Not By Works

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Sep 27, 2016
34
0
0
Water cannot but be wet! A man of faith cannot except but be faithful!! Whereas his works alone cannot save him, indeed, if he is a man of faith, surely there will be works!!
 
Mar 7, 2016
4,678
24
0
Oh I thought I left this debate in the CALVINIST thread..

Guess God really wants me to figure it out eh?
I think she makes a valid point that free will is also something that must come from the sinner to accept Jesus...
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
lol anothger pack of lies i was jasonj, deleted my own account i had to send the operator a message , then i came back again if anyone is actually interseted in the truth ....and im here now you gracers are amazing in how you have no scruples lol .....
Jason, there is a point were it does not matter what the insult is, because it is just a distraction.
Once you talk about the behaviour, they use that as ammunition. It then becomes a fight, lol.

Some just want this because to them others are just evil.
Truth. They do not know how to love, which means it is all
over in spiritual terms. Everyone is a future brother or sister
or already there. We have no real enemies, just the lost and
those who can see. This is a good place to learn how to bless
and rejoice, people praise Jesus, a miracle, amen.
 
Mar 7, 2016
4,678
24
0
I agree.
Romans explains it really well:

Romans 8:29-30 New American Standard Bible (NASB)

29 For those whom He foreknew,
He also predestined to become conformed to the image of His Son, so that He would be the firstborn among many brethren;
30 and these whom He predestined, He also called;
and these whom He called, He also justified;
and these whom He justified, He also glorified.
mighty scripture.. but who gets justified ? is it those after Gods own heart. or is it those in whom he see someone special ?... or is it those who Cod sees as needing salvation ?...answers on a post card please sis...
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
No I haven't and to be honest today I have felt attacked and judged and accused.
I can't recall me getting angry and accusing and condemning others to hell, neither can I see you have.

I am not here to attack and scold, just to talk and discuss.

With regards to your thoughts concerning Catholics and hatred.

A few years ago when I was going through a very hard time, losing my foster parents over a period of 3 months not once did anyone in my church reach out to me.

Who reached out to me? A couple of Catholic friends, in fact the husband went back to Ireland to light a candle and pray for my loss and pain.

Now whilst I do not fully agree with the dogma of the Catholic Chruch (and to be honest I haven't researched their position as of today) there is one thing I have learned

My catholic friends sought me out, lifted me up and asked Jesus to comfort me.

Not one person in my church during this period contacted me during this time. I was sat on a bench overlooking a harbour with tears strolling down my face.

as I was sat their my wife called me and said Enda (Catholic friend) just called me and asked me to let you know he is praying for you and lifting you up.

Thank you Enda my catholic friend.

Anyway today I feel I have been flattened and I feel flatten.

Not sure where I want to go now here.
I love your brother. The Lord is our comforter, in Him we have our rest.
The cross for me shows me where my centre is, so there I go.
I pray you find refreshment in Him and know His people are there for you,
Amen
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
I wonder how many see Jesus calls us to walk in another's shoes, because we love them.
So when a believe stone walls me, I know love has still work to do.

A heart of flesh. Jesus wept at the death of Lazarus because his heart went out to His friends.
Grace and the power of the cross and love stunning, but this condemnation, so out of phase
with the cross. Trouble is you cannot fake a good heart, God has to make it.

Now if people jump to, "you are being arrogant" they are not seeing the cross at all but pride
and self condemnation. This is were we all have to start. I did many years ago, and I could
not believe how much pride and defence I had. I am just a voice, no more pointing to the King.
 

PennEd

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2013
13,085
8,748
113
Are you GOD that you could declare who is saved and who isn't?

Works for salvation leads to hell????

This is interesting. The truth DOES come out.

Works are leading to hell. So you believe that we must NOT WORK in order to get to heaven?

That surely makes no sense at all.

And you should stop judging people. Have you read Mathew 7?
As you judge
So shall YOU be judged.
This is a truly sad and scary post, but I absolutely appreciate your honesty in outright stating that you believe your works are necessary for salvation.

I can only pray that the Holy Spirit reveals to you that Jesus perfect Sacrifice is sufficient ALONE for your redemption, and to add to His finished work is insulting His Spirit of Grace.

If your work was necessary, why did God say NO to His Son when Jesus prayed to Him that if there were ANY other way, to take the cup from Him. Can't you see how insulting it is to add to His Sacrifice?
 
L

limey410

Guest
Its easier to give what God has asked us to give, what he has laid on our heart. If it's from the heart then that's what God looks at and is pleased with.
Yes and Amen, it is ALL about the heart. We give out of the abundance of what we have, and I don't mean in a fleshly way (money, resources etc).

Think of what we have been given, we have been given EVERYTHING for life and godliness. Nothing in there about stuff or doing or giving, or taking or working or anything. When we were saved we were given HIM, He is our inheritance, He is what we must truly give.

The best gift we could ever give someone is to point them toward Jesus so that He can give them the MOST valuable gift of Himself.
Somebody that is lost, that believes they have no hope, show them that there is a "way out" of this world, while we are still physically alive and eternally as we move to the next.

The rules and laws and doctrines do not account for any of that. Only God.
 
Mar 7, 2016
4,678
24
0
Are you GOD that you could declare who is saved and who isn't?

Works for salvation leads to hell????

This is interesting. The truth DOES come out.

Works are leading to hell. So you believe that we must NOT WORK in order to get to heaven?

That surely makes no sense at all.

And you should stop judging people. Have you read Mathew 7?
As you judge
So shall YOU be judged.
amen sis Truly inspired
 
A

Ariel82

Guest
I think she makes a valid point that free will is also something that must come from the sinner to accept Jesus...
I learned that Calvinist believe in free will too. Just they also believe all good comes from God.

I agree with that.

Then it gets more complicated.
 
A

Ariel82

Guest
Jason, there is a point were it does not matter what the insult is, because it is just a distraction.
Once you talk about the behaviour, they use that as ammunition. It then becomes a fight, lol.

Some just want this because to them others are just evil.
Truth. They do not know how to love, which means it is all
over in spiritual terms. Everyone is a future brother or sister
or already there. We have no real enemies, just the lost and
those who can see. This is a good place to learn how to bless
and rejoice, people praise Jesus, a miracle, amen.
So you believe everyone will eventually be saved?
 

AllenW

Senior Member
Apr 20, 2016
1,450
70
48
Yes. This all sounds good.

But where does our free will come into play???

Do we have free will?
If God forces us to stay with Him, do we still have free will?

Must go.
You can do whatever you want, you have free will.
But God can do what he wants.
He has free will too.
I think God gets in the last word for our own good.
 
A

Ariel82

Guest
mighty scripture.. but who gets justified ? is it those after Gods own heart. or is it those in whom he see someone special ?... or is it those who Cod sees as needing salvation ?...answers on a post card please sis...
None of the above. And in a way All.

People only seek after His heart after God draws them.

He does not choose based on something they did but for his own will and purpose...the elect are not more special or good then other sinners to be chosen.they are made special because God choses them.

Everyone needs salvation. Is everyone saved?

No post card but that's what I believe.
 
A

Ariel82

Guest
This is a truly sad and scary post, but I absolutely appreciate your honesty in outright stating that you believe your works are necessary for salvation.

I can only pray that the Holy Spirit reveals to you that Jesus perfect Sacrifice is sufficient ALONE for your redemption, and to add to His finished work is insulting His Spirit of Grace.

If your work was necessary, why did God say NO to His Son when Jesus prayed to Him that if there were ANY other way, to take the cup from Him. Can't you see how insulting it is to add to His Sacrifice?
Not sure if that's what she meant.

I think she ask if you are against doing good works after salvation?
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
So you believe everyone will eventually be saved?
Did not expect this question? No. I think the lost are lost, without hope of restoration.
Without Christ being invited in to ones heart, we are forever lost, with no hope of redemption.

What I mean about no real enemies, people are just disfunctional mal-adjusted individuals.
Why would anyone want to kill people who desire love and truth and find a way to help others.
There has to be something very wrong inside, but this is what happens.

When you see this you realise nothing is really about oneself but the odd way emotions twist
peoples thinking and focus. But this does not change the repetition of these feelings.
 
Feb 5, 2017
1,118
36
0
PeterJens I have always felt that your intentions are kind and well-meaning. I'm not sure why some are blind to that and try to, in a sense, put out your fire. The fact is, they know that they do that, and then they continue doing it. What kinds of works are they?

I always wonder how do we get through to these kind of people. I admire your strength, for me, it just makes this a toxic environment to me that I need to avoid.

There are groups/places online where people can discuss things in kindness, each with very different views, and being very different people. But you would have thought in a Christian environment, every one of us would hold this as key to all discussion. Sometimes I am here wondering if this is an asylum of some kind.


Did not expect this question? No. I think the lost are lost, without hope of restoration.
Without Christ being invited in to ones heart, we are forever lost, with no hope of redemption.

What I mean about no real enemies, people are just disfunctional mal-adjusted individuals.
Why would anyone want to kill people who desire love and truth and find a way to help others.
There has to be something very wrong inside, but this is what happens.

When you see this you realise nothing is really about oneself but the odd way emotions twist
peoples thinking and focus. But this does not change the repetition of these feelings.
 
A

Ariel82

Guest
PeterJens I have always felt that your intentions are kind and well-meaning. I'm not sure why some are blind to that and try to, in a sense, put out your fire. The fact is, they know that they do that, and then they continue doing it. What kinds of works are they?

I always wonder how do we get through to these kind of people. I admire your strength, for me, it just makes this a toxic environment to me that I need to avoid.

There are groups/places online where people can discuss things in kindness, each with very different views, and being very different people. But you would have thought in a Christian environment, every one of us would hold this as key to all discussion. Sometimes I am here wondering if this is an asylum of some kind.
Yeah and some people ask questions and give others the chance to clarify and PeterJens answers instead of jumping to the false conclusion that they, as you say, are "trying to put out his fire"

Nice..,fed into the "your being attack,your such a matyr" mentality.

Wonder if he will swallow this lie?
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
Ariel - I am curious. You said in another post you were very sensitive to people pride
and arrogance. You have said some very strong things to me, which is fine, but I wonder
if you are seeing something that is not there.

I wonder if we justify our positions, and then read in others feelings to make sense why
they behave as they do, but it might be completely wrong. I have seen two sides in a debate
do this when actually different things were going on. Often groups just play to their own
audience, and communication is irrelevant, just passing on party policy. The opposition are
then just a cartoon. It is disappointing, but this is group human behaviour. lol
 
A

Ariel82

Guest
Did not expect this question? No. I think the lost are lost, without hope of restoration.
Without Christ being invited in to ones heart, we are forever lost, with no hope of redemption.

What I mean about no real enemies, people are just disfunctional mal-adjusted individuals.
Why would anyone want to kill people who desire love and truth and find a way to help others.
There has to be something very wrong inside, but this is what happens.

When you see this you realise nothing is really about oneself but the odd way emotions twist
peoples thinking and focus. But this does not change the repetition of these feelings.
So your those on free will?

Why do some accept Jesus and others do not?