Sarah Young Devotionals (I believe this has been discussed before, but...)

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
G

Gojira

Guest
#22
no offense meant toward either you or Mrs. Young. she certainly hears more clearly now. she went to be with the Lord a few months ago, God rest her soul.

i just meant she wasn't my cup of tea. can we be friends? :)
You misunderstood me. The friend who sent them to me is the one I was talking about. I don't know if the author heard from God or not, and her devotionals are profoundly frustrating to me. I'm not offended in the least.
 
G

Gojira

Guest
#23
it is a drug! lol

it's called oxytocin, produced by your hypothalamus when you exercise, so it's perfectly legit. :giggle:
Funny, I never get any dosages of that drug when I exercise. I hate working out.
 

HealthAndHappiness

Well-known member
Jul 7, 2022
10,280
4,329
113
Almost Heaven West Virginia
#24
You misunderstood me. The friend who sent them to me is the one I was talking about. I don't know if the author heard from God or not, and her devotionals are profoundly frustrating to me. I'm not offended in the least.
Why even use them?
Whenever I hear sassy preacherette Joyce Meyer by accident, it sounds like a combination of the teacher scolding Linus for sleeping in Peanuts and the naggings of Chinese water torture.

Proverbs 27:15
"A continual dropping in a very rainy day and a contentious woman are alike."

Maybe some good sermons are what you need in addition to the daily Bible reading?
 

TheLearner

Well-known member
Jan 14, 2019
8,191
1,577
113
68
Brighton, MI
#27
She proclaims the insufficiency of the Bible
She is inspired by untrustworthy models
She mimics occult practices.
7. Her emphasis does not match the Bible’s. Young’s emphasis in Jesus Calling is markedly different from the emphases of the Bible. For example, she speaks seldom of sin and repentance and even less of Christ’s work on the cross.
She generates confusion.
0. Her book has been corrected. Most people don’t know that Jesus Calling has undergone revisions, not only in the introduction where she removed references to God Calling, but also in the words she claims to have received from Jesus.
https://www.challies.com/articles/10-serious-problems-with-jesus-calling/
https://ses.edu/jesus-calling-by-sarah-young-a-false-jesus/
https://www.cicministry.org/commentary/issue125.htm
https://bereanresearch.org/changing-jesus-calling-damage-control-for-a-false-christ/
 

Mem

Senior Member
Sep 23, 2014
7,159
2,174
113
#28
Solomon was brought up and the train of thought caused me to pull the emergency break as one particular thought of Solomon's was the key to all of his foolishness, the one saying something like, 'there are no good women in existence.' In spite of all the wisdom he'd been given, I think he might've done better to, when God said that He'd grant him whatever that he wished, he might've done a whole lot better if, instead of asking to know wisdom (since hindsight shows us how it all turned out), he might've asked to know love. Solomon wrote the song of songs, so he was at least acquainted with it, yet still comes to the conclusion 'but not one woman...' (which seems to me to exhibit a seed of bitterness? emptyness?) that he thought he could fill with 1000 women, and loving not one of them (even if you might argue that). Anyway, it is my suspicion that the root of this bitterness/emptiness? was handed down to him by David (who inherited from his father, who shrugged him off as even a consideration for the designated future king). David also thought to fill/remedy this unrequited desire (which is totally legitimate) with Bathsheba, so....


I was going somewhere with this but, seems I should give room for protest, or at least check if all ears have stopped up at this point...

I was going to post in the last post wins thread after @Gojira's post about the twilight zone...
but maybe it'd fit better here?

 

Noel25

Active member
Dec 17, 2022
140
130
43
#29
Solomon was brought up and the train of thought caused me to pull the emergency break as one particular thought of Solomon's was the key to all of his foolishness, the one saying something like, 'there are no good women in existence.' In spite of all the wisdom he'd been given, I think he might've done better to, when God said that He'd grant him whatever that he wished, he might've done a whole lot better if, instead of asking to know wisdom (since hindsight shows us how it all turned out), he might've asked to know love. Solomon wrote the song of songs, so he was at least acquainted with it, yet still comes to the conclusion 'but not one woman...' (which seems to me to exhibit a seed of bitterness? emptyness?) that he thought he could fill with 1000 women, and loving not one of them (even if you might argue that). Anyway, it is my suspicion that the root of this bitterness/emptiness? was handed down to him by David (who inherited from his father, who shrugged him off as even a consideration for the designated future king). David also thought to fill/remedy this unrequited desire (which is totally legitimate) with Bathsheba, so....


I was going somewhere with this but, seems I should give room for protest, or at least check if all ears have stopped up at this point...

I was going to post in the last post wins thread after @Gojira's post about the twilight zone...
but maybe it'd fit better here?

This was an interesting read! I have always wondered why Solomon did what he did with all the wisdom he had. I hadn't realized that wisdom does not equal love.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
60,135
29,451
113
#30
it is a drug! lol

it's called oxytocin, produced by your hypothalamus when you exercise, so it's perfectly legit. :giggle:
I thought it was endorphins? Oxytocin is an essential hormone for childbirth and lactation.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
60,135
29,451
113
#31
This was an interesting read! I have always wondered why Solomon did what he
did with all the wisdom he had. I hadn't realized that wisdom does not equal love.

Ecclesiastes1-17-18
:)
 

Mem

Senior Member
Sep 23, 2014
7,159
2,174
113
#32
This was an interesting read! I have always wondered why Solomon did what he did with all the wisdom he had. I hadn't realized that wisdom does not equal love.
I will be refraining from elaborating further at this time, to give those that it may have cut a little time to heal. But I will say, David loved God's law, and Solomon concluded Ecclesiastes that the end of the matter was to love God and obey his commandments. However, it wasn't until Jesus came that the Father's love was actually revealed in all true individual expression (like there is no other) toward you, and me, distinctly, especially, and ever so intimately.
 

Mem

Senior Member
Sep 23, 2014
7,159
2,174
113
#33
Aaand, I don't want to give credit for some influence in forming my opinion (because of various 'God winks' such as the source mentioning "young" (in this case, Carl) like, just a minute ago while I'm catching up on some broadcasts that struck me as interesting, and helpful btw). He reminds me of a mild manner Clark type that's been through struggles in searching for his Kal-El identity, by the actual name of DeJesus, if I might recommend any reading at all apart from the Bible, I do his.
 

HealthAndHappiness

Well-known member
Jul 7, 2022
10,280
4,329
113
Almost Heaven West Virginia
#34
I got a message from someone who wanted me to justify Astrology with Christianity yesterday. I just got done studying Deuteronomy 18 and the topic of the occult, dowsing and other included topics last week. When I decided to look up videos on former astrologers, I came across a panel discussion about the Book Jesus Calling with a former astrologer.

...I did not pay very close attention to it, and now I can't find the threads.

Back in... 2014 I believe it was, one of her devotionals was "talking" to me. What I mean by that is, after I prayed for the night, I'd open one of her books, and every other day or so I'd get not one sentence, but a paragraph in response to something I had prayed about. It started to get to the point where I began to say, "Okay, what am I going to hear today?" And, lo and behold, there was another "response".

This went on for about 2 or so months until I had to put her books down. Why? The overall message of her devotionals seems to be, "This life's going to suck. But, hold on to Me, and console yourself knowing that relief will come with an eternity in MY presence!" And, I seemed to be reprimanded more than once as well. What's wrong with that?

Well, here's my dilemma. These messages became very heavy to keep reading. They gave no hope for this life. The prospect of (possibly) another 30+ years on this earth, with no relief from the things I deeply want relief from (a crappy, unfulfilling work life, loneliness -- no friends / buddies here in Arizona, and no prospects at all for a wife and a holy sex life), is not relieved a whole lot by the prospect that it may take several more decades to end my need / desire for such things.

I have not learned to be totally content in God despite circumstances. I am praying for that. But, even as I do, and even as I try to thank Him for the circumstances out of which He promised to bring good, I still battle with my desires for those aforementioned things.

The reason this is getting to me is because I recently picked up one of her devotionals again. I've been reading it each night for a few months. I thought that maybe God might have been displeased with my putting them down in the first place, and so I thought I'd try again. The result has not been the same sense of "talking" to me, but that same message of hope for the next life, with little mention of any for this life, persists. I've punched the book once, slammed it another, grieved for the lack of hope and the end of my simple dreams more than once.

What do you think? I'm an idolater, yes? Yet, I cannot get past it. I cannot make myself see this life the way God seems to want me to see it. And, I remain sad and depressed because there does not seem to be any message of hope that my circumstances will change, and the spiritual progress I seek is very slow in coming as well.
Here's an article that I found about it if you are interested. I just got done with over an hour of teaching on Jesus Calling and the author, but will spare you the boring details and chuck of your life. This for brevity.

Say NO to Jesus Calling new age channeled books
 
G

Gojira

Guest
#35
Why even use them?
Whenever I hear sassy preacherette Joyce Meyer by accident, it sounds like a combination of the teacher scolding Linus for sleeping in Peanuts and the naggings of Chinese water torture.

Proverbs 27:15
"A continual dropping in a very rainy day and a contentious woman are alike."

Maybe some good sermons are what you need in addition to the daily Bible reading?
I don't see the problem with devotionals, and am confused by the reaction to devotionals in general that I've gotten here. Why NOT use them? We go to extra-Biblical sources every time we listen to a sermon.

My issue and my inner battle is over the overall message of Sarah Young's devotionals, and that is the point of my original message.
 
G

Gojira

Guest
#36
I got a message from someone who wanted me to justify Astrology with Christianity yesterday. I just got done studying Deuteronomy 18 and the topic of the occult, dowsing and other included topics last week. When I decided to look up videos on former astrologers, I came across a panel discussion about the Book Jesus Calling with a former astrologer.



Here's an article that I found about it if you are interested. I just got done with over an hour of teaching on Jesus Calling and the author, but will spare you the boring details and chuck of your life. This for brevity.

Say NO to Jesus Calling new age channeled books
Hmmm.... :unsure: Maybe I will rabbit...
 

notmyown

Senior Member
May 26, 2016
4,927
1,272
113
#37
I thought it was endorphins? Oxytocin is an essential hormone for childbirth and lactation.
yep, them, too! oxy is produced causing uterine contractions, and while lactating (causing uterine contractions-- how wise is God?), but also during exercise, listening to music, or simply at physical touch. it's produced by the hypothalamus, but released by an aspect of the pituitary, which does produce endorphins. :)
 
G

Gojira

Guest
#38
yep, them, too! oxy is produced causing uterine contractions, and while lactating (causing uterine contractions-- how wise is God?), but also during exercise, listening to music, or simply at physical touch. it's produced by the hypothalamus, but released by an aspect of the pituitary, which does produce endorphins. :)
Well poop, not in me!
 

Noel25

Active member
Dec 17, 2022
140
130
43
#39
I don't see the problem with devotionals, and am confused by the reaction to devotionals in general that I've gotten here. Why NOT use them? We go to extra-Biblical sources every time we listen to a sermon.

My issue and my inner battle is over the overall message of Sarah Young's devotionals, and that is the point of my original message.
I think you should read the Bible if you are looking for something to make you feel better. Have you tried that before? I find it really fun to learn about all the different people in the Bible and what they did and how God helped them. Ask God to help you learn and to give you peace.
 

notmyown

Senior Member
May 26, 2016
4,927
1,272
113
#40
Well poop, not in me!
without wishing to diminish what you're undergoing, i have to ask, could you possibly be suffering from nutritional deficiencies? there are some that can cause depression. you needn't answer me at all. i'm just concerned for you, and thought i ought to mention it.