Ask an Atheist

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Apr 26, 2014
93
0
0
#1
Ever had a question you wanted to ask an unbeliever but don't know any or were afraid to ask? I'd be happy to answer anything about myself, atheists, or atheism in general. I'll try to answer all of them to the best of my ability. Thanks
 
Mar 18, 2011
2,540
22
0
#2
Was Jesus a lunatic? a liar? or who He said He was? (please explain your answer.) thanks :)
 

Hizikyah

Senior Member
Aug 25, 2013
11,634
372
0
#3
How can an atheist explain prophecies of Daniyl particularly that of the 70 weeks prophecy of Daniyl? (I understand most atheistis dont know but I usually go through it with them.)
 

Hizikyah

Senior Member
Aug 25, 2013
11,634
372
0
#4
How did these men know these scientific facts when the whole world thought the world was flat for thousands of years later?

Proverbs 8:26-29, "Before Yahweh made the earth or the fields, or any of the dust of the world, I, was with Him. When He prepared the heavens, I, was there. When He drew a circle on the face of the deep, When He established the clouds above, and securely fixed the fountains of the deep."

Iyowb (Job) 26:7, "He stretches out the north sky over an empty space, and He hangs the earth upon nothing."
 
Apr 26, 2014
93
0
0
#5
Was Jesus a lunatic? a liar? or who He said He was? (please explain your answer.) thanks :)
I guess my only honest answer is I don't know. The documentation of his life is really shotty. I'm also not a historian. Some historians have given evidence for why such a man never existed. Others say he did. I honestly think that he was a real man that may have been a prophet and teacher that lived a normal life and attracted a following. People then wrote stories about him and turned him into the character in the bible by attaching the supernatural claims. He was probably written in to fulfill the OT prophecies and to reform the religion to make it more appealing as the OT laws were becoming outdated as society and their morals changed.
 

Hizikyah

Senior Member
Aug 25, 2013
11,634
372
0
#6
How can an atheist explain prophecies of Daniyl particularly that of the 70 weeks prophecy of Daniyl? (I understand most atheistis dont know but I usually go through it with them.)
And none have ever made prophecies this accurate in history, I own Nostradamus book and it is drastically vague.
 

posthuman

Senior Member
Jul 31, 2013
36,691
13,135
113
#7
(in parallel with another popular thread)

do you exist?
 
Apr 26, 2014
93
0
0
#8
How did these men know these scientific facts when the whole world thought the world was flat for thousands of years later?

Proverbs 8:26-29, "Before Yahweh made the earth or the fields, or any of the dust of the world, I, was with Him. When He prepared the heavens, I, was there. When He drew a circle on the face of the deep, When He established the clouds above, and securely fixed the fountains of the deep."

Iyowb (Job) 26:7, "He stretches out the north sky over an empty space, and He hangs the earth upon nothing."
Saying the earth is a circle isn't the same as saying the earth is a sphere. When you stand atop a mountain it's clear the earth's plane from your view is a flat circle. This does not show they knew it was spherical. And I don't see how the next one tells us they knew about space. It shows that they knew the earth was it's own separate entity.
 
Mar 18, 2011
2,540
22
0
#9
I guess my only honest answer is I don't know. The documentation of his life is really shotty. I'm also not a historian. Some historians have given evidence for why such a man never existed. Others say he did. I honestly think that he was a real man that may have been a prophet and teacher that lived a normal life and attracted a following. People then wrote stories about him and turned him into the character in the bible by attaching the supernatural claims. He was probably written in to fulfill the OT prophecies and to reform the religion to make it more appealing as the OT laws were becoming outdated as society and their morals changed.
1st, I appreciate your honest answer. "I don't know." I guess my response would be. "Shouldn't you check it out?" not just the biased websites. Think about this. The bible says satan is the ruler of this world. So even from a biblical standpoint you have to assume that there is false information designed to lead you away from the truth. Ergo, you would have to search more extensively. Isn't it worth it? after all if Jesus really is the Son of God, you don't want to miss THAT boat.

Next, there are amazing documentaries and testimonies from historians and researchers, archaeologists and beyond that will show you the truth ( I have to leave in 5 minutes to visit a friend, sorry this will be brief but I will be back) Once upon a time Pontius Pilate was thought to be a made up character by the world. Then we have real solid proof. Then Caiphus the head Pharisee at the time. They found his burial container and indeed he was the head Pharisee. So these aren't made up characters, they really existed.

We find ancient manuscript which match the Word of God we have today that date as early as the first century, and the way it is written is. "as you all know" and "as you all have seen." can you imagine if a mass scale book came out that said basically that within our lifetime all of these great lies occurred? those documents never would have survived and in such numbers. You really must seek harder my friend.

I will return. Thank you for being so honest and open to discussion.
 

Pie

Senior Member
May 21, 2011
151
1
18
#10
What is human rationality (chemical reactions in our brain, atoms colliding with one another to form thoughts?) and why do you trust it to tell you the truths of our existence, meaning, purpose? Why do we even have the ability to ask these questions?

Also, do you believe in objective moral values and duties? Is it objectively wrong to rape baby or is it just subjectively wrong?
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#11
Do atheists believe in aliens?
 
Apr 26, 2014
93
0
0
#12
1st, I appreciate your honest answer. "I don't know." I guess my response would be. "Shouldn't you check it out?" not just the biased websites. Think about this. The bible says satan is the ruler of this world. So even from a biblical standpoint you have to assume that there is false information designed to lead you away from the truth. Ergo, you would have to search more extensively. Isn't it worth it? after all if Jesus really is the Son of God, you don't want to miss THAT boat.
Well I don't believe Satan actually exists so that isn't persuasive to me at all. And if that's true wouldn't that mean it's possible satan wrote or altered the bible to lead you away from the truer god? If he's as sneaky as you say that would be the sneakyest thing imaginable. Also just because I donot know for sure doesn't mean I havenot researched it or have a good idea or the answer. Imy not positive exactly what's true about him but I am sure that he wasn't divine. Your last line is almost like pascal wager which fails for its own reasons.
[/QUOTE]

Next, there are amazing documentaries and testimonies from historians and researchers, archaeologists and beyond that will show you the truth ( I have to leave in 5 minutes to visit a friend, sorry this will be brief but I will be back) Once upon a time Pontius Pilate was thought to be a made up character by the world. Then we have real solid proof. Then Caiphus the head Pharisee at the time. They found his burial container and indeed he was the head Pharisee. So these aren't made up characters, they really existed.
I never said they weren't real people. Theres lots of physical and extra biblical documents supporting their existence. The Romans kept very good records. Jesus on the other hand has only the bible to support his existence and not much else. Maybe just enough to support the idea that a man named Jesus may have existed but certainly not that he did what he did.

We find ancient manuscript which match the Word of God we have today that date as early as the first century, and the way it is written is. "as you all know" and "as you all have seen." can you imagine if a mass scale book came out that said basically that within our lifetime all of these great lies occurred? those documents never would have survived and in such numbers. You really must seek harder my friend.
I don't follow. Can you clarify what you mean here? Thanks

I will return. Thank you for being so honest and open to discussion.
No thank you! I'll talk to you later
 
Apr 26, 2014
93
0
0
#13
Do atheists believe in aliens?
Well I can't speak for all atheists in this matter but I would say yes and no. Not aliens like they're depicted in movies but most atheists do believe that alien life exists in the universe. It's just a matter of probability.
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
41,355
16,320
113
69
Tennessee
#14
Ever had a question you wanted to ask an unbeliever but don't know any or were afraid to ask? I'd be happy to answer anything about myself, atheists, or atheism in general. I'll try to answer all of them to the best of my ability. Thanks
What do you base your hope in so that you may be happy and joyful? The existence and reality of God is not predicated on one's personal beliefs, no matter how sincere. It is clear to me as a Christian that God is quite real an is the author of happiness and joy. If there is no God then there is no hope for those that believe in him. Faith is the hope in the evidence that is unseen. I pray that you may experience this type of faith. Good luck to you Sir.
 

Hizikyah

Senior Member
Aug 25, 2013
11,634
372
0
#15
How can an atheist explain prophecies of Daniyl particularly that of the 70 weeks prophecy of Daniyl? (I understand most atheistis dont know but I usually go through it with them.)
And none have ever made prophecies this accurate in history, I own Nostradamus book and it is drastically vague.
Thank you for answering my other question, and your answer is fair.

But I ask that you ponder this, if one looks into these things it is hard to ignore.
 
Feb 16, 2014
903
2
0
#16
Also, do you believe in objective moral values and duties? Is it objectively wrong to rape baby or is it just subjectively wrong?
If it turns out there is no God, would it become appropriate to rape babies? Or do you believe we would have other means of determining such horrid behaviors as being wrong?

What is human rationality (chemical reactions in our brain, atoms colliding with one another to form thoughts?) and why do you trust it to tell you the truths of our existence, meaning, purpose? Why do we even have the ability to ask these questions?
Well, our rationality stems from our thoughts, which are created by our brains. If you cut down to it, as an atheist, I do believe we are the result of chemical reactions. Does this mean we can't trust our senses? Well, yes and no. We do our best to understand the world around us. For the most part, what we come to understand about the world works well enough for us. We are constantly finding examples of how misleading our senses can be. Optical illusions are a great example of this! But just because we find flaws with our senses and often our logic, doesn't mean we can't trust them at all. After all, we are able to survive precisely because we trust our logic and our senses!

My body and mind isn't perfect, but it works.
 

skipp

Senior Member
Mar 6, 2014
654
7
0
#17
How do you explain the fact that many religious people feel God's presence when they communicate with him? Do you believe that we are just hallucinating or imagining it? And if so, why would humans have evolved to have these feelings?
 
Apr 26, 2014
93
0
0
#18
(in parallel with another popular thread)

do you exist?
I'm fairly certain yes I do exist. However I acknowledge that I could be part of some kind of Matrix computer program or some other alternate reality that I can't percieve. I don't think that's likely though. Possible but not likely. I also don't like getting into this Sye Ten Brugencate style of arguing about absolutes and reality and junk because it's unnecessary and confusing
 
Apr 26, 2014
93
0
0
#19
How do you explain the fact that many religious people feel God's presence when they communicate with him? Do you believe that we are just hallucinating or imagining it? And if so, why would humans have evolved to have these feelings?
I don't think it's hallucination at all. That seems belittling to me. I think it's simply misinterpretation and wish full thinking. "Reading too much into it" if you will. Like where I see a coincidence someone else might see evidence of god. It's just a different way of perceiving things.

As fAR as evolving to have these traits it's not that we evolved to have this perception, it's that we evolved a brain complex enough so that these perceptions are possible and they happened for other reasons.this then gets into simply why religion exists and how religion evolved to be more complex over time.
 
S

Sirk

Guest
#20
Well I can't speak for all atheists in this matter but I would say yes and no. Not aliens like they're depicted in movies but most atheists do believe that alien life exists in the universe. It's just a matter of probability.
You have no evidence they exist yet you believe they do? Interesting.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.