"replacement theology" - what is it?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Mar 28, 2016
15,954
1,528
113
You better go back and read that again tanakh, for the tribe of Joseph is most surely mentioned in the OT in the listing of the son's of Jacob, along with his brother Benjamin.


  • Reuben
  • Simeon
  • Levi
  • Judah
  • Zebulun
  • Issachar
  • Dan
  • Gad
  • Asher
  • Naphtali
  • Joseph
  • Benjamin
And all that means what as a spiritual understanding ?

The refomation has come. Does it mean we can have the faith of Christ, the faith of God that works in to both will and do His good pleasure in respect to tribes of sinners? Where they crucified for our sin? Are we baptized in their names.?

1Corinthians 1:13 Is Christ divided? was Paul crucified for you? or were ye baptized in the name of Paul?
 
Mar 28, 2016
15,954
1,528
113
You will find there are a 'Baker's Dozen" tribes..(13) Both sons of Joseph founded a tribe yet both sons founded only one Tribe (Joseph). The Bible uses his sons as tribes in different verses that call for different meanings. There are passages that remove the tribe Levi to make a statement. There are many other statements made by using the 'Baker's Dozen'.
12 tribes, 12 apostles .Six of one a half a dozen of another? Together they make one bride.Why the division between tribes and apostles as if there were two wife's, two gospels?
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
back on topic: "Replacement Theology"

....

Supersessionism

Supersessionism is the traditional Christian belief that Christianity is the fulfillment of Biblical Judaism, and therefore that Jews who deny that Jesus is the Jewish Messiah fall short of their calling as God's Chosen people....

...The traditional form of supersessionism does not theorize a replacement; instead it argues that Israel has been superseded only in the sense that the Church has been entrusted with the fulfillment of the promises of which Jewish Israel is the trustee. This belief has served not only as the explanation for why believers in Christ should not become Jews, but is also the reason that Jews are not exempted by the Christian churches, from the call of the Gospel to believe in Jesus Christ for salvation from sin and from the penalties due to sin.

Supersessionism | Theopedia
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
In recent times, the doctrine of supersessionism has been blamed for mistreatment of the Jews in the past. Some liberal Protestant groups have therefore formally renounced supersessionism, affirming that Jews and other non-Christians have a valid way to find God within their own faith, which breaks from historic Protestant teaching. Dispensationalism affirms that salvation is only through faith in Christ, and that Jews fall short of obtaining the kingdom of the promised Messiah, unless they are converted to Christianity.

However, in their view, a future mass conversion will result in the restoration of the nation Israel prior to the Millennium, apart from the church dispensation. This anticipation of a future role for the ethnic and geo-political nation of Israel in the plan of God, apart from the Church, is what is meant by some dispensationalists who style themselves as rejectors of "supersessionism" or "replacement theology", and thus they are using the terms in a way that is distinctive to their expectation of future events.

Supersessionism | Theopedia
 
Mar 28, 2016
15,954
1,528
113
back on topic: "Replacement Theology"

....

Supersessionism

Supersessionism is the traditional Christian belief that Christianity is the fulfillment of Biblical Judaism, and therefore that Jews who deny that Jesus is the Jewish Messiah fall short of their calling as God's Chosen people....

...The traditional form of supersessionism does not theorize a replacement; instead it argues that Israel has been superseded only in the sense that the Church has been entrusted with the fulfillment of the promises of which Jewish Israel is the trustee. This belief has served not only as the explanation for why believers in Christ should not become Jews, but is also the reason that Jews are not exempted by the Christian churches, from the call of the Gospel to believe in Jesus Christ for salvation from sin and from the penalties due to sin.

Supersessionism | Theopedia
Amen reformation not replacement .
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,395
113
Dcontroversal,

There is a barrier that cannot be crossed regarding the church. Scripture is clear that the seals, trumpets and bowls judgment, which are the wrath of God, must take place prior to Christ's return to the earth to end the age, which is what Matt.24:29-31 and Rev.19:11-21 is representing. Therefore, if you have the church being resurrected at the end of the age, you are then putting them through the entire wrath of God, which scripture states that we are not appointed to suffer and which Jesus rescued us from.

You would also have to explain who is riding on those white horses following Christ out of heaven to end the age in Rev.19:14. Scripture identifies these on white horses as the bride/church, His called, chosen and faithful followers (Rev.17:14), which would demonstrate that in order for the church to follow Christ out of heaven, they would already have to be in heaven. It is the comparison and cross referencing of all of these truths regarding end-time events and bringing them into alignment in order to come to a proper conclusion.



Your error above is not discerning that there is a difference between common trial and tribulation which comes at the hands of men and the powers of darkness vs. God's coming wrath. Those whom you mention above that have been persecuted for 2000 years were/are experiencing common trials and tribulation from the world, which Jesus said we would suffer. That said, those people were/are not suffering from God's direct wrath.

The wrath of God via the seals, trumpets and bowl judgments will be an unprecedented time of wrath that has been prophesied of by the prophets and the apostles. It is during the time of this coming wrath that believers are not appointed to suffer. There is a big difference between the tribulation that you are describing above vs. God's coming wrath. You see, Jesus already took upon himself the wrath that all believers deserve and thereby satisfying God's wrath against us. Understand the difference between these two.
[/SIZE]
Your error which blinds you to the truth is believing that WRATH and TRIBULATION are the same thing....
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,395
113
Well then, I will leave you with your own beliefs regarding this. But what I am saying is the truth. Maybe some day God will open your eyes to it. If you think that the only reason that the word church is no longer used from chapter 4 onward because the word saint is sufficient, then you are just not recognizing this hidden truth here that God is providing.

If the word church and saint were used interchangeably throughout chapters 1 thru 3 and also used interchangeably from chapter 4 onward, then your claim would be valid and there would be no issue and I would not be teaching this. But it is because this is not the case that I teach this. I'm telling you that the division of both church and saint is pertinent to understanding this scriptural truth.
To quote my Aussie friends....whatevz

The bible teaches a post tribulation pre WRATH ingathering....

When the sun goes dark, the stars fall from heaven and the moon does not give her light, half of the world's population has been killed, and almost all vestige of Christianity has been suppressed, almost wiped out and silenced....then look up...until then smoke in the wind bro!
 

notuptome

Senior Member
May 17, 2013
15,050
2,538
113
12 tribes, 12 apostles .Six of one a half a dozen of another? Together they make one bride.Why the division between tribes and apostles as if there were two wife's, two gospels?
Israel is the bride of Jehovah. Israel is stiff necked and rebellious. The church is the bride of Christ. The church pure, chaste and obedient to her Savior.

Not two gospels but two covenants.

For the cause of Christ
Roger
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,395
113
I am sorry...to me you are going in different directions all at once......It appears you want everybody to suffer to get to Heaven?
You must be seriously out of your mind to ASSUME that I want anything pal.....the word is clear...disregard, reject, deny whatevz......soon enough we will all know....and the bible teaches a post GREAT tribulation PRE WRATH ingathering....there are no verses in context that teach an imminent return of Christ and POOF we all disappear.....sorry...not there!
 

tanakh

Senior Member
Dec 1, 2015
4,635
1,040
113
76
Ahwatuki

The reference you cite is about the SONS of Jacob not the tribes. When the Israelites left Egypt they took Josephs remains with them. From then on Ephraim and Manasseh are mentioned often but never a tribe of Joseph until you get to Revelation.
Incidentally the tribe of Dan is not in the revelation list. The point is that I dont believe that these are necessarily literal
Jews from the twelve tribes of Israel. If they are what happens to the descendants of Ephraim and Dan when this 144000
appear in the last days?
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
Your error which blinds you to the truth is believing that WRATH and TRIBULATION are the same thing....
or just simply that God can and does deliver from/out of His wrath by many means.
we have 70AD as one example - Jesus told them to flee Jerusalem when they saw God's instrument of wrath (The Roman army) surrounding her. and the ones who believed Him did flee.

what other instances do we have where God preserves His people from His own wrath?
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
Ahwatuki

The reference you cite is about the SONS of Jacob not the tribes. When the Israelites left Egypt they took Josephs remains with them. From then on Ephraim and Manasseh are mentioned often but never a tribe of Joseph until you get to Revelation.
Incidentally the tribe of Dan is not in the revelation list. The point is that I dont believe that these are necessarily literal
Jews from the twelve tribes of Israel. If they are what happens to the descendants of Ephraim and Dan when this 144000
appear in the last days?
I wonder why Dan isn't mentioned.
any ideas?
 
Nov 19, 2016
502
23
0
To quote my Aussie friends....whatevz

The bible teaches a post tribulation pre WRATH ingathering....

When the sun goes dark, the stars fall from heaven and the moon does not give her light, half of the world's population has been killed, and almost all vestige of Christianity has been suppressed, almost wiped out and silenced....then look up...until then smoke in the wind bro!
That is how it will be is persecution towards the saints for the three and one half years that the beast rules,then the resurrection,then the wrath of God poured upon the world leading up to the battle of Armageddon where they attack Israel,and then Jesus comes back with His saints,and fights the world,and Jesus and the saints rule over the people that God spared at the battle of Armageddon.Satan is bound for that 1000 years which there is peace,and then loosed and deceives the people and they go against Jesus and the saints,and then God rains fire on them and devours them,for they still have punishment coming for they took the mark of the beast,but God postponed it until the 1000 years were expired so Jesus and the saints had people to rule over.You cannot rule for a 1000 years if there is nobody to rule over.

The Bible says there is only two resurrections,one before the millennial reign,and one after the millennial reign.

The beast makes war against the saints,and prevails against them.

The last king shall destroy the mighty and holy people physically.

They shall be given in to the little horn's hands for three and one half years.

When the world has accomplished to scatter the power of the holy people,then the things in Daniel are finished,which is then the resurrection.

The Bible says immediately after the persecution then the resurrection happens.

The saints cannot be united with Christ until the man of sin claims to be God,and the world knows about it.

God is love,and will not give up on the world until they give up on Him,and God will let them go as far as going against the saints during the last half of the 7 years period,for there will be no excuses,but shown on their part that they definitely wanted nothing to do with Christianity.

The world cannot repent of their sins after they take the mark of the beast,which is halfway through the 7 years period that God gives the world their way,and cause all who do not love Him to follow the beast kingdom,so the world can still repent of their sins for the first half of the 7 years period,and the saints are not going anywhere as long as repentance is still available to the world.

The beast blasphemes against God and His tabernacle,which if the saints are not on earth he would not have to do that,for he would not have to go against something that is not represented in his sight on earth,which he tells the world that Christianity is not true,and their God not true,and no prosperity there,for he does not regard any god,but honors the God of forces,the evolutionary process.

The Bible says the saints will go through the 7 years period,and then be resurrected,and the wrath of God poured upon the world,leading up to the battle of Armageddon where Jesus comes back with His saints,which Jesus will descend the same way He did ascend,which is on the Mount of Olives,and God said He will gather all nations together to fight Israel,then He will come back with His saints,and step down on the Mount of Olives,and fight the world as He did in the day of battle,and the plague will be their flesh will melt off their bones(Zechariah 14),and in Joel 3 that God will gather the nations,and thither call thy mighty ones to come down,oh LORD,who is the saints,and Revelation 19 where Jesus comes back with His saints and fights the world,and puts down the false prophet and the beast.

There is no pre-trib resurrection,for there is too much information that the saints will go through it,but of course many saints will not make it to the end of the tribulation for they will have been killed before that time,but they are with the LORD,which the saints under the altar say,how long Lord until you avenge us,and He said when the rest of the saints meet with us,and when all the saints are with Jesus then He will come back and put down the world.

If some say but God is love,He would not allow the saints to go through the tribulation,that does not make sense,for then God would not of allowed any saint to be persecuted for the entire history of the Church.

Who do people think the tribulation,and persecution is for,it is not for the world because they are together,they are not persecuting each other,and the wrath of God does not get poured out until the end of the 7 years period,which the Bible says that the beast has power to continue for the last three and one half years after he addresses the world,and they follow him,which means God is allowing him to rule with no interference from Him,for if the wrath was poured out then,how does the beast have power to rule for the three and one half years.
 
Last edited:

Ahwatukee

Senior Member
Mar 12, 2015
11,159
2,373
113
The reference you cite is about the SONS of Jacob not the tribes.
Tanakh, the son's of Jacob are the twelve tribes of Israel, as they are one and the same.

The point is that I don't believe that these are necessarily literal Jews from the twelve tribes of Israel. If they are what happens to the descendants of Ephraim and Dan when this 144000 appear in the last days?
Dan missing from the list is a well known excuse used as an attempt to make these 144,000 as not being literal Israel. This is a false assumption and an error in exegesis based only on the fact that the tribe of Dan is missing. The fact is that John says, "I heard the number of those who were sealed, twelve thousand from the tribes of Israel." Therefore, the scripture proclaims that this group is in fact the twelve tribes of literal Israel, minus the tribe of Dan and replaced with Manasseh. But Dan not being included in the line-up is not a reason to dismiss these as not being the literal tribes of Israel.

If they are what happens to the descendants of Ephraim and Dan when this 144000 appear in the last days?



Nothing happens to Dan and Ephraim, for whatever reason, they are just not included with the rest of the tribes that will be here during the first half of that last seven year period. For whatever reasons God omitted Dan and the Holy Spirit has not yet revealed the reason why to me. Some have said that it is because of idolatry, which dismiss and that because all of tribes committed idolatry. That has to be some other reason, which I continue to watch for. But as I said, the absence of Dan from the list does not warrant, throwing the baby out with the bath water, so to speak. These will be the first fruits out of the literal twelve tribes of Israel. The woman (unbelieving Israel) gives birth to them, i.e. they come out of Israel, as those who recognize Jesus as their Messiah.

I whole-heartedly believe that the Male Child of Rev.12, is a collective name for the 144,000, who will be snatched up to God's throne in the middle of the seven year period.
 
Last edited:

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
replacement theology/supersessionism is the topic.
 

Ahwatukee

Senior Member
Mar 12, 2015
11,159
2,373
113
To quote my Aussie friends....whatevz

The bible teaches a post tribulation pre WRATH ingathering....

When the sun goes dark, the stars fall from heaven and the moon does not give her light, half of the world's population has been killed, and almost all vestige of Christianity has been suppressed, almost wiped out and silenced....then look up...until then smoke in the wind bro!


G-Day dcontroversal,

You can't have a post tribulation gathering. The reason for this is the wrath of God, which is what that tribulation is. Scripture states that believers are not appointed to suffer God's wrath. Jesus said that those who overcome and keep the patience of his word, that he would keep them out of the hour of trial that is coming upon the whole world to test those who dwell upon the face of the earth.

The major problem with this controversy, for one, stems from people not understanding the severity and magnitude of God's coming wrath. That it will not be like anything ever seen or experienced in history. The end result being the majority of the earth's population being decimated and all human government being dismantled.

After Paul gave his detailed account of the gathering of the church, he finished with "therefore, comfort each other with these words. When writing to Titus, Paul referred to our gathering as "the blessed hope." That said, if the church was to go through the wrath of God and be gathered afterwards, believers could not comfort one another with those words nor would it be a blessed hope. If that was the case, God would in fact be punishing the righteous with the wicked.
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
can we please take rapture stuff to a rapture thread etc.
this one is about replacement theology/the Church is Israel
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
41,313
16,301
113
69
Tennessee
12 tribes, 12 apostles .Six of one a half a dozen of another? Together they make one bride.Why the division between tribes and apostles as if there were two wife's, two gospels?
Maybe they're Mormons.
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,395
113
or just simply that God can and does deliver from/out of His wrath by many means.
we have 70AD as one example - Jesus told them to flee Jerusalem when they saw God's instrument of wrath (The Roman army) surrounding her. and the ones who believed Him did flee.

what other instances do we have where God preserves His people from His own wrath?
Noah was one example......God told him exactly what to do....Noah was here when it rained...not magically BEAMED up