Elin said:
If your heart does not tell you that is wrong (Heb 8:10; Jer 31:31-34), then you are not born again.
Hmmm,
contrary to what Paul said...
Rom 7:7 What shall we say then? Is the law sin? God forbid. Nay,
I had not known sin, but by the law: for I had not known lust, except the law had said, Thou shalt not covet.
Not contrary to what Paul said at all.
Let's have a look at what Paul says in Ro 7.
Previous to v. 7, he states that he
was alive without the law and that
when the law came he died.
Since the law was given long before Paul was even
born,
and since he did not actually
die,
is he speaking idiomatically?
He had
not known sin but by the law.
Like a mirror reveals our natural face with its spots and blemishes,
so the law revealed his natural sin to him (Jas 1:23-25),
gave him a knowledge of it, which led to repentance
when he compared his heart to the law.
In the law
the Holy Spirit mirrored to him that, even
without any sinful
act,
concupiscence (lust) in the
heart was sinful.
The
Holy Spirit made him
aware in the law of his
indwelling sin, which he knew
nothing of before.
Unregenerate (natural) Paul had been blind regarding his original corruption,
and he remained in the dark until the
Holy Spirit by the law showed it to him when he was reborn.
That is how the law is an instructor to bring us to Christ.
The
Holy Spirit showed Paul in the law what sin really is, how it is
exceedingly sinful (v.13).
While a Pharisee, Paul was sure of his confidence in his goodness ("
I was alive").
But in reality he was without the law, he did not understand its spiritual meaning,
it was in his head, but not in his heart, he had a mental apprehension of it,
but there was no
power of it in his
heart.
But when he was
reborn, "
the commandment came" in its
power to his heart, not just to his head,
"
sin revived,"
appeared, the Holy Spirit showed him what he had never seen before in sin,
his
naturally (unregenerate) corrupt bias
toward it,
"and I died," the Holy Spirit convincing him with such power that Paul, the obedient Pharisee,
was not righteous, but in a state of sin, and in spiritual death because of that sin.
So
powerful was this revelation by the Holy Spirit to Paul that it stood his former theology on its head.
We can see this in his presentation of it in
Ro 3:10-20, 5:18-19, 7:7-13, 8:7-8; Eph 2:1, 3, 5; Col 2:13.
So Ro 7 is idiomatically dealing with the unregenerate Pharisee Paul
before he was born again (regenerated) by the holy Spirit,
who then revealed to him by the law his previous original innate corruption,
indwelling sin, and natural bias toward it,
which is why we have such strong presentation of man's innate corruption in Paul's writings.
This is in no way contrary to the Holy Spirit giving you to know in your heart what is wrongful.
In fact, rather than being contrary to what Paul said, it is a powerful example of just that.
Jer 17:9 The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it?
And what would David (a man after God's own heart) know?
All prior to the
indwelling Holy Spirit of the NT writing his commands on the hearts of those in Christ.