What do You think when... A cessationist encounters a continuationist?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
K

kaylagrl

Guest
#21
Thank you ForthAngel for your honest opinion. :)


God bless you.

Rachael are you just wanting people to give their opinions or to have a discussion? I dont want to cause an issue but forth angel calling me either a liar or deluded is kind of hard for me to let go without answering. Dont see how this thread wont get "inflammatory" as you say when people are being called liars.
 

ForthAngel

Senior Member
Aug 31, 2012
2,171
91
48
#22
Rachael are you just wanting people to give their opinions or to have a discussion? I dont want to cause an issue but forth angel calling me either a liar or deluded is kind of hard for me to let go without answering. Dont see how this thread wont get "inflammatory" as you say when people are being called liars.
My opinion wasn't directed at you personally :) Take it however you wish though.
 
P

popeye

Guest
#23
My personal opinions:
About tongues: They either a) Know that they are liars or b) are incredibly deceived, most likely brought up as a kid being taught this "gift". As you stated, Acts is clear about what tongues were on the day of Pentecost, and it is a world of difference from what we see today.

About Prophecy: It's such vanity to get a personal prophecy about a new job or a new promotion or anything carnal along these lines. Demons or familiar spirits are just as good at setting up minor events like this as anything else, and trusting them is along the lines of divination or fortune telling. Those who make grand claims of prophecy, i.e. a global event, are always proven false. Always. I, again, believe these propagating this to be a) liars or b) incredibly deceived.

About "healing": Compare modern healing to a biblical healing. It is not even close. It's so asinine to even compare the so-called healing we see today to anything that is reported in the bible. It's again another vanity. I believe a) the people propagating these "healings" are a) liars or b) incredibly deceived.

I have been to one church for a good bit of time that did these things. It was an assembly of God, and the Gospel was rarely preached, and when it was, it was watered down and more focused on sign gifts than anything else. The bible was hardly used at all during service. Just random clippings of it here and there to kinda go along with whatever nonsense was being preached on.

Just my opinion.
the people propagating these "healings" are a) liars or b) incredibly deceived.
Ok,we got you down as Paul and Jesus being outside your box.
 
P

popeye

Guest
#24
My opinion wasn't directed at you personally :) Take it however you wish though.
Yes it was
You specifically called her and myself "either liars,or decieved"
 
C

ChristIsGod

Guest
#25
Dear Sis Rachel, I'm going to have to just post on Auto-Pilot at this point and can't use my very tired brain. I have Dyautonomia from long term, multiple reinfections and not treated than under-treated Lyme and I just exhausted all of my 'natural' resources on reading a whole 11 pg thread.

I'm PRAISING GOD that this was what I wanted to get onto after that thread - but I'm not a good 'thread starter' AND I am SO GRATEFUL that a Sister started this thread and not a man - so I don't have my fear of 'teaching men' when I'm NOT a Teacher at all. I just like to post Scripture and quote Scripture but in this case, I'd just like to post from my heart-of-hearts and let the chips fall where they may.

I am a continuationist - needless to say - as I already "liked" the posts I've read thus far - up to kaylagrl's 1st post.

Why this same thought about what your OP is about was on my mind so much today, is because of what I've seen in the years that I've been saved and 'church hopping' so much but not by choice - but now by called-to.

What's on my mind the most is John 16:13!!!

And that 3 times - The Lord calls His Spirit, "The Spirit of Truth" and the verse above states that HE will "lead us into All Truth".

My problem with what I've seen in 38 yrs of hopping around and reading a lot is that there are some that totally neglect the fact that being filled with the Spirit happens upon regeneration/salvation - the cup is filled - as in filled - but being Baptized in the Holy Spirit is like a cup of water being filled to 'Over-Flowing' and continually so - no stated point of it not being continuously being over-flowed except rebellion.

Now - IF His Spirit is called "the Spirit of Truth" - wouldn't one think that this same "Spirit" that one receives by choice as in Pentecost, would also be the over-flowing of "The Spirit of TRUTH"?

The gifts without The Truth is not the genuine. It's another spirit.

We are all 'growing in the Truth' if we are in The Truth to begin with ... but if we've already accepted a false doctrine or doctrines of men - then we are not operating out of the "Spirit" because HE promised that HIS Spirit would lead us into All Truth. Maybe not over-night or after 38 yrs but everyday we're growing and learning and will be 'learning' even when we SEE HIM. If we think that we won't be 'learning' after we see Him -- then we think we'll be as Omniscient as GOD, therefore being equal or as God when we're with Him and there's nothing to back that up.
We'll be 'like' Him for we shall see Him as He is --- but 'like' is not "as God".

The people that I knew [that are in Heaven now] and those that I know now all believe this same way. Some that are in Heaven that I knew 38 yrs ago, believed this way -- so I've never ever felt alone in what I'm saying here. We were and are 'of one mind' and I only need to pick up the phone and call one of them that are continuationists but are attending different denominational churches because they don't segregate from the rest of the Body of Christ. Some do not attend continuationist churches, because there's none that haven't gone 'wacky' in their area ... as compared to 38 yrs ago --- MOST have.

I'm a member of a Church in a State that I moved from 5 yrs ago that are basically known to be cesstationists but they took me in as a member because they do believe I'm saved and though I'm a continuation and they're not and because I'm not Reformed Theology but they are. Amazing Love, that's all I can say about how He works, in that regard.
I no more believe in most of what they believe and yet - I know they love Him and preach Holiness and if someone is not "living the life" they say that that person "isn't saved" ... we just have a different view on how the elect are chosen.

I would love to continue to Church Hop, now that I've moved away from my Family in Christ in that Church - but I've tried all of the near-by Churches and did not feel The Lord telling me to stay at any of them. I was desperate for fellowship and fought Him over this - but it's what He wants, not me - that I should be here, finding this forum as my 'fellowship' and not a local body of believers or to continue to search any further from home, because I've only moved here to be by the phone for my 96 y.o. Dad and to care for him and not be miles away if he falls or something, where he needs me. I know how badly I've cried out for 'fellowship' but it took until I found CC to find it and He led me every step of the way because I love and fear Him and wanted whatever He wanted and waited and tested & tried this site before I signed on. I'm fussy where it comes to 'forums' and had to read everything I could written on the tops of Index pages written by the Admin.s before I'd join. I tested the waters but that doesn't mean that HE won't tell me to move on tomorrow or whenever. But for now - I'm here and grateful for as long as He keeps me grateful or until He has me banned... which He does when I linger in obeying Him to leave because I get attached to people fast.

Anyhow - my main deal with the Baptism in the Holy Spirit is that it is mainly displayed in the evidence of the leading of the Spirit of Truth when it comes to interpreting Scripture. Now that may sound "arrogant" to some - and so be it - but if we're led by His Spirit - WE cannot take any credit for the things that HE has written and how HIS Spirit leads us according to "what is written" ... we just follow along - like tail-gating. What credit does the one get, that needs to tail gate in order to find the way to a certain destination? Did they find the way to that destination themselves?
Obviously, No and all that they can do is THANK the person that led the way - in this case - His Spirit.

The Holy Spirit is a "gentlemen" in that He won't force Himself on certain folks. Like me attending services in cesstationist's fellowships or my friends doing so. "I become all things to all people" and so do they - as what Paul meant that. I also would wear a head covering with those that believe in such when praying or prophesying - though that's not my custom as my hair is long enough to please most that worry about those verses.
To those that don't wear slacks, make-up nor jewelry - I won't wear slacks, make-up but just my wedding band when I visit their gatherings and so on and so forth. Becoming all things to all men only excludes sinning for anybody. All things are lawful to me but not all things are expedient - as Paul meant it when he said it twice in 1 Cor.

If a person or group want to ignore these verses below - it's up to them - but I don't judge people by whether they believe in the continuation of Pentecost, but by their love for God, the truth in holiness [2Cor 7:1], and lastly, their love for their fellow humans.

1Th 5:19 Quench not the Spirit.
1Th 5:20 Despise not prophesyings.
1Th 5:21 Prove all things; hold fast that which is good.


I reckon that's all or it.


Thank you, for following His leading!!!

Love in Christ to all.
 

ForthAngel

Senior Member
Aug 31, 2012
2,171
91
48
#26
Ok,we got you down as Paul and Jesus being outside your box.
Ok?

My opinions are on modern sign gifts which she asked about, not biblical accounts which I trust in implicitly.
 
A

AtonedFor

Guest
#27
.
I hope someone might be able to find this both interesting and invaluable ...

The Scripture passages below explain the results of the baptism with the Holy Spirit.
And the important DETAILS in each passage are shown in the chart below.
Please notice how these details are so
inter-connected (linked together) in the chart.
And realize the obvious truth that all the details of an event
are seldom recorded every time the event occurs.


1 Luke 24:49 ------ 8 Acts 8:14-19
2 Acts 1:4-8 ------ 9 Acts 9:17-18
3 Acts 2:1-4 ----- 10 Romans 15:19
4 Acts 2:33-39 --- 11 Acts 10:44-48
5 Acts 4:8-16 ---- 12 Acts 11:15-17
6 Acts 4:31 ------ 13 Acts 14:3
7 Acts 5:12-16 ----14 Acts 19:5-6

------------------- 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
the Promise --------Y-Y---Y-------------------------
baptism with H.S. ----Y-------------Y--------Y-----Y
the gift -----------------Y---------------Y--Y------
upon ---------------Y Y Y---------Y-------Y--Y-----Y
laying on of hands ---------------Y-Y-----------Y--Y
filled with H.S. -------Y---Y-Y-----Y---------------
received H.S. --------------------Y-------Y---------
speaking tongues -------Y-----------------Y--------Y
power --------------Y-Y-----------Y----Y------------
boldness -------------------Y-Y-----------------Y---
miracles -------------------Y---Y---Y--Y--------Y---

I should add that this baptism sometimes happens
simultaneously with a person being born-again
(when the Holy Spirit comes INSIDE the person).

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Rachel20

Senior Member
May 7, 2013
1,639
105
63
#28
Rachael are you just wanting people to give their opinions or to have a discussion? I dont want to cause an issue but forth angel calling me either a liar or deluded is kind of hard for me to let go without answering. Dont see how this thread wont get "inflammatory" as you say when people are being called liars.

Kayla girl, I know. It's hard to respond back but I would appreciate it if you don't.

The reason being so, is that we're not letting anyone judge anyone else but let the intents of everyone be out in the open.

So you know now a few people think in such a manner, you can pray for them.

However for Forthangel too, if he feels that this is deluded thinking, than he can read your posts and everyone else's experiences and pray for them.

I am so sorry I am asking such a thing from you and everyone else :( But thank you really for respecting this so much.


I KNOW how hard it can be to take things personally and get offended. It's a big thing to ask of anyone, but I would rather you didn't respond to his post if you felt it was offensive unless you can correct him on some aspect with Scripture.


Love you so much kaylagirl for being so kind about everything!
 

Rachel20

Senior Member
May 7, 2013
1,639
105
63
#29
Thank you ChristinGod for your response and being so open.

I agree with the last three Scripture that you posted so much. God bless you and I hope you recover and have good health.

Take care and much love in Christ to you,


Rachel
 
K

kaylagrl

Guest
#30
My opinion wasn't directed at you personally :) Take it however you wish though.

Well see I dont know you and you dont me.I dont want to be an enemy of anyone here.If we knew each other in person perhaps we'd be good friends.You cant generalize all Pentecostal churches to be the same first of all.I've been to hundreds of churches of all denominations and one Baptist can believe totally different from another.I've been in all denominations,even Catholic. So I dont judge people by whats over the door.I have criticized Pentecostals before when I have seen wrong done.

I'm not sure whether your comment was sarcastic or not because,well you cant tell by reading sometimes. If you knew me you'd know I am no liar.Now I was brought up in the Pentecostal church,yes,but it doesnt always hold true that because you're brought up that way you're the only one to experience it.I'll tell you an experience about this ....

I traveled and sang with my family for many years.Thats why I've been in so many different churches.When we first started singing just in our town we had a guy join the group ,he was a bass player.Now we went to all churches and did not preach Pentecostal doctrine.We wanted to see people saved and attend the church they felt comfortable in. The bass player was of the Baptist faith but he was willing to travel in all churches as we did.We were in a Pentecostal service one morning and there was a message in tongues and then an interpretation.Then we went on to finish the service.After the service the bass player said "I knew what that person said before it was said in English". We weren't sure what he meant at first.He said when the tongues was spoken he knew what was being said in English before anyone said a word. I dont know who was more surprised him or us.He stayed in the Baptist church but he would tell people he believed in tongues because of his experience.He wasnt a liar,he wasn't demon possessed and if he was delusional how could he have known the English before it was spoken? So maybe dont generalize and look a little deeper into the issue.And Im not saying that in sarcasm or to put you down,just to make you think.
 

maxwel

Senior Member
Apr 18, 2013
9,351
2,436
113
#31
Well I just understood better what she was asking.I dont want to focus or derail her thread on a minor issue.She's just asking what our experience is.
I agree.

I'd hate to derail a thread over a minor issue.

However, I think when the OP starts her thread by THREATENING people... that's a major issue.


What was she threatening people about?
She was threatening people NOT to post links to orthodox websites that use SCRIPTURE to disagree with her point of view.
Doesn't this seem odd?
What is wrong with scripture?
Why should we be afraid of scripture?

Threatening people about bringing scriptural information into a Christian discussion... isn't that kind of odd?

Shouldn't we always STRIVE to bring MORE scripture into every discussion?

Everything we think, or do, or see, should be filtered through the scripture.
Why should scripture frighten anyone?
Why should scripture upset the OP so much she is willing to threaten people who rely on scriptural answers, and want to link out to them?
Why is she so worried about the scripture?

This all seems very odd to me.
 
Last edited:
P

popeye

Guest
#32
Ok?

My opinions are on modern sign gifts which she asked about, not biblical accounts which I trust in implicitly.
Anytime ,anybody steps out we can easily see the "human" element.
Those biblical characters were flawed. peter especially. Did not seem to bother the HS. Peter went on,inspite of his misuse,abuse,and error.

Jesus did not preach a powerless gospel that gave glory to infirmity and sent them away sick and blind.
The test of jesus being alive today is in fact the miracles signs and wonders.
It takes guts to step out and pray for healing,and dead to be raised. We are backslidden into a 'powerless gospel' that preaches a mental salvation.
Shame on us
 
K

kaylagrl

Guest
#33
I agree.

I'd hate to derail a thread over a minor issue.

However, I think when the OP starts her thread by THREATENING people... that's a major issue.


What was she threatening people about?
She was threatening people NOT to post links to orthodox websites that use SCRIPTURE to disagree with her point of view.
Doesn't this seem odd?
What is wrong with scripture?
Why should we be afraid of scripture?

Threatening people about bringing scriptural information into a Christian discussion... isn't that kind of odd?

Shouldn't we always STRIVE to bring MORE scripture into every discussion?

Everything we think, or do, or see, should be filtered through the scripture.
Why should scripture frighten anyone?
Why should scripture upset the OP so much she is willing to threaten people who rely on it, and want to link to it?

This all seems very odd to me.

I think i'll let the OP answer that one.I think i'll be too busy defending myself in this thread.Apparently Im a liar or a lunatic.Oh my...sigh.
 

Rachel20

Senior Member
May 7, 2013
1,639
105
63
#34
I think i'll let the OP answer that one.I think i'll be too busy defending myself in this thread.Apparently Im a liar or a lunatic.Oh my...sigh.
Haha. Kaylagirl :)


I just want to say don't let it get to you, just like I am not even bothered by this guy, Maxwel's myopic arguments.


It is so shortsighted and stupid, and clearly a waste of time.


I will clarify to anyone else reading this thread.



1. I have not stated any of my personal views, and I am trying to be as neutral and hear out others before I share my own.

2. I have nothing against Scripture. Please post Scripture. Just don't copy paste opinions from other sites or links of an organization's opinion. Paraphrase your own opinions and experiences. That is all.
 
Last edited:
E

elf3

Guest
#35
I think i'll let the OP answer that one.I think i'll be too busy defending myself in this thread.Apparently Im a liar or a lunatic.Oh my...sigh.
Kaylagrl I understand your frustration in this as I myself am a "Son of thunder, lighting, hail and high winds". I know you want to respond and I can "picture" your response boiling up inside you. I will tell you a little trick I do myself. Grab a piece of paper and a pen. Write down what you want to say. Every single word. Then read back through it. Do not post it but just in writing down what you want to say can relieve some of your frustration. If you still feel you need to post it then send it to me in a personal message. As I said, just the act of writing can relieve some of your frustration. :)
 
K

kaylagrl

Guest
#36
Kaylagrl I understand your frustration in this as I myself am a "Son of thunder, lighting, hail and high winds". I know you want to respond and I can "picture" your response boiling up inside you. I will tell you a little trick I do myself. Grab a piece of paper and a pen. Write down what you want to say. Every single word. Then read back through it. Do not post it but just in writing down what you want to say can relieve some of your frustration. If you still feel you need to post it then send it to me in a personal message. As I said, just the act of writing can relieve some of your frustration. :)

Its not so much the attack on me but on the truth. It greatly frustrates me.But so far so good.I think Im being good lol I may need to use that pm as an out though.I think I'll go bake a cake.Baking helps frustration. :)
 

Rachel20

Senior Member
May 7, 2013
1,639
105
63
#37
Kaylagrl I understand your frustration in this as I myself am a "Son of thunder, lighting, hail and high winds". I know you want to respond and I can "picture" your response boiling up inside you. I will tell you a little trick I do myself. Grab a piece of paper and a pen. Write down what you want to say. Every single word. Then read back through it. Do not post it but just in writing down what you want to say can relieve some of your frustration. If you still feel you need to post it then send it to me in a personal message. As I said, just the act of writing can relieve some of your frustration. :)

Hi Elf3.

I smiled at your post. Is your services open for all or just kaylagirl ? :p


@ ALL

I just want to thank all of you for your responses and most of you have respected what I asked you to do and furthermore have let go and been kind about my strict streamlining.


I am very grateful.

Thank you for doing that.:)

I know how hard it is ! Much love to you in Christ,

Rachel
 

ForthAngel

Senior Member
Aug 31, 2012
2,171
91
48
#38
Kaylagrl I understand your frustration in this as I myself am a "Son of thunder, lighting, hail and high winds". I know you want to respond and I can "picture" your response boiling up inside you. I will tell you a little trick I do myself. Grab a piece of paper and a pen. Write down what you want to say. Every single word. Then read back through it. Do not post it but just in writing down what you want to say can relieve some of your frustration. If you still feel you need to post it then send it to me in a personal message. As I said, just the act of writing can relieve some of your frustration. :)
While I agree with your first piece of advice, if she writes a letter flaming me and sends it to you, that would be gossip would it not ;) I would rather her send it to me personally and we can discuss it civilly, rather than her needing to talk trash about me behind my back.

To give people who were offended an idea of what I was talking about:

Acts 2
2 When the day of Pentecost arrived, they were all together in one place. 2 And suddenly there came from heaven a sound like a mighty rushing wind, and it filled the entire house where they were sitting. 3 And divided tongues as of fire appeared to them and rested on each one of them. 4 And they were all filled with the Holy Spirit and began to speak in other tongues as the Spirit gave them utterance.

5 Now there were dwelling in Jerusalem Jews, devout men from every nation under heaven. 6 And at this sound the multitude came together, and they were bewildered, because each one was hearing them speak in his own language. 7 And they were amazed and astonished, saying, “Are not all these who are speaking Galileans? 8 And how is it that we hear, each of us in his own native language? 9 Parthians and Medes and Elamites and residents of Mesopotamia, Judea and Cappadocia, Pontus and Asia, 10 Phrygia and Pamphylia, Egypt and the parts of Libya belonging to Cyrene, and visitors from Rome, 11 both Jews and proselytes, Cretans and Arabians—we hear them telling in our own tongues the mighty works of God.” 12 And all were amazed and perplexed, saying to one another, “What does this mean?” 13 But others mocking said, “They are filled with new wine.”
There is no room for another interpretation here. None. Scripture is clear that these were either a) Human languages miraculously learned by the speaker or b) The speaker speaking in their native language and the hearers miraculously hearing their own language. Compare what we see today with this, and it falls hard.

About the miracles. Here is an example of a biblical miracle:

John 5
John 5 English Standard Version (ESV)
The Healing at the Pool on the Sabbath

5 After this there was a feast of the Jews, and Jesus went up to Jerusalem.

2 Now there is in Jerusalem by the Sheep Gate a pool, in Aramaic called Bethesda, which has five roofed colonnades. 3 In these lay a multitude of invalids—blind, lame, and paralyzed. 5 One man was there who had been an invalid for thirty-eight years. 6 When Jesus saw him lying there and knew that he had already been there a long time, he said to him, “Do you want to be healed?” 7 The sick man answered him, “Sir, I have no one to put me into the pool when the water is stirred up, and while I am going another steps down before me.” 8 Jesus said to him, “Get up, take up your bed, and walk.” 9 And at once the man was healed, and he took up his bed and walked.
This was a bonafide miracle. This man was probably seen by many people for 30 years and without a doubt could not walk, at all. He was healed instantly and got up and walked. We do not see b blind, lame, or paralyzed people being healed today. Only unverifiable stories. There is not one single verifiable account, or anyone willing to provide evidence that a real miracle has taken place. Minor aches and pains, or someone who has a non-disabling infirmity are not what we see in the bible. This is vanity. We see legitimately crippled people healed instantly in scripture.
 

Rachel20

Senior Member
May 7, 2013
1,639
105
63
#39
@ForthAngel,


and what of Scripture such as this?

Romans 8:26
And the Holy Spirit helps us in our weakness. For example, we don't know what God wants us to pray for. But the Holy Spirit prays for us with groanings that cannot be expressed in words.


1 Corinthians 14: 2-4

For he who speaks in a tongue does not speak to men but to God, for no one understands him;however, in the spirit he speaks mysteries. 3 But he who prophesies speaks edification and exhortation and comfort to men. 4 He who speaks in a tongue edifies himself, but he who prophesies edifies the church.
 
E

elf3

Guest
#40
OK now as to the OP...I personally believe the Holy Spirit still works through tongues and healing. The reason I say this is because I personally have witnessed both.

I'll give one example of each that I have seen.

Healing...I have seen someone in my church actually get healed of cancer by someone laying on hand and praying over them. The guy in question had been diagnosed by two different doctors and a battery of tests as having pancreatic cancer. He was going back on a Monday to have some more tests done to see what the "next step" might be. A lady in our church layer on hands and prayed with him on the Sunday before the tests. His results from the "new tests" came back as negative for cancer. Only way I can explain it (or anyone else including one of his doctors) is by that lady through the power of the Holy Spirit healed him.

Tongues...this would actually be from a couple Bible studies I was in (happened more than just once and by different people each time). At the start of the study, after we read through the particular passage for the night in different translations, someone wrote down a word. When they got up the courage to reveal the word they wrote we found it to be a Greek word. When we looked up the word we found it to be a word that was so relevant to what we were studying that it "helped" us understand the passages. I believe in this way the Holy Spirit spoke through that person with tongues to help us in our study.

Now prophecy..well I am very leary of that because we have had so many people say "God showed them something" only to be proven wrong. Take for example all of those who have said "God showed me the world will end on this date". Well since we are still here I would say they were a bit "off the mark".

So these are just what I personally have seen so I believe the spiritual gifts of healing and tongues are still in affect. I'm not worried if you believe me or not but just my opinion :)