Do people observe Halloween or Christmas to worship Satan just because its roots are pagan? You can't answer that.
What I see is people turning what once may not have been Christian into something as a reminder of God, Jesus, and eternal life.
An object like a Christmas tree, or a Halloween decoration is amoral. Just like a wedding ring. Whatever the meaning is behind it for an individual is what matters. To me it is wrong to promote that observing certain things as "wrong" when you don't know ones heart.
I agree with you to some extent. I know the majority of Christians celebrate Christmas to honor God, and that none of them celebrate Halloween to worship satan (at least I sure hope not!). I respect the fact that much of my family and friends celebrate christmas as a legitimate form of worship. As I've said before, I'm not anyone's Holy Spirit, only He can lay on someone's heart to celebrate or not celebrate it.
What I see is people turning what once may not have been Christian into something as a reminder of God, Jesus, and eternal life.
And I suppose I have a concern with people saying it's ok to take these pagan holidays and traditions and redeem them for God, but it isn't ok for people to take the holidays and traditions found in the Old Testament and use those to worship God. I'm not saying you do this Elizabeth, because our paths haven't crossed too much in this forum, so I don't know much of what you believe. I'm speaking in generalities.
Would anyone be celebrating either of these holidays if they hadn't been started to worship other gods? I still see a difference between doing things that were once done by other nations or groups in daily life, and celebrating and using things that were specifically created and designed to worship another God.
Is there a Biblical precedent or command for God's people to take other forms of worship, traditions or idols and "redeem" them for Godly use and worship?
And again, there is no Biblical command or instruction or example to Christians celebrating these days. It wasn't until after it was created (for pagan practices) that it was celebrated by Christians, but still using the same traditions.
Again, I'm not going to judge anyone if they do or don't, these are just questions and concerns I have. And again, I wasn't anticipating discussing this for another month or so. Early bird gets the worm I suppose.