Fundamentalism and Particular Baptists

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

cv5

Well-known member
Nov 20, 2018
24,167
8,749
113
Jesus said this

View attachment 271838

There is no Middle Ground -----you either believe God's word or you don't ----so your either a True Christian who literally takes God's word as it is -----as God Himself says His Word it Truth or you don't -

View attachment 271840

Or you're a False Christian ----a person who is using the Word Christian cause it feels good -----


You cannot say ---well I believe this piece of Scripture but not that piece of Scripture -----you either believe the Scriptures or you Don't -----

There is no Religion with God Folks -------there is no catholic ---baptise ----protestant ---united ---calvinist ---lutheran ----etc --etc ----these are all man made religions with all their own Doctrines and traditions ---

There is one God and One way and He says His word is truth -----so anyone who wants to argue with that ----Good luck to ya -----

Jesus Christ is the Word ---and His Religion is the Way -----the Truth and the Life ----cause without Christ in you your Doomed ----being a calvinist ---baptise --catholic ----etc will not help you get eternal life

People seem to forget:
Israel went to seed doctrinally. Broken beyond repair.
Jesus did not try and salvage it. He decommissioned it.

Similarly take a look at the Church today and ask yourself: is the end of the Church age and tribulation right around the corner?
 
Oct 15, 2024
180
56
28
People seem to forget:
Israel went to seed doctrinally. Broken beyond repair.
Jesus did not try and salvage it. He decommissioned it.

Similarly take a look at the Church today and ask yourself: is the end of the Church age and tribulation right around the corner?
His Name is Yeshua, revere It and learn
 
Dec 18, 2021
6,134
1,969
113
Many, many US Baptist Churches directly descend from the Particular Baptists, who were indeed Calvinist, and Gill-Spurgeon regular Baptists, who are indeed Calvinists. That being said, the John Smith General Baptist tradition is quite old, and American Baptists have a wide variety of influence from outside Baptist and Reformed Churches. The Aminian Baptists are also semi-Calvinist: Arminius was a Reformed theologian.

The SBC is not explicitly Weslayen or Calvinistic, but allowed for either core either in church creed or individual believers. I'm fine with that. I've studied Reformed theology for years, I think Calvin is right, but I know plenty of General Baptists who believe in the same gospel I do. Theology is important, but its not the gospel.
I do not remember any calvin teaching in the baptist churches I grew up in. Not saying it was not there (i was a kid for most of it) but when I became an adult. the churches I went to did not deal with TULIP.

They all believed in free will (it was not a free will baptist) from my recollections. But I know they also partnered or promoted books or churches who would be considered calvinisitc in nature.

it is interesting that until I joined a christian chat about 5 years ago. I never knew the animosity between arminian and calvin thinking peoples. I have seen some heated debates (in this chatroom on debate got so heated. probably 10 or 15 people got banned)
 
Dec 27, 2024
128
43
28
I do not remember any calvin teaching in the baptist churches I grew up in. Not saying it was not there (i was a kid for most of it) but when I became an adult. the churches I went to did not deal with TULIP.
I have noticed a lot of Calvinist ideas, and Reformed ideas more generally, in Baptist Churches which area not Calvinistic. Offhand, Sola Scriptura, a covenantal view of church life, the regulative principle of worship, moral and cultural transformation, preaching as central to worship, the priesthood of all believers, congregational polity with an emphasis on elder leadership, misssional theology, god’s sovereignty in history, piety and discipline. All of these were articulated and brought into central focus by Calvin and others like him, but non-Calvinists are unaware of this because they're so commonplace. They only know Calvin for the doctrines of grace, when in fact they have indirectly absorbed many things from Calvin's pastoral works and Reformed controversies.

Particular/Regular Baptists are most common in the south/northwest of the USA, and England. General Baptists are definitely more common. However, 3/10 pastors identifies as a Calvinist in Baptist Churches: it's more the parishioners who don't know what their pastor wants them to believe, or the denomination allows for multiple views.

it is interesting that until I joined a christian chat about 5 years ago. I never knew the animosity between arminian and calvin thinking peoples. I have seen some heated debates (in this chatroom on debate got so heated. probably 10 or 15 people got banned)
It's mostly just emotionally unhealthy people and weirdos on the internet who have too much free time. There are a few preachers who still have real life meltdowns over Calvinism, but most Christians know nothing about it and aren't especially invested. Old Calvinist churches are not usually fantastical about proving predestination to everyone.
 
Nov 1, 2024
1,532
479
83
So does anyone have any insight into what happened in the first church in Providence that originally adhered to the 6 principles? I read that there was a split-off into another church after a Calvinist pastor was appointed. I really don't care about ecclesiological matters at all, but I would like to know more about that particular church because an ancestor was one of the original 12 founders
 
Dec 18, 2021
6,134
1,969
113
Jesus said this

View attachment 271838

There is no Middle Ground -----you either believe God's word or you don't ----so your either a True Christian who literally takes God's word as it is -----as God Himself says His Word it Truth or you don't -

View attachment 271840

Or you're a False Christian ----a person who is using the Word Christian cause it feels good -----


You cannot say ---well I believe this piece of Scripture but not that piece of Scripture -----you either believe the Scriptures or you Don't -----

There is no Religion with God Folks -------there is no catholic ---baptise ----protestant ---united ---calvinist ---lutheran ----etc --etc ----these are all man made religions with all their own Doctrines and traditions ---

There is one God and One way and He says His word is truth -----so anyone who wants to argue with that ----Good luck to ya -----

Jesus Christ is the Word ---and His Religion is the Way -----the Truth and the Life ----cause without Christ in you your Doomed ----being a calvinist ---baptise --catholic ----etc will not help you get eternal life

Amen, as for as entrance into the kingdom. there is only one gospel.. Yet of all churches. three general gospels are proclaimed.

it is not the church that gets you in, Its the gospel.
 
Dec 18, 2021
6,134
1,969
113
I have noticed a lot of Calvinist ideas, and Reformed ideas more generally, in Baptist Churches which area not Calvinistic. Offhand, Sola Scriptura, a covenantal view of church life, the regulative principle of worship, moral and cultural transformation, preaching as central to worship, the priesthood of all believers, congregational polity with an emphasis on elder leadership, misssional theology, god’s sovereignty in history, piety and discipline. All of these were articulated and brought into central focus by Calvin and others like him, but non-Calvinists are unaware of this because they're so commonplace. They only know Calvin for the doctrines of grace, when in fact they have indirectly absorbed many things from Calvin's pastoral works and Reformed controversies.

Particular/Regular Baptists are most common in the south/northwest of the USA, and England. General Baptists are definitely more common. However, 3/10 pastors identifies as a Calvinist in Baptist Churches: it's more the parishioners who don't know what their pastor wants them to believe, or the denomination allows for multiple views.
I grew up in Central Ohio. We went from GARBC. to regular to independent right before the church folded (I drove by it last year for memory purposes. it was empty, and the sign they had up was in Spanish. I could not read it. But it was no longer a baptist church, and I think even the ones on the sign were no longer using it.
I have read many a calvinist pastors works. and like you said here. Most if it is not anything I would disagree with.

The issue begins with TULIP. And then the fight between Arminian 5 points and Tulip. I think that is where the heated debates come in.. And if you notice. If you believe in grace, your automatically deemed a calvinist. Even if you are not.. Which is where the breakdown comes. If I say I believe in Grace through faith alone. and someone tries to point me as a calvinist who believes in TULIP (which I do not) there can be no discussion., so it gets heated and the accusations keep flying..


It's mostly just emotionally unhealthy people and weirdos on the internet who have too much free time. There are a few preachers who still have real life meltdowns over Calvinism, but most Christians know nothing about it and aren't especially invested. Old Calvinist churches are not usually fantastical about proving predestination to everyone.
Most likely this is true
 
Feb 15, 2014
3,801
946
113
62
I've met people who call themselves 'Fundamentalists' and they take the Bible very seriously. We often agree on things like eternal security, God's complete control, and His greatness. We even agree on some things where I disagree with most Reformed people, like believer's baptism.
I'm not sure exactly what 'Fundamentalism' means. I haven't read the books called "The Fundamentals," so I don't know much about it. I've seen lists of things they believe, like the Bible is true in the original writings, God is one God in three persons, Jesus was born of a virgin, He died for our sins, rose from the dead, and will come back.
I believe all these things. Does that make me a Fundamentalist? Or are there other things that make someone a Fundamentalist?

I'm a Calvinistic Baptist, but I've met Pentecostals and Fundamentalists who love God and preach the gospel. I get my ideas from many different places, but I don't understand where some modern General Baptists and Fundamentalists get their ideas (whether I agree with them or not). I also don't know what they think about strict Reformed beliefs.
The term fundamentalist has in germany sadly a very bad interpretation. Most people have in mind Islam Fundamentalism.
For me the word fundamentalist as child of God means that the bible is my fundament!
Independet from any denomination doctrine.
 
Dec 16, 2016
14,010
7,913
113
Local Baptist pastor and family were at a gathering of our local Bible camp with several "denominations" , His family was sitting at our table, Holy Spirit manifested on us all at the table, I explained this to his family who were in awe. Pastor raced over to explain how this doesn't happen anymore, I was able to share how his family just experienced what he says God doesn't do anymore.
He is gone from that church after more than a 15 years, the new pastor and his bride and family are Spirit filled.
I had a divine encounter with them first time we met, Holy Spirit manifested strongly we then prayed for their ministry here, they are now experiencing over whelming growth in this previously underwhelming congregation.
In addition He always manifests confirmation when I ask if harpazo is near, we are running out of time to get right.
blessings
 
Dec 27, 2024
128
43
28
yes.. I believe Calvin followed them. Its amazing he gets credit for their work.
Especially because he never claimed credit for it!
From Institutes of the Christian Religion:
"I do not now teach new and unheard-of doctrines; I hold fast the ancient faith which I have received from the Fathers, especially from Augustine, and I declare that nothing new has been introduced into the church."
— Preface
"I did not invent these doctrines, but I have drawn them from the ancient fountains of the holy Scriptures, from which the purest doctrine has always flowed, and from the mouths of the fathers, especially Augustine, whose testimony has been invaluable to me."
— Book 1, Chapter 9
"I have nothing to do with the inventions of men, but I confess that I have learned from Augustine."
— Book 2, Chapter 2
"Augustine is, and always has been, the true teacher in the church. I am not ashamed to confess that I have drunk deep from his well, and that my doctrines are the same as his, as far as the Bible and the light of Christ will permit."
— Book 3, Chapter 11

And:
"For my part, I neither consider myself to be a follower of the Papists nor of the heretics. I am, as I have been for many years, a follower of Augustine."
— Letter to the King of France, 1543
 
Dec 18, 2021
6,134
1,969
113
Especially because he never claimed credit for it!
From Institutes of the Christian Religion:

— Preface

— Book 1, Chapter 9

— Book 2, Chapter 2

— Book 3, Chapter 11

And:

— Letter to the King of France, 1543
I think all the calvin debates is just satan trying to divide the church
 
Dec 27, 2024
128
43
28
I think all the calvin debates is just satan trying to divide the church
It's not so much the debates or the subject but the way people turn it into tribal identity politics. Don't get me wrong, I'm in favor of a certain amount of identity politics - in politics. There's no place for it in theology, though. I feel like Lutherans sometimes adopt views Luther would reject just because they don't want to admit how close he was to a Calvinist, out of some sectarian antagonism. It's not reciprocated: Calvinists generally like Lutheranism.
 
Dec 18, 2021
6,134
1,969
113
It's not so much the debates or the subject but the way people turn it into tribal identity politics. Don't get me wrong, I'm in favor of a certain amount of identity politics - in politics. There's no place for it in theology, though. I feel like Lutherans sometimes adopt views Luther would reject just because they don't want to admit how close he was to a Calvinist, out of some sectarian antagonism. It's not reciprocated: Calvinists generally like Lutheranism.
Just wait until you get into a real calvinist debate. It will blow your mind that Christians can treat each other this way.

I personally would rather discuss doctrine or the word of God. not what this church or that church teaches. I think if we could just do this. would be so much more peaceful. As an example. Open a thread on OSAS and watch the fireworks.
 

cv5

Well-known member
Nov 20, 2018
24,167
8,749
113
I have read many a calvinist pastors works. and like you said here. Most if it is not anything I would disagree with.

The issue begins with TULIP. And then the fight between Arminian 5 points and Tulip. I think that is where the heated debates come in.. And if you notice. If you believe in grace, your automatically deemed a calvinist. Even if you are not.. Which is where the breakdown comes. If I say I believe in Grace through faith alone. and someone tries to point me as a calvinist who believes in TULIP (which I do not) there can be no discussion., so it gets heated and the accusations keep flying..




Most likely this is true
From my post on a different thread. The stakes are far too high in this debate to simply brush off in the name of "unity".
This bogus doctrine of the Pharisees was confronted by Jesus, taught by Jesus to be FALSE, then warned of by Jesus, then condemned by Jesus. This is no joke.

************************************************************************

The Pharisees thought they were born saved..................Proven wrong by Jesus Himself.
Calvinites think they are pre-born saved..............................Same heresy amped to the next level.

And what does the Final Authority say about this?

He says that you must be BORN ***AGAIN*** AFTER you were firstly born in sin.
Not PRE-SELECTED BEFORE you were born when there IS NO SIN.

IMO the pharisaical doctrine of being "born saved" and "saved by surgery" was the ultimate cause of the downfall of the nation.
They lost their salvation message mojo (that being ANYONE may enter the covenant of His Blood) and then they lost their commission and nation.