For you to postulate this grave error of eschatology indicates a massive disconnect from sound Biblical exegesis. All to common in these last days. Tragically.
- Many expect a future 7-year tribulation as Daniel’s 70th week. But scripture and history show it was fulfilled in Christ's 3½-year ministry and the events of AD 66–70. Let’s examine Daniel 9.
- Daniel 9:24: “Seventy weeks are decreed about your people (Israel) and your holy city (All 70 weeks are about Israel), to finish the transgression, to put an end to sin, and to atone for iniquity, to bring in everlasting righteousness, to seal both vision and prophet, and to anoint a most holy place.”
- After 69 weeks the Messiah comes: Daniel 9:25–26 — “...to the coming of an anointed one, a prince... And after the sixty-two weeks, an anointed one shall be cut off (The Crucifixion)... And the people of the prince who is to come shall destroy the city and the sanctuary... Desolations are decreed.”
- Clarification: The Anointed One (Messiah) is cut off. The “prince who is to come” is a Different figure (since it just said The Anointed One is cut off) the "prince who is to come" is fulfilled in the Roman commander Titus, whose legions destroyed Jerusalem in AD 70.
- The 70th week: Daniel 9:27 — “And he shall make a strong covenant with many for one week, and for half of the week he shall put an end to sacrifice and offering...”
- First half (AD 27–30/33): Jesus confirms the New Covenant in His 3½-year ministry. At the midpoint (the cross) He ends the old sacrifices: Hebrews 10:12,14 “But when Christ had offered for all time a single sacrifice for sins, he sat down at the right hand of God...”
- Last 3.5 years (AD 66/67–70): Cestius Gallus surrounded Jerusalem in AD 66 then suddenly retreated (allowing Christians to flee). Jewish civil war followed. In AD 70 Titus returned, besieged the city. After terrible suffering (famine and fighting), the Romans destroyed the Temple and much of Jerusalem. Josephus records ~1.1 million deaths and 97,000 taken captive.
- Jesus warned: Matthew 24:15 “So when you see the abomination of desolation spoken of by the prophet Daniel... then let those who are in Judea flee...”
- Luke 21:20,22 (ESV): “But when you see Jerusalem surrounded by armies, then know that its desolation has come near... for these are days of vengeance, to fulfill all that is written.” (Daniel 9:26)
- Note on 9:27: The “he” primarily refers to the Messiah (covenant and cross), while the Romans complete the desolations in the second half. Hebrew prophecy often works with layered fulfillment.
- Daniel 9:24’s Six goals were accomplished in Christ and the judgment of AD 70.
- Bottom line: Daniel’s final week (including the dramatic last 3½ years with armies appearing/retreating and final destruction) was fulfilled in the 1st century. “It is finished” (John 19:30).
Dr. Arnold Fruchtenbaum, a prominent Messianic Jewish theologian and founder of Ariel Ministries, provides a highly systematic, literal, and grammatically precise interpretation of Daniel 9:24–27.
His teaching, particularly detailed in his landmark eschatological work *The Footsteps of the Messiah*, conclusively proves that the 70th week is a **future seven-year period** (the Tribulation) and demonstrates how this timeline perfectly aligns with the Pre-Tribulation *harpazo* (Rapture).
## 1. How Fruchtenbaum Proves the 70th Week is Yet Future
Fruchtenbaum’s proof rests on a literal reading of the Hebrew text, historical chronology, and the explicit scope of the prophecy.
### The Chronological "Gap" in Daniel 9:26
Daniel’s prophecy divides the 490 years (70 "sevens" of years) into three distinct periods: 7 weeks (49 years), 62 weeks (434 years), and 1 final week (7 years). Together, the first two periods equal 69 weeks (483 years).
Fruchtenbaum points out that Daniel 9:26 explicitly states:
> *"And **after** the sixty-two weeks [which followed the first seven, totaling 69 weeks], an anointed one shall be cut off... and the people of the prince who is to come shall destroy the city and the sanctuary."*
>
* **The Timing:** The Messiah's death ("cut off") and the destruction of Jerusalem and the second Temple do not happen *during* the 69th week, nor do they happen *in* the 70th week. They happen **after** the 69th week has ended, but **before** the 70th week begins.
* **The Historical Proof:** The Messiah was crucified in approximately A.D. 30. The Roman destruction of Jerusalem occurred in A.D. 70. This 40-year historical interval proves that God's prophetic clock for Israel paused.
* **The Intermission:** Because these two major events happened in a historical "intermission" between the end of the 69th week and the start of the 70th, Fruchtenbaum proves that a chronological gap (the Church Age) exists.
### The Six Unfulfilled Purposes of Verse 24
Fruchtenbaum highlights the six divine goals decreed for **"your people [Israel] and your holy city [Jerusalem]"** in Daniel 9:24:
1. To finish the transgression
2. To make an end of sins
3. To atone for iniquity
4. To bring in everlasting righteousness
5. To seal up vision and prophecy
6. To anoint the most holy place
While the atonement was legally secured at the cross, Fruchtenbaum notes that these six conditions have **not yet been physically realized or applied to national Israel or Jerusalem**. Jerusalem is still trodden down by the Gentiles, and national Israel has not yet turned to her Messiah. Thus, the 70th week must be future to allow for these promises to be fully accomplished.
### The Triggering Event Has Not Happened
The 70th week is not triggered by the Rapture, nor does it begin automatically. According to Daniel 9:27, the final seven years officially start **only** when the Antichrist ("the prince who is to come") makes a firm, seven-year treaty/covenant with Israel. Since no such global leader has signed a seven-year security covenant with Israel in history, this week remains entirely future.
## 2. How the Future 70th Week Dovetails with the Harpazo
Fruchtenbaum’s dispensational framework illustrates how the *harpazo* (the catching up, or Rapture of the Church) beautifully harmonizes with this future timeline without causing theological contradictions:
| Concept | The Church (*Harpazo*) | Israel (Daniel's 70th Week) |
|---|---|---|
| **Direct Target** | The Body of Christ (Jew & Gentile believers) | "Thy people" (Israel) and "Thy holy city" (Jerusalem) |
| **Nature of Period** | A "Mystery" age not revealed in the Old Testament | The resumption of God's Old Testament program for Israel |
| **Divine Purpose** | To call out a bride for the Messiah | To bring Israel to national repentance through judgment |
### The Separation of Programs
Fruchtenbaum teaches that God has two distinct programs: one for Israel, and one for the Church. Because **all 70 weeks** of Daniel are strictly decreed for *Israel and Jerusalem* (Daniel 9:24), the Church has no part in them.
The Church Age is a "parenthesis" or mystery period inserted during the gap between the 69th and 70th weeks. Therefore, the Church must be physically removed via the *harpazo* before God's prophetic clock resumes ticking for Israel’s final seven years.
### No "Overlap" of Wraths
Scripture promises that the Church is "not destined for wrath" (1 Thessalonians 5:9). Because the 70th week is a period of global divine wrath (the Day of the Lord / Tribulation), the Church must be evacuated before this period begins.
### The Time Gap Between the Rapture and the Tribulation
A unique nuance of Fruchtenbaum's teaching is that **the Rapture does not start the Tribulation**. The signing of the covenant starts the Tribulation.
This means there could be a gap of days, months, or even years between the *harpazo* and the start of the 70th week. This gap allows ample time for:
* The post-Rapture chaos and global restructuring.
* The rise of the Antichrist to a position of global influence.
* The geopolitical conditions necessary for Israel to willingly sign a security covenant with him.
By keeping the Rapture (which is signless and imminent) separate from the trigger of the 70th week (the covenant), Fruchtenbaum maintains biblical consistency and preserves the "blessed hope" of the imminent return of Christ for His Bride.