Ever OK to hit spouse?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Feb 27, 2007
3,179
19
0
It's one thing to stand up for one's self, it's entirely another to threaten to take someone's life.


So you disagree, that's fine. My only regret is that you're still peddling the 'hitting is always abuse' line which is false. I don't think anyone here has ever condoned putting someone in hospital, or the habitual beating of another person. Ironically you have implied the condoning of emotional abuse in your applause of that woman issuing a death threat.
It was effective dear child. He never beat her again, the family unity remained intact where he was an integral part of the incredible love & support to the family unit. He, much like you I assume, grew up with an abusive father who justified his cruelty and I thank God that this cycle of abuse was stopped so the sons of the family do not continue in abuse of women. Now, he never thought it was ok to do what he did, in fact, he had great remorse and didnt even want to accept the fact that he did this. Some times you have to shock someone so they fully understand the impact of their actions. Yes I celebrate her for not becoming a victum. Oh & btw I totally & completely and fully LOVE her agressor. You, young man, can not go in to a realationship thinking it is your right to abuse your wife. As I drove up the driveway from dropping off my boys I praised God for my husband... for the sight of my home being the sight of safe refuge, warmth & acceptance not fear. I try to be a wife of nobel charactor who is uplifting and supporting to my husband. There are times when i fail and I praise the Lord that I dont have to endure a calm slap because of this. my husband is 6'2 and 200lbs. I'm pretty sure even a calm slap issued with absolutely no emotion attached to it would hurt badly. (I'm not quite sure how that is possible the no emotion thing... but if it were it would still be quite the hit) I apologise for the way I responded to you before, we are to speak the truth in love. I sincerely hope that you change your opinion on this and that you make the decision to make your home the place where, when your wife is alowed to leave (say to get groceries or go to a school function), when she returns she is joyful that she is home and not fearful over what she may have said or done.
 
M

Maddog

Guest
He, much like you I assume, grew up with an abusive father who justified his cruelty
That's a whopper of an assumption, you know.

Now, he never thought it was ok to do what he did, in fact, he had great remorse and didnt even want to accept the fact that he did this.
I'm not surprised. From your description it sounded quite terrible.

You, young man, can not go in to a realationship thinking it is your right to abuse your wife.
I don't think anyone has a right to abuse anyone. Either we're just talking past each other or we have a different understanding of what constitutes abuse.

I apologise for the way I responded to you before
That's okay, I know it's quite an emotive issue. I can't help but think that somewhere along the line there has been a gross misunderstanding (especially given your extreme examples and turns of phrase).

I sincerely hope that you change your opinion on this and that you make the decision to make your home the place where, when your wife is alowed to leave (say to get groceries or go to a school function), when she returns she is joyful that she is home and not fearful over what she may have said or done.
I don't see why that would require me to change my opinion.
 
S

spiritualplaguekeith

Guest
"Let thee who is of no sin, cast the first stone!" (as said by Jesus) Thats about all I have to say on this subject.
 
G

greatkraw

Guest
I have seen some out of control women, saved and unsaved. I am of the opinion that when they were little girls their dad needed to lovingly and consistently pull them into line. Now it is far too late.(I got to know a christian girl well who was out of control in some ways. she explained that her brother was disciplined but you never hit little girls. She was really very self centred)
 
W

wwjd_kilden

Guest
if someone hit me, father or husband, I'd never trust him again, and definitely not respect him...
 
F

FixYourWeave

Guest
If i got married and my husband hit me, he'd better sleep with his eyes open.
 
Oct 13, 2009
237
1
0
why would you ask this? of course it's not okay, don't hit people...it's bad. mmmkay?
 
Feb 27, 2007
3,179
19
0
I don't see why that would require me to change my opinion.[/quote]

so you arent interested in being married to someone who feels loved, secure and safe in their own home... pitty the girl. who knows, perhaps these very postings will be used as evidence one day...
 
M

Maddog

Guest
so you arent interested in being married to someone who feels loved, secure and safe in their own home... pitty the girl. who knows, perhaps these very postings will be used as evidence one day...
You're obviously misunderstanding. I meant I don't see the two as incompatible.
 
F

FixYourWeave

Guest
imoss, clearly maddog has a mental illness of some sort, So what is it you have maddog, mild retardation?? down syndrome??
 
W

wwjd_kilden

Guest
Everyone, please keep it civil -,-
 
M

Maddog

Guest
imoss, clearly maddog has a mental illness of some sort, So what is it you have maddog, mild retardation?? down syndrome??
With respect, my health is none of your business.

I will, however, advise you not to make such rash conclusions simply because someone may have views contrary to your own.
 
Feb 27, 2007
3,179
19
0
You're obviously misunderstanding. I meant I don't see the two as incompatible.
Oh, ok, I am female... I would fear home if i were being hit there. just so ya know, it would definitely not be my happy place. I speak to you in the hopes of changing your heart on this matter. God bless you.
 
F

FixYourWeave

Guest
With respect, my health is none of your business.

I will, however, advise you not to make such rash conclusions simply because someone may have views contrary to your own.

your right, your mental illnesses are none of my business, thats something you should discuss with your psych doctor.
 
M

Maddog

Guest
Oh, ok, I am female... I would fear home if i were being hit there. just so ya know, it would definitely not be my happy place. I speak to you in the hopes of changing your heart on this matter. God bless you.
But I'm not talking about habitual hitting. The best analogy I can think of is when you hit your kids - if executed properly, they don't live in fear yet they do learn when they've crossed the line.

Anyway, I appreciate your genuine concern and strength of feeling on this matter.
 
M

Maddog

Guest
your right, your mental illnesses are none of my business, thats something you should discuss with your psych doctor.
I already told you:
I will, however, advise you not to make such rash conclusions simply because someone may have views contrary to your own.
You still seem to be presuming things about the state of my health which are unsubstantiated. If you have a genuine concern for my well being then PM me, rather than slandering me in public.
 
A

Amped88

Guest
It is not only WRONG but a sin to hit or emotionally abuse ANYONE!