False Doctrine

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Gideon300

Ancient Mariner
Mar 18, 2021
9,835
7,474
113
Frankston, Victoria
christianlife.au
There are a number of false doctrines, some relatively new and some that are as old as the Church herself. I do not intend to answer each doctrine. I want to explain how false doctrine comes about and how to avoid being caught up.

False doctrine usually arises because of taking scripture out of context and in isolation. There are 66 books in the Bible and each one is there according to God's purpose and will.

It can be difficult to understand some passages. For example, some stumble over the idea of God destroying everything that breaths air except for a few people in a wooden barge. We need to rely on the Holy Spirit to lead us into the truth, not human logic and reason.

Our first response must not be, "I don't understand so it must be a myth or an allegory." We also must not allow the wisdom of the world to colour our understanding. Science is not God and vast numbers of scientists are anti God. We also need to know that the Bible is indeed God's word. When Jesus was tempted in the wilderness, He quoted scripture. He did not use His own wisdom and knowledge, even though He is the Living Word.

There are two extreme heresies floating around at present. One is that the Hebrew scriptures are no longer relevant and can be ignored. The other end of the scale is that believers must obey the Torah still. Neither is correct.

Any sensible reading of scripture reveals that the Old Testament still has spiritual value and truly is God's word. Lord Jesus confirmed this and around one third of the NT consists of quotes from the OT.

At the other extreme, it is also clear that the Torah not God's rulebook for Christians. One example destroys that argument. The Torah mandates circumcision for God's covenant people. Moses failed to obey God on that issue and the Lord came to kill him. (Exodus 4:24-26). Paul specifically states that circumcision no longer applies to believers.

"For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision nor uncircumcision has any value. What matters is faith expressing itself through love." (Galatians 5:6)

An argument can be made that circumcision is still required for Messianic Jews. I don't agree with that, but I understand the reasoning.

There is much that is now a matter of conscience. If you conscience says not to eat pork, then don't. If your conscience says to be a vegetarian, don't eat meat. If your conscience says that you should be celibate, that too is for you to decide. The error comes in when you seek to impose your views on others. That's how cults arise. Don't fall for it.
 
There are a number of false doctrines, some relatively new and some that are as old as the Church herself. I do not intend to answer each doctrine. I want to explain how false doctrine comes about and how to avoid being caught up.

False doctrine usually arises because of taking scripture out of context and in isolation. There are 66 books in the Bible and each one is there according to God's purpose and will.

It can be difficult to understand some passages. For example, some stumble over the idea of God destroying everything that breaths air except for a few people in a wooden barge. We need to rely on the Holy Spirit to lead us into the truth, not human logic and reason.

Our first response must not be, "I don't understand so it must be a myth or an allegory." We also must not allow the wisdom of the world to colour our understanding. Science is not God and vast numbers of scientists are anti God. We also need to know that the Bible is indeed God's word. When Jesus was tempted in the wilderness, He quoted scripture. He did not use His own wisdom and knowledge, even though He is the Living Word.

There are two extreme heresies floating around at present. One is that the Hebrew scriptures are no longer relevant and can be ignored. The other end of the scale is that believers must obey the Torah still. Neither is correct.

Any sensible reading of scripture reveals that the Old Testament still has spiritual value and truly is God's word. Lord Jesus confirmed this and around one third of the NT consists of quotes from the OT.

At the other extreme, it is also clear that the Torah not God's rulebook for Christians. One example destroys that argument. The Torah mandates circumcision for God's covenant people. Moses failed to obey God on that issue and the Lord came to kill him. (Exodus 4:24-26). Paul specifically states that circumcision no longer applies to believers.

"For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision nor uncircumcision has any value. What matters is faith expressing itself through love." (Galatians 5:6)

An argument can be made that circumcision is still required for Messianic Jews. I don't agree with that, but I understand the reasoning.

There is much that is now a matter of conscience. If you conscience says not to eat pork, then don't. If your conscience says to be a vegetarian, don't eat meat. If your conscience says that you should be celibate, that too is for you to decide. The error comes in when you seek to impose your views on others. That's how cults arise. Don't fall for it.

So are we allowed in your thread to acknowledge the elephant in the room, the false doctrine of all false doctrines? The false doctrine that the mistranslated word "believe " is what saving faith is?
That "believing " in what Jesus did and taught will result in receiving the Spirit of Christ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2Christ
There are a number of false doctrines, some relatively new and some that are as old as the Church herself. I do not intend to answer each doctrine. I want to explain how false doctrine comes about and how to avoid being caught up.

False doctrine usually arises because of taking scripture out of context and in isolation. There are 66 books in the Bible and each one is there according to God's purpose and will.

It can be difficult to understand some passages. For example, some stumble over the idea of God destroying everything that breaths air except for a few people in a wooden barge. We need to rely on the Holy Spirit to lead us into the truth, not human logic and reason.

Our first response must not be, "I don't understand so it must be a myth or an allegory." We also must not allow the wisdom of the world to colour our understanding. Science is not God and vast numbers of scientists are anti God. We also need to know that the Bible is indeed God's word. When Jesus was tempted in the wilderness, He quoted scripture. He did not use His own wisdom and knowledge, even though He is the Living Word.

There are two extreme heresies floating around at present. One is that the Hebrew scriptures are no longer relevant and can be ignored. The other end of the scale is that believers must obey the Torah still. Neither is correct.

Any sensible reading of scripture reveals that the Old Testament still has spiritual value and truly is God's word. Lord Jesus confirmed this and around one third of the NT consists of quotes from the OT.

At the other extreme, it is also clear that the Torah not God's rulebook for Christians. One example destroys that argument. The Torah mandates circumcision for God's covenant people. Moses failed to obey God on that issue and the Lord came to kill him. (Exodus 4:24-26). Paul specifically states that circumcision no longer applies to believers.

"For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision nor uncircumcision has any value. What matters is faith expressing itself through love." (Galatians 5:6)

An argument can be made that circumcision is still required for Messianic Jews. I don't agree with that, but I understand the reasoning.

There is much that is now a matter of conscience. If you conscience says not to eat pork, then don't. If your conscience says to be a vegetarian, don't eat meat. If your conscience says that you should be celibate, that too is for you to decide. The error comes in when you seek to impose your views on others. That's how cults arise. Don't fall for it.

I agree with what you said and will comment on several items by way of clarification:

1. The root cause of false doctrine is not loving Truth/not being a truthseeker/not having humility or willingness to learn or repent of wrong beliefs (2Thes. 2:10). Paul exemplified such a person until God stuck him blind so he would see Jesus.

2. It must be assumed that God permitted the biblical books to become the canon of Scripture, but the process was like making sausage and Song of Solomon probably was the most problematic.

3. Proof-texting is indeed a main cause of false doctrine; people need to pray for the gift of harmonizing all Scripture.

4. If a person cannot explain how a loving and just God would want everyone in the world except Noah's family or every Canaanite exterminated, then their response should be "I don't understand" rather than portray God as hateful and unrighteous.

5. We also need to realize that science is merely an occupation like teacher or plumber, so being anti-God is not because of their job but because of their heart.

6. Scripture is God's Word, but that does not mean post-canonical insights cannot be true as long as they do not contradict the Gospel, because the NT does not specifically answer questions about all modern issues, but insights must be tested.

7. Jesus often cited the OT, but he also taught new wisdom. IOW, "both-and" divine logic was employed. Jesus also inspired Paul, John and Peter to teach new truth.

8. The Torah contains two types of laws: Levitical, which were temporary and superseded when fulfilled by Messiah's atonement (Heb. 7:21-10:1), and moral, which were recommanded in the NT and summarized as the law of love (Matt. 22:37-40, John 13:35, Gal. 5:6).

9. Paul taught that spiritual circumcision of the heart is what applies to both Jews and Gentiles.

10. We should not divorce the Holy Spirit from logic and reason, because that is how the Logos communicates with humans.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Revelation1v8
Great post and I do not disagree. I would add a personal belief on this topic.

Both David in Psalm 51:17 and Christ during His discussion with the woman at the Samarian well made it clear, worship is in spirit and in truth. God and Paul both advocated circumcision of the heart, a spiritual act of worship, not a physical act. I believe we can keep every one of God's commandments in spirit and truth.

But of course, you can be a great Christian and disagree. This is just where I have been led.