Dating outside of your denomination

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
B

Beckster

Guest
I was talking to a Christian male on a dating site, I found out what church he belongs to, and I've been to it a handful of times when I was hopping, but for certain reasons I didn't agree with it. I was turned off from that non-denominational church; I didn't feel close to God there. Anyways, I found out that this guy goes there and loves it. To be honest, a part of me became disinterested in the guy, which is fine with me. Am I as picky as I think I am? Or do you feel/felt the same?

Would you date someone that was out of your denomination? Are there certain denominations that you wouldn't date someone from?

(Please Lord, let there be no Catholic-bashing in this thread)
I hear you. I would also become disinterested because, well, dating leads to marriage which then leads to family. I would want to raise our kids with same beliefs. It just wouldn't work if both of us held different beliefs: such as worshiping with our hands in the air and he did not believe in worshiping out there like that. Or praying in the holy spirit. I would want to instill in my children to dance for God and speak in the holy spirit.

If he was open to trying then I might consider but if he is closed up and firmly in his denomination then no.
 
J

jeremyPJ

Guest
dating outside of my denomination? haha Not a chance lol!
 

JesusLives

Senior Member
Oct 11, 2013
14,551
2,171
113
Yes I would, because I am older now and raising children would not really be a problem. As long as we can respect each others beliefs and believe that Jesus has saved us and is the Son of God I just don't see a real problem with dating another denomination. We might be in church all weekend as I am an SDA, there is probably nothing wrong with staying close to God sitting in a pew with someone you love.
 

Desdichado

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2014
8,768
838
113
Finding a good Christian woman is hard enough. However, we are talking about opening ourselves up to lifetime relationships, so it is wise to have guidelines.

Note: Having standards/guidelines when choosing a partner does not necessarily equate to bigotry. We're talking about someone we'll potentially be spending the rest of our lives with.

Guidelines:

1. Theological beliefs must be reasonably similar. Not only for the sake of possible children being reared later on, but I find that meeting life's struggles is easier if people share some semblance of a foundation.

2. One of the reasons people choose denominations has to do with their emotional choices and what clicks best with their personality. Knowing someone's denomination can be helpful in determining what sort of person they are outside of theological matters.

3. Socioeconomic, cultural, and political factors also have a play in what churches people choose. For this sort, church is more of a place where they associate with other people in their chosen group than it is a place of spiritual fellowship.


Where does that leave me?

Well, it would be wise for me to stay away from most charismatic and pentecostal women for reasons one and two. Similarly with Catholics though I think Catholics tend to tread the line between being a separate denomination and another religion entirely.

Mind you my great-grandmother (who witnessed to my father) was a Catholic AND a Charismatic Christian at varying times of her life. She'll have a bigger crown than me, but that doesn't mean I could or have to consider sustaining a long-term romantic relationship with one of her theological sisters.

The liberals that make mainline protestant churches their Sunday haunt wouldn't be a wise choice either. That, of course, excludes the more conservative subsets of those mainline groups. I happen to be one of those (Presbyterians represent!).

I'm open to everyone else unless they're pseudo-pelagian.

Caveat- I believe I could date a strong Christian who is a part of an aforementioned restricted denomination if they didn't insist on going to these places on deep grounds and yield most decision-making power me as far as church attendance is concerned.

Either way, to quote Clint Eastwood, a man's gotta know his limitations.
 

Desdichado

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2014
8,768
838
113
Just re-read my post. Sorry guys, this is what you get when I've been briefing cases all night and then decide to talk about relationships.

Don't blame me- blame my law school.

At least I didn't use terms like "In rem" and "dicta."
 

Descyple

Senior Member
Jun 7, 2010
3,023
48
48
I'm a Baptist, and I once dated an Amish girl.

But I broke up with her because there wasn't any "electricity" between us!!!
 

Descyple

Senior Member
Jun 7, 2010
3,023
48
48
I'm a Baptist, and I once dated a girl from a Liberal church.

But I broke up with her when she declared that our relationship was just a myth (just like she believes the miracles in the Bible are a myth).

I hope she realized my tears were not a myth that day (whoa, I wrote that to be funny, but it sounds so sad!!!).
 
T

Tintin

Guest
Descyple, I love you, mate. You make me both groan and laugh out loud, all in the same moment. You have quite a talent there, wield it wisely. :)
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
41,315
16,302
113
69
Tennessee
I hear you. I would also become disinterested because, well, dating leads to marriage which then leads to family. I would want to raise our kids with same beliefs. It just wouldn't work if both of us held different beliefs: such as worshiping with our hands in the air and he did not believe in worshiping out there like that. Or praying in the holy spirit. I would want to instill in my children to dance for God and speak in the holy spirit.

If he was open to trying then I might consider but if he is closed up and firmly in his denomination then no.
I would as long as we shared the same belief on salvation, the love of God and the Word of God. The Father, Son and the Holy Spirit. It is a love triangle.
 

JesusLives

Senior Member
Oct 11, 2013
14,551
2,171
113
I would as long as we shared the same belief on salvation, the love of God and the Word of God. The Father, Son and the Holy Spirit. It is a love triangle.
I am and ditto what tourist said.
 

Descyple

Senior Member
Jun 7, 2010
3,023
48
48
Descyple, I love you, mate. You make me both groan and laugh out loud, all in the same moment. You have quite a talent there, wield it wisely. :)
Whoa, Tintin, that is the second time you've told me you love me on CC.

I think you better play low-key on the "L" word, or Arlene might think we have a history together.


P.S. Speaking of our history, I am still waiting for my Varsity jacket back from that day I let you wear it when we were walking along the beach and it was chilly out (okay, even I am creeped out by that sentence, and I'm the one who made it up - lol).

P.S.S. AzureAfire, you don't need to worry either, you are the only one that I will allow to wear my Varsity jacket (unfortunately I never went to College, so it's not actually my Varsity coat, I picked it up at a local Salvation Army for $5). But its the thought that counts, and the thought for the day is "SAVE MONEY ANY WAY YOU CAN"
 

AzureAfire

Senior Member
Apr 16, 2013
488
22
18
Whoa, Tintin, that is the second time you've told me you love me on CC.

I think you better play low-key on the "L" word, or Arlene might think we have a history together.


P.S. Speaking of our history, I am still waiting for my Varsity jacket back from that day I let you wear it when we were walking along the beach and it was chilly out (okay, even I am creeped out by that sentence, and I'm the one who made it up - lol).

P.S.S. AzureAfire, you don't need to worry either, you are the only one that I will allow to wear my Varsity jacket (unfortunately I never went to College, so it's not actually my Varsity coat, I picked it up at a local Salvation Army for $5). But its the thought that counts, and the thought for the day is "SAVE MONEY ANY WAY YOU CAN"
!!! :eek:

Is Tintin trying to steal my bases with you whenever I'm on my 24-hour work shift??? :mad: you got some 'splainin' to do, Mr. Goodly Bearded Taco Dude!!! The same goes for you, Descyple :mad: I wanted to take you out for walks along the beach, but you said you didn't want to 'coz you don't like the leash I got for you (It was on sale :( I thought you wouldn't mind that it's pink and lined with ribbons). What's a girl supposed to do??? XD I got that money saving part right, at least!!!

Me and Arlene better set-up a "Girl's Powwow" to sort this trouble!!! :rolleyes: KIDDING??? XD

Oh, Descyple :eek: it's okay that you don't have a Varsity Jacket!!! I'd much prefer a bear hug from you to keep me warm on that chilly walk by the beach :eek: just let me get a gasp of air every 5-10 minutes before total oxygen deprivation to my brain sets in, and to ease up once you hear one of my ribs crack :rolleyes: but then again, it'd be kind of sweet if you carry me around once I do get unconscious!!!

Aw....visions of going on a date with you!!! :eek:
 
C

Charcoal

Guest
Generally speaking, if you are carrying around your "date" because she is unconscious, you're probably going to get arrested (or leastwise need to be) no matter what denomination the two of you are.
Just sayin.
 

DuchessAimee

Senior Member
Apr 27, 2011
3,922
129
63
Not to sound like Bill Clinton, but Charcoal, please define the word if...

:D
 
C

Charcoal

Guest
Not to sound like Bill Clinton, but Charcoal, please define the word if...

:D

I had intended "IF" to mean "should it come to pass that.." or "on the off chance that..."

If | Define If at Dictionary.com The first definition given may further elucidate this for you. Should you not be a link clicker it states, "in case that; granting or supposing that; on condition that"

I'm too lazy to do it, but the Fry Meme now reads, " Not sure if being a smart alec or being a smart alec back..." lol
 

Descyple

Senior Member
Jun 7, 2010
3,023
48
48
it'd be kind of sweet if you carry me around once I do get unconscious!!!

Carrying women around when they are unconscious is my specialty (wait, that totally did not sound right).

How do I delete a post? HOW DO I DELETE A POST???
 
A

Abster

Guest
Im not about religion, but Im big on relationship. Ive met men who go to church every Sunday...and that's it. It stops there.I want to be with a man loves and serves the Lord...so that wont work. Also i think its important to determine the teaching at a church.that same guy I dated? Yeah, he was under a teaching that stressed wealth or "prosperity". So God told him things and one of them was that he would be a millionaire. Sigh....eventually his faith seemed based on hocus pocus and had little to do with the word of God. I went to another church where the pastor cursed on the pulpit. That was it for me. So there is a lot to be said of where someone chooses to worship. I pay attention to that. Forget dinner, invite me to.your church. Lets get that out of the way! :)
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
24,922
8,170
113
You can come to our church any time (and you won't find any cussing from the pulpit or "God will make you rich" messages...) but it'll be a bit of a drive from wherever you are to west TN.

You might get scared away though. We're pentecostals, and some of what you've heard about us is true... some great church services, mostly. :D
 

posthuman

Senior Member
Jul 31, 2013
36,672
13,131
113
i was raised non-denominational, and my wife was raised Episcopal.

it's not about the name on the church sign - it's about Jesus. we moved a few years ago and visited lots of different churches looking for the one the Spirit said "here"

can you guess where we wound up?
:D