Guys, would you give a girl addicted to romance novels a chance?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Fenner

Senior Member
Jan 26, 2013
7,507
111
0
#22
But Gaston died and he was so full of himself.
He was very full of himself, he died? Oh did he fall off the roof? The Beast held her hostage, so I don't know if was much better than Gaston. Well first he locked up her daffy old father and then threw her in the tower. I know he had issues, but Belle had Stolkholm syndrome for sure.

I think Belle was probably better off single. The Disney Prince's I've seen are always so, ok this will sound awful but very feminine. I understand they want these strong female role models but they need to even the field out a little more. With the exception of Flynn Rider from Tangled or Kristoph from Frozen. They were funny and not all annoying.
 

Fenner

Senior Member
Jan 26, 2013
7,507
111
0
#23
You brought up a very good point and I will take it one step further....how is reading a romance novel different from watching a romantic comedy? I mean we all want to be swept off our feet, but reality check.....it doesn't happen the way we think it should or the way Hollywood shows it to be. There is nothing wrong with allowing our minds to be creative in the romantic department, but as long as you know there is a difference between reality and fantasies
The unrealistic life in romantic movies could skew a person's brain if they let it, I suppose. They would be with both novels and movies. I've liked some comedy romance movies. I don't enjoy many romance movies. With the exception of Frozen and Tangled and Shrek, but I realize my Husband isn't going to break out into song or hopefully never have to rescue me from falling off of a cliff. We both turn into Ogers now and then.

Im not a huge fan of Nicholas Spark movies or anything like that. It's not my taste. I do watch Days of Our Lives occasionally, but it's like anything you have to know reality from fiction. Not understanding that would be a similar mindset to pornography. If you make that seem like a reality, then you need help. :)
 
Y

Yahweh_is_gracious

Guest
#24
Less important to me is what she reads. More important is why she reads it and what she gets from it. If she reads romance novels because they are an escape for her, fine. If she's a naughty minx and likes reading the sexy-time parts in them, fine. If she reads them with the idea she'll meet some beau hunk like one of the characters in them, well that's just silly.

Who am I to judge though? I'm nearly 40 years old and I still read comic books.
 

jsr1221

Senior Member
Jul 7, 2013
4,265
77
48
#25
I can see how one views it as porn, though. Some pretty much are just sex stories. In that case, you're just reading porn and imaging the scenario in your mind. It actually does the same kind of damage to your brain as watching porn does. But if you're just reading a book and there might be a chapter that has romance, I think that might be different. Ultimately, though, I don't think I'd be comfortable with a woman reading this. Because more often than not, these romance novels are porn. And the field of addiction has shown this type of stuff really is no different than porn.
 

PennEd

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2013
12,962
8,671
113
#26
The unrealistic life in romantic movies could skew a person's brain if they let it, I suppose. They would be with both novels and movies. I've liked some comedy romance movies. I don't enjoy many romance movies. With the exception of Frozen and Tangled and Shrek, but I realize my Husband isn't going to break out into song or hopefully never have to rescue me from falling off of a cliff. We both turn into Ogers now and then.

Im not a huge fan of Nicholas Spark movies or anything like that. It's not my taste. I do watch Days of Our Lives occasionally, but it's like anything you have to know reality from fiction. Not understanding that would be a similar mindset to pornography. If you make that seem like a reality, then you need help. :)
I was talking with someone about my biggest pet peeve movie, Pretty Woman. The messages in that movie are astoundingly horrible.

How many young girls got the notion that prostitution is a viable way to find, fall in love, and marry a rich handsome guy, who will magically give up prostitutes, and solely love them happily ever after?
 

Fenner

Senior Member
Jan 26, 2013
7,507
111
0
#27
I was talking with someone about my biggest pet peeve movie, Pretty Woman. The messages in that movie are astoundingly horrible.

How many young girls got the notion that prostitution is a viable way to find, fall in love, and marry a rich handsome guy, who will magically give up prostitutes, and solely love them happily ever after?
Yeah I hate that movie, the idea and that it was a crappy movie in my opinion.
 

Fenner

Senior Member
Jan 26, 2013
7,507
111
0
#28
Oh another thing about the movie Pretty Woman that bothered me was, she wouldn't kiss him because it was to personal. So you won't swap spit with him but you'll do the most intimate thing two people can do together and that's not getting personal??
 
N

NukePooch

Guest
#29
Personally, I found them to be 100 times worse because again, they fed into the idea that, "I am a King's daughter--a PRINCESS!!!" and so there were all these ridiculous stories about going to the grocery store and finding the Ultimate Man of God standing in front of the carrots and broccoli.

Wait...the Ultimate Man Of God is vegetarian? Talk about unbelievable fiction!
 

Fenner

Senior Member
Jan 26, 2013
7,507
111
0
#30
Less important to me is what she reads. More important is why she reads it and what she gets from it. If she reads romance novels because they are an escape for her, fine. If she's a naughty minx and likes reading the sexy-time parts in them, fine. If she reads them with the idea she'll meet some beau hunk like one of the characters in them, well that's just silly.

Who am I to judge though? I'm nearly 40 years old and I still read comic books.
I haven't heard the word minx in year's. I have half of a big attic filled with mint condition comic books and a whole closet full at my Mother in laws house. Please come purge them!!
 

Yeraza_Bats

Senior Member
Dec 11, 2014
3,632
175
63
35
#32
I figured I should clarify in case someone thought my post here contradicted my post in the other thread.

I read the title as "would give a girl who was addicted to romance novels a chance", and took that as it was. Its not the same as "a guy who struggles with pornography", as I didnt see anything about a desire to leave behind to novels. So I read it as that, a girl who read these books actively. Which then I would feel uncomfortable with the idea and wouldnt want to be involved in it.

If she was someone who dealt with this in the past and was actively making a change, then Id feel much more comfortable with her, as I do not come from a life of perfection either : p
 
S

sassylady

Guest
#33
I'm a woman and have read those types of books many years ago. Not a good idea for any woman because it can put thoughts in your mind when you are not happy about something in your marriage and cause a lot of additional discontent. Like men looking at naked women or pornography, it's not the real world.
 
W

wwjd_kilden

Guest
#34
Eeeewww, romance novels

(Sorry, just had to get it out of my system) :p
 

Lenardzw

Senior Member
Jul 31, 2015
425
22
18
#35
I had a childhood friend who was really into romantic novels and movies. But she turned out okay. I suppose after every page she'd mutter to herself, "Now remember this is not real" and then move onto the next page.

But then would a lady date a guy who is into "chick flicks" more than her?
 

Deidre

Senior Member
Sep 4, 2016
258
7
18
#37
I think that anything could become an idol, if you let it. Whether it's erotic literature, porn, alcohol, money, etc...anything can become an idol and take over your whole life, if you let it. Anything can serve as a distraction to our relationships with others too if we let it. So, maybe some habits aren't terrible if they're occasional, but is occasionally sinning acceptable to God? lol

Hmmm....

We shouldn't strive for perfection, but we should strive to ''go and sin no more.'' (as Jesus said) Not always easy, for sure.
 

Yeraza_Bats

Senior Member
Dec 11, 2014
3,632
175
63
35
#38
I think that anything could become an idol, if you let it. Whether it's erotic literature, porn, alcohol, money, etc...anything can become an idol and take over your whole life, if you let it. Anything can serve as a distraction to our relationships with others too if we let it. So, maybe some habits aren't terrible if they're occasional, but is occasionally sinning acceptable to God? lol

Hmmm....

We shouldn't strive for perfection, but we should strive to ''go and sin no more.'' (as Jesus said) Not always easy, for sure.
I agree with all this, except the not striving to be perfect. Why not strive to be perfect? Of course we arent and we arent saved by works and all that stuff we already know, but whats wrong with working to be perfect? : p
 

Desdichado

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2014
8,768
838
113
#39
I agree with all this, except the not striving to be perfect. Why not strive to be perfect? Of course we arent and we arent saved by works and all that stuff we already know, but whats wrong with working to be perfect? : p
Good question. It seems you both agree, but there is just a difference in terminology.

I suppose "go and sin no more" is striving toward perfection in a manner of speaking. I mean God's standards are perfect.

Perfection could also imply things we have no Biblical command to strive for. Hopelessly high standards in more than one realm.

This is starting to sound like Romans 7.
 

Desdichado

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2014
8,768
838
113
#40
To answer the OP, a woman who is waist deep in romance novels is probably incompatible with me and most men for more reasons than possible distortions in her view of the opposite sex.

It'd be a red flag for me, but not an automatic disqualifier.