals no salvation.

if you understood this basic fact you would see the flaw in your resoning.

There are only two states mentioned in scripture.

In Adam, Dead

In Christ, Alive

there is no inbetween, If God saved everyone, then the penalty of death has been removed from everyone, and everyone is already made alive in Christ.

Yet you say salvation does not occure till heaven, thus you have dead people being saved, and given the spirit of God as a guarantee of their inheritance.

Sorry, but this is wrong.



No I do not.
1. All Men at ALL times have been eternal beings.
2. ALL men in adam was deamed to suffer eternal death
3. Only those in Christ are offered eternal life.
4. The dead will not be ressurected to life, they will be delivered for judgment, That judgment being eternal death.
5. Only those IN CHRIST are promised to be ressurected to life.

You do not understand the term spiritul death vs spiritual life. You have tons of more study to do. And I would recomend you study yourself. and stop listening to the men you trust, for they have led you astray in untruths.




Where do you get this stuff from? Hell was created for satan, It was created the moment he fell. Man was never intended to go there, but it was STILL THERE.

Man chose to go their in their rebellion. They do not follow adam there, Adam will not be their, they follow their father satan there.

Gen 3:19. Even the New Heaven and New Earth is possible because Christ redeemed this world from destruction and death.



study what? There is nothing there to study.

You are the one who needs to study, to learn what spiritual death means, To learn what salvation means, To learn was being made alive IN CHRIST means.

to learn what ressurection means, To learn who will be ressurected and who will not. To learn who will be delivered for judgment, and who has passed from judgment to life.



Amen and I agree with everything you said....I stand amazed at some of the (stuff)<----cow pies...that get twisted and wrested out of the truth to only become heresy...especially when men teach you can loose (ETERNAL) life and have to do your own fleshly works to keep or gain (ETERNAL) life.....

Eternal life---looses it....Gains Eternal life---looses it---gains eternal life-----looses it<-----NOT SAVED PERIOD!
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,396
113
i was talking about God guaranteeing my inheritance, which is eternal life with him.

theres no guarantee everybody in the world is going to have faith. in fact we know the opposite is true. but we are talking about us are we not. i have faith. that faith tells me there is a God who came as man and died for my sin and was buried and rose again and is alive forevermore. my faith tells me that he has guaranteed my salvation, and that he can do it, since it isnt MY WORK but his own. untainted by me.

do i need to work out my salvation. yes. i need to take heed i have heard the right gospel. not a false gospel. i need to be certain i lay aside daily the deeds of the flesh more and more and turn and serve God more and more. and i need to trust and believe that WHEN (not if) i sin and fail, he is there to forgive. period.

when i have truly heard and truly believed, i am truly aware of how badly i need Christ. and i believe what God has said about him. that he came to SAVE.

if God the holy spirit as a GUARANTEE FROM GOD ALMIGHTY is not enough of a guarantee for you, no doubt youre working so hard. that is unbelief.
I agree with this as well and it makes a good point.....people who believe works for salvation or to keep them saved are in a state of unbelief as JESUS is not good enough for them!
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,396
113
Not only will he miss out on that, But he missed out on the many blessings, and the huge amount of joy he would have had while alive on earth if he just trusted Christ with more parts of his life. And the many people they could have spent eternity with who would be gratefull to them for allowing god to work through them.

I agree with this as well.....all because he/they do not trust Jesus to keep his word or that Jesus CAN keep his word....
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I agree with this as well and it makes a good point.....people who believe works for salvation or to keep them saved are in a state of unbelief as JESUS is not good enough for them!
amen,

and i might add. they may believe in Jesus and even that he died for their sins. But their faith is in themselves. and their ability to do these works worthy of salvation. or keep doing these works, so they do not lose salvation.
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,396
113
I think you would be right, he already denys that scripture alone is enough to make one wise for salvation, or to even give us the information necessary to place our faith in Christ.

What blows my mind is that people who teach works to get or keep salvation fail to see and or understand the (simplicity) that is in Christ....It pleased God to save men by preaching and faith based upon unmerited favor and mercy!
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,396
113
Ah, why would Truth or logic have anything to do with someone trying to develop a theory, or trying to support some other guys theory.
Maybe you should read and apply what you write as your statement is just as applicable unto you as unto anyone who posts on CC......So did you do enough works today to keep yourself in the grace of God?
 
Mar 5, 2014
494
3
0
Yes, and it is the what you call the extra bibical that confirms what scripture has always meant. The Body through the ages has accepted these writings because they were faithful to the original teaching, the teaching they all knew for the oral.

Paul is not a sola scripturist. He lived only up to about 70 and only his letters existed at that time. He would not have thought that they might become Scripture as you understand it.
Sola scriptura is a slogan right out of the Reformation, though the RCC uses the principle but never gave it a name. Protestants simply employed the method and set themselves up as individual Popes and declared their interpretation of scripture. The consequence thousands of gospels all derived by man, all based on scripture, but according to their own personal interpretation. The fact that there are thousands, we can know that all are false, except one, if that were possible, because there has only been ONE meaning to scripture.
The Septuagint /ˈsɛptjuːəˌɪnt/, /ˈsɛptəˌɪnt/, /ˌsɛpˈtəɪnt/, /ˈsɛpəˌɪnt/, from the Latin word septuaginta (meaning seventy), is a translation of the Hebrew Bible and some related texts into Koine Greek. The title and its Roman numeral acronym LXX refer to the legendary seventy Jewish scholars who completed the translation as early as the late 2nd century BCE


the greek translation of the hebrew scriptures were completed as early as the 2nd century ( before the Incarnation).
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,396
113
Righteousness (justification) of Christ (Ro 5:18-19) is right standing before God
because my sin has been forgiven through faith by grace,
which saves me from the wrath of God (Ro 5:9) on my sin at the Final Judgment.


You betcha'. . .in spades!
Amen and not the spades only but the whole deck!!!
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,396
113
perhaps. but i think they live in terror.
there is the chance that they are in the deluded state john mentioned (sinless). but overall i think they dont believe, and are afraid of God.
I AGREE and will add that I don't even have to think that at all.....They believe a gospel of a different kind which has no power to save and is double cursed...NO SALVATION for those who trust into works to get or keep salvation....
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,396
113
And?

So did Jesus.
AMEN.....Jesus, Paul, the Prophets, Stephen etc. all called it like it was.....No salvation for those who believe into works to get or keep salvation......