Charismatics

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
E

ember

Guest
I don't like labels because they mean something different to everyone.
I just don't like labels period...put one on me, and I will do my best to wiggle out of it

labels are for plants in the garden, eh?
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,710
3,651
113
I just don't like labels period...put one on me, and I will do my best to wiggle out of it

labels are for plants in the garden, eh?
I label you a "label disliker". :)
 

Agricola

Senior Member
Dec 10, 2012
2,638
88
48
I just don't like labels period...put one on me, and I will do my best to wiggle out of it

labels are for plants in the garden, eh?
DO not forget they are for lost bears as well.

Paddington-bear-Original-TV-Series-1975.jpg
 
J

JesusistheChrist

Guest
I know it wasn't aimed at me LOL!

I'm not sure who you do mean it for though...
I mean it for everybody in the sense that we ought to expect an increase in evil men and seducers. We are in a spiritual war and Satan's ministers, like Pharaoh's magicians of old, do have supernatural powers at their disposal at times as well. We need to be careful in relation to what types of "spirits" we allow in our midst. Again, Paul warned of "another Jesus", "another gospel" AND "another spirit". If the Jesus being preached isn't truly the Jesus of scripture and if the gospel being preached isn't truly the gospel of Christ, then we can be sure that there is "another spirit" at work. Do you know what happened in the church that I used to attend? Right in the midst of this alleged "move of the Spirit" which prompted the pastor to actually remove the first 5 rows of pews from the church so people could roll around on the floor laughing their heads off due to alleged "holy laughter", THE EVANGELISM TEAM DISMANTLED. I actually went to the pastor and tried to reason with him by reminding him that the Holy Spirit came to convict or convince the world of sin, righteousness and judgment and that He does so indirectly through the preaching of the gospel and that any true "move of the Spirit" would inevitably involve/include the same, but it was like I was talking to a brick wall.
 

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,782
2,950
113
As I have said before, I was a charismatic/pentecostal the first 15 years after I got saved. I was lied to in the Vineyard, the Pentecostal church had no time to counsel a couple with marriage issues (10 pastors, 1 couple!) (but we got help later from secular sources!)

The other BIG reason, is that I began to see the shallowness of the doctrine. Everything was about tongues and signs. Although I will admit that some of the Pentecostals did have a heart for the lost.

I also saw that shallow doctrine resulted in shallow and unethical character. Nothing that was preached, was what I was reading in my Bible, which I loved to read and study.

So a few years in an Evangelical Free church, which had an elder board that was dominating and controlling, and kept firing awesome pastors, if they didn't tow their line.

Finally, God called me to a Baptist church. WOW! I finally heard a preacher who was preaching from the same Bible I was reading. His knowledge of the Word of God was amazing. And when he started encouraging the young men to go to Seminary, I heard the call of God - one of the best things that ever happened to me - growing and getting close to God, hearing his voice, and really learning the Word of God.

I am in my third Baptist Convention, after moving a few times. I love my church. People raise their hands, as the Bible says to do, in praise of God. The messages are incredible, with real unity from week to week, even though we have a different preacher every week in the summer. It is God orchestrating the message. That is the Holy Spirit moving!

And the depth of character in the leadership - pastors and elders is astounding. From small things to the big - I see people who are truly deep in their walk with God and teaching it in word and deed to the congregation.

So my answer is that all these nonsense demonstrations are actually destroying the walks of Christians. Instead of digging into God's Word for answers about how to live, they get caught in the very shallow experiences and outer signs, instead of growing in both in spirit and in the knowledge of God's gift to us - the Bible.
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
Can you elaborate on that?
It's not just tongues. It's dancing. It's shouting out something when it's prayer time. (In English, since tongues was already covered.) It's getting up to "share" something that often really sounded good, unless you knew the sharer. (What was said was usually was not the way the people lived their lives.) It's this effort to put on a show for others, even when the people weren't the leaders of the church. It's the worship music being more about getting the troops rallied.

When I was in Charismatic churches, my brother also convinced us to get into Amway. There were little quiet get-togethers that taught the newbies how to sell the product. And then there were bigger get-togethers to rejoice in all things Amway. And then there was the time where a big-wig (high-tiered Amway salesman) came to talk. He had a Rolls Royce back at home. He came on his own private jet. We all went to meet him. We were all dressed up. (I was actually wearing a dress. I don't even wear dresses to churches, unless a big-wig comes to town. lol) And it dawned on me while everyone was going gaga over this guy -- this isn't any different than church. It's a pep rally to talk us into something I honestly never wanted in the first place. I didn't want a fancy car or a jet.

And I didn't want to waste my time looking all spiritual to impress others. It's an experience that doesn't last until kickoff on Sunday football.
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
53510,
How did you find a Vineyard that claimed they were Pentecostal?
 
Last edited:
A

atwhatcost

Guest
You have just, basically, said that if a person lacks the intellectual magnitude to fathom all the Bible, they are in trouble. (even though you didn't MEAN to say that) If you "know" more than me, or if I "know" more than you, or if we both know more than a mentally disabled person who can't even read the Bible to discover this "God" we say we know.... what do you believe that means? I think it means next to nothing.

I think the disabled girl probably may "know" more of God than us simply because she asks God if He sees her.

It is not about us learning God (for whatever reason), but Him knowing us. Remember the verse...."But, but, GOD! Didn't we study and "know" all about you, and then begin to do all sorts of cool things in your name?" And what did He say? "I never knew you."
Um, I am the disabled girl. :confused:

So, not so much try to understand/know him as waiting for him? I'm not saying you're one of them, but the vast majority of people who I've met who believes this do so, because it's easier than opening God's word and learning. "Humanly possible" meant something. It means however far we can do it, do it. This isn't an IQ test. It's getting to know God because he knows us and wants a two-way relationship with us.

In like kind, I've listened and asked for stories from hubby's family about him before I met him. I've seen the pictures. I've heard the good stories and bad stories. From him, I've heard them more then once. Will I ever know him complete? Of course not, but I like him so want to know him more.

Same idea with God.
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
Modern "Charismatic" Churches are the result of the hybridization over the past 60 years or so of Pentecostal beliefs concerning the gifts of the Spirit and Baptist views on grace & sanctification. Basically what you have are people who think that they can operate in the gifts of the Spirit yet still be self motivated / carnally minded.

Biblically, the Spiritual gifts are an extension of the nature (presence) of the Holy Spirit at work in one's life. Scripture, Galatians 5:16 to be exact, clearly teaches that a person can not walk in the Spirit and walk in sin simultaneously. However, many Charismatic Churches, including mainline Pentecostal denominations such as AoG, CoG, & IPHC, have embraced Baptist views on sanctification, the idea that sanctification is a life long involuntary process. Because of this, unfortunately, many are attempting to operate in the Spirit while the flesh is still in control. The result of which are alleged "manifestations of the Spirit" that do not produce authentic spiritual reasults (ie. souls saved, bodies healed, mental & emotional bondage broken).

This could have been avoided if modern Pentecostalism, established in 1906, would have embraced Classical Pentecostal (Keswick) views on sanctification, est in 1885.
Hmmm, and I keep thinking it's about God, not about older denominations.
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
Hmmm, and I keep thinking it's about God, not about older denominations.
Nope. You have to decide which statement made down through history matches what you want to hold high and defend. Then you have to stubbornly and blindly stand behind those words some old guy, long dead, uttered or wrote down in a creed, come Hell or high water.
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
Oh, fun! He got ahold of some of Piper's teachings. LOL
You know? You get very upset if you think anyone might even be possibly putting your church in negative light.

How about being of like kind when it comes to what others think of their churches? I'm very tired of your swipes at reformed. I know you don't like it, but is it necessary to laugh at anyone that might? I have four brothers. I can go there. I learned mock very well. I'm just trying not to. (Not always successfully, but I'm trying.) Mock is a family trait.
 

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,782
2,950
113
53510,
How did you find a Vineyard that claimed they were Pentecostal?
My mistake! It should have been "the Vineyard; the Pentecostal church.."

So a semi-colon separating two totally different churches. Although the Vineyard had really good music (Brian Doerkson's home church) and dancing and flag waving, which I had never seen in a Pentecostal Church. And very loud!


The Pentecostal church was the big one, and the pastors had no time to deal with the congregation! Just lip service to helping people!
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
I just don't like labels period...put one on me, and I will do my best to wiggle out of it

labels are for plants in the garden, eh?
Not so much. Watering or rain tends to make the label stakes fade away too quickly. lol
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
Is it too personal to ask what the preacher lied to you about at the Vineyard?
 
Feb 7, 2015
22,418
413
0
My mistake! It should have been "the Vineyard; the Pentecostal church.."

So a semi-colon separating two totally different churches. Although the Vineyard had really good music (Brian Doerkson's home church) and dancing and flag waving, which I had never seen in a Pentecostal Church. And very loud!


The Pentecostal church was the big one, and the pastors had no time to deal with the congregation! Just lip service to helping people!
We really and truly have a bowl full of ear plugs at our little Welcome Station to hand out to all of us old people who dislike the loud music. I think most of those musicians long ago destroyed 40% of their hearing.
 

Galatians2-20

Senior Member
Mar 17, 2013
261
19
18
Oh, fun! He got ahold of some of Piper's teachings. LOL
Actually, while I respect Mr. Piper, I am not huge fan of Calvinism. If I were going to lean in that direction, I much prefer Paul Washer. :)
 

Galatians2-20

Senior Member
Mar 17, 2013
261
19
18
Hmmm, and I keep thinking it's about God, not about older denominations.

Perhaps you didn't hear, salvation is not about what you or I believe. Salvation is a person. His name is Jesus Christ and unless you live in Him, your salvation is no salvation at all. :)