The Trinity Discussion

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
124
63
Okay! In John 1:1, the scripture that trinity believers cling to like a kid to its mother, it starts "in the beginning...." Please explain what that beginning is the beginning of. It can't be the beginning of God as He has no beginning, so???????
It is the beginning of all things visible and invisible apart from God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit. .
 

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
124
63
But only one logos. Jesus the image of his invisible Father could have been with God for billions of years before the heavens and earth were started to be created, no one knows.
God had both word and wisdom for all eternity. There was no time when they did not exist. The Word (Who became Jesus) therefore existed for all eternity. I know. 'In the beginning the Word was already in existence' (John 1.1).


The Hell theory and the trinity theory try to destroy that close fatherly/son relationship that God and Jesus had with each other. The Hell fire issue suggests that through Jesus God created this place
Jesus specifically stated that Hell was created for the Devil and his angels.

I count these theories with Mary entering heaven in flesh and blood form, which is completely in contradiction of scripture.
Mary is the only thing we agree on,

But the Catholic Church has decided that where scripture and tradition conflict that tradition should be accepted. so too, is the idiocy of Hades, Hell and the trinity.
Not the Catholic (universal) church but the ROMAN Catholic church.

However, the doctrine of the Triune God is scriptural
 

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
124
63
but then you ARE a Jehovah's Witness relying on your totally distorted New World Translation.
 
Jul 26, 2017
155
1
0
but then you ARE a Jehovah's Witness relying on your totally distorted New World Translation.
Ohhh! AHHH! not one of them Jehovah Witnesses, Heaven forbid, we w ill now all be dashed to Hell, or Hades, Or purgatory or limbo or some other place invented by those that are not Jehovah witnesses.

And just think, there are almost 9 million of these little critters around the earth, all teaching only what is in the Bible and not in the addled minds of the clergy and their followers.

They do not accept the pagan traditions of Xmas and Easter, Do you? Do you agree with praying to many saints? Do you know why there are many saints in Christendom? In Jesus time, who were the ones that dressed in purple and gold and made a great extravaganza of their position in the churches that came up after the end of the apostolic period? Who was it that Jesus condemned, those that stood on street corners and loudly recited prayers so t hey could be seen to be pious....I will tell you, those that you follow and Christendom follows, that’s' who.


Why is the Catholics called Papists, as in Papal Palace etc? What were the dark ages? How many innocent humans have been killed in the name of religion in the modern era, and did the JWs have any doing in this killing? Have you been involved in world governments when they go to war and killed millions of humans for a political/religious reason?

Ohh! No!! Not the Jehovah Witness, let's run and hide.
 

trofimus

Senior Member
Aug 17, 2015
10,684
794
113
Ohhh! AHHH! not one of them Jehovah Witnesses, Heaven forbid, we w ill now all be dashed to Hell, or Hades, Or purgatory or limbo or some other place invented by those that are not Jehovah witnesses.

And just think, there are almost 9 million of these little critters around the earth, all teaching only what is in the Bible and not in the addled minds of the clergy and their followers.

They do not accept the pagan traditions of Xmas and Easter, Do you? Do you agree with praying to many saints? Do you know why there are many saints in Christendom? In Jesus time, who were the ones that dressed in purple and gold and made a great extravaganza of their position in the churches that came up after the end of the apostolic period? Who was it that Jesus condemned, those that stood on street corners and loudly recited prayers so t hey could be seen to be pious....I will tell you, those that you follow and Christendom follows, that’s' who.


Why is the Catholics called Papists, as in Papal Palace etc? What were the dark ages? How many innocent humans have been killed in the name of religion in the modern era, and did the JWs have any doing in this killing? Have you been involved in world governments when they go to war and killed millions of humans for a political/religious reason?

Ohh! No!! Not the Jehovah Witness, let's run and hide.
You are so disoriented... you do not even know on what page you are right now.

This is a protestant page, protestants do not pray to saints. And have nothing to do with Pope etc.

Also, if you think that JW just follow the Bible and not people, you are disoriented even more. Ever heard of Brooklyn and the Watch Tower?
 

fredoheaven

Senior Member
Nov 17, 2015
3,993
927
113
Ohhh! AHHH! not one of them Jehovah Witnesses, Heaven forbid, we w ill now all be dashed to Hell, or Hades, Or purgatory or limbo or some other place invented by those that are not Jehovah witnesses.

And just think, there are almost 9 million of these little critters around the earth, all teaching only what is in the Bible and not in the addled minds of the clergy and their followers.

They do not accept the pagan traditions of Xmas and Easter, Do you? Do you agree with praying to many saints? Do you know why there are many saints in Christendom? In Jesus time, who were the ones that dressed in purple and gold and made a great extravaganza of their position in the churches that came up after the end of the apostolic period? Who was it that Jesus condemned, those that stood on street corners and loudly recited prayers so t hey could be seen to be pious....I will tell you, those that you follow and Christendom follows, that’s' who.


Why is the Catholics called Papists, as in Papal Palace etc? What were the dark ages? How many innocent humans have been killed in the name of religion in the modern era, and did the JWs have any doing in this killing? Have you been involved in world governments when they go to war and killed millions of humans for a political/religious reason?

Ohh! No!! Not the Jehovah Witness, let's run and hide.
This is absolutely an off topic!
 

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
124
63
Ohhh! AHHH! not one of them Jehovah Witnesses, Heaven forbid, we w ill now all be dashed to Hell, or Hades, Or purgatory or limbo or some other place invented by those that are not Jehovah witnesses.
Yes you will be cast into Hell, unless you repent,

And just think, there are almost 9 million of these little critters around the earth, all teaching only what is in the Bible and not in the addled minds of the clergy and their followers.
Teaching what is in the New World 'Translation' which is packd full of heresy. You ignore the Bible proper.

They do not accept the pagan traditions of Xmas and Easter, Do you?
I accept no pagan traditions. But I celebrate the death and resurrection of Christ and His birth daily.

Do you agree with praying to many saints?
No

Do you know why there are many saints in Christendom?
All who are true Christians are saints, sanctified in Christ Jesus,

In Jesus time, who were the ones that dressed in purple and gold and made a great extravaganza of their position in the churches that came up after the end of the apostolic period?

No one in the true church. Just heretics like the JWs

Who was it that Jesus condemned, those that stood on street corners and loudly recited prayers so they could be seen to be pious
The Scribes and Pharisees.

....I will tell you, those that you follow and Christendom follows, that’s' who.
Actually no, and we also don't sell books and make great profits like you do,

Why is the Catholics called Papists, as in Papal Palace etc?
You mean the ROMAN Catholics? You'd better ask them. They are nearly as mercenary as you are.
What were the dark ages? How many innocent humans have been killed in the name of religion in the modern era.,
None by the true church.

and did the JWs have any doing in this killing?
The JWs have done their share,


Have you been involved in world governments when they go to war and killed millions of humans for a political/religious reason?
You are not talking about the true church. You are talking about hypocrites who make religion an excuse.

Ohh! No!! Not the Jehovah Witness, let's run and hide.
Lets just ignore their ignorance and stupidity, and recognise they do not know the living Christ.
 

bluto

Senior Member
Aug 4, 2016
2,034
509
113
No mattforjesus, Revelation 3:14 was "NOT" done in any other fashion when you said, "Jesus is the beginning of the creation of God in this fashion." The words are explicit after you look them up in the Greek that Jesus Christ is the "CREATOR," that is what the verse means.

You have to understand that "grammar" has as much to do with the meaning of a sentence as do the words, So if you say a sentence means something and you can't find it in the sentence, that's not what the sentence means. This is exactly what your doing.

You imposing on the explicitly meaning and grammar of the verse that, "God calls things that have not happened yet,as though they already happened,for if it is a plan of God to happen in the future,it is the same as if it happened in the beginning,for it will surely come to pass with no hindrance."

So mattforjesus, where in Revelation 3:14 is God calling things that have happened as though they already happened?" It's simply not there so let me give you a little tip. Something can not mean something other than what it says, and what it says is BASED in the words, their definitions, grammar, and syntax. I don't care whether it is literal, figurative, metaphorical, poetic: SOMETHING CAN NOT MEAN SOMETHING OTHER THAN WHAT IT SAYS, PERIOD.

The shortest verse in the Bible is "Jesus wept." (John 11:35). So tell me, when did this happen? Did it happen in the plan of God at some future time or did it happen in real time when Jesus actually wept? And does it really mean "Jesus wept" or does it mean something else that I'm not aware of? :eek: PS: I should also say there is a time and place when God has called things in advance like, "The Lamb of God was slain from the foundation of the world" but that is in a completly different context. :eek:

IN GOD THE SON,
bluto
 
J

jaybird88

Guest
whats the benefit of believing in the trinity?
 
J

jaybird88

Guest
If one is in a love relationship then it is important to understand the person/persons that you love...
so without the trinity one will never understand the Most High? this would mean great Patriarchs like Samuel, Elijah, Moses had no understanding of the Father. the Father even spoke to Moses face to face, hard to believe Moses didnt have any understanding of Him.
 
Jul 26, 2017
155
1
0
so without the trinity one will never understand the Most High? this would mean great Patriarchs like Samuel, Elijah, Moses had no understanding of the Father. the Father even spoke to Moses face to face, hard to believe Moses didnt have any understanding of Him.

Just check out that face to face comment about Moses. Moses was told to turn away and Jehovah showed his brilliance through the powerful angel that was talking to Moses form the burning bush. The brilliance was so great, and it was not a face to face with the God of all men, Moses descended from the mountain with a sunburned face that was noticed by the Israelites.

This coincides with the scripture:
In accounts where it might seem that the Bible says that humans literally saw God, the context shows that God was represented by an angel or appeared by means of a vision.
[h=3]Angels.[/h] In ancient times, God sent angels as his representatives to appear to humans and to speak in his name. (Psalm 103:20) For example, God once spoke to Moses from a burning bush, and the Bible says that “Moses hid his face, because he was afraid to look at the true God.” (Exodus 3:4, 6) Moses did not literally see God, though, for the context shows that he actually saw “Jehovah’s angel.”—Exodus 3:2.
Similarly, when the Bible says that God “spoke to Moses face-to-face,” it means that God conversed with Moses intimately. (Exodus 4:10, 11; 33:11) Moses did not actually see God’s face, for the information he received from God “was transmitted through angels.” (Galatians 3:19; Acts 7:53) Still, Moses’ faith in God was so strong that the Bible described him as “seeing the One who is invisible.”—Hebrews 11:27.
 

bluto

Senior Member
Aug 4, 2016
2,034
509
113
Just check out that face to face comment about Moses. Moses was told to turn away and Jehovah showed his brilliance through the powerful angel that was talking to Moses form the burning bush. The brilliance was so great, and it was not a face to face with the God of all men, Moses descended from the mountain with a sunburned face that was noticed by the Israelites.

This coincides with the scripture:
In accounts where it might seem that the Bible says that humans literally saw God, the context shows that God was represented by an angel or appeared by means of a vision.
Angels.

In ancient times, God sent angels as his representatives to appear to humans and to speak in his name. (Psalm 103:20) For example, God once spoke to Moses from a burning bush, and the Bible says that “Moses hid his face, because he was afraid to look at the true God.” (Exodus 3:4, 6) Moses did not literally see God, though, for the context shows that he actually saw “Jehovah’s angel.”—Exodus 3:2.
Similarly, when the Bible says that God “spoke to Moses face-to-face,” it means that God conversed with Moses intimately. (Exodus 4:10, 11; 33:11) Moses did not actually see God’s face, for the information he received from God “was transmitted through angels.” (Galatians 3:19; Acts 7:53) Still, Moses’ faith in God was so strong that the Bible described him as “seeing the One who is invisible.”—Hebrews 11:27.
Well tell me something bronson? It says the following at Genesis 17:1,2, "Now when Abram was ninety-nine years old, the Lord appeared to Abraham and said to him, "I am God Almighty, Walk before Me and be blameless, vs2, And I will establish My covenant between Me and you, And I will multiply you excedingly." So bronson, who physically appeared to Abram? :eek:

IN GOD THE SON,
bluto
 
D

Dagallen

Guest
Just check out that face to face comment about Moses. Moses was told to turn away and Jehovah showed his brilliance through the powerful angel that was talking to Moses form the burning bush. The brilliance was so great, and it was not a face to face with the God of all men, Moses descended from the mountain with a sunburned face that was noticed by the Israelites.

This coincides with the scripture:
In accounts where it might seem that the Bible says that humans literally saw God, the context shows that God was represented by an angel or appeared by means of a vision.
[h=3]Angels.[/h] In ancient times, God sent angels as his representatives to appear to humans and to speak in his name. (Psalm 103:20) For example, God once spoke to Moses from a burning bush, and the Bible says that “Moses hid his face, because he was afraid to look at the true God.” (Exodus 3:4, 6) Moses did not literally see God, though, for the context shows that he actually saw “Jehovah’s angel.”—Exodus 3:2.
Similarly, when the Bible says that God “spoke to Moses face-to-face,” it means that God conversed with Moses intimately. (Exodus 4:10, 11; 33:11) Moses did not actually see God’s face, for the information he received from God “was transmitted through angels.” (Galatians 3:19; Acts 7:53) Still, Moses’ faith in God was so strong that the Bible described him as “seeing the One who is invisible.”—Hebrews 11:27.
Moses did not speak to God face to face, Moses did not see God in the burning bush, would be correct.
 

bluto

Senior Member
Aug 4, 2016
2,034
509
113
Moses did not speak to God face to face, Moses did not see God in the burning bush, would be correct.
Well dagallen, who did Moses see in the burning bush at Exodus 3:2 and at Exodus 3:4 it says, "When the Lord saw that he turned aside to look, GOD called to him from the midst of the bush," Why does it say the Lord not only turned to see Moses but it says God called to Moses from the bush? :eek:

IN GOD THE SON,
bluto
 
D

Dagallen

Guest
Well dagallen, who did Moses see in the burning bush at Exodus 3:2 and at Exodus 3:4 it says, "When the Lord saw that he turned aside to look, GOD called to him from the midst of the bush," Why does it say the Lord not only turned to see Moses but it says God called to Moses from the bush? :eek:

IN GOD THE SON,
bluto
Metaphorically speaking or figuratively yes, literally speaking, Moses saw the Angel of the Lord.
 
D

Dagallen

Guest
Well dagallen, who did Moses see in the burning bush at Exodus 3:2 and at Exodus 3:4 it says, "When the Lord saw that he turned aside to look, GOD called to him from the midst of the bush," Why does it say the Lord not only turned to see Moses but it says God called to Moses from the bush? :eek:

IN GOD THE SON,
bluto
What does Moses or the burning have to do with, whether the trinity concept is true or false ?
 

bluto

Senior Member
Aug 4, 2016
2,034
509
113
Metaphorically speaking or figuratively yes, literally speaking, Moses saw the Angel of the Lord.
So then dagallen, that must mean the angel of the Lord is the Lord God according to the text because it "literally" says God called to him from the midst of the bush. It's right there at Exodus 3:4. Not metaphorically and not figuratively right? :eek:

IN GOD THE SON,
bluto
 
Jul 26, 2017
155
1
0
Well tell me something bronson? It says the following at Genesis 17:1,2, "Now when Abram was ninety-nine years old, the Lord appeared to Abraham and said to him, "I am God Almighty, Walk before Me and be blameless, vs2, And I will establish My covenant between Me and you, And I will multiply you excedingly." So bronson, who physically appeared to Abram? :eek:

IN GOD THE SON,
bluto
An angel, as related in my excerpt from JW.org
 
Jul 26, 2017
155
1
0
What does Moses or the burning have to do with, whether the trinity concept is true or false ?
Go back to Jabbird88 posting.However is is also proving the true identity of Jehovah the only true God.